Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Shutterfly Review

Friday, February 23rd

2024 Wedding Invitation Site Reviews

Shutterfly Review 2.5 Star Rating


2.5 Star Rating
  • 100% happiness guarantee
  • Save 20% when you sign up for texts
  • Browse products using your own photos
  • Afterpay options

Shutterfly first existed as a source to print 4x6 photographs from your digital camera in 1999. They now provide a massive range of custom photo services for those looking to make personalized cards and stationery, prints, gifts, calendars, wall art, home decor, and wedding products. All of their inventory can be customized using photos uploaded from your phone or computer. They have a few sister companies that include Tinyprints, Lifetouch, Groovebook, and Spoonflower.

Lots of photo card choices

There are over 350 wedding invitation templates that you can narrow down by foil color, trim options, the number of photos you want to use, design color, theme, style (artistic, contemporary, modern, vintage, whimsical), price, card size (5x7 or 6x8), designer, and format. If you want to upload the photo(s) you're planning to use on your announcement, Shutterfly will show it on all the applicable designs so you can quickly see what styles go along with your picture. Unlike some other retailers, Shutterfly has a lot of designs that feature photos.

Minimal design change options

Shutterfly has three different paper options that you can have your wedding invitations printed on (signature smooth, pearl shimmer, or luxe double-thick cardstock) and they offer pre-printed addressing on most envelopes. Their customization tools are easy to use, but you aren't able to make many changes to the card you select. For example, you can't drag and drop text boxes or change fonts on most products, so what you see is what you get.

Frequent sitewide sales

As with most other online card stores, the more wedding invitations you purchase from Shutterfly, the cheaper each card is. Wedding invitation pricing is based on ordering 75 cards, although you can order anywhere from 1 to 1,000. A sale for 50% off cards plus free shipping was happening at the time of this review, so some invitations were as inexpensive as $0.98 per card. If you are willing to provide your mobile number to Shutterfly, you'll also get a code for 20% off your order, which could save you quite a bit in the end.

Best Wedding Invitation Sites


If you need to make a big order from Shutterfly and don't want to pay for it all at once, you have the option of using Afterpay. This is a service that breaks up your total into four interest-free payments that you can pay off every two weeks so your purchases don't hit your wallet too fast and furious.

The Shutterfly satisfaction guarantee

Shutterfly has a 100% happiness guarantee policy that says if you aren't happy with your order once it arrives, contact their customer service and they'll take care of it. Nowhere does it specifically say you'll get a refund, so you can't necessarily depend on that, but you'll most likely get the option for reprints or a store credit. Shutterfly also promises to never delete the photos you upload to their site and they provide free, unlimited storage of your images.

In a downward spiral

Shutterfly has a lousy "D-" rating from the Better Business Bureau, which is significantly lower than ratings they've had in the past. This was as disappointing as the thousands of poor reviews they receive directly from customers who have used their services. Over the last year, people have been very frustrated by how long it takes to receive their orders and many say that they are poor quality. Some people wait months and have a hard time communicating with customer service about the status of their shipments. Others said their cards unexpectedly arrived with big Shutterfly watermarks on them that they were furious about.

Better choices available

It seems most people would not recommend this company, which is unfortunate. Shutterfly hasn't always had a poor reputation, but apparently their company has taken a dip recently. They have a lot of work to do to get customer satisfaction back on track. In the meantime, we recommend ordering wedding announcements from a higher-rated company.

Where is the Best Place to Create Wedding Invitations?

There are so many to-do items and details that go into planning a wedding! One of the first is to design invitations to let your loved ones know about your big day. It's exciting to make it official and get the word out about your celebration. It's important to find a good place that will let you customize your invitations to fit you and your significant other's style as well as provide a quick turnaround time to make sure you have plenty of leeway when getting them in the mail.

Your friends and family will want to be there for your wedding and to know about other important events that go along with it - like a reception or dinner. In addition, most couples add information about their wedding registry to their invitations, so you'll be sure to get gifts that will help you jumpstart your new life with your spouse.

The Best Wedding Invitation Sites Compare Wedding Invitation Sites Compare Wedding Invitation Site Reviews What are the best Wedding Invitation Sites Best Wedding Invitation Site Reviews

Wedding Invitation Site FAQ

You can get online and create all your wedding invitations in an hour or less. Wedding invitation sites have easy-to-use templates that allow you to drag and drop photos, graphics, and text to make a beautiful design in a short amount of time. You'll be able to select the font, color, and size of your invitations as well. As soon as your design is complete, you can submit your order and receive your invitations within a matter of days.
The total cost of wedding invitations is dependent on a few factors like the type of paper, quantity, and size. They are usually priced individually, but prices tend to drop the more you buy. On average, you can expect to pay between $400 and $650. That number can be a lot higher if you have a long guest list, want addresses printed on all your envelopes or other fanciful options.
The classiest and timeless way to do wedding invitations is on paper in the mail. That way people get a beautiful picture of the engaged couple, all the details for the wedding day, and can save the invitation and look at it so they don't forget. It is a much more formal option than evites. Evites are more acceptable for events like birthday parties or baby showers.
Yes! Some companies charge extra for envelopes, while others have them priced in with the invitation itself. You might choose to change the color of the envelope or have addresses printed for you, which could alter your overall cost. However, envelopes are a necessary part of the deal when you're purchasing wedding invitations online.
Oftentimes companies will mail you your invitation before you place your full order so you know what they look like. This way you get to feel the paper, see the quality of the printing, and make sure everything is formatted the way you want. Another option is just viewing an online preview of your invitation before submitting your full order, which also gives you an adequate idea of how they will turn out.
You could collect wedding invitations the old fashioned way and make a list of all your guests, then text or call to request their address. Another option is to make an account through a website that emails or texts your guest list and asks them to respond with their address. There are quite a few free options for doing this. Also, some people simply put it out there on social media that they're getting married and would like a direct message with people's addresses if they are interested in receiving an announcement.
The most traditional size for a wedding invitation is a 4.5 inch by 6.25 inch rectangular card. Most of the time wedding invitations aren't much bigger than a 5 inch by 7 inch design. If it's too big it will look silly, but if it's too small it might be hard to read. Nowadays there are lots of creative designs for wedding invitations like circular scalloped, oval, or other unique shapes that all come in reasonable sizes and add flair to your wedding invitation.
Some key pieces of information you'll want to include on your wedding invitation include the names of the bride and groom (sometimes the parents of the happy couple are listed too), wedding date, location, and time, and other special ceremonies the guest is invited to. You might include whether or not you'll be serving food, where the couple is registered for gifts, RSVP information, and a note about attire.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Creating wedding invitations is a key part of a successful wedding and it is also one of the easiest things you'll do. There are quite a few online platforms that allow you to create your invitations within minutes and have them either mailed to your house or directly to guests.

Wedding announcements can be formal or whimsical and fun, reflecting the couple's personalities together. Many people choose to add engagement photos to the invitations, but it isn't absolutely necessary. Whatever your style is, you can easily design a wedding announcement you like among the hundreds of template options available online.

There are quite a few companies that offer custom wedding invitations, so we have provided important information for you to consider when deciding who to buy from:

  • Selection: Are there plenty of options to choose from to reflect your style, fit the photographs you want to use, and include all the information you need? You'll want something unique and beautiful, so be sure to find a company that offers lots of design choices.
  • Cost: How does the cost of wedding announcements from one company compare to another? Do you get better pricing if you purchase high quantities of invitations? Is shipping a reasonable price?
  • Production time: Once you've designed your wedding announcements online, how long does it take for them to be printed and shipped to your house? Make sure you have plenty of time to mail your invitations before your big day.

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best wedding invitation companies available today. We hope this information helps you find the right wedding announcements to celebrate one of the most momentous occasions of your life!

Compare Wedding Invitation Sites

Select any 2 Wedding Invitation Sites to compare them head to head

See the Best Wedding Invitation Site
The Best Reviews of Wedding Invitation Sites