Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Bitters + Bottles vs Taster's Club

Sunday, March 23rd

2025 Whiskey Club Reviews

Bitters + Bottles Review 3.5 Star Rating

Bitters + Bottles

3.5 Star Rating
  • $90 to $110 per quarter
  • $16.50 to $7,399.50 for single purchase bottles
  • American whiskeys
  • 1 full bottle per quarter
  • 2 clubs for whiskey fans
  • Free shipping on all orders for reward members
  • 4.9-star average rating

Bitters & Bottles is a great option for whiskey lovers looking for a curated subscription, offering a full-size bottle of limited-edition whiskey every quarter. While the quality of the selections is impressive, the fluctuating price and lack of variety in each shipment may not appeal to everyone. With solid customer reviews for the store overall but less buzz around the subscription service itself, we give Bitters & Bottles a balanced rating until it earns more third-party reviews from whiskey fans.

Taster's Club Review 2 Star Rating

Taster's Club

2 Star Rating
  • Monthly costs from $69.99 to $184.99
  • $15.99 to $14,117.99 for single purchase bottles
  • International and American whiskeys
  • Full bar one-stop shop
  • 1 full-size whiskey per month
  • 2,204 a-la-carte spirits
  • Free shipping on prepaid packages

Taster's Club is a whiskey subscription service that delivers a full-size bottle each month, offering four different options for whiskey, and a range of other spirits from around the world. With a massive selection of whiskey and other liquors in its online store, it's theoretically a great spot for those looking to explore new flavors. However, recent customer complaints about shipping and cancellations have lowered its reputation, earning it one of the lowest ratings in our review.

What is the Best Whiskey Club Available Online?

When you think of a classic drink, among the favorites like vodka and rum, one of the top picks for mixers and a relaxing boozy beverage on the rocks is whiskey. Whiskey is a versatile drink: whether you like a classic Crown Royal or something a little more exotic, whiskey's various flavors are enhanced by "notes” and scents that will bring out your inner bartender.

Whether you're a whiskey newbie, and you don't know what to try, or a connoisseur who's looking to add a bit more variety to your home bar, joining a whiskey club is the best way to enjoy new whiskeys from around the world. After all, there are so many different whiskeys available today that it's hard to know where to start.

The Best Whiskey Clubs Compare Whiskey Clubs Compare Whiskey Club Reviews What are the best Whiskey Clubs Best Whiskey Club Reviews

Whiskey Club FAQ

A whiskey club is a membership that delivers delicious and rare selections to you on a regular basis. The bulk of these clubs require zero commitment and offer anytime cancellation, which is something to look into prior to finalizing your order.
The idea of a whiskey club is to try new brands and wonderful whiskey flavors unavailable to most enthusiasts. Each bottle is handpicked from the individual club and can originate in international lands far, far away or domestic distilleries across the U.S.
The frequency of whiskey club deliveries depends on you and your budget. Most whiskey clubs offer a variety of flexibility in terms of options. Choose from monthly, semi-monthly, or quarterly deliveries depending on your needs and wallet.
Whiskey clubs can be an amazing gift for the fine spirits aficionado in your life and those hard to shop for family members. Imagine delicious, hard to find and unique whiskey arriving each month to your gift recipient. Whiskey clubs can also make a well appreciated gift for any special client.
A Whiskey Sour is a very popular whiskey mixed drink. Here's how you make one:
Ingredients
  - 1 1/2 ounces of quality whiskey
  - 3/4 ounce fresh squeezed lemon juice
  - 3/4 ounce simple syrup
  - Ice
  - 1 maraschino cherry
Instructions
In a cocktail shaker, combine the whiskey, lemon juice, and simple syrup. Add the ice and shake. Pour into a rocks glass filled with ice. Then garnish with cherry!
The bulk of whiskey clubs cost between $69 to $239 per delivery, before shipping. The cost of shipping is also something to consider. Many companies charge a flat rate fee for each delivery, while others provide free shipping to customers. Whiskey club shoppers will find the option to pay in full or to be charged at each delivery.
Should the whiskey delivery appear damaged on a door step contact the customer service of the club that you selected. Most whiskey clubs are very customer oriented and want to fix any problems that happen if damage occurs in transit.
Each whiskey club package typically includes tasting notes. Tasting notes identify the whiskey distillery, often the history behind the business and any special aromas and flavors that the taster might experience.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Whiskey originated over 1,000 years ago when the practice of distillation made its way to Scotland and Ireland. Since grapes were scarce at Scottish and Irish monasteries, they decided to ferment grains. The first written record of "whisky” appeared in 1405 in the Irish Annals of Clonmacnoise. You might note the difference in spelling. This is due to the origins (not just an old-timey language quirk), and for modern whiskey, you can still tell where your drink is from by how they spell the word. If you see "whiskey" with an "E," it likely comes from the U.S., while "whisky" without the "E" is typically from Scotland, Canada, or Japan.

Well-known names like Jack Daniels, Jim Beam, and Maker's Mark have built strong reputations for their quality and consistency. But beyond these big names, smaller craft distilleries are also gaining recognition for exceptional whiskey.

If you're worried you might never be able to find them all, don't be! This is the perfect reason to join a whiskey club. This way, you'll have the opportunity to try some of the best whiskeys out there and some unique options you might not find in your local stores. From curated shipments to pick-your-own boxes, there are plenty of ways to try and enjoy whiskey through a new whiskey club.

Whether you prefer your whiskey on the rocks, in a cocktail, or neat, you can definitely find some delicious options at a whiskey club. But given the variety of whiskeys and the range of impressive whiskey clubs out there, it can be hard to know where to start. Here are a few factors to consider that might help you pick:

  • Price. The memberships for whiskey clubs are often monthly, quarterly, or yearly. So keep an eye on the cost over time to make sure the value matches what you'll get in each shipment.
  • On the shelf. Many whiskey clubs offer bottles for purchase outside of the club memberships. If you're looking for a place to buy a full bottle, check out what each club has on the shelf to see if you like their extras.
  • Sample sizes. Some whiskey clubs ship you sample sizes each month to try multiple whiskeys at a time and others send you a full bottle in every box. Knowing how much whiskey you want can help you choose the best whiskey club for you.
  • Feedback. What are other whiskey fans saying about your chosen club? Check out third-party reviews for your favorite picks to make sure that the quality is what you deserve.

To help you find the right club to join, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the most popular subscriptions for whiskey out there today. This way you can trust that your next glass of whiskey is on the way, and you can sit back, relax, and enjoy your well-deserved nightcaps in peace!

The Best Reviews of Whiskey Clubs