Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Wilson Trophy Review

Monday, April 15th

2024 Trophy Store Reviews

Wilson Trophy Review 4.5 Star Rating

Wilson Trophy

4.5 Star Rating
  • Licensed by AYSO and Little League Baseball
  • Prices start at $7.25
  • Customized awards for all occasions
  • Free shipping on orders over $200
  • In business for over 55 years

For over 55 years, Wilson Trophy has offered top-quality trophies, awards, plaques, and more. They aim to provide a vast range of excellent trophies, medals, and awards, including custom designs based on your unique ideas.

Little League trophy experts

As the official supplier for over 20 youth sports groups and a licensee of Little League Baseball, they specialize in enhancing official league awards by adding logos and personal touches. This includes the ability to add the Little League logo to your little slugger's participation trophy.

Official AYSO awards

You can also find AYSO awards here. They offer a selection of official cups, trophies, resins, custom insert medals, acrylics, plaques, and more.

Free shipping on orders of $200+

Wilson Trophy offers free shipping for orders over $200, but this only includes trophies, resins, and non-acrylic plaques. So if you were hoping to meet that amount by stocking up on Wilson's pens, BBQ cutting boards, phone accessories, or Bible covers (seriously, what an odd assortment of stock), you're out of luck. For your reference, most of the other websites in our review offer free shipping on orders over $100.

Best Trophy Stores

Some categories had no results

While browsing Wilson Trophy's website, we noticed some empty categories. For example, they didn't have any swimming trophies when we looked, and tournament packages were empty. The same was true for wood column trophies. If you're dead set on purchasing either of these from Wilson Trophy, you'll have to reach out to find out if and when they'll be back in stock.

Build-your-own-trophy feature could use some work

With Wilson, you can create your own trophies starting from as low as $7.30. However, it would be helpful if the example image changed to match your customizations. Otherwise, it may be easier to choose one of the pre-made designs, as you won't have a clear idea of what you'll be getting - unless your imagination is really powerful. In that case, carry on.

Awards categorized by product type

While categories are organized by award type, not sport (meaning if you want to look at swimming awards, you have to first go to "Trophies" , or "Resins" ), you can get around this by using the search function and typing in the name of the sport or occasion you're looking to commemorate. When we searched for swimming, results included 83 individual awards with the ability to filter by size, award type, price range, and medal series. There was also a checkbox to filter by sport, which, strangely, brought our number of results down to 52.

Best Trophy Stores

Slightly more expensive than competing websites

The "sort by price" function is inaccurate on a couple of pages - it gets the order wrong, but not by a huge margin. Additionally, we noticed that the prices shown on the result pages don't match the prices when we click on individual products. For example, the result page states that the price of a 7" soccer trophy is "As low as $5.35," but when we clicked on the product page, the price for a quantity of 1-99 was actually $7.25. In order to be eligible for the displayed price of $5.35, you'd need to order at least 500 trophies. Wilson's competitors tend to be a couple of dollars cheaper.

Catalogs for select sports available

If you're still feeling a little lost, consider checking out Wilson's catalogs. The link is located at the bottom right of any page just above the "About Us" link. There are editions of the current year's designs for Soccer, Baseball & Softball, Football & Cheer, Basketball, and even the Armed Forces. You can browse the catalogs right from the website, no purchase or download required.

Top-quality award choices

We find that Wilson's offers awards that are better quality than competitors and there are more types to choose from. If you can only afford cheap plastic cup trophies, you can find those here too. But, you can also find medals from the USA Sport Series line and trophies made entirely of metal.

Best Trophy Stores

Request customized awards for all occasions

Wilson Trophy makes cool custom awards for any occasion. Want a trophy for the "Best Pancake Flipper" in your house? They've got you covered. From pins and medals to trophies and rings, they can make something special for everyone, whether it's for a big sports event or just fun recognition at home. Their designs work for business events, sports, or even wacky family challenges. Getting started is easy - just fill out their quick online form.

$50 Rush fee applies to orders needed 10 days out

When you check out, you'll be asked to enter the date you need your order in your hands, (for example, the date of the celebration or commemoration). If that date is within the next 10 calendar days, you'll be charged a $50 Rush Fee. This means that Wilson Trophy is not really the best option if you're a procrastinator on a budget. Your options for shipping are Ground, Next Day Air, and 2- and 3-Day Air. You won't find out the exact price or expected delivery date until you proceed with checkout and give them your personal information.

High quality trophies

To sum up, Wilson Trophy has a good reputation after being in the industry for 55 years. If you want official Little League or AYSO awards, this is the place to look. Although their prices are a bit higher than competitors, their quality and customization choices are impressive. Moreover, they provide free shipping for orders over $200. Despite a few small drawbacks, Wilson Trophy is still a dependable option for high-quality recognition products.

Where Can You Find the Best Trophies and Awards?

Trophies are more than just shiny metals and polished woods. They represent important milestones, victories, and efforts. If you're in charge of picking one out, you want to be sure it shows that you appreciate this significance.

Having trouble locating a specialty trophy store locally? Don't worry - the majority of teams, organizations, and companies prefer to rely on reputable online trophy providers. It's easy to see why: online stores offer abundant options, boast competitive prices, and promise fast deliveries, matching the convenience of buying from a local physical store. Plus, any customizations you need can be handled without hassle, guaranteeing that your award will be ready in time for awards night.

The Best Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Stores Compare Trophy Store Reviews What are the best Trophy Stores Best Trophy Store Reviews

Trophy Store FAQ

You're only limited by your imagination. Trophies can be purchased pre-made and are a great choice for end-of-season awards ceremonies, sporting events, and much more. Metal or plastic? Crystal or acrylic? You'll find all of that and then some. And, for the truly special moments, consider a custom-designed trophy for the occasion.
Not necessarily. You can find options starting as low as $3!
That depends: are you buying a ready-made trophy that's in stock and just adding engraving, or are you designing a one-of-a-kind award? If you're going with something in stock, you can probably get your trophies in under a week.
Many trophy stores give you free delivery with your order! If you have a rush job, you might be able to pay extra for expedited shipping.
There are two basic types of personalization: the engraving that specifies the award recipient, award type, and so on, and the customization to include your group's logo or other images. Each trophy store has its own process for submitting the latter and it may take some time to work out the details. On the other hand, the engraving information is usually entered right on the website at the time you place your order.
Sometimes. Check the retailer's policy if you think you might need to return some of the trophies you're buying (like if you have fewer athletes than anticipated).
You won't find a better selection anywhere else! Plus, many trophy stores you'll find online have been in business for decades and have a loyal customer base: you can trust them to get your trophies done right. It's also an easy way to make sure that all of your engraving is accurate - with names spelled correctly and all of the other information exactly as you intended - because you can see it for yourself before you enter your order.
There are a lot of really great options out there, so it may be hard to choose! Pick one with a strong reputation - look for an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and/or plenty of positive customer reviews. After that, as long as the store you're considering has what you want in stock, at a price you like, and can get it to you on time for your event, you can trust that your trophy order is in good hands.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Lots of occasions warrant a commemorative trophy or plaque. Whether it's to acknowledge a student's academic excellence, celebrate an athlete's success, recognize a professional's achievement, or simply commemorate personal milestones, these awards can be meaningful keepsakes displayed by proud family members for many years to come.

When it comes to trophies, there are so many options to choose from, each suited for specific occasions and achievements. Cup trophies, for example, are commonly associated with sports like soccer and symbolize victory. Endurance athletes like marathon runners or swimming champions often receive medals to commemorate their achievements. In the corporate and academic world, crystal awards are used to celebrate professional milestones and academic excellence, recognizing the accomplishments of outstanding employees and scholars. Plaques, on the other hand, can be seen on the walls of dedicated educators or long-serving employees, telling stories of commitment and dedication in their respective fields. These trophies can be made from a variety of materials, including plastic, wood, metal, and glass.

So, how do you determine which trophy store is worthy of your patronage, especially considering your team or organization might be buying from them repeatedly in the future?

Here are some factors that might help you make up your mind when browsing trophy options:

  • Variety. Does the store offer a wide range of trophy styles? You'll want to avoid monotony in your awards ceremonies, especially in team sports where players return year after year. That's why it's recommended to choose a store that offers a robust inventory of trophies with various designs available.
  • Customer service. Is the purchasing process smooth and hassle-free? Are the customization processes easy to navigate or do they take a lot of time? And speaking of time, it's important to know if there's an option for fast delivery in case you need your trophies quickly.
  • Cost. Given the similarity in products among various trophy stores, how does the pricing of each store compare? Is it competitive, providing value for your money? Does expedited shipping cost an arm and a leg?
  • Credibility. What is the store's reputation in terms of customer satisfaction? Is there a policy that guarantees refunds or replacements for products that aren't to your liking? How is the company rated by the BBB?

Top Consumer Reviews has conducted an insightful evaluation and ranking of the leading trophy stores currently available. We hope this information helps you find the perfect trophies and awards for your upcoming end-of-season ceremony, celebratory banquet, or any recognition of excellence!

Compare Trophy Stores

Select any 2 Trophy Stores to compare them head to head

The Best Reviews of Trophy Stores