Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Firstleaf Review

Monday, June 17th

2024 Wine Club Reviews

Firstleaf Review 4.5 Star Rating


4.5 Star Rating
  • $89.94 for shipments of wine
  • 6-12 bottle shipment options
  • Credits for reviewing wine and inviting friends
  • Free cancellation
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee
  • Quiz-based personalization
  • "A+" and accreditation from the BBB

Firstleaf is a wine club owned by Penrose Hill, which promises to be the "most personalized" wine club on the market, and as an award-winning service, it looks like they deliver on that promise. Firstleaf sells all its wine from its location in Healdsburg, California. Though they have only been in business for 8 years, Firstleaf has made an impact on the wine club industry.

Wines tailored to each customer

Each shipment at Firstleaf comes with 6 bottles determined by the answers you provide during a welcome quiz, resulting in a variety of wines to try each time you order. The wine club tailors its selection to customers through flavor profiling and an interactive rating system. You can customize your membership by changing the bottles you receive and/or your delivery dates. Firstleaf delivers to over 40 states and has won numerous medals in well-known wine competitions.

Quiz-based personalization

When you start the ordering process, Firstleaf asks you questions to find out your preferences. The quiz-like questions include whether you prefer sweet or non-sweet wines, which varieties appeal to you, what flavors you like in your wines (like butler or citrus), whether you prefer exciting or boring wines, what level of expertise you have, and which wines you dislike. Firstleaf's method of determining your preferences is an intuitive way of tailoring the wines you receive to your tastes. During the ordering process, you can change a bottle you don't think you'll like, and you'll see your expected ship date after you place your order.

Initial shipment is cheaper

The initial shipment includes six bottles at a discounted price of $44.95 plus tax, with free shipping. You can double your order to 12 bottles and shipping on 12+ bottle orders is always free. After the initial delivery, the monthly cost is $89.94 plus tax and shipping for six-bottle deliveries, but you can change the number of bottles and shipping frequency any time you want.

Best Wine Clubs

Credits for reviewing and bringing friends

As an added benefit, you can earn credit toward your next order by rating your wines. If you rate the wines within 30 days Firstleaf will provide you a $10 credit toward your next order. Providing ratings for the wines is the best way to communicate your taste preferences to the club's wine experts, who will use this information when selecting future club shipments. They also offer a "refer a friend" program that gives you $40 off your next box of wines and gives your friend their first six bottles for free.

Buy cases or bottles

On top of the 6- or 12-bottle shipment options, Firstleaf also offers an online shop where you can buy wine bottles or bundles a la carte. The selections for wine bundles include cases of red, white, and rose, as well as curated bundles in themes like "Best of the Old World" or "French Varietals" . You can also buy individual bottles for all types of wine including "exclusive' options only available from Firstleaf.

Compares favorably

To compare Firstleaf to other memberships that sell wine by the bottle, we looked at the price range for red wines. The reds range from $19 to $57 per bottle, and they can be purchased by anyone with or without a membership. As a perk, members get the added benefit of a discount between $10-$15 off each bottle of wine. While this does exclude some of the high-end bottles of wine, there is still a competitive variety that will appeal to most wine enthusiasts.

100% satisfaction guarantee

Another standout feature of Firstleaf is its satisfaction guarantee. Their promise of great wines includes every bottle they send you. If you are not satisfied with any wine, the company promises to credit you for the value of that bottle, no questions asked. On top of that, if you feel like you aren't satisfied with the club as a whole, you can easily make changes, reschedule, or cancel without any minimum commitments or cancellation fees.

Best Wine Clubs

60% lower prices than retail

Firstleaf keeps its prices down for customers by working directly with winemakers and wineries, enabling them to remove the distributors, importers, and retailers from the supply chain to the customer. This process promises to take as much as 60% of the price off, making sure that the wine club is low-cost and low-commitment for the members.

Top rated service

In terms of customer satisfaction, Firstleaf is one of the top contenders in our review. The company has an "A+" rating and accreditation by the BBB as well as a 4.4-star average on Trustpilot with over 500 individual reviews. Customers rave about the variety of flavors, the ease of ordering, and the pleasant experience of working with Firstleaf customer service. Some of the lower-rated reviews expressed frustration with shipping times and delivery dates. While this only makes up 5% of the overall reviews, it may be useful to know that you do need to be home to sign for the wine package, and this could be frustrating for some customers.

Best option for personalization and benefits

Overall, Firstleaf is a personalized wine club that offers a unique experience for its members. With its interactive quiz and flavor profiling, customers can receive a tailored selection of wines that fit their preferences. The club's commitment to customer satisfaction is evident in its satisfaction guarantee, credit system for ratings, and flexible membership options. Additionally, Firstleaf's direct relationships with winemakers and wineries allow for cost-effective pricing that benefits members. With its variety of wine options and flexible membership options, Firstleaf is an excellent choice for wine enthusiasts looking for a personalized and convenient wine club experience.

Where Can You Find the Best Wine Club?

Whether you're looking for a cool way to discover new and unique wines from all over the world, or you're looking to level up your nose and taste for wine, a wine club is a unique and exciting way to explore the wide world of sommeliers. Wine has so many intricacies and nuances that make it such a fascinating beverage. From the type of the grapes to the winemaking techniques used, every aspect of wine plays a role in its taste and character.

If you're a wine fan already, you may already know about wine pairings and the fun of choosing a wine for dinner or dessert. However, if you're new to wine and want to explore all the flavors in a wine club, you can look forward to novel ways to enjoy your meals and snacks with a little red or white on the side. In a good wine club, you can find out more about all the best wines and the different ways to experience them.

The Best Wine Clubs Compare Wine Clubs Compare Wine Club Reviews What are the best Wine Clubs Best Wine Club Reviews

Wine Club FAQ

A wine club is a membership that delivers wine to you on a regular basis and without any long term commitment. The majority of these clubs simply require you to cancel your membership prior to your next shipment. The fine print of each club should be perused before making a final decision.
The idea of a wine club is to provide delicious new wine brands and flavors that most consumers wouldn't otherwise have access to. Whether the wine originated from California's popular Sonoma Valley or a small and quaint village in Southern France, customers can take care in knowing that each wine is selectively handpicked by wine connoisseurs with great care.
The frequency of a wine club delivery really depends on you. Some wine club memberships offer a variety of flexibility in terms of options. Choose from monthly, semi-monthly, seasonal, or quarterly depending on your needs and budget.
On average, wine clubs start around $7 per bottle and up. The cost of shipping is also something to consider before buying. Most companies charge a flat rate fee for each delivery, while others provide free shipping. Wine club shoppers will find the option to pay in full or be charged at each delivery.
If your wine club delivery shows up damaged or missing you simply need to contact the customer service department. The bulk of wine club membership are very customer oriented and want to fix any problems that might occur during transit.
Typically, all wine club memberships include tasting notes. Tasting notes allow the wine taster to learn about the winery and history of the establishment. Generally, the aromas and flavors will also be listed along with food pairing.
Sangria is a very well-known drink that features wine. Here's one popular recipe:
  - 1 (750-mL.) bottle or sweet red or white wine
  - 1 c. orange juice
  - 1/2 c. brandy
  - 1/4 c. granulated sugar
  - 1 orange, sliced
  - 1 apple, sliced
  - 1 c. blueberries
  - 1 c. sliced strawberries
  - Other fruits if so desired
  - 1 (12-oz.) can seltzer
In a large pitcher, mix together wine, orange juice, brandy, and sugar then stir in oranges, apples, blueberries, and strawberries. Refrigerate until ready to serve, preferably 2 hours. Top off with seltzer before serving.
Wine clubs can be a great gift for the wine lovers in your life and those hard to shop for family members. Imagine delicious, hard to find and unique, wine arriving each month to your gift recipient. Wine clubs can also make a wonderful business gift for your special client.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

One of the primary benefits of joining a wine club is that you'll receive a selection of carefully curated wines on a regular basis, usually monthly or quarterly. You can have these wines at home, share them with friends and family, or simply savor them on your own. From the fruity, bold flavors of a Cabernet Sauvignon to the delicate, floral notes of a Riesling, there is truly a wine for every taste.

The best part about wine clubs is that they offer the chance to try different types of wines that you might not have come across otherwise. They often have exclusive access to wines that you can't find in stores or restaurants, which can broaden your horizons and expand your palate.

Joining a wine club is also super convenient. Instead of spending time and energy searching for new wines to try, you can rely on the expertise of the club's curators to provide you with a regular supply of high-quality wines. Plus, they often offer educational resources like tasting notes and food pairing suggestions, so you can learn more about wine and become a bit of an expert yourself.

If you're ready to say "Cheers" and celebrate a new Wine Club membership, we're totally on board. But with so many online clubs to choose from, it can be hard to know where to start. Here are a few important factors to consider to help you find the best fit for you:

  • Cost. What are the prices like? Are you being charged a fair price for the subscription based on the wines you'll receive? How do individual bottles stack up against pricing from other companies?
  • User-friendly shopping. Is the website difficult to navigate? Can you easily find the wine or club you're looking for?
  • Flexibility. Are you looking for an ongoing membership? Or are you looking to purchase a prepaid short-term club option? Perhaps you are looking for a club that lets you join some months and skip others? Thinking about the flexibility you want from your wine club will help you decide where to shop.
  • By the bottle. Are you only looking for a wine club that will ship you new flavors? Or are you looking for a place where you can enjoy club shipments as well as buy wine by the bottle? Some businesses offer deals for your membership that reduce by-the-bottle prices, which may help you as you look through the options.
  • Other products. Are you looking for more than just wine? Some club sites offer other memberships to foods, flowers, and more. Additionally, some wine club memberships offer a ship with not only additional wines but products like glassware to help you build your home bar.

Top Consumer Reviews is here to make the process of finding your next wine club a breeze. We have reviewed and ranked the best wine clubs out there today. We hope this information helps you feel ready to pop the cork and enjoy a glass of your next favorite wine as soon as possible!

Compare Wine Clubs

Select any 2 Wine Clubs to compare them head to head

  • Gold Medal Wine Club
  • Firstleaf
  • Wine Access
  • Cellars Wine Club
  • Amazing Clubs
  • The California Wine Club
  • Bright Cellars
  • Plonk Wine Club
  • Wine of the Month
  • International Wine Club
  • Wine Awesomeness
  • Harry & David
  • Picked
  • Vinesse Wines
Gold Medal Wine Club vs Firstleaf Gold Medal Wine Club vs Wine Access Gold Medal Wine Club vs Cellars Wine Club Gold Medal Wine Club vs Amazing Clubs Gold Medal Wine Club vs The California Wine Club Gold Medal Wine Club vs Bright Cellars Gold Medal Wine Club vs Plonk Wine Club Gold Medal Wine Club vs Wine of the Month Gold Medal Wine Club vs International Wine Club Gold Medal Wine Club vs Wine Awesomeness Gold Medal Wine Club vs Harry & David Gold Medal Wine Club vs Picked Gold Medal Wine Club vs Vinesse Wines Firstleaf vs Wine Access Firstleaf vs Cellars Wine Club Firstleaf vs Amazing Clubs Firstleaf vs The California Wine Club Firstleaf vs Bright Cellars Firstleaf vs Plonk Wine Club Firstleaf vs Wine of the Month Firstleaf vs International Wine Club Firstleaf vs Wine Awesomeness Firstleaf vs Harry & David Firstleaf vs Picked Firstleaf vs Vinesse Wines Wine Access vs Cellars Wine Club Wine Access vs Amazing Clubs Wine Access vs The California Wine Club Wine Access vs Bright Cellars Wine Access vs Plonk Wine Club Wine Access vs Wine of the Month Wine Access vs International Wine Club Wine Access vs Wine Awesomeness Wine Access vs Harry & David Wine Access vs Picked Wine Access vs Vinesse Wines Cellars Wine Club vs Amazing Clubs Cellars Wine Club vs The California Wine Club Cellars Wine Club vs Bright Cellars Cellars Wine Club vs Plonk Wine Club Cellars Wine Club vs Wine of the Month Cellars Wine Club vs International Wine Club Cellars Wine Club vs Wine Awesomeness Cellars Wine Club vs Harry & David Cellars Wine Club vs Picked Cellars Wine Club vs Vinesse Wines Amazing Clubs vs The California Wine Club Amazing Clubs vs Bright Cellars Amazing Clubs vs Plonk Wine Club Amazing Clubs vs Wine of the Month Amazing Clubs vs International Wine Club Amazing Clubs vs Wine Awesomeness Amazing Clubs vs Harry & David Amazing Clubs vs Picked Amazing Clubs vs Vinesse Wines The California Wine Club vs Bright Cellars The California Wine Club vs Plonk Wine Club The California Wine Club vs Wine of the Month The California Wine Club vs International Wine Club The California Wine Club vs Wine Awesomeness The California Wine Club vs Harry & David The California Wine Club vs Picked The California Wine Club vs Vinesse Wines Bright Cellars vs Plonk Wine Club Bright Cellars vs Wine of the Month Bright Cellars vs International Wine Club Bright Cellars vs Wine Awesomeness Bright Cellars vs Harry & David Bright Cellars vs Picked Bright Cellars vs Vinesse Wines Plonk Wine Club vs Wine of the Month Plonk Wine Club vs International Wine Club Plonk Wine Club vs Wine Awesomeness Plonk Wine Club vs Harry & David Plonk Wine Club vs Picked Plonk Wine Club vs Vinesse Wines Wine of the Month vs International Wine Club Wine of the Month vs Wine Awesomeness Wine of the Month vs Harry & David Wine of the Month vs Picked Wine of the Month vs Vinesse Wines International Wine Club vs Wine Awesomeness International Wine Club vs Harry & David International Wine Club vs Picked International Wine Club vs Vinesse Wines Wine Awesomeness vs Harry & David Wine Awesomeness vs Picked Wine Awesomeness vs Vinesse Wines Harry & David vs Picked Harry & David vs Vinesse Wines Picked vs Vinesse Wines
Compare the Best Wine Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Wine Clubs
See the Best Wine Club
The Best Reviews of Wine Clubs