Here you can see how Gold Medal Wine Club and Plonk Wine Club match up head-to-head in a battle for the Best Wine Clubs in 2025.
Gold Medal Wine Club is a high-end wine subscription that focuses on premium bottles from California and international vineyards. With club tiers like Gold, Platinum, and Diamond, it has plenty of high-quality wines to offer. While the wines receive strong praise in general, the extra shipping costs and limited third-party reviews may make Gold Medal Wine Club a better fit for experienced wine lovers with a flexible budget.
Plonk Wine Club is all about organic, sustainably-made wines without any additives or artificial ingredients, and it offers red, white, or mixed boxes shipped monthly. Each subscription includes 4, 6, or 12 bottles and ranges from $134.99 to $324.99 per month. While Plonk Wine Club earns praise for unique and clean-tasting wines, the limited a-la-carte options and lack of verified reviews keep it from being a top choice overall.
If you love wine, tracking down something new - or even a dependable source for your go-to Riesling, Moscato, or Champagne - can feel like a chore. Instead of relying on whatever the local shops have, consider a wine club: a subscription that delivers bottles straight to your door so your bar stays stocked without the last-minute grocery run. You won't have to remember to place orders, and you'll get a taste of the sommelier life at home with each shipment. Many clubs also tailor selections to your preferences, turning routine deliveries into an easy way to explore.
Wine clubs are all about convenience - perfect if you'd rather kick back with a glass and let someone else curate the bottles. Sign up once, choose how long you want deliveries to run (ongoing or a set 3- or 6-month stint), then just wait for the next box to land on your doorstep. There's no shortage of options, from distinctive small-batch picks and local bottles from homegrown vineyards to rare gems sourced from international cellars. Many services also let you skip a month or tweak your plan when your rack is full or your plans change.
Whether you want to keep your favorite rosé on hand or you're bored with the usual local picks and itching to discover new bottles every month, there's a wine club that matches the way you like to drink. Some lean into your preferred style - all whites or all reds - while others spotlight regional flavors or send curated selections handpicked by on-staff sommeliers. Many even let you rate each bottle so future shipments fit your palate more closely. Best of all, most deliveries arrive with tasting notes and other educational extras that help you feel like a wine pro.
Here's another perk: many top wine clubs run their own online stores, so you can quickly reorder the bottles you loved from your shipment, often at a steep discount. Members usually unlock even better pricing when they shop through the club's store, making it easy to stock up or grab gifts without overspending. Many clubs also offer member-only releases and early access to limited runs, which keeps the experience feeling special. If you're exploring new styles - or sending a few bottles to friends - these membership benefits can make a good thing even better.
If you're ready to sign up for shipments of bubbly proseccos, smooth reds, light whites, or fruity rosés, but don't know where to start searching, don't worry - we've put together a list of factors you'll want to consider as you check out your future wine club, Here's what you might want to keep in mind:
To help you find the right place to build your wine cellar, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked today's most popular wine clubs. This way you can pop a cork for an evening in with your favorite wine, entertain your friends with the best flavors, and continue your journey to be a wine expert. Cheers!
Compare Any 2 Products
How Wine Clubs Work
Wine clubs are great ways to learn about wines as well as discover your favorite new flavors. If you have years of wine experience under your belt or are brand new to wine tasting, wine clubs create an efficient way to discover and learn more about wine. From the convenience of your home you'll enjoy receiving your regular deliveries to taste and enjoy month after month.
If you've never purchased a wine club membership the idea is a little foreign to most. Each wine club is different but here's how the majority work.
Regular Deliveries
Depending on what you sign-up for, and the options available at your wine club, you can anticipate one to two bottles (or more) of wines delivered direct to your door on a regular basis. Many wine clubs offer a lot of flexibility in the number of deliveries you can choose from. Again, depending on the where you establish your wine club membership, you may select monthly, every
other month, quarterly, or semiannual wine deliveries. The more frequent your wine deliveries the higher the cost.
Wine Flavors
If you prefer white or red wine you'll want to read closely the options available at the club you ultimately select. Most companies don't give you a choice of what wines you'll receive each order but some allow you to choose what color. We liked the wine clubs that offer a bottle of each every delivery but for those that only drink red wine or white wine you'll be more limited in
the
options available. Be sure and look closely and find a club that best suits your needs.
Wineries
One of the benefits of discovering new wines, through a wine club, is trying a number of different flavors from wines manufactured in locations you wouldn't typically try. If you're very flexible about what region of the world your wine originates from then any wine club will probably due. For those that prefer international wines or wines only made in California there are also plenty
of clubs
to choose from that will specifically meet your needs - you just may have to look a little harder.
Repurchase
If you really like a wine that shows up at your doorstep and want more, many wine clubs have the flexibility to allow for you to buy additional bottles, outside of your membership deliveries, often at a discounted price. This is a popular reason why wine enthusiasts get into wine clubs - to discover new wines they love and have the option of buying more to share with their friends.
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.