Sunday, June 22nd
2025 Wine Store Reviews
Buy Wines Online
- Prices from $5.95 to $949.95
- 5,566 different wines
- Red, white, mixes, rosé, and champagne
- Oldest vintage: 2003
- Shipping starts at $25
- Returns within 30 days
- Stored in temperature-controlled facilities
Buy Wines Online is a wine store that's been around for over 25 years. This retailer specializes in direct-to-consumer services. With tons of wine in stock online, you can expect to see familiar as well as new and unique wines you've never found before. All wines in the Buy Wines Online store are kept in a temperature-controlled warehouse for maximum freshness, and the wine is handled directly by Buy Wines Online employees to avoid any chance of breakage.
5,566 different wines dating back to 2003
At the time of our review, we found 5,566 different wines in stock. To break it down a little, there were 761 Cabernet Sauvignon, 561 Chardonnay, 521 Pinot Noir, 344 Sauvignon Blanc, and 279 rosés. You'll also find red blends and sparkling wines at Buy Wines Online. Currently, the majority of Buy Wines Online's selection comes from California, but there are also a significant number of wines from Italy. You'll also see vintages from France, Spain, Argentina, and Oregon. If you're looking for older vintages, you might be disappointed. Currently, 1,383 of the wines at Buy Wines Online are non-vintage, and the oldest vintage you can find is 1 wine from 2003.
Great browsing experience and auto-ship options
Browsing on Buy Wines Online is easy. The range of filters on the left-hand side of the window will help you easily find what you want with just a few clicks. You can buy single bottles or large cases of "tasting sets” that include 12-20 bottles in one shipment. When you decide you want a wine (or wines), it's simple to add your selections to the cart with the red button on every listing. Adding wines doesn't interrupt your shopping, and you can keep browsing until your cart is full of all the bottles you want to try. If you decide to choose a tasting set, select from three options: a mixed set, an all-red set, or an all-white set. To make it easier, Buy Wines Online also offers an auto-ship feature. if you plan to regularly repurchase the same wines, for a 10% discount. Checkout is simple and Buy Wines Online lets you complete your purchase with Shop Pay, Amazon Pay, or Google Pay.
Prices from $5.95 to $949.95
To compare prices across different retailers, we looked at three types of wine at each wine store: reds, whites, and rosé. To show you an accurate comparison, we found the most and least expensive wine in each category. We also found the most expensive vintage to show the range of unique wines available. Here's what the prices look like at Buy Wines Online:
- Red wine: $5.95 to $949.95
- White wine: $5.95 to $324.95
- Rosé: $5.95 to $549.95
- Top vintage: Masseto 2020 (red) with blackberries, cherries, and black currants. This costs $949.95.
Shipping starts at $25 per bottle
Orders from Buy Wines Online are usually shipped within 1-2 business days. Shipping is promised to be the best rate in the industry. 1 bottle ships at $25 and the shipping fee is increased by $1 for every additional bottle. Notably, this is more costly than some of the wine stores in our review, showing this isn't actually the best rate in the industry. The cost caps at $39 for 15 bottles. Anything above that is considered a "separate package” which you'll pay for starting at an additional $25 for one bottle and repeating the "package” increase until you hit another $39.
30 days for returns, but you pay restocking fees
Buy Wines Online promises that if you have any issues with your order, they're happy to assist. You just need to contact Buy Wines Online within 30 days of your purchase day. Buy Wines Online will arrange for pickup of your wine, and once the items are back in the warehouse, you will be issued a refund for the items you returned. Shipping and restocking fees may be deducted from your final return amount, but the totals aren't listed on the Buy Wines Online return policy.
Extremely strong opinions on quality
Currently, Buy Wines Online does not have a page with the Better Business Bureau. So, most of the feedback we found came from third-party websites like Trustpilot. There aren't a lot of reviews out there, though. We found just 21 individual reviews for Buy Wines Online on Trustpilot, and they were almost evenly split between 1- and 5-star ratings. While some customers praise fast shipping and solid packaging to protect the wine, others complain about dishonest sales practices, rude customer service, and issues with delivery windows (where they needed to be home to accept the order). While we aren't sure how trustworthy Buy Wines Online is, we can see that former shoppers have some strong feelings about their experiences.
Reputation doesn't impress
While the selection is competitive if you don't mind newer vintages, we aren't overly impressed with Buy Wines Online. On top of the polarized opinions in customer reviews, we don't love the unclear policies regarding return shipping and restocking fees. Given the opportunities to find unique wines at other retailers, Buy Wines Online doesn't quite make it to the "average” mark in our review. It needs to do a little work on its reputation before it can earn a higher rating.
More Wine Store Reviews
The 9 Best Wine Stores
Which Wine Store is the Best?
It's 5 o'clock somewhere, and wherever you're located, shopping for the right wine can be a wonderful way to relax at the end of a long day. Whether you're looking for a perfect pairing to go with dinner or searching for a gift to surprise your in-laws, there's always an occasion for wine. And, it's no wonder wine is a favorite. It's been around for thousands of years.
The oldest known traces of grape wine production have been found in digs in Georgia (in Europe) that date back to 6000 BC. Wine has been a staple throughout Ancient Greece, the Roman Empire, and modern times. And it isn't location-specific, either. You can find wines made all over the globe, from the USA to the Middle East, to world-renowned wineries in Italy and France.
Wine Store FAQ
Continued from above...
With so much history behind wine, it's not such a surprise that there are so many kinds to choose from. Whether you have a staple favorite or you're a burgeoning sommelier hoping to try them all, there are tons of choices from around the world. From Sauvignon Blanc to Merlot, or Chardonnay to Pinot Grigio, there are plenty of flavors, grapes, and vineyards to pick from.
You can even find some unique distilleries like those in Japan that offer Plum Wine or Rice Wine (better known as Sake). Whatever your pleasure, there's wine (or wines) out there just for you. You may never get tired of this longtime favorite boozy beverage. But the trick is finding the best wine store to score those sweet reds, fruity whites, or balanced rosés.
There are tons of places to find good, great, and rare wines, and it can be hard to decide where to start browsing. Whether you're looking to pick out a single bottle or stock your home wine cellar, shopping online can take a lot of the travel worries out of purchasing your favorite flavors. With access to wineries around the world, online wine stores offer a wider variety than at your local shop or a winery that just produces its own vintages. Plus, someone else can do the heavy lifting for you, so if you are buying a case (or two), getting the wine shipped through an online service can save you some sore muscles from moving the bottles from the shelf to the cart to the car.
Now, if your head is spinning from too many options, we've got your back. We get it, the internet is overflowing with wine stores and wines to choose from. How do you pick out the best wine store for your needs? To help you narrow the field (or vineyard, we should say), here are a few factors you can consider:
- Cost. Whether you're looking for your everyday red wine or something a little exotic, the price matters. If you can find a wine somewhere for a slightly lower cost, it's definitely worth a look. Some wine stores charge you a retail price that's padded for extra profit. So, make sure you get good value for your money. Check sizes, vintages, and quality to make sure that if you want to pay top dollar for some fancy wine, you get your money's worth.
- Shipping. Since you're shipping something breakable and perishable, you'll want to check out the shipping policies for the wine store you're considering. Make sure the shipping costs are competitive with other stores, and check for guarantees against breakage or damaged bottles.
- Wine selection. The selection of wine is a big deal for choosing a wine store. You don't want to pay for shipping just to find the same few wines you'll get at your local grocery store. Make sure the wine store you pick has a competitive variety that carries all the wines you want plus all the ones you want to try too.
- Reputation. A wine store's reputation can tell you a lot about the quality of its vintages and service. Look for wine stores that have "A+” ratings from the Better Business Bureau or that have lots of positive reviews from other amateur (or pro) sommeliers out there. That way, you'll know you're getting the best wine for your money.
To help you with your home wine cellar (or maybe just a wine shelf), Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked today's top wine stores. We hope this helps you sit back, relax, and enjoy a glass or two of your favorite bubbly or fruity vintages. You deserve a little treat. And maybe, you'll be able to try some new flavors or wines you've never considered. Cheers!
Compare Wine Stores
Select any 2 Wine Stores to compare them head to head
Trending Wine News
Related Wine Store Reviews
Since you're interested in Wine Stores, here are some other reviews you might find interesting.
Newest Reviews
