Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

Shoe Carnival Review

Tuesday, October 8th

2024 Women's Shoe Store Reviews

Shoe Carnival Review 2.5 Star Rating

Shoe Carnival

2.5 Star Rating
  • Priced from $14.98 to $309.99
  • Almost 8,000 options for women's shoes
  • 60-day return policy

Shoe Carnival was founded in 1978 by David Russell, and in 2021, they acquired Shoe Station. Their headquarters is located in Evansville, Indiana. Shoe Carnival stores are located in 35 states and Puerto Rico along with the retailer's online storefront.

Large variety of products

Shoe Carnival has 7,920 options when looking at women's shoes. Amongst these are Y-Not Craft Sandals for $14.98 and Dan Post Loverly Over the Knee Western Boots for $309.99. They offer women's shoes in sizes 5 through 14 depending on the shoe. Their website provides information about the features of the shoe, customer reviews and how to choose a size. Some of the shoes included the heel height, but not all of them.

Returning your shoes

If you need to return your new shoes, you have 60 days to do it. The shoes must be in new, unused condition and contain all the original packaging. Shoe Carnival will accept used items if there is an obvious defect. If you purchased your new shoes online, you may return them online or to any of the retail store locations. If they were purchased in store, then they must also be returned in store.

Best Women's Shoe Stores

Spend $75 for free shipping

Shoe Carnival offers free standard shipping on their shoes, but you must spend $75 or more. If you haven't spent $75 or you need your new shoes sooner, they have some other options that will cost extra. Standard shipping on shoes under $75, it will cost $7.95 and take 4-7 business days. Expedited shipping will cost $13.95 and will arrive in 2-3 business days. Rush shipping on shoes will cost $22.95 and they will arrive in 1-2 business days.

Numerous negative reviews

The Better Business Bureau has awarded Shoe Carnival an "A+” rating. However, their customer reviews speak differently: over 80% of them are negative. Some shoppers are upset with the poor customer service being offered. Others said they had extra charges when they checked out. One even said the cashier never asked them to donate to a charity, yet charged them multiple dollars for a donation. Some customers said the shoes are difficult to return and they do not make the process an easy one. Finally, multiple customers experienced their shoes being delivered to the wrong location or missing altogether. Getting assistance to rectify this was proven difficult by numerous customers.

Better options are out there

When looking to purchase women's shoes, there are better options out there than Shoe Carnival. There are many other locations with a lower amount to spend for free shipping and they have better customer satisfaction. The only reason this company didn't get a lower score was their "A+” Better Business Bureau rating. Between having to spend $75 to get free shipping and numerous negative complaints, we do not recommend purchasing shoes here.

Which Women's Shoe Store is Best?

Everyone wears shoes, and their look and comfort matter. These are something everyone will use on a daily basis whether it be for going to work, exercise or even slippers to wear around the house.

For some women, there is nothing more fun than splurging on some new kicks. Having the perfect pair to accentuate any outfit is a must. While it can be enjoyable to go from shoe retailer to shoe retailer, it doesn't offer the instant selection that online shopping does. Not only do you get a wide variety of shoe styles, but you can compare prices and score great deals when buying shoes online. And if you score a great deal, why not buy two pairs of shoes instead of one?

The Best Women's Shoe Stores Compare Women's Shoe Stores Compare Women's Shoe Store Reviews What are the best Women's Shoe Stores Best Women's Shoe Store Reviews

Women's Shoe Store FAQ

Luckily shoe sizes don't vary much from retailer to retailer. If you have a few pairs of shoes in a certain size that fit comfortably, don't hesitate to go off of that number for any shoes you're buying online. Some product descriptions will let you know if customers generally feel like the shoe runs big or small, so this could help you know if you should size up or down.
Yes! Almost all women's shoe retailers online have a return policy that allows you to return or exchange your items. Read the company policy before submitting an order so that you know how long you have to send your shoes back if needed. Usually return policies are anywhere from 30-90 days. Sometimes you are even able to buy your shoes online and return them in-person to one of their stores if you have one locally.
A better question would be what shoes are not available online? You can find platform heels, hiking boots, sandals, ankle boots, snow boots, slippers, and everything in-between from online shoe retailers. Most companies will have an inventory with thousands of different styles for you to choose from.
Since online women's shoe retailers carry such a big selection of shoes, they make it easy to narrow down their selection. Most websites have filter features that allow you to select the type of shoe you want, size, color, features, material, and other relevant details so that you can find what you want quickly. If you know the name of the shoe or brand, you could always type it into the retailer's search bar and find them that way.
It is not uncommon for shoes to come in regular sizes and also have the option for them to be wide. This is something you would select from the product page. When you're using the filtering features to find shoes you like, there is usually a way to select that you only want to browse the shoes that come in wide sizes as well.
Shopping online gives you access to browse thousands more pairs of women's shoes than you would find going into a store. In addition, you can compare prices between retailers and get a lot more details on the shoes than you would if you saw them in a store. Oftentimes, online shops run sales that end up making your purchase even cheaper than it would be otherwise.
If you're shopping from a reputable online women's shoe shop that has a good Better Business Bureau rating, you won't have an issue with shoe quality. Most product listings allow for customers to leave reviews about the shoes so that you can read what others have said about quality, price, comfort, and more. Buying online doesn't make the quality of shoes any less than you'd find in-store.
The cost for women's shoes depends entirely on the brand, style, and type of shoe you're buying. You can easily find a nice, cute pair of shoes for anywhere between $20 and $80. Know the price range you're hoping to stay in before shopping online and you can filter your shoe options to fit your budget.
Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

When you shop for women's shoes online, you're more likely to find the exact shoe you want down to the pattern, brand, type, size, and color. Some online retailers even have customer reviews for all their products that let you know if the shoe is good quality and if others have found them comfortable. The world of online shopping opens you up to endless options when it comes to finding the most stylish pair of shoes to flaunt around town.

When looking to buy women's shoes, you need to know their purpose. Are you looking for a casual, everyday shoe? A shoe for exercise? Shoes for work or dressy occasions? Do you want heels or flats? With most stores carrying boots, sneakers, casual shoes, sandals and slippers, you'll want to use filters to narrow down the options when you go to websites looking for your next kicks.

Also when choosing a retailer for your next pair of women's shoes, you need to determine what quality of shoe you are looking for. Does price matter, or is craftsmanship your main focus? Are you looking for a designer over function?

As you consider where to purchase your next pair of women's shoes, here are a few key features to consider about each store's inventory and policies.

  • Price point. How much are you willing to spend on your new pair of shoes?
  • Brand. Do you need a name-brand designer or will off-brand work for your needs?
  • Return policy. Will it be easy for you to make a return or exchange if your shoes do not fit the way you had hoped?
  • Comfort. Does the retailer offer comfortable shoes that will allow you to wear them all day?
  • Shipping. How much will it cost to get your shoes sent to you? Are there any promotions that would get you free shipping?
  • Variety. Does the retailer have a large variety of shoes for you to choose from?
  • Customer reviews. What are other customers saying about the shoes and the retailer?

To assist you in finding the best women's shoes for your needs, Top Consumer Reviews has evaluated and ranked a compilation of shoe stores to shop from today. We are confident that this information will make your shoe shopping a fun and enjoyable experience.

The Best Reviews of Women's Shoe Stores