Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

St. Brendan's Isle vs Traveling Mailbox

Monday, February 10th

2025 Virtual Mailbox Service Reviews

St. Brendan's Isle Review 4.5 Star Rating

St. Brendan's Isle

4.5 Star Rating
  • Price: $13.99 to $29.99/month for base plans, plus $7.99-15.99/month for mail scanning
  • Scanning plans include 40 or 125 envelope scans per month
  • Same-day scanning available, when requested by noon Eastern Time
  • No third-party outsourcing
  • "A+” BBB rating
  • In business since 1988

If you need a virtual mailbox service that feels more like a trusted friend than a faceless corporation, St. Brendan's Isle might be your perfect match. While their website could use an update and their pricing structure isn't the most straightforward, you'll get exceptional personal service from a family-owned business that truly understands the unique challenges of mobile living. They particularly shine when it comes to helping establish Florida residency and managing mail for sailors, RVers, and traveling professionals. St. Brendan's Isle is not the cheapest or most modern option out there (and you'll be limited to a Florida address) but it's a rock-solid choice if you value reliability and human connection over flashy features.

Traveling Mailbox Review 3 Star Rating

Traveling Mailbox

3 Star Rating
  • Price: Starts at $15/month for Basic plan, $25/month for Extended, $55/month for Small Business
  • 50 US addresses across different states; also available in 47 countries
  • Mail volume: Basic - 40 envelopes, Extended - 100 envelopes, Small Business - 200 envelopes per month
  • All mail services handled in-house with US team
  • Check depositing available for $4.95 + postage per check
  • Integrates with OneDrive, Google Drive, Box, Dropbox, and Evernote
  • "A+” BBB rating and accreditation
  • In business since 2011

Traveling Mailbox offers a comprehensive set of features at competitive prices, with plans starting at just $15 monthly and access to 50 different US addresses. While their cloud storage integration and in-house mail processing are solid perks, their customer service has raised some serious red flags, from unannounced location closures to poor communication and concerning customer interactions. The service might work if you're on a tight budget and don't anticipate needing much support, but given the critical customer feedback and service issues, we can only give them a middle-of-the-road rating.

What is the Best Virtual Mailbox Service?

Dreaming of an extended vacation, but don't want to saddle a relative with the task of sorting your junk mail? Have you ever wished you could check your mail from anywhere in the world? Virtual mailbox services can help you do just that.

Let's say you're a digital nomad running a US-based graphic design business while traveling through Southeast Asia. Instead of worrying about missing important documents or having mail pile up at home, you could use a virtual mailbox service that gives you a real street address (not a P.O. box) in Denver. Whenever mail arrives, it'll be quickly scanned and uploaded to an app on your phone or accessible via a website.

The Best Virtual Mailbox Services Compare Virtual Mailbox Services Compare Virtual Mailbox Service Reviews What are the best Virtual Mailbox Services Best Virtual Mailbox Service Reviews

Virtual Mailbox Service FAQ

A virtual mailbox makes all of your physical mail digital. You choose a location to receive your junk mail, letters, and anything else you might get via USPS, FedEx, UPS, and so on. Everything you get will be scanned on the outside, to give you an idea of what it contains. After you view the scan image, you decide if the piece of mail should be opened and scanned, forwarded to you (wherever you may be), or shredded and discarded. To sign up, you'll typically need to fill out USPS Form 1583 and have it notarized: this authorizes the virtual mailbox company to receive mail in your name.
Virtual mailboxes are frequently used by RVers, travelers, and digital nomads who need a way to get their postal mail without having a fixed permanent address in the US. They're also popular with small business owners who don't want to have their residence showing up as the location of their business. And, even some big corporations use virtual mailboxes as a way of outsourcing the time-consuming task of sorting physical mail: it gives them all of the services of a mailroom without the hassle.
Depending on the virtual mailbox provider you choose, your services might include check depositing, remote notarization, junk mail recycling, and package processing. Some virtual mailbox companies include those services as part of your monthly or annual fees, while others charge a la carte as needed.
Maybe. Some virtual mailbox providers process all of your mail themselves, so you're limited to the company's locations (often a choice among 3-5 addresses in that many states). Other services use a network of third-party mail centers - like the UPS Store and Mailboxes Etc. - which gives you hundreds, if not thousands, of address choices.
Typically, the envelope scans of your mail pieces are made available on a digital dashboard. You'll access it through your desktop browser, though some services include a smartphone app for easy access on the go. Keep in mind that scanning the contents of your mail may come at an extra cost.
Yes, that's typically included in virtual mailbox services. You can pay to have the package forwarded to your current location and/or to have an employee open and inspect the package's contents. Be aware that you'll likely have a limited window to decide what should be done with the package (forward or discard); after as few as five days, you could be charged for storage.
No problem! Your virtual mailbox dashboard should let you specify what you want forwarded and where it should go. You'll usually pay a per-item fee plus postage; some companies give you big discounts over retail shipping fees, while others seem to use it as a money-maker and upcharge on the delivery fees. If you think you'll need a lot of forwarding, be sure to read the details on estimated costs.
Not necessarily. Many virtual mailboxes cost $10/month or less. Shop around to see which providers have the services you need, keeping in mind that some features are pay-per-use and can add up quickly.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

This type of service is perfect for frequent travelers, RVers, small business owners, or anyone who wants a smarter way to handle their physical mail while on the move. In some cases, they can even help you provide proof of residency.

Virtual mailbox services typically offer tiered plans to accommodate different needs. Plans for individuals start anywhere from $10 to $30 per month and focus on essential services like mail scanning, forwarding, and secure shredding. Business plans include additional features, such as registered agent services, premium street addresses, and multi-user access. Many providers offer combination plans that blend both personal and business features. While some services might only offer virtual addresses in a handful of US states, others operate a broad network of addresses across the country or internationally.

Setting up a virtual mailbox is straightforward but requires some paperwork. You'll need to complete USPS Form 1583 (which must be notarized) to authorize the service to receive your mail. Some services offer that notarization via Zoom for an additional fee. Once set up, you'll receive notifications when new mail arrives. Through your online dashboard, you can decide whether to have items scanned, forwarded, shredded, or recycled. For example, you might choose to have important documents scanned immediately while having packages forwarded to your current location.

While you're shopping for the right virtual mailbox service, there are a few factors to keep in mind:

  • Location availability. Make sure the service offers addresses in areas that make sense for your needs, whether for tax purposes or client accessibility.
  • Security measures. Is your virtual address serviced by the company itself, or do they outsource to a third party? You may need to research your mail center independently to verify their protocols for handling sensitive mail and protecting your digital information.
  • Pricing structure. How many free envelope or content scans do you get each month? Compare these and also consider storage limits to find the best value for your expected mail volume.
  • Additional services. Do you need features like check depositing, package consolidation, or international mail forwarding? Not every virtual mailbox service offers all of these, and prices vary.
  • Customer support. Can you get in touch with someone via support chat? What about over the phone? The availability and quality of customer service is important to know, especially if you'll be accessing your mail from different time zones.

Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked the best virtual mailbox services available. We've assessed factors like reliability, feature sets, pricing, and customer satisfaction to help you make an informed decision. Whether you've got big plans to travel the world or are a small business owner looking to make a more professional impression on your customers, we hope these reviews help you find the perfect virtual mailbox service for your specific needs!

Compare Virtual Mailbox Services

Select any 2 Virtual Mailbox Services to compare them head to head

best-virtual-mailbox-services
  • US Global Mail
  • Physical Address
  • St. Brendan's Isle
  • Post Scan Mail
  • Virtual Post Mail
  • USA2Me
  • iPostal1
  • Traveling Mailbox
  • Anytime Mailbox
  • Sasquatch Mail
US Global Mail vs Physical Address US Global Mail vs St. Brendan's Isle US Global Mail vs Post Scan Mail US Global Mail vs Virtual Post Mail US Global Mail vs USA2Me US Global Mail vs iPostal1 US Global Mail vs Traveling Mailbox US Global Mail vs Anytime Mailbox US Global Mail vs Sasquatch Mail Physical Address vs St. Brendan's Isle Physical Address vs Post Scan Mail Physical Address vs Virtual Post Mail Physical Address vs USA2Me Physical Address vs iPostal1 Physical Address vs Traveling Mailbox Physical Address vs Anytime Mailbox Physical Address vs Sasquatch Mail St. Brendan's Isle vs Post Scan Mail St. Brendan's Isle vs Virtual Post Mail St. Brendan's Isle vs USA2Me St. Brendan's Isle vs iPostal1 St. Brendan's Isle vs Traveling Mailbox St. Brendan's Isle vs Anytime Mailbox St. Brendan's Isle vs Sasquatch Mail Post Scan Mail vs Virtual Post Mail Post Scan Mail vs USA2Me Post Scan Mail vs iPostal1 Post Scan Mail vs Traveling Mailbox Post Scan Mail vs Anytime Mailbox Post Scan Mail vs Sasquatch Mail Virtual Post Mail vs USA2Me Virtual Post Mail vs iPostal1 Virtual Post Mail vs Traveling Mailbox Virtual Post Mail vs Anytime Mailbox Virtual Post Mail vs Sasquatch Mail USA2Me vs iPostal1 USA2Me vs Traveling Mailbox USA2Me vs Anytime Mailbox USA2Me vs Sasquatch Mail iPostal1 vs Traveling Mailbox iPostal1 vs Anytime Mailbox iPostal1 vs Sasquatch Mail Traveling Mailbox vs Anytime Mailbox Traveling Mailbox vs Sasquatch Mail Anytime Mailbox vs Sasquatch Mail
Compare the Best Virtual Mailbox Services
- VS -
Review the Best Virtual Mailbox Services
The Best Reviews of Virtual Mailbox Services