Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Wine Insiders Review

Saturday, February 15th

2025 Wine Store Reviews

Wine Insiders Review 4 Star Rating

Wine Insiders

4 Star Rating
  • Prices from $9.99 to $27.99
  • 220 different wines
  • Red, white, and rosé
  • Oldest vintage: 2018
  • Free shipping on orders with 6+ bottles
  • 100% satisfaction guarantee for refunds
  • 4.6-star average
  • "A+” rating from the BBB

Wine Insiders is an online wine store that hopes to make shopping for wine easy, convenient, and fun. It also promises to make it more affordable. When considering how to design the site, the team at Wine Insiders wanted to avoid the feeling of a grocery store wine aisle: a wall of wine with no helpful details. So, Wine Insiders created an online wine store that mixes the affordability of traditional retail prices but offers the ease of use that comes from an online platform. They partner with wineries to get you the deals directly, so you're not paying for exorbitant markups.

220 wines with a vintage from 2018

Wine Insiders offers 220 different wines focusing primarily on the three major wine styles: red, white, and rosé. Breaking them down, we found 130 red wines, 18 rosés, and 72 whites. You'll find wines from 10 different countries. Most of the selections come from the United States (54 wines), but there are plenty from Spain and Italy too. You'll also see wine from Argentina, Australia, Chile, France, Hungary, Mexico, and South Africa. The earliest vintage we found at Wine Insiders was from 2018.

Clean site with simple filters

You can easily browse all of the wines offered by Wine Insiders or simplify your search by looking at sets, featured wines, or wine collections by celebrity partners like Martha Stewart, Geoffrey Zakarian, and Ludo Lefebvre. When you decide how you want to browse, the site offers filters like color, sweetness, country, varietal, and vintage to narrow the bottles to the perfect wine for you. Some additional filters include wines separated by those that have won awards, those that are 100% organic, staff picks, and vegan wines. While it isn't the most robust filtering system (like the one offered by our top pick), it does the job and Wine Insiders remains easy to use.

Best Wine Stores

Prices from $9.99 to $27.99

The prices at Wine Insiders are meant to be impressively low. So, to compare the numbers with other wine stores in our review, we looked at the price ranges for all three of Wine Insiders' major selections: red, white, and rosé. We also looked for the most expensive vintage offered at Wine Insiders to see how the top-quality wines stack up. Here's what we found from Wine Insiders:

  • Red wine: $9.99 to $27.99
  • White wine: $10.99 to $21.99
  • Rosé: $11.99 to $24.99
  • Top vintage: 2020 Leo by Leo Medoc Bordeaux with red fruit and chocolate aromas. This costs $31.99 full price.

In all, Wine Insiders succeeds at offering affordable wines. However, if you're looking for older or collectible vintages, you may be disappointed by the selection.

Shipping free if you buy 6+ bottles

Wine Insiders offers free shipping on any order of 6 or more bottles. Notably, you will need to purchase a minimum of 3 bottles of wine to complete checkout. If you don't reach the 6-bottle threshold, shipping will be around $14.95. There may also be a small processing fee. For our test order, the fee was $2.95. If you score free shipping, the processing fee will still apply, but it doesn't go up if you buy more bottles.

100% satisfaction guarantee

Wine Insiders offers a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If you're not completely happy with your wine (any wine for any reason), you can reach out to the Wine Insiders customer service and you'll get a refund. The fastest way to contact Wine Insiders is to call them or use the Live Chat feature. You can get your refund started anytime between 9:00 am to 6:30 pm (EST) on Mon-Fri. If you need help on a weekend, the hours are adjusted to 10:00 am-7:00 pm (EST).

Best Wine Stores

Solid reviews, but could have more buzz

Wine Insiders has a solid presence on the few reviews that are out there. Trustpilot shows just 25 total reviews, but 48% of those are all 5 stars. There are a few more reviews on Sitejabber (1,036 total reviews) where Wine Insiders currently holds a 4.6-star average out of 5. Many of the reviews show customers who are consistently happy with the quality, free shipping options, and flavors of Wine Insiders' wines. There are multiple reviews commending the packaging for transit. From the few poor reviews, Wine Insiders could stand to improve its customer service responsiveness and better resolutions when issues do pop up. Thankfully, Wine Insiders does respond to every review (good and bad) with solutions on Sitejabber. Plus, Wine Insiders has an outstanding reputation with the Better Business Bureau where the company holds an "A+” rating as well as a 4.6-star average out of 5.

Great low-cost option

Wine Insiders is a great site for low-cost wines from a site that specializes in shipping wine directly to your door. If you're looking to try a couple of bottles of wine, this is a great no-commitment-required wine store. While it could use a little improvement in customer service, it's still a solid choice for your next low-cost wine store. For this reason, it earns a solid rating in our review.

Which Wine Store is the Best?

It's 5 o'clock somewhere, and wherever you're located, shopping for the right wine can be a wonderful way to relax at the end of a long day. Whether you're looking for a perfect pairing to go with dinner or searching for a gift to surprise your in-laws, there's always an occasion for wine. And, it's no wonder wine is a favorite. It's been around for thousands of years.

The oldest known traces of grape wine production have been found in digs in Georgia (in Europe) that date back to 6000 BC. Wine has been a staple throughout Ancient Greece, the Roman Empire, and modern times. And it isn't location-specific, either. You can find wines made all over the globe, from the USA to the Middle East, to world-renowned wineries in Italy and France.

The Best Wine Stores Compare Wine Stores Compare Wine Store Reviews What are the best Wine Stores Best Wine Store Reviews

Wine Store FAQ

Wine is typically shipped in specially designed boxes that protect the bottles from damage. The boxes may also include insulation and ice packs to keep the wine at the proper temperature during shipping. Some online wine stores even offer options for expedited or temperature-controlled shipping.
This depends on the policies of the online wine store. Some stores may allow returns or exchanges, while others may not. If you're concerned about this, be sure to check the store's return policy before placing an order.
Shipping costs for wine can vary depending on the size of your order, the distance the wine needs to be shipped, and the shipping options you choose. Some online wine stores offer free shipping for orders over a certain amount.
This depends on the policies of the online wine store. Some stores may allow you to specify a delivery date, while others may not. You can check the store's delivery policy before placing an order.
The delivery time for wine orders can vary depending on the distance the wine needs to be shipped and the shipping options you choose. Most online wine stores provide estimated delivery times on their websites.
Yes! Many online wine stores offer a wide selection of rare and hard-to-find wines. However, these wines may be in high demand and may sell out quickly. Be sure to check the in-stock availability of these wines before placing your order.
Many online wine stores offer discounts or promotions to customers. These may include discounts on specific wines or wine bundles, free shipping, or other special offers. You can check the store's website or sign up for their newsletter to stay informed about current promotions.
In most cases, yes. Ultimately it depends on the laws in your jurisdiction. In some states in the United States, it is legal to purchase wine online, while in others it is only legal to purchase wine from in-state wineries or through a licensed retailer. Most online wine stores will alert you to any issues prior to placing an order. If you're still concerned, you can cneck the laws in your area before purchasing wine online.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

With so much history behind wine, it's not such a surprise that there are so many kinds to choose from. Whether you have a staple favorite or you're a burgeoning sommelier hoping to try them all, there are tons of choices from around the world. From Sauvignon Blanc to Merlot, or Chardonnay to Pinot Grigio, there are plenty of flavors, grapes, and vineyards to pick from.

You can even find some unique distilleries like those in Japan that offer Plum Wine or Rice Wine (better known as Sake). Whatever your pleasure, there's wine (or wines) out there just for you. You may never get tired of this longtime favorite boozy beverage. But the trick is finding the best wine store to score those sweet reds, fruity whites, or balanced rosés.

There are tons of places to find good, great, and rare wines, and it can be hard to decide where to start browsing. Whether you're looking to pick out a single bottle or stock your home wine cellar, shopping online can take a lot of the travel worries out of purchasing your favorite flavors. With access to wineries around the world, online wine stores offer a wider variety than at your local shop or a winery that just produces its own vintages. Plus, someone else can do the heavy lifting for you, so if you are buying a case (or two), getting the wine shipped through an online service can save you some sore muscles from moving the bottles from the shelf to the cart to the car.

Now, if your head is spinning from too many options, we've got your back. We get it, the internet is overflowing with wine stores and wines to choose from. How do you pick out the best wine store for your needs? To help you narrow the field (or vineyard, we should say), here are a few factors you can consider:

  • Cost. Whether you're looking for your everyday red wine or something a little exotic, the price matters. If you can find a wine somewhere for a slightly lower cost, it's definitely worth a look. Some wine stores charge you a retail price that's padded for extra profit. So, make sure you get good value for your money. Check sizes, vintages, and quality to make sure that if you want to pay top dollar for some fancy wine, you get your money's worth.
  • Shipping. Since you're shipping something breakable and perishable, you'll want to check out the shipping policies for the wine store you're considering. Make sure the shipping costs are competitive with other stores, and check for guarantees against breakage or damaged bottles.
  • Wine selection. The selection of wine is a big deal for choosing a wine store. You don't want to pay for shipping just to find the same few wines you'll get at your local grocery store. Make sure the wine store you pick has a competitive variety that carries all the wines you want plus all the ones you want to try too.
  • Reputation. A wine store's reputation can tell you a lot about the quality of its vintages and service. Look for wine stores that have "A+” ratings from the Better Business Bureau or that have lots of positive reviews from other amateur (or pro) sommeliers out there. That way, you'll know you're getting the best wine for your money.

To help you with your home wine cellar (or maybe just a wine shelf), Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked today's top wine stores. We hope this helps you sit back, relax, and enjoy a glass or two of your favorite bubbly or fruity vintages. You deserve a little treat. And maybe, you'll be able to try some new flavors or wines you've never considered. Cheers!

The Best Reviews of Wine Stores