Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Bitters + Bottles Review

Sunday, April 14th

2024 Whiskey Club Reviews

Bitters + Bottles Review 4 Star Rating

Bitters + Bottles

4 Star Rating
  • From $80 to $85 per quarter for shipments
  • From $25 to $134.50 per bottle for single purchase
  • 2 whiskey focused club options
  • Full size spirits and mixers

Bitters + Bottles is a subscription box that aims to help members build their home bar and improve their cocktail-making skills. Each quarter, full-sized spirits, mixers, and recipes for classic cocktails are sent to the subscribers from a curated selection made by the Bitters + Bottles team. The box aims to provide a collection of whiskey and recipes that build upon the previous shipment. Bitters + Bottles offers two whiskey-focused clubs on the site: Whiskey and Old Fashioned.

2 different whiskey clubs with options for more spirits

There are only 2 ways to get your whiskey from the Whiskey Club, either shipped from California or in-store pickup. If you choose to have yours shipped (or you're not based in Cali), you will have to pay a set shipping fee of $12.99 on top of the $80 quarterly fee for your spirits. The full price is listed only after you sign up.

Full size bottles

If you decide to go with the Old Fashioned Club, you get full-size bottles of spirits and bitters to help build your favorite whiskey-based drink. This club also offers shipping or in-store pickup with a $12.99 shipping fee. The price for the Old Fashioned Club subscription itself starts at $85.

More clubs to choose from

There are also a variety of other clubs available at Bitters + Bottles including clubs for spirits like:

  • Rum
  • Gin
  • Negroni

So, if you want more than one spirit type, or you're looking for options to shake up your whiskey membership, Bitters + Bottles does offer a few alternate spirit options for you.

Special options for club members

On top of getting quarterly shipments of spirits, you also get access to select bottles of spirits on the website store. While anyone can buy items by the bottle if they choose, Bitters + Bottles members have access to more unique and hard-to-find options that the rest of their customers don't: the Club Store is completely separate and inaccessible for shoppers without a membership. If you want to pick from their general selection, their prices range from $25-$134.50 for a bottle of whiskey. This is much lower than many options in this review that offer high-end and extremely select bottles for sale. However, they do offer a range of options for your home bar such as bitters, mixers, and other fun ideas. Plus, with access to the exclusive store as a member, you will get a larger range of individual purchase options than the average shopper.

Best Whiskey Clubs

Website could use an update.

While some parts of the Bitters + Bottles website feel sleek and modern, some areas need a little retouching. For example, the purchase window feels old-fashioned and hard to navigate, and there are several typos on the website including "Shippin" instead of "shipping" at the bottom of the Old Fashioned page. It would also help future customers of Bitters + Bottles to know more about what they're getting in a shipment before they buy. Currently, the website doesn't offer a lot of detail in that department, and what there is on the site is hard to find.

Highest praise in this review

In terms of customer satisfaction, those who have purchased Bitters + Bottles are happy. Across the 300+ reviews, we found from third-party websites, Bitters + Bottles has an impressive 4.9 out of 5 stars from reviewers. Many of the reviews, however, are from customers who live in the California area and regularly stop by the brick-and-mortar location there. It was harder to find up-to-date reviews on the subscription service itself, and according to reviews that state the subscription used to be a monthly service, many of those comments that are available may be out of date for the new quarterly shipment service.

Build your bar

Bitters + Bottles seems to be a good option for those interested in building their home bar and improving their cocktail-making skills. The subscription box offers a curated selection of full-sized spirits, mixers, and classic cocktail recipes, with the option of choosing between the Whiskey and Old Fashioned Clubs. While the website could use an update, customer satisfaction seems to be high, with an impressive 4.9 out of 5 stars from reviewers. However, it's worth noting that many of these reviews focus on an older subscription model.

Strong choice for new mixologists

The price range for the general selection of bottles of whiskey is lower than many options in this review that offer high-end and extremely select bottles for sale. Bitters + Bottles seems to offer a solid option for those looking for a subscription box to improve their home bar experience, but it may not be ideal for someone who wants a new whiskey every month: this box is quarterly only.

Where's the Best Place to Join a Whiskey Club?

Many of us love a little nightcap or something tasty to bring out our inner bartender. As one of the most classic drinks out there, whiskey is usually top of the list. A versatile drink with a variety of flavors, or "notes" if you're a connoisseur, whiskey can stand out in your home collection as a sophisticated liquor for special nights.

But what if you don't know what to get? Or where to get it? That's where whiskey clubs come in. It doesn't matter if you're a whiskey superfan and you want to make sure you stay stocked up, or if you're looking to try new flavors once in a while, a Whiskey Club can make the process of buying your favorite drinks that much easier.

The Best Whiskey Clubs Compare Whiskey Clubs Compare Whiskey Club Reviews What are the best Whiskey Clubs Best Whiskey Club Reviews

Whiskey Club FAQ

A whiskey club is a membership that delivers delicious and rare selections to you on a regular basis. The bulk of these clubs require zero commitment and offer anytime cancellation, which is something to look into prior to finalizing your order.
The idea of a whiskey club is to try new brands and wonderful whiskey flavors unavailable to most enthusiasts. Each bottle is handpicked from the individual club and can originate in international lands far, far away or domestic distilleries across the U.S.
The frequency of whiskey club deliveries depends on you and your budget. Most whiskey clubs offer a variety of flexibility in terms of options. Choose from monthly, semi-monthly, or quarterly deliveries depending on your needs and wallet.
Whiskey clubs can be an amazing gift for the fine spirits aficionado in your life and those hard to shop for family members. Imagine delicious, hard to find and unique whiskey arriving each month to your gift recipient. Whiskey clubs can also make a well appreciated gift for any special client.
A Whiskey Sour is a very popular whiskey mixed drink. Here's how you make one:
Ingredients
  - 1 1/2 ounces of quality whiskey
  - 3/4 ounce fresh squeezed lemon juice
  - 3/4 ounce simple syrup
  - Ice
  - 1 maraschino cherry
Instructions
In a cocktail shaker, combine the whiskey, lemon juice, and simple syrup. Add the ice and shake. Pour into a rocks glass filled with ice. Then garnish with cherry!
The bulk of whiskey clubs cost between $69 to $239 per delivery, before shipping. The cost of shipping is also something to consider. Many companies charge a flat rate fee for each delivery, while others provide free shipping to customers. Whiskey club shoppers will find the option to pay in full or to be charged at each delivery.
Should the whiskey delivery appear damaged on a door step contact the customer service of the club that you selected. Most whiskey clubs are very customer oriented and want to fix any problems that happen if damage occurs in transit.
Each whiskey club package typically includes tasting notes. Tasting notes identify the whiskey distillery, often the history behind the business and any special aromas and flavors that the taster might experience.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

Whiskey clubs are organizations dedicated to the appreciation and enjoyment of whiskey. Members of these clubs typically gather to taste different types of whiskey, learn about the history and production of the spirit, and share their knowledge and experiences with other enthusiasts. Whiskey clubs can range from informal groups of friends to formal organizations with membership fees, events, and exclusive access to rare and limited-edition bottles.

There are many different brands of whiskey on the market today, each with its unique flavor and history. Some of the most popular brands include Jack Daniels, Jim Beam, and Maker's Mark. These brands are known for their quality and consistency, and they have developed a loyal following over the years. In addition to these popular brands, there are also many smaller, craft distilleries that produce high-quality whiskey.

Sometimes you can tell where a spirit was made just by the spelling: Whiskey (with an E) is American or Irish, for example, and Whisky (with no E) is Scottish, Canadian, or Japanese. Location-specific distilleries often use traditional methods and locally sourced ingredients to create unique and flavorful whiskies that are beloved by whiskey enthusiasts.

One of the main benefits of joining a whiskey club is the opportunity to try some of the new and unique whiskeys that might not be available in your local liquor store. Clubs often send curated shipments so members can sample different varieties of whiskey and learn about their flavor profiles and production processes. These events can be a great way to expand your knowledge of whiskey and discover new favorites.

Whether you prefer your whiskey neat, on the rocks, or mixed into a cocktail, there is no denying that whiskey is a versatile and delicious drink. So, either as a seasoned whiskey connoisseur or as a newbie just starting to explore the world of whiskey, there is something out there for everyone to enjoy. But it can be hard to know which whiskey club is the best place for you to start.

Here are a few important factors to help you get narrow down your search for a whiskey club:

  • Cost. What are the prices like? Do the membership fees match the quality and size of the spirits you receive?
  • What's in stock. Many Whiskey Clubs offer full-size bottles for purchase on their site. Make sure that the kind of whiskey experience you're looking for is available, whether that's local distilleries or European flavors.
  • Bottle sizes. Some companies offer samples only, while other clubs give you a full bottle. It's important to know how much whiskey you want. Do you want a taste test for different and new flavors, or do you want a full bottle to add to your growing home bar?
  • Frequency. How often do you want shipments? Many whiskey clubs allow you to decide for yourself how often you want it shipped. However, some have more limited options for a full-year membership only. So knowing how often you want a new spirit or how long you want to commit to a membership may help you decide.

If you're still not sure, Top Consumer Reviews is here to make the process of finding your next Whiskey Club an easy one. We have reviewed and ranked the best whiskey clubs out there today to help you find your next glass neat or on the rocks so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a few well-deserved adult bevvies.

The Best Reviews of Whiskey Clubs