Best Reviews Best Bridesmaid Dresses Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      June 1, 2020

Home  >  Bridesmaid Dresses  >  BHLDN vs J Crew


Bridesmaid Dresses

  1. BHLDN
  2. David's Bridal
  3. J. Crew
  4. House of Brides
  5. Eric Dress

Your Information Is Secure
Beauty Tips Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Bad Credit Loans

Buying Gold

College Textbooks

Investment Newsletters

MCAT Test Prep

Photo Books

Photo Cards

Salsa Clubs


Structured Settlement Buyers


Individual Reviews



David's Bridal

J Crew

House of Brides

Eric Dress


Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

BHLDN vs J Crew

To help you find the Best Bridesmaid Dresses, provides you with an in-depth comparison of BHLDN and J Crew.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Bridesmaid Dresses, please Click Here

Buy Your Bridesmaid Dresses at Dessy Today! One of the most memorable, special moments in your life is your wedding day. Deciding which of your friends and loved ones will surround you at the altar as part of your wedding party is an important part of the event, and coordinating your bridesmaid dresses can be a fun, yet challenging, experience.

You may want all of your attendants to wear the exact same dress with perfectly-matching color, or you may opt to give them the freedom to choose the style that fits their personalities - or you may be a bridesmaid yourself, and you’re looking for the attire that will match what your bride-to-be friend or family member has asked you to find.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews


Bridesmaid Dress Store Reviews

4.5 stars


Visit Site

BHLDN - typically pronounced as "Beholden" - is named for the Dutch word that means "to keep". As part of the Anthropologie brand, this retailer of Bridesmaid Dresses promotes its "passion for tradition with a twist" with options that include both long and short dresses and separates in classic and modern styles.

At first glance, BHLDN has a decent number of Bridesmaid Dresses from which to choose: more than 70 listed on their site. It's worth noting, however, that many of the dresses pictured separately are simply different color options of the same dress style, reducing the number of unique styles to less than 30. Sizing is also somewhat limited, with some dresses only going up to size 14, and others to 18.

On the other hand, BHLDN is a fantastic choice for bridesmaids on a budget. Unlike their wedding dresses, which are priced as high as nearly $4000, BHLDN keeps their Bridesmaid Dresses under $400. When we looked at other retailers, using the Iva Crepe Maxi by designer Jill Stuart as an example, we found BHLDN to be competitively priced within the market.

Shipping starts at $6.95 for orders up to $200 and is $10.95 for orders of $501 and up, in the event that several bridesmaids choose to order their dresses together to save on shipping costs. BHLDN does have an additional charge of $15 for all "gowns", but fortunately that applies only to wedding dresses.

We love that BHLDN's return policy is customer-friendly: Bridesmaid Dresses in original condition and packaging with all tags attached can be returned within 30 days, and every shipment includes a prepaid UPS label. Also, shoppers should be aware that dresses purchased online cannot be returned to a local BHLDN location.

BHLDN is genuinely committed to assisting brides in finding the perfect dresses for their wedding party. BHLDN has stylists who can help with selecting and sizing the right separates or dresses, to match the overall style and theme of the wedding; brides and bridesmaids alike can access these stylists via phone or email and are encouraged to do so before making a final purchase decision. Also, each Bridesmaid Dress comes with suggestions for jewelry, belts and other accessories to get the exact look pictured on the website. Some of the dresses also have customer reviews that give an idea as to how it fit "in real life", the body type of the wearer, and a star rating from 1-5.

Although BHLDN's selection is somewhat smaller than other retailers in our review, we appreciate their commitment to working with brides and their bridesmaids to find the right dress for the wedding, and their customer-friendly returns policy on their well-priced Bridesmaid Dresses.

Visit Site
3.5 stars
J Crew


Visit Site

J.Crew is retailer known for its NYC-designed, classic with a twist" apparel line that has expanded in recent years to include Wedding Gowns and Bridesmaid Dresses. True to their traditional classic styling and simple lines, J.Crew's Bridesmaid Dresses look like clothing that could easily be worn for other occasions, such as a cocktail party or a formal night on a cruise.

The majority of the Bridesmaid Dresses at J.Crew are available in regular and tall sizes 00 through 16, with a few styles in sizes 18 and 20 and petite sizes up to 12. Shoppers can see other customers' reviews below each dress, which indicate the overall fit from "runs small" to "runs large". J.Crew also provides an online size chart to help ladies get the best possible fit. J.Crew dress experts are easily reachable via phone or email, to answer any questions the bride or her bridesmaids have about sizing, colors, and more prior to making a purchase.

J.Crew continues to make shopping for a Bridesmaid Dress as worry-free as possible by offering a fantastic return policy: dresses in unused condition may be returned a full 60 days from the date of purchase, either via UPS for $5 (which J.Crew does deduct from the refund amount) or to one of their retail store locations. Shipping is fast: 3-6 business days, just like their regular apparel. We were amused and pleased by J.Crew's promise to even track down out-of-stock items at the last minute, because they "know people" who can get it done. J.Crew also offers free shipping on all orders of $150 or more, so bridesmaids may want to order their dresses at the same time when possible.

We were surprised that J.Crew's selection of Bridesmaid Dresses was larger than their options for Wedding Dresses - helping to keep them closer to competitive with other retailers of Bridesmaid Dresses in our review.

We like J.Crew's friendly approach to customer service, particularly in regards to their shipping and return policies. We're confident that if a bride finds her Bridesmaids' Dresses among their somewhat limited selection, the shopping experience is likely to be a positive one.

Visit Site

Continued from above

If you limit your search only to local bridal and formalwear stores, you’re likely to come away aggravated and empty-handed. Bridesmaid dress selection may be extremely limited, and you’ll find yourself at the mercy of the retailers with respect to pricing.

Fortunately, finding the right Bridesmaid dress becomes much easier when you shop for your dress online. In just a matter of minutes, you can easily search through thousands of options in a rainbow of colors and a wide variety of styles until you spot just the right dress.

Of course, not all online retailers selling bridesmaid dresses are the same. You will want to keep in mind several key points as you begin the hunt for your outfit:

  • Selection. How many bridesmaid dresses does the retailer offer, and are they typically in-stock? The more options you have to choose from, the more likely it is that you’ll find a dress that matches what your bride has in mind.
  • Quality. Does the retailer sell original dresses or knock-off replicas of designer gowns? Do the dresses shown online match what is eventually delivered to the customer, especially with respect to fabrics and detailing?
  • Return Policy. If the bridesmaid dress is delivered and you want to return it—the sizing is off, or the color is different from how it looked online, for example—can you return it? has reviewed and ranked the best Bridesmaid Dress stores available today. We hope this information helps you find that perfect bridesmaid dress for your wedding attendants, or for your friend’s beautiful wedding!

14 Fashion-Forward Places To Buy A Wedding Dress Online

The last few years have seen a significant spike in the number of retailers offering wedding dresses online. While brick-and-mortar stores are still very popular for their appointment-only model, ...

Published:  Fri, 29 May 2020 17:04:00 GMT

Blu Rayne Bridal in Commack launches virtual wedding dress shopping

When the coronavirus hit, Carrie Lish, owner of Blu Rayne Bridal Boutique in Commack, didn't want brides to get wed to the idea that they couldn't still be excited about their trip down the aisle. "Th ...

Published:  Thu, 28 May 2020 10:26:00 GMT

Five Global Retailers Share What's Selling Online, From Sweatpants to Wedding Dresses

Luxury e-commerce trends paint a future of fashion that's focused on comfort, flashy statement pieces, and investments in fashion that really last.

Published:  Tue, 26 May 2020 20:08:00 GMT

The Queen Reportedly Found One Thing About Meghan Markle's Wedding Dress 'Questionable'

On May 19, 2018, Prince Harry and Meghan Markle tied the knot in a lavish, televised royal wedding. For the big day, Meghan wore a simple and elegant gown des ...

Published:  Tue, 26 May 2020 15:23:00 GMT

Open for Business: Atelier Bridal delivers wedding dresses (and fun) to brides' homes

Atelier Bridal in Montclair is doing virtual appointments and at-home try ons for brides during the coronavirus pandemic, and maybe beyond ...

Published:  Sun, 31 May 2020 03:03:00 GMT

Bridal shop makes face masks to match wedding dresses

Oana Chaicac, who opened Angelo Bridal in Dublin just before the pandemic hit Ireland, has received a stream of orders for face masks that match wedding dresses from brides-to-be.

Published:  Sun, 31 May 2020 09:01:00 GMT

This wedding dress might have some bad juju - but it could be yours, for free

Eighteen years ago, according to her Facebook post, Heather Wilson got married, soon followed by divorce. Now she's giving away the dress.

Published:  Fri, 29 May 2020 17:48:00 GMT

Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure