Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Vacasa Review

Friday, February 23rd

2024 Vacation Rental Site Reviews

Vacasa Review 2 Star Rating

Vacasa

2 Star Rating
  • 44,000+ properties in 35 US states, Central America
  • "A+" rated and accredited by the BBB since 2014
  • 24-hour customer support
  • Premium Clean program with standardized cleaning guidelines based on CDC recommendations
  • Virtual tours

Looking for the perfect vacation rental in the United States, Canada, Mexico, Belize, or Costa Rica? With over 44,000 homes spread across 35 U.S. states and several stunning destinations in Central America, Vacasa has you covered. However, if you're dreaming of a European getaway or a Caribbean paradise, you'll have to set your sights elsewhere. But hey, specialization can be a good thing, right? In theory, Vacasa focuses on what it knows best: delivering memorable vacations in the U.S.

Homeowner-focused property management

Vacasa's story began in 2009 after its founder struggled to find a trustworthy property manager for his vacation home. Determined to create a solution, Vacasa was born. Their local teams take care of the homes, aiming to "maximize revenue for homeowners." While this might not sound ideal for thrifty travelers, it does mean that Vacasa should have a laser focus on delivering excellent experiences for homeowners and guests alike.

Standard search and filter functions plus virtual tours

Vacasa's search functions are pretty standard. Simply type your desired location and travel dates into the search bar, and you're immediately presented with an overview of available properties, including average prices per night and essential information like occupancy. The filters allow you to customize your search based on preferences such as views, washer and dryer availability, and even whether the property is "snowbird friendly," or, in other words, available for long-term stays during the winter months. One standout feature of Vacasa is the ability to take virtual, 360-degree tours of their properties. This lets you get a feel for the space before committing to it.

Best Vacation Rental Sites

Fees will make your heart sink

Vacasa's fees may raise an eyebrow or two. Vacasa charges property owners between 20% and 50% per booking, and those costs are inevitably passed on to you, the guest. The breakdown of fees isn't crystal clear, but brace yourself for a potentially hefty bill. For example, a 3-night booking in Maine costing $540 saw additional charges of $348.35, encompassing cleaning fees, a limited damage waiver, state taxes, and a booking fee. For a grand total of nearly $1,000, it's worth shopping around to see if other vacation rental services offer a more affordable option for your desired property.

Standardized cleaning guidelines in wake of COVID-19

What do you get for that hefty cleaning fee? Vacasa's Premium Clean program, launched after the outbreak of COVID-19, implements standardized cleaning guidelines based on CDC recommendations. According to their website, housekeepers are required to dedicate extra time to thorough cleaning, ensuring high-touch surfaces are disinfected. Employees who come into contact with someone with COVID-19 are barred from working. The pre-pandemic cleaning guidelines outlined on Vacasa's website were already pretty rigorous, too. We liked that the process is standardized so you should never have to wonder if your bedding was washed or if the hot tub was cleaned when staying in a Vacasa rental - it should be the same everywhere.

Best Vacation Rental Sites

More lip service than customer service

Now, let's address the elephant in the room: whether Vacasa actually delivers on their promises. While Vacasa has an "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau and has been accredited since 2014, many customers have voiced their discontent with Vacasa's management - and we find many of the issues in these complaints unacceptable in the first place, whether or not Vacasa followed up with the customer afterwards.

Shockingly descriptive complaints

Such complaints range from slow responses to maintenance requests, to dirty properties, and, shockingly, heating issues due to unpaid propane bills. This review says it all: "For a $12k mansion rental for my daughter's wedding, it was very disappointing. The house was not maintained properly with broken screen doors and porch lights that didn't work. Dead animal smell upstairs and mold in the tile grout. There was an inch of dust on the fan blades and theater room tv didn't work. We paid over $1,600 in fees for cleaning and we didn't receive a clean house ourselves!"

Property management companies: less of a personal touch?

There have also been grumbles about unexpected fees and charges for other services without corresponding value: one disgruntled customer lost his wedding band at a property and was charged an extra fee for Vacasa to search for it, but was made to feel like he was low-priority and no empathy was expressed for his situation. It could be that property management companies may not be the best choice for vacation home rentals. When you communicate directly with the owners, they may feel a greater sense of ownership and accountability for your experience. We have the impression that Vacasa is run by individuals who dislike their jobs and are only in it for the paycheck. After all, what's one more unhappy customer among thousands when you're clocking out at 5pm anyway?

Best Vacation Rental Sites

Flexibility for me, not for thee

Vacasa's return policy does not inspire faith, either. If you accidentally book or have a change of heart, you have a 24-hour window to cancel and receive a full refund. (However, this exemption doesn't apply to last-minute bookings made the day before your trip.) After those initial 24 hours, canceling within 30 days of check-in will only grant you a partial refund, leaving behind your booking fee and tax money. And in some states, you'll need to cancel a whopping 60 days in advance. It seems Vacasa expects flexibility from its guests but may not extend the same courtesy in return, given some customers reported their bookings were canceled last-minute with no explanation offered. Vacasa also did not offer to cover the difference for a replacement rental.

Avoid Vacasa

In summary, Vacasa offers a "just okay" selection of vacation rentals across most of the United States and Central America, but their customer reviews raise concerns about maintenance, cleanliness, and higher-than-appropriate fees for the quality of the service delivered. Their cancellation policies are more rigid than other services we have reviewed, earning Vacasa a lower-than-average ranking among vacation rental sites.

What's the Best Website to Use for Booking a Vacation Rental?

Are you tired of the same old hotel experience when you go on vacation? Do you crave something more unique and personalized, where you can truly feel at home even when you're away? If so, then vacation rentals might just be the perfect solution for you.

If you've ever stayed in a vacation rental property, you already know their charm and allure. Unlike traditional hotels, vacation rentals offer a level of comfort, privacy, and flexibility that is hard to match. These properties are often privately-owned homes or apartments that are rented out to travelers on a short-term basis.

The Best Vacation Rental Sites Compare Vacation Rental Sites Compare Vacation Rental Site Reviews What are the best Vacation Rental Sites Best Vacation Rental Site Reviews

Vacation Rental Site FAQ

A vacation rental property is a fully-furnished apartment, condo, house (or even a castle, boat or RV!) that you can book for your next trip instead of a traditional motel/hotel. Many vacation rentals are privately owned, and the owners take pleasure in showing you everything they love about their hometown. It's a great way to get the inside scoop on your destination, from restaurants to activities.
A vacation rental is like having a home away from home. You'll have more room to stretch out, play games, eat and cook (if you want!), and maybe even throw in a load of laundry while you go explore your destination. If you're traveling with a large party - your kids, friends, extended family - a vacation rental will almost always provide the most value if you're staying for more than a night or two.
There are many well-known listing sites that let you browse by destination, number of guests, and desired amenities. Some vacation rental properties are more off the beaten path and not listed with the larger services; you can find those by searching for rentals in the area where you plan to travel.
Just about! (Maybe not in Antarctica though.) You'll have an easier time finding vacation rentals in popular tourist towns and their suburbs, but you may still discover something over the river and through the woods near Grandma's house too.
Most vacation rentals are fully furnished, with all of the linens you need for the bathrooms and bedrooms, kitchen equipment for cooking and eating meals, and often a washer and dryer. Depending on where you're traveling, you could get access to parking spots, a community pool, Wifi and more. Some really attentive property owners stock the bathrooms with spa-quality shampoo and conditioner, offer beach chairs and boogie boards for your use, and so on. You can almost always find a thorough description in the listing of what the rental has to offer.
Read the details to see what your vacation rental has. If it's not listed, it might not be there (e.g. Wifi, coffee maker, etc.). You can usually contact the owner before booking if there's something obviously missing. Also, most vacation rentals do not offer daily maid service; the cleaning is done after you leave, to prepare for the next guests.
Policies vary by owner and by listing service. Most have a required deposit that may or may not be refundable, depending on when you cancel: it's hard for rental properties to book last-minute guests. A travel insurance policy might be a smart add-on, whether you use a vacation rental property or not.
That's not common, but it does happen. It's a good idea to read through reviews from previous guests of the rental properties that interest you: that's usually the first indicator of whether or not a rental is going to be amazing or awful. But, if you book a rental and have problems - you arrive and can't get in according to the instructions you were given, the property is significantly different from what was described, you don't have running water or heat/AC - the listing service might have a toll-free number you can call to get help if you can't reach the property owner/manager.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Vacation home rentals come fully furnished and equipped with all the amenities you need for a comfortable stay, from kitchen cupboards full of cookware, to cozy living areas and comfortable bedrooms. It's like having a home away from home, complete with personal touches that reflect the unique style and taste of the owner.

One of the best things about vacation rentals is the sheer variety of options available. Whether you're planning a family reunion, a romantic getaway, or a solo adventure, you can find a vacation rental that fits your needs perfectly. Want to relax by the beach? There are countless beachfront properties waiting for you. Prefer a secluded cabin in the woods? You'll find plenty of those too. From urban lofts to countryside villas, there's something for everyone.

Unlike traditional hotels that are typically owned by large hotel chains or corporations, vacation rentals are often owned by individuals who use them as second homes or investment properties. These owners may be local residents or people from different parts of the world. Some vacation rentals are also owned by small property management companies or vacation rental agencies that handle the day-to-day operations on behalf of the owners. These agencies may handle tasks such as marketing, guest communication, and property maintenance.

How do you go about choosing the right vacation rental? That's where vacation rental websites come in. These platforms connect travelers with property owners, making it easy to browse and book the perfect vacation rental for your needs. Not all vacation rental websites are created equal, though. It doesn't matter how many properties they have if they don't offer good customer service or aren't responsive when you need assistance.

Here are some things to keep in mind when making your choice:

  • Reputation. You want to use a website that has a solid track record and positive reviews from previous users. Look for platforms that have been around for a while and have established themselves as trustworthy and reliable. Has the platform been rated by the Better Business Bureau?
  • Selection. The more properties a website has, the greater your chances of finding the perfect vacation rental. Top rental websites have extensive listings across various destinations, ensuring you have plenty of options to choose from, while others may be limited to one country. If you're looking for something special or traveling to a popular destination during a busy time, like a holiday or summer break, you'll have better luck finding a place to stay if the company has a large selection.
  • Pricing and fees. Some websites advertise a lower per-night cost on the search page than what you'll actually end up paying after cleaning and amenity fees. It's also a good idea to check if the vacation rental you're interested in is listed on multiple websites, as there may be price differences that could help you save some cash. Look for websites that offer transparent pricing and don't surprise you with hidden costs.
  • Cancellation policy. Life is unpredictable, and sometimes plans change unexpectedly. A flexible cancellation policy can provide peace of mind in case you need to modify or cancel your reservation. Make sure to read and understand the terms and conditions regarding cancellations, refunds, and any applicable fees. Does the property owner determine the terms of the cancellation period, or does the website have a blanket policy?

Ready for a vacay? To make it a breeze to find the perfect stay, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best vacation rental websites currently on the market. We hope this information helps you find the perfect home-away-from home accommodations for your next trip, no matter where you want to go.

The Best Reviews of Vacation Rental Sites