Where is the Best Place to Find Wine Clubs Online? For wine fans, finding something new (or a reliable place to get your favorite Riesling, Moscato, or champagne) can be a hassle. Whether you feel limited by local shops or you just want to restock your wine bar, a wine club membership can be a unique way to bring a taste of a sommelier's lifestyle into your home. Wine clubs are subscription-based services that ship wine directly to your door. You don't have to worry about remembering to order or make last-minute runs to your local grocery if you're hosting a dinner party.
Best Option
Splash is a wine membership that started as a family business. Splash's founder, Rob, worked with his father in the winery industry, so when they started their wine club service, they already had tons of connections with vineyards and wineries to build their curated shipments. Wines from Splash include international vintages, with the goal of giving you an opportunity to try different grapes, different soil compositions, and different climatic conditions (and see how that impacts your wine flavors).
Pick from three tiers of wine
There are three different tiers for wine clubs at Splash, and the differences depend on how luxurious you want your wine bottles. The Standard plan includes wines from international wineries and is meant to have a broad appeal no matter what level of wine expert you are. The Vineyard plan includes specially selected wines from top vineyards around the world; these are more complex wine flavors that may appeal to those with more experience (or those looking to gain more experience). Finally, the Cellar tier is a selection of all red wines that are developed for expert sommeliers who are hoping to build up their wine cellar (though you can drink them right away too). All of the tiers offer a 6-bottle pack and a 15-bottle pack. You can choose to get your delivery monthly, every other month, or quarterly. Finally, you can choose your mix of all red, all white, or a blend (unless you choose the Cellar tier which is all red wine).
Pricing from $59 to $159 per month
The pricing at Splash includes the cost of shipping, which makes this a highly competitive option overall. The Standard plan costs $59 per month for 6 bottles and $89 per month for 15 bottles. The Vineyard plan is $69 for 6 bottles and $99 for 15 bottles. Finally, the Cellar plan is $98 per month for 6 bottles and $159 per month for 15 bottles. This is a notably lower cost for this number of bottles compared to prices we've seen at other wine clubs that offer the same or similar shipment sizes. So, if you're looking for a deal on tons of wine, Splash is a great place to subscribe.
Affordable wines, but you have to buy 15
Like a few other wine clubs in our review, Splash has an a-la-carte menu, but you can't just buy single bottles. Instead, you need to buy a case of wine (15 bottles total) to make a purchase. You can pick from 61 different wines, with prices ranging from $8.99 for a Sogno Italiano Rosso up to $24.95 for a Layer Cake Deep Roots Reserve Cabernet. In general, most of the wines on the a-la-carte menu are much more affordable than some we've seen (for over $100 per bottle) at other wine clubs.
Refund for any bottle you don't like
Splash offers a satisfaction guarantee that stands out from the pack. It states that if any bottle of wine doesn't meet your expectations for any reason, you won't have to pay for that wine. They'll completely refund you for the bottle, no questions asked. Plus, if you're choosing a recurring plan, you can cancel at any time. Splash stands out as a flexible choice for your next wine club: you try as much as you like for as long as you like.
Top quality for low costs
Currently, Splash has a middle-tier rating of a "B-" from the Better Business Bureau. However, it performs extremely well on third-party review sites with verified customer feedback. For example, on Trustpilot, Splash holds a 4.4-star average rating out of 5 across over 46,000 individual customer reviews. Almost 80% of all feedback is a full 5 stars. Recent reviews suggest that most customers enjoy the flavor delivered by Splash's wine club. Some customers had complaints about receiving rosé wines in a white wine box, but overall, customers say they are "pleasantly surprised" by the quality of the wine for the cost charged by Splash.
Top pick for cost-conscious wine fans
If you're looking for a low-cost wine club with lots of bottles in every shipment, you'll love the options at Splash. Whether you want white, red, or a mix of both wines, you'll get anywhere from 6-15 bottles per shipment without breaking the bank. With an impressive satisfaction guarantee and 46,000 positive reviews on Trustpilot, Splash stands out as one of the most affordable wine clubs in our review for the number of wines you get. Given that, it earns 5 stars overall. If you're a low-cost wine lover, you'll definitely need to check out Splash.
Great
Amazing Clubs is a one-stop shop of subscription clubs that is a favorite among many customers. The Wine of the Month Club is the Amazing Clubs' version of a wine subscription. It stands out with hard-to-find and premium wine flavors that are hand-selected by an advisory board that reviews each box, so you know you're getting the real stuff every time. Each shipment includes 2-4 bottles of wine and a variety of flavors that's a surprise every month.
Choose between 2 or 4 bottles in each box
There are two types of plans for the Amazing Clubs wine club: 2 bottles and 4 bottles. Regardless of which one you choose, both the 2- and 4-bottle clubs offer 3-month, 6-month, 12-month, and seasonal memberships if you prefer to pay ahead of time. If you want an ongoing membership instead, you can just choose the "pay monthly" option at the top. Amazing Clubs also allows you to choose whether you want 2 bottles of red or 2 bottles of white each month and your preferred frequency (between monthly deliveries or shipments every other month). The only difference between the 2 bottles package and the 4 bottles package is that there's no flavor selection option for the 4 bottles. You'll get 2 reds and 2 whites in every shipment regardless of preferences.
Pricing starts at $49.95 per month
The costs for this wine club are better the longer you subscribe. For example, the 12-month plan offers a much better monthly price than the shorter terms. Here's what we found for both subscriptions:
These are the only costs you'll be responsible for, as Amazing Clubs also offers free shipping throughout the continental US.
No a-la-carte selections
Unfortunately, unlike some competitors in our review, you can't buy any wines a-la-carte at Amazing Clubs because there isn't a separate online shop. Instead, Amazing Clubs is a one-stop shop for all things subscription boxes. So, if you want to find other subscriptions like beer clubs or cheesecake clubs, you're in luck with this provider. However, if you're looking to stock up on extra wines outside of your Amazing Clubs wine club subscription, you might be disappointed by this particular site. If you're curious about recent flavors, previous wine boxes included:
Cancel for a refund at any time
According to the satisfaction guarantee (that applies to all its clubs, including the wine club), Amazing Clubs promises that anyone who isn't fully satisfied with their wine club purchase can contact customer service at any time. Customers can cancel their memberships for any reason. If you decide to end your membership before a prepaid term is up, you will receive full credit back to you for any unused months (if you pre-pay for a 12-month subscription and only use 3 months of the shipments before canceling, you will get a refund for 9 months of your plan). On top of that, Amazing Clubs promises to do everything in its power to make sure you feel satisfied with how they resolved the issue.
High praise for customer service
Amazing Clubs has a competitive score with the Better Business Bureau, currently holding an "A-" rating. On top of that, it has an impressive 4.8-star average rating out of 5 on Trustpilot. A whopping 94% of all reviews for Amazing Clubs are 5 stars. While this includes feedback for other clubs sourced by Amazing Clubs, there were specific reviews for the wine club too. In general, customers praised Amazing Clubs for having competitive wine flavors that tasted fantastic. There were also a few customers who ran into small issues, like missing bottles, that were resolved immediately by the staff at Amazing Clubs. Many customers are repeat subscribers of the wine club, and have also gifted the club to other family and friends who enjoy wine too.
An established and reliable wine club
If you're looking for a reliable place to get 2-4 full-size bottles of wine every month, Amazing Clubs is a great place to start. It has high praise from customers and the cost doesn't break the bank. It's a great option for gifting, and the policy that allows for partial refunds of unused months is highly competitive. With praise for its customer service and the wide selection of trusted clubs at Amazing Clubs, it earns a great rating in our review and a high recommendation if you want professionally selected wine delivered to you each month.
Great
Firstleaf is a wine club that promises a deep level of personalization for your monthly shipments. The club starts with a questionnaire to help gauge your wine tastes, and "take the guesswork out of wine selection." Promising a 98% unique wine experience, this award-winning wine club asks you questions like whether you prefer red or white, and what level of sweetness you lean toward (on a sliding scale). You'll also be asked to rate specific wine flavors like Cabernet Sauvignon, Chardonnay, and more. Further questions include whether you prefer to be cautious or adventurous with your wine selections, and where you're at in your wine journey. Finally, Firstleaf will ask you some questions about foods that you enjoy (for wine pairing purposes), and your ideal flavor notes in wines you've had before. Then, Firstleaf will curate your box, and you're good to go.
Order 6 or 12 bottles
There's only one subscription box at Firstleaf, but you can choose between 6 and 12 bottles depending on how much you want in every wine club delivery. After you finish the quiz, Firstleaf will provide you with your suggested wines based on your answers. If for some reason you don't like one of the wines that Firstleaf suggested, you can click the "swap" button on any of the wines. Each selection will show you the main tasting notes. When we went through the process, we were suggested three reds, two whites, and one rosé. If you want an even better upgrade, you can add up to 3 bottles from the Fine Wine Collection, but there is an additional charge for this feature.
Pricing from $90 to $180 per month
The costs for this wine club are simple at Firstleaf, and sometimes you can score some discounts, so keep an eye out for those. The regular cost for 6 bottles is $90 per month. If you prefer 12 bottles, it's exactly double at $180 per month. For the Fine Wine Collection upgrade, you'll pay between $10 and $30 more depending on if you want to swap 1, 2, or 3 bottles in your shipment for a premium selection. As for shipping, you're in luck. Firstleaf offers 100% free shipping, and you can choose whether to have your wine shipped directly to your home or to a local store for you to pick up when you're ready (our shipment was recommended to be sent to a local Walgreens, for example). This is beneficial for those who are unsure if they'll be home to sign for the wine, since a 21+ adult is required to sign at delivery if the package is sent to your home.
Enjoy discounted wines a-la-carte
Firstleaf has a solid online store for buying wines a-la-carte. When you have a membership, Firstleaf will track your wines and ratings so you can easily find your favorites again and again. There are 228 different wines to browse including red, white, rosé, and sparkling. Costs start from $16 for Lost Dog Lane Pinot Grigio and go as high as $65 per bottle for a Noetic Merlot. Notably, all of the wines have two prices listed: retail price and member price (this is where those discounts we mentioned come into play). So, if you're a subscriber to the Firstleaf wine club, you'll get a discounted price on a-la-carte wines. For example, the Lost Dog Lane wine costs $11.20 for members and the Noetic wine costs $45.50.
Flexible subscription with no obligations
Firstleaf offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee to help with your peace of mind when subscribing to this wine club. If you don't like a wine that Firstleaf selected for you, the company promises to credit you for the price of the bottle. If you're not satisfied with the service, you can cancel your subscription at any time with zero commitment. On top of that, you can pause shipments if you want to shake up your schedule or plan to travel.
Top-notch wine selections
Firstleaf has a top-notch rating from the Better Business Bureau with a full "A+" rating and accreditation. On top of that, it's well-rated on third-party review sites like Trustpilot. Currently, Firstleaf holds a 4.3-star average rating from wine fans, with over 70% of all reviews holding a full 5 stars. Recent feedback notes that Firstleaf offers a unique selection of wines from different wine regions and extremely accurate selections based on the personalization quiz. Reviews frequently list Firstleaf as being a "fun" wine club with continuous curation of tastes and like/dislike profiles. Customers also found the orders were easy to track so they could sign for them as required, and there's also significant praise for the customer service representatives at Firstleaf.
Best pick for personalized wines
If you're looking for a wine club that has you in mind with every monthly box, Firstleaf is going to be a top pick. With an impressive satisfaction guarantee, free shipping, and a curated box that's based on your taste profile, Firstleaf is a standout among wine clubs of all kinds. With 6 full-size bottles at a minimum, you'll never feel like you're running out of wine, and it isn't too costly either. For these reasons, Firstleaf earns an excellent rating in our review.
Very Good
Winc is another forward-thinking wine club that bases its shipments on a quick profile quiz - to make sure the wines you receive are wines you actually want to drink. The quiz figures out your wine tastes with just six simple questions. During our research we found that Winc looks at whether you like a particular flavor or wine over another, what flavors or tasting notes appeal to you, what countries you want to try wines from, and what food you like (so they can suggest pairings). The final question is just a place to put in your email so you can sign up and see the results of your quiz.
Two plans for 6 or 12 bottles
There are two wine club plans available through Winc: a 6-Bottle Membership and a 12-Bottle Membership. The 6-Bottle Membership sends you 6 wines every month. On the other hand, the shipping schedule for the 12-Bottle Membership is repeated every 12 weeks instead. When we finished our quiz, we were suggested four whites and two reds for the 6-bottle pack and the 12-pack will just double each of your wines automatically. But if you don't like any of the wines for any reason, you can easily swap them out for something else.
Pricing at $102.40 per month or $204.80 per quarter
The wine club memberships are priced out depending on how many bottles you order. The 6-Bottle Membership costs $102.40 per month. The 12-Bottle Membership (which bills and ships every 12 weeks) is $204.80. While this is a little costly, the frequency of the 12-Bottle Membership makes this a little easier. Plus, both plans come with 100% free shipping. If you choose the 12-Bottle Membership, you'll also get a 10% discount on buying from the Winc a-la-carte shop.
Pick from 141 different wines
The a-la-carte online store is a great place to pick out your next wines for your future shipments or grab more wine in flavors you already love. You can find 141 different wines to browse on Winc's online shop. This is an average size for an online wine store attached to a wine club. Prices for wines range from $13.60 to $23.20 per bottle. So, you might not find some of the rare or pricey vintages seen at some other wine clubs, but you'll get some fun flavors without breaking the bank.
Replacement or credit for bottles
You can cancel your wine club membership with Winc at any time and as long as you haven't been charged for your next cycle (either monthly or quarterly). If any wine is damaged during shipping or is incorrect, or you have another reason that you're not satisfied with your wine, you can call the customer service team at Winc. They will either replace the wine or give you a credit to your account to be used for a different variety.
Praise for its customer service
Winc has a top score from the Better Business Bureau with an "A+" rating overall. It also has a positive reputation as a tasty wine club on trusted third-party review sites like Trustpilot. Currently, our research shows that Winc holds a 4-star average out of 5. Recent reviews are all 5 stars with many of the comments directed at the customer service team at Winc, with compliments regarding problem resolution and helpful communication. Other recent reviews praise the flavors of the wines, especially the reds. While a few customers complained about the refund process, it seemed that many did not understand the policy that refunds are only in the form of store credit. So, it's important to cancel before you are charged.
Perfect for wine newbies
Winc is a competitive choice if you're looking for a wine club that won't break the bank. With both a monthly and a quarterly wine club available, you can choose how often you want your wine, and either let Winc pick the flavors or completely tailor your experience with your preferred wines. While we wish there was a bit more variety (especially with more luxury or premium wines) it's a great place to start exploring if you're new to wine.
Very Good
Wine Access is a site for the top wine fans. It's got 9 different wine clubs to choose from that cover almost every "style" or theme you could imagine. Whether you want a club to discover new vintages, get collector-quality bottles, focus on the wines of the West Coast, or specialize just in champagne, Wine Access has you covered. Wine Access has experts who taste over 20,000 of the best wines (that sounds like our kind of job) to pick only the best vintages for your wine club boxes.
Pick from 9 different plans
There are 9 different wine clubs you can subscribe to through Wine Access. Here's what you can expect:
Pricing from $120 to $300 per shipment
Each wine club at Wine Access has its own cost that depends on the number of bottles and the quality. The prices are charged on the listed frequency. Here's what we found (listed from least to most costly):
Rare wines included in a-la-carte shop
On top of having tons of wine clubs to choose from, Wine Access also offers an extensive online store for a-la-carte purchases. Across the inventory, you'll find over 400 different wines to browse. This is one of the largest online wine shops attached to a wine club (though that's not surprising given how many different kinds of wine clubs are offered here). There is a wide selection of red, white, rosé, and champagne, too. The least costly wine at Wine Access is a Black Cabra Malbec for $14. At the high end (and we mean the really high-end) Wine Access offers a Domaine Coche-Dury Corton-Charlemagne Grand Cru wine for $6,550.
Never settle for wine at Wine Access
Wine Access has a competitive satisfaction guarantee with a "never settle" policy. This means that if you dislike any bottle you get during your wine club subscription for any reason, Wine Access guarantees that they'll credit your account for the order. Wine Access's membership is an auto-renewing membership, so to cancel, you'll have to contact them directly. If you want to change or cancel an upcoming order, you need to do so 24 hours before the scheduled order/shipping date to avoid being charged for that shipment.
Great wines and loyal customers
Currently, Wine Access is not rated by the Better Business Bureau, but it does have some competitive reviews on other trusted third-party review sites. For example, on Trustpilot, Wine Access has a 4.2-star average rating out of 5 with more than 75% of all reviews holding a full 5 stars. Recent feedback includes reviews from customers who have been buying wine from Wine Access since 2008. Many recurring customers highly recommend the flavors, and they love the helpful description sheets included in each order. One reviewer said he had "never had a bad bottle" from Wine Access.
Best pick for those who love luxury
If you're looking for a high-class place to grab your next wine club membership, Wine Access is going to be the one to beat. With rare vintages worth thousands, and 9 different clubs to choose from, you can pick exactly what you want with this subscription service. However, it does come with a bit of a price hike since you're getting premium wines in most of the packages. If you're not looking for a starting price of $120 every two months, you might want to check out some of our other highly-rated (and lower-cost) wine clubs instead. But if you have a larger budget, or you want a wine that will truly stand out, Wine Access is going to be the go-to for you.
Good
Cellars Wine Club is known for its wide variety of subscriptions to choose from. They've been around since 1999, and their club does more than just send you wine. When you subscribe, you get access to exclusive discounts, plus tips on enjoying your wine to make you feel like an official sommelier. Whether you want wine for yourself or as a gift for someone you love, Cellars Wine Club's Pinos, sweet, or sparkling wines might be right up your alley.
12 different clubs to choose from
There are a whopping 12 different options to subscribe to at Cellars Wine Club. Across the site, you'll find the Premium Club, 90+ Point Club, Red Trio Club, Sparkling Club, West Coast Club, Sweet Club, International Club, Organic-Natural, and the Rose Club for the normal size clubs (between 2-3 bottles per shipment). Cellars Wine Club also offers "Case Clubs" where you get a case of wine (12 bottles) sent each month. These include the Premium Case Club, Sparkling Case Club, and 90+ Point Case Club. When you click on one of the clubs, you'll get to choose the number of total shipments from 2-12, the frequency, and (for those that aren't type-specific) your wine preferences. You can also choose an "auto renew" if you'd prefer an ongoing membership.
Pricing from $49 to $369 per month
For all of the wine clubs here, you can choose to pay ahead of time for a selected period of time or per shipment. Each club has a slightly different price, so here's the breakdown:
The best part is the price you see is the price you'll pay, since Cellars Wine Club offers free shipping on all of its clubs. So, you won't have to worry about additional shipping costs during your subscription.
Unique wines, but no a-la-carte menu
Currently, Cellars Wine Club does not offer any a-la-carte wines. You can only buy this wine club's selections through the subscription plans. To give you an idea of flavors and vintages you might run across, we found some examples from past shipments. You might see wines like:
Enjoy a "No Bad Bottle" Guarantee
Cellars Wine Club offers a 100% "No Bad Bottle" Guarantee, so if there's anything wrong with a bottle of wine you receive, you can contact Cellars Wine Club to get the issue resolved. On top of that, it does have a stated refund policy, but the only details we found during our research showed that you have up to 30 days to request a refund. So, it is possible that if you get your first shipment of wine, you won't be refunded on a month-to-month payment schedule, but you also won't have to pay for additional shipments.
High praise from the BBB
Cellars Wine Club currently holds an "A+'" rating from the Better Business Bureau, showing that its policies and quality stand out among the pack. However, it's hard to find verified third-party reviews for Cellars Wine Club. It wasn't reviewed on Trustpilot or Sitejabber, for example. We did find some buzz on another review site, but there was only one review with a 4.5-star average. For this reason, we're a little more cautious, since many of the long-established wine clubs on our list have quite a few reviews. We'd love to see a bit more feedback for Cellars Wine Club as a whole. For now, their policies and BBB rating show that it's a place worth your consideration.
Good for those looking for unique clubs
If you're looking for a site with wine club variety, Cellars Wine Club is going to be one to keep an eye on. With international flavors, natural and organic wines, 90+ point wines, and more, you'll never get bored. You can subscribe for as long as you like, and if you decide something isn't for you, you'll be protected by the "No Bad Bottle" guarantee. For these reasons, we suggest you take a look at Cellars Wine Club, especially if you want a unique wine club or flavors from across the globe. It could do a little extra work by generating more third-party feedback and by offering an online store, but for now it still earns a solid rating.
Good
The California Wine Club is a subscription service designed to bring you a more custom-feeling wine experience, whether you're buying for yourself or as a gift for a loved one. California Wine Club has been around since 1990, and it offers access to premium red and white wines that are more exclusive or difficult to source, all coming from different regions of California. Most of the plans at this wine club include between 2-12 bottles of your preferred type of wine. These are all from "artisan" wineries that are vetted and tasted by the experts on staff at California Wine Club.
Pick from three wine styles
There are three different wine styles to choose from at California Wine Club: Premier Series, Signature Series, and Aged Cabernet Series. In the Premier Series, you can choose between 2, 4, 6, and 12 bottles of wine with your choice of all reds, all whites, or an even mix. The Signature Series has the same number of bottles available as the Premier Series, but you don't get to choose the wine style. Instead, you'll receive a mix of hand-picked premium wines (both red and white) from across California's artisan wineries. Finally, the Aged Cabernet Series offers 2, 4, and 6 bottle options and all of these wines will be Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley with occasional inclusions from Sonoma or Lake County.
Pricing from $49 to $807 per month before shipping
The monthly cost at California Wine Club can vary significantly depending on which subscription you choose. The least costly plan is a 2-bottle plan for $49 per month (from the Premier Series). If you want to subscribe for 12 bottles in that series, it can cost you up to $294 per month. As for the Signature Series, the lowest cost is $134 for just 2 bottles. If you choose 12 bottles per month, you're looking at $804 instead. Finally, the Aged Cabernet Series starts at $269 for 2 bottles and goes up to $807 for 6 bottles of wine. Notably, you will have to pay additional shipping fees. For our area, we were only offered one shipping option for $20 (per month) on top of the cost of the monthly club shipments.
A mix of low-cost and premium wines
California Wine Club's a-la-carte menu includes 60 different wines that you can buy at any time. The site offers flavors that range from $21 to $165 per bottle. There is a large range of wines and years available at California Wine Club. For example, our research showed some interesting choices like:
Refunds if you cancel before shipment
The only policy that California Wine Club offers regarding your shipments is that you're allowed to cancel a recurring subscription at any time. You will want to make sure to cancel before your next order ships since if you are charged, you won't get your money back for that month. However, since you don't prepay for any subscription plans, there isn't any additional balance to refund you. But, you will only be refunded for a charged wine club subscription month if the item has not already been shipped out.
Not as much buzz as other wine clubs
Currently, California Wine Club is not rated by the Better Business Bureau. We also couldn't find any third-party reviews on trusted platforms like Sitejabber or Trustpilot. The few third-party reviews we did find during our research were competitive. One site showed a 4.5-star average rating for California Wine Club (though it didn't have as many reviews as we've seen for other wine clubs). In general, it ranked well for wine flavor, variety, and customer service. The only real downside mentioned for California Wine Club was the overall cost. Since the prices can be high with more bottles, and shipping is not included, you may be paying significantly more than you might at some of California Wine Club's competitors.
A great pick for California wine lovers
While we love the high praise from the few reviews we could find on California Wine Club, we'd love to see a bit more buzz before it becomes one of our top recommendations. As it is, California Wine Club is said to have a great variety and impressive customer service. However, you are paying for it. This club is much more costly than others in our review. On the other hand, if high-quality Californian wines are a must-have for your home collection, you'll want to check out this wine club next.
Average
Gold Medal Wine Club is a premium wine club site that offers multiple club tiers to suit any taste. The company was founded in 1993 by David and Linda Chesterfield, who started out as wine collectors, and now they source delicious vintages to get the good stuff from their place to yours. The wines are sourced from vineyards located in California and around the world. The best feature? If you love one club, but are hoping for a bit more variety, you can switch to one of the other clubs with ease and without interrupting your shipment plans.
Pick from three quality tiers
There are three different wine club types at Gold Medal Wine Club: Gold Wine Club, Platinum Wine Club, and Diamond Wine Club. Each has a slightly different focus. The Gold Wine Club is one that offers award-winning wines with both red and white selections. There are options for 2, 3, 4, 6, or 12 bottles, and you can choose an all-white, all-red, or mixed monthly shipments. The Platinum focuses on 90+ rated extremely premium wines. You can choose from the same bottle number and flavor options as the Gold club. Finally, the Diamond tier only includes wines rated 92-99. These are the most luxurious wines. The flavor and bottle number options are exactly the same as the lower tiers.
Pricing from $49 to $1,320 per month
The costs depend on the level of luxury you want to pay for. At the low end, the Gold Wine Club starts at $49 for 2 bottles. The most costly for Gold is $249 for 12 bottles per shipment. For Platinum, the costs range from $114 for 2 bottles up to $684 for 12 bottles. Finally, the Diamond tier costs $220 for 2 bottles of wine and goes up to $1,320 for 12 bottles. Regrettably, the only way to get free shipping at Gold Medal Wine Club is by choosing the 12-bottle option, though this applies to Gold, Platinum, and Diamond tiers. If you want a smaller shipment, shipping in our area was estimated to be around $20 per box, which significantly increases the cost per shipment of even the Gold tier.
Pick from 74 a-la-carte wines
Gold Medal Wine Club does offer an online store with red and white wines as their main selections. The least costly wine offered by Gold Medal Wine Club is the Astral Fuego Chardonnay for $14. The most premium wine in the online shop is an Old Acre Winery Cabernet Sauvignon for $170 per bottle. There don't appear to be any special sales for members, but you can rebuy some of the in-club wines if you love one. There are a total of 74 different wines to choose from at Gold Medal Wine Club's store.
Cancel your subscription at any time
Gold Medal Wine Club promises that there is no ongoing commitment to your subscription plan. You can cancel at any time without waiting for any particular period and without penalty. If you make an individual order of wine, make sure that you cancel your order prior to shipment, or you won't be able to get your refund for the purchase. Your card will usually be charged at the end of the business day that you made your original purchase (and then the same time in subsequent months).
Not as popular as clubs with free shipping
Gold Medal Wine Club has a mid-tier rating of "B-" for its services on the Better Business Bureau. Finding reviews for Gold Medal Wine Club is a little difficult too. Most of the trusted third-party review sites don't have any reviews for this wine club. Instead, we found a few wine-focused blog reviews that had rated the Gold and Diamond tiers of this wine club. The gold has a competitive 4.6 stars from reviews and the Diamond has a higher 4.8-star average out of 5. According to the feedback, the wines themselves are high-quality and most customers loved their wines in both tiers. The only real complaint we saw regularly was that the cost of shipping was higher, making even the cost-effective club more pricey than similar competitors.
Best for those who prefer premium wines
If you're looking for the most premium wines on the market (and a lot of them) you might want to give Gold Medal Wine Club a look. However, with more costly shipping (except on 12-bottle packages) and a more expensive subscription overall, this wine club may not be for everyone. If you need those 90+ point bottles, though, this is a great way to explore new flavors. For these reasons, Gold Medal Wine Club earns a balanced score in our review. It's good if you're a connoisseur with a big budget, but it might not be ideal for more beginner wine fans.
Average
Plonk Wine Club is a site that specializes in providing only organic wines that are sustainably grown and sourced from around the world. Whether you want red wine, white wine, or a mix of the two, Plonk Wine Club has got you covered. None of the wines offered in this subscription include pesticides, herbicides, or colorants. You also won't see artificial sugars or any kind of alcohol enhancements in your bottles. Modeled as a "trust me" service, you'll need to rely on Plonk Wine Club's experts to pick out your bottles every month.
Pick from three flavor boxes
There are three different subscriptions at Plonk Wine Club: the Mixed Organic Wine Club, the Red Organic Wine Club, and the White Organic Wine Club. All three plans offer the same options: you can choose from 4, 6, or 12 bottles per shipment and between a month-to-month ongoing membership or a pre-paid membership for 3, 6, or 12 months. All of the packages ship out monthly for all the wine options.
Pricing from $134.99 to $324.99 per month
Plonk Wine Club makes its pricing simple since all of the different clubs cost the same. The only difference between the boxes is what wines you'll receive each month. The 4-bottle shipments all cost $134.99 per month, the 6-bottle boxes cost $184.99 per month, and the 12-bottle boxes all cost $324.99 per month. This package starts a bit higher than other wine clubs since you can't get anything smaller than 4 bottles. On the bright side, Plonk Wine Club offers free shipping on all orders (no matter which size you choose), so you won't have any additional costs on top of the monthly subscription fees.
Purchase minimum is 6 bottles in the shop
The a-la-carte shop works a little differently at Plonk Wine Club than you'll see at other wine clubs in our review. If you want to purchase from the online store, you'll have to pick a minimum of 6 bottles of wine. Otherwise, you can't buy a-la-carte selections. To help with this, Plonk Wine Club has put together 6-packs so you can easily pick up some extra wine. If you prefer to make your selections yourself, there are 34 different wines to choose from. Across the shop, costs for wine bottles range from $29.99 to $50.99. Here's some flavors you might expect:
No refunds for prepaid memberships
According to the FAQ, Plonk Wine Club does not allow you to get a refund if you choose a pre-paid duration of 3, 6, or 12 months. Our research shows that these prepaid membership fees are "non-refundable one-time credit card" payments. If you have an ongoing subscription, you can cancel any time, but you'll want to catch it before your billing period or you'll still be charged for the next shipment. In general, this is a much less generous refund policy than we've seen at most of Plonk Wine Club's competitors.
An eclectic choice according to reviewers
Despite its less-than-stellar refund policy, Plonk Wine Club currently holds a top-tier "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, it's hard to find any verified, third-party reviews for Plonk Wine Club. It isn't rated on most trusted review sites like Sitejabber and Trustpilot. On the other hand, other third-party review sites and blogs show a 4.3-star rating average out of 5 for Plonk Wine Club. Currently, the wine club has praise for its "eclectic" selection of wines. The main complaint is the lack of a solid refund policy, but overall, there is decent praise for the flavor of the organic wines.
Best for those who want organic wines
If organic is your jam, you'll want to check out Plonk Wine Club. However, if you're looking for the most cost-effective wine club subscription, you might be disappointed by this service. While it offers tons of healthy and environmentally-conscious choices, it isn't the best bang for your buck in terms of wine bottles, and the limitation of a 6-bottle minimum to purchase from the a-la-carte store makes it less competitive if you just want to buy a bottle of wine to stock up. For these reasons, it earns a middle-of-the-road rating in our review with the potential to move up if the amount of third-party feedback available increases in the future.
Fair
International Wine Club has been around since 1994. It specializes in sending you bottles from boutique wineries, and every bottle is curated by the on-staff tasting panel. With 4 different clubs to choose from, you'll get a taste of somewhere different with almost all international wines. However, International Wine Clubs' policies and offerings are about average when compared to other wine clubs in our review, earning it a slightly lower rating.
Choose from 4 wine clubs
You can pick from one of four total plans at International Wine Club: the Premier Series Wine Club, the Bold Reds Wine Club, the Masters Series Wine Club, and the Collection Series Wine Club. Each has a slightly different focus. For example, the Premier Series offers 2 bottles of international wines. You can choose 2 reds, 2 whites, or a mix (one of each) in every package. The Bold Reds is exactly what it says, two red wines per month with selections from California, France, Italy, and more. The Masters Series sends you two estate-bottled and limited-production wines from two different wineries each month. You can choose 2 reds, 2 whites, or a mix of the two every month. Finally, the Collectors Series offers only limited-production wines that have been well-aged. You receive 2 bottles of rare wines that include international selections every time. You can select the same distribution of wine styles as with the other mixed packages.
Pricing from $43.95 to $77.95 per month
The costs here are simple, but International Wine Club does charge separately for shipping, so you'll need to add that to your final total. The Premier Series costs $43.95 per month, Bold Reds costs $59.95 per month, Masters Series costs $57.95 per month, and the Collectors Series costs $77.95 per month. Every box ships for $16 per box no matter which tier you choose. While this isn't the most costly shipping fee we've seen in our review, it does set International Wine Club behind the pack a bit.
Enjoy 99 wines a-la-carte
There are 99 different wines that you can buy from the International Wine Club shop. You'll find an array of mostly red and white wines. The least costly wine on the site is a La Planta Ribera del Duero red wine for $15.25. The most premium wine is Gaicosa Fratelli Barbaresco, which costs $59.75. This is notably a smaller selection than we've seen at some other online stores attached to competing wine clubs.
100% satisfaction guarantee
If you'd like to cancel your shipment, you can do so at any time unless you subscribed to a promotional offer that might require a minimum term length. There weren't any promos at the time of our review, so there weren't any concerns there. On top of that, International Wine Club offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee that promises that every wine you get will meet your needs or they'll refund your purchase (or replace the wine, as the case may be).
Not a lot of buzz for this wine club
Currently, International Wine Club is not rated by the Better Business Bureau. Further, it's hard to find reviews for this company on trusted third-party review sites like Sitjabber or Trustpilot. We had to rely on other third-party sites in our research as well as wine bloggers to get an idea of the quality of this wine club. According to one review site (but based on only one review), International Wine Club receives a 4.6-star average rating. The customer felt that International Wine Club had an affordable mix of wines with high-quality flavors. However, the limit of only 2 bottles a month was a particular drawback (especially considering that most competitors offer 2-12 bottle cases).
Needs to work getting verified reviews
Given the limitations on the number of bottles and the fact that you can find international wines from other wine clubs online, International Wine Club doesn't stand out as well as it could. With no rating from the BBB or on trusted review sites, it falls a bit behind the pack. While its satisfaction guarantee keeps it competitive, and it offers low costs (before shipping) for the different club options, International Wine Club just isn't as competitive in other areas where competing wine clubs excel. If it improves its online reputation in the future, International Wine Club has solid potential to be a favorite.
Subpar
Wine Insiders aims to take the grocery store feel of shopping in person and really browsing through different wines and offer you an online shopping experience that has the same feel. The wine club maintains affordability and convenience as two of its main tenets, hoping to give you a top-quality experience without compromising your budget. While there's only one club, you can get a few variations, and with a dozen bottles of wine headed to your door, you'll have plenty of flavors to try while subscribed to Wine Insiders.
Pick from three flavors
There's one wine club at Wine Insiders, but you can pick between three style varieties: Red, White, and Mixed. Your first time subscribing will give you a discount, and you can use a coupon code provided by Wine Insiders to score almost half off your first shipment of wine. Each box comes with 12 bottles of your chosen variety. And, at the time of our review, the introductory box came with three bonus bottles of 90-point, award-winning red wine. The boxes ship out every 12 weeks no matter which flavor you choose.
Pricing $89 to $155 per quarter
All of the wine club flavors are the same cost, and all of them offer your first box at a discounted rate. At the time of our review, we were quoted $89 for the first shipment. Your subsequent shipments will be at the full price for 12 bottles of wine, which is $155 per 12-week cycle. On top of the wine, you'll also get a free professional corkscrew with your first shipment, to help you get started on your wine journey if you're just a beginner sommelier. On the other hand, shipping is not free with Wine Insiders, but it also isn't pricey either. We were quoted $2.95 for shipping and handling in our area.
Almost 300 wines in the online store
The wine store on Wine Insiders's website has about 288 different bottles to choose from including red, white, and rosé varieties. The least costly wine offered by Wine Insiders is a Cantus Rosso for $10.99. On the high end, you can find a Cameron Hughes Zinfandel for $27.99. So, there aren't a lot of rare or luxury wines on this a-la-carte menu. However, if you're fine with the more basic selections from this wine club, you might enjoy picking through Wine Insiders' extensive collection.
Refunds for wines you don't like
Wine Insiders promises a no-obligation wine club, so you don't have to worry about any issues with cancellation. As long as you cancel before your next 12-week cycle renews, you can stop your subscription without any worries about being charged. Wine Insiders also has a "perfect pour promise" that states that you'll love every bottle of your shipment. If you're not happy with a wine, Wine Insiders will issue you a refund for that bottle. You don't have to worry about getting a wine that doesn't suit your palate.
Mixed reviews about shipment quality
Wine Insiders has a stellar "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. However, its reputation is a little more mixed with other third-party review sites. On Trustpilot, Wine Insiders has a middle-tier rating average of 3.5 stars out of 5. This is almost evenly balanced between 1-star and 5-star reviews, showing a lot of disagreement on the quality of service at Wine Insiders. While some wine club customers had their concerns addressed immediately by customer service, others complained that the company didn't respond to calls. One wine lover noted that there was tampering evidence on one of his bottles where it had previously had the cork removed. There are also regular complaints about shipments missing items or containing fewer bottles of wine than ordered.
May not be worth the worry
At the end of the day, you don't want to buy wine and be worried if it will actually arrive. There are a lot of pros for giving Wine Insiders a try, but it doesn't stack up as well against our other services. Given the concerns from customers on Trustpilot, and the large number of 1-star reviews for this wine club, Wine Insiders earns a lower rating in our review. While it may be worth a look if you like lower-cost wine, you can find more reliable services among the higher-rated wine clubs in our review. You might want to check out one of those first.
Weak
Wine of the Month is one of many clubs offered by the GreatClubs company. In addition to wine, you can find clubs for beer, flowers, cigars, fruit, coffee, and more. The wine club, specifically, focuses on great-tasting wines in full-size bottles. You can expect red, white, or a mix of both, depending on your preferences. Plus, Wine of the Month offers a newsletter with every shipment to help you learn more about the ins and outs of wine. This is a great spot for gifting too, since you can include personalized gift letters to your loved ones when you send them a fun subscription to a wine club.
One club with three wines
The Wine of the Month Club focuses on sending you well-aged wines from limited wineries that are small and award-winning locations. Every box will come with 3 bottles of wine, and you can choose to receive only white wine, only red wine, or a mix of both. Your wine club membership can be prepaid for 2, 3, 4, 6, or 12 months; however, you can't just pick an ongoing subscription at this wine club. This differs significantly from other sites that allow you to choose an auto-renewing monthly payment. We were surprised to see you can only pre-pay at Wine of the Month. You can also choose to get your boxes sent every month, every other month, or quarterly.
Pricing from $49.95 to $52.95 per month
You get some additional savings on your wine club subscription if you pre-commit to a higher number of months. The 2 month club costs $52.95 per month for a total of $105.90 at the time of checkout. The 3 month option costs $51.95 per month for a total of $155.85, and the 4 month club costs the same as the 3 month option but is a total of $207.80 when all the months are accounted for. The 6 month club is $50.95 per month ($305.70 total), and the 12 month club is $49.95 per month or $599.40 total. On the bright side, all shipping costs are free of charge at Wine of the Month.
International selections in each box
Since Wine of the Month is one of many clubs offered by GreatClubs, you won't find any a-la-carte wines offered separately from the wine club itself. To give you an idea of the wines you might expect in the club boxes, we researched some of the previous shipments to see what other customers have received before. Here's what you might expect:
Cancel only after 2 months
Unlike many of the wine clubs in our review which allow you to cancel with no obligation, Wine of the Month requires that you stay on for a minimum of 2 months before you are able to cancel. Once you've completed your second month you will be able to cancel at any time. You can also take advantage of a 100% satisfaction guarantee which states that if there's a problem with your shipment, the company will replace the item or give you a refund for the items that didn't work out.
Not a lot of buzz
When researching Wine of the Month's reputation, you have to do a little digging. Wine of the Month is owned by GreatClubs, which is also owned by the parent company Clubs of America. This is the company that you'll find is rated by the Better Business Bureau. Currently, Clubs of America has a stellar "A+" rating from the BBB. As for other third-party review sites, we couldn't find any reviews on Trustpilot or Sitejabber for this company. There are plenty of reviews for companies of similar names, but not this Wine of the Month specifically. We also couldn't find any reviews for this wine club under either of its parent companies.
Restrictive and not well-known enough
At the end of the day, Wine of the Month doesn't quite stack up against the competition. Since you need to wait 2 months to cancel your membership, it's not as flexible as most wine clubs in our review. On top of that, you can't preview many wines, or buy any directly from the wine club site like you can with many rivals. While the prices aren't bad for 3 bottles of wine in every shipment, the costs are higher than average as you have to prepay for the period you want to subscribe for. For these reasons, along with the lack of reviews on third-party sites, Wine of the Month earns one of the lowest ratings in our review.
Continued from above...
For wine fans, finding something new (or a reliable place to get your favorite Riesling, Moscato, or champagne) can be a hassle. Whether you feel limited by local shops or you just want to restock your wine bar, a wine club membership can be a unique way to bring a taste of a sommelier's lifestyle into your home. Wine clubs are subscription-based services that ship wine directly to your door. You don't have to worry about remembering to order or make last-minute runs to your local grocery if you're hosting a dinner party.
One of the main perks of wine clubs is ease of use. If you're someone who likes to sit back and relax (preferably with your favorite vintage) and let someone else do the work for you, a wine club is right up your alley. You subscribe once, choose your length (many sites offer ongoing subscriptions or limited-time subscriptions like 3 or 6-month terms), and wait for your next wine package to arrive. There are tons of sites out there that offer unique wines, local vintages from home-grown vineyards, or even rare selections from international wineries.
You can pick and choose your experience, whether you want to keep your favorite rosé in stock or if you're bored of the local finds and want to try new wines you've never seen each month, there's a wine club out there that fits your needs. Some clubs cater to your favorite style, with all white wines or all red wines, while other wine clubs focus on local flavors or curated bottles that are hand-selected by professional sommeliers on staff. The best part is, with each wine shipment, most wine clubs will give you details like tasting notes or educational material that make you feel like a wine pro too.
Another benefit? Some of the top wine clubs in the industry also have an online wine store. So, if you find something you like in your wine shipment, you can easily re-purchase your favorite bottles over and over, generally at a significant discount. At the best wine clubs, subscribers get better deals if they shop for wine at their club membership store. So, if you're looking for other wines (or bottles to send as gifts) you might enjoy these perks of wine club membership.
If you're ready to sign up for shipments of bubbly proseccos, smooth reds, light whites, or fruity rosés, but don't know where to start searching, don't worry - we've put together a list of factors you'll want to consider as you check out your future wine club, Here's what you might want to keep in mind:
To help you find the right place to build your wine cellar, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked today's most popular wine clubs. This way you can pop a cork for an evening in with your favorite wine, entertain your friends with the best flavors, and continue your journey to be a wine expert. Cheers!
Compare Any 2 Products
How Wine Clubs Work
Wine clubs are great ways to learn about wines as well as discover your favorite new flavors. If you have years of wine experience under your belt or are brand new to wine tasting, wine clubs create an efficient way to discover and learn more about wine. From the convenience of your home you'll enjoy receiving your regular deliveries to taste and enjoy month after month.
If you've never purchased a wine club membership the idea is a little foreign to most. Each wine club is different but here's how the majority work.
Regular Deliveries
Depending on what you sign-up for, and the options available at your wine club, you can anticipate one to two bottles (or more) of wines delivered direct to your door on a regular basis. Many wine clubs offer a lot of flexibility in the number of deliveries you can choose from. Again, depending on the where you establish your wine club membership, you may select monthly, every
other month, quarterly, or semiannual wine deliveries. The more frequent your wine deliveries the higher the cost.
Wine Flavors
If you prefer white or red wine you'll want to read closely the options available at the club you ultimately select. Most companies don't give you a choice of what wines you'll receive each order but some allow you to choose what color. We liked the wine clubs that offer a bottle of each every delivery but for those that only drink red wine or white wine you'll be more limited in
the
options available. Be sure and look closely and find a club that best suits your needs.
Wineries
One of the benefits of discovering new wines, through a wine club, is trying a number of different flavors from wines manufactured in locations you wouldn't typically try. If you're very flexible about what region of the world your wine originates from then any wine club will probably due. For those that prefer international wines or wines only made in California there are also plenty
of clubs
to choose from that will specifically meet your needs - you just may have to look a little harder.
Repurchase
If you really like a wine that shows up at your doorstep and want more, many wine clubs have the flexibility to allow for you to buy additional bottles, outside of your membership deliveries, often at a discounted price. This is a popular reason why wine enthusiasts get into wine clubs - to discover new wines they love and have the option of buying more to share with their friends.
Top Products.
Top Reviews.
Top Consumer Reviews.
Reviews
Browse through thousands of reviews.
Social Media
Like us? Follow us! We'd love to have you join our community.
Newsletter
Stay up to date with the latest reviews. We'll keep you informed, and we'll never sell your information to anyone.
