Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Trophy Central Review

Friday, October 22nd

2021 Trophy Store Reviews

Trophy Central Review 3.5 Star Rating

Trophy Central

3.5 Star Rating
  • Cost: From $5 to $504
  • Free economy shipping on orders over $100

Over the last 20 years, Trophy Central has provided trophies and awards for more than 100,000 customers - including more than 60% of Fortune 500 companies and nearly 10,000 elementary and secondary schools.

Trophy categories

You won't have any difficulties finding what you need on this well-organized trophy store's site. Across the top of the page, you'll see helpful categories to guide your shopping:

  • Trophies
  • Trophy Cups
  • Plaques
  • Engraving
  • Crystal Awards
  • Medals
  • Pins
  • Ribbons
  • Certificates
  • Gifts
  • Promotional
  • Trophy & Display Cases

Finding your trophy

You can also scroll down the home page and see if anything catches your eye, click on the dropdown at the top of the page to shop by category/sport/school subject, or simply enter a search keyword or phrase.

Not as many selections

Trophy Central didn't have as many selections as we were expecting in certain categories. For example, under Funny/Gag trophies, there seemed to be only one style: a horse's rear end! Also, under the Science category, there were only a handful of certificates, one trophy, and a few assorted medals and pins. But for some of the more popular activities you'd associate with awards, like sports, there were usually at least two dozen options for trophies alone.

Best Trophy Stores

Extra work

Once you've selected a particular award, the product page will give you the details you need regarding pricing and any other options. Pricing is usually dependent upon the number of items you order, typically in increments from 1-9, 10-49, 50-99, and 100+. We didn't like that you had to click on a tiny blue link to see samples of color options (for example, the pedestal or column for a trophy) - many of Trophy Central's competitors make that much easier to see without having to take any extra steps.

Reasonable return policy

Trophy Central has a reasonable return policy. Items can be returned within 21 days for replacement or refund, as long as the product hasn't been engraved. However, if the engraving plate can be removed and the item can be reused, the customer service team at Trophy Central will make every effort to accept your return. You may have to pay a restocking fee ranging from 15-25%, depending on the item.

Rewards program

This is also the only trophy store we found that has a rewards program. While the details on the site were a little thin, generally speaking you'll get rewards points on every purchase that can be redeemed for anything sold on the Trophy Central site. You'll have to set up an account on the site, and you'll be enrolled in the program at no cost. If you regularly place orders for trophies and awards - quarterly ceremonies, yearly awards banquets, etc. - that could be a strong factor to consider ordering from this retailer.

Satisfied customers

Trophy Central enjoys an "A+" rating from the BBB, and it's hard to find any negative customer reviews for this trophy store. By all appearances, it's a good place to shop for awards of all kinds.

Better choices available

But, when compared with other retailers, this shop has fewer options and the site isn't as clear when looking at various options for personalization, colors, and so forth. If you find what you're looking for on the Trophy Central online store, you can order confidently knowing that it's a reputable company that will do everything possible to make you happy - but it just doesn't have the options we found on some of the higher-ranked stores we reviewed.

Where Can You Find the Best Trophies and Awards?

That's a great question if you're in charge of recognizing athletes for their participation and accomplishments, giving employees a well-deserved award for being their team's MVP during a tough quarter at work, or giving any other type of praise and applause in a more formal, tangible way.

Trophies and awards really run the gamut when considering options for designs, shapes, materials, and budgets. On one end of the spectrum, you'll find the inexpensive plastic-and-metal trophies common at Little League baseball end-of-season awards nights, usually with a generic inscription congratulating the little slugger for being a part of the team.

The Best Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Store Reviews What are the best Trophy Stores Best Trophy Store Reviews

Trophy Store FAQ

You're only limited by your imagination. Trophies can be purchased pre-made and are a great choice for end-of-season awards ceremonies, sporting events, and much more. Metal or plastic? Crystal or acrylic? You'll find all of that and then some. And, for the truly special moments, consider a custom-designed trophy for the occasion.
Not necessarily. You can find options starting as low as $3!
That depends: are you buying a ready-made trophy that's in stock and just adding engraving, or are you designing a one-of-a-kind award? If you're going with something in stock, you can probably get your trophies in under a week.
Many trophy stores give you free delivery with your order! If you have a rush job, you might be able to pay extra for expedited shipping.
There are two basic types of personalization: the engraving that specifies the award recipient, award type, and so on, and the customization to include your group's logo or other images. Each trophy store has its own process for submitting the latter and it may take some time to work out the details. On the other hand, the engraving information is usually entered right on the website at the time you place your order.
Sometimes. Check the retailer's policy if you think you might need to return some of the trophies you're buying (like if you have fewer athletes than anticipated).
You won't find a better selection anywhere else! Plus, many trophy stores you'll find online have been in business for decades and have a loyal customer base: you can trust them to get your trophies done right. It's also an easy way to make sure that all of your engraving is accurate - with names spelled correctly and all of the other information exactly as you intended - because you can see it for yourself before you enter your order.
There are a lot of really great options out there, so it may be hard to choose! Pick one with a strong reputation - look for an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and/or plenty of positive customer reviews. After that, as long as the store you're considering has what you want in stock, at a price you like, and can get it to you on time for your event, you can trust that your trophy order is in good hands.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

On the other end of the spectrum, the sky's the limit: crystal, art deco glass, and other high-quality materials make up the products you'll find here. Think of what you'd expect when honoring someone for a lifetime's worth of achievements in a highly-competitive field, and you'll get an idea of the types of awards on the upper end of the price range.

Can't find a specialty trophy store near you? No problem! Most teams, organizations and companies turn to trusted online providers of trophies anyway: why not, when the options are plentiful, prices are competitive, and you can get your order just as quickly as if you purchased it from a local brick-and-mortar shop? Even your customizations can be taken care of quickly, ensuring that you have the perfect award for the ceremony, right on time.

So, how can you decide which trophy store should get your business, both now and hopefully for years to come? Here are several factors that may influence your purchasing decision when ordering trophies:

  • Selection. How many different types of trophies are in stock? You don't want to hand out the same thing year after year, so choosing a store with a wide variety in the category you need (e.g. soccer, academics, etc.) makes it easier to keep your recognition fresh with each season or year.
  • Service. What does the trophy store do to make your purchase easier? Is it difficult or time-consuming to get customizations? Can you get expedited delivery if needed? What will you spend for shipping?
  • Price. Given that many trophy stores sell awards that are very similar, how does the company measure up when looking at price? Are they competitive with other retailers?
  • Reputation. How well is the company doing when it comes to keeping customers happy? Do they offer a satisfaction policy that gets you a refund or replacement if your awards or trophies arrive and don't look like they did on the website? Has the company been rated by the BBB?

TopConsumerReviews has reviewed and ranked the best trophy stores available today. We hope this information helps you find the ideal trophies and awards for your next recognition ceremony, end-of-season banquet, or celebration of excellence!

The Best Reviews of Trophy Stores