Our reviewers evaluate products and services based on unbiased research. Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on a link. Learn more about our process.

The Best Candy Clubs

Where Can You Find the Best Candy Club?

Do you, or someone you know, have a craving for sugary treats that just won't quit? If you're looking for a delightful way to satisfy your sweet tooth on a regular basis, you might want to consider joining a candy club - or giving one as a gift. These delectable subscriptions offer a wide variety of candies, from classic favorites to exotic treasures sourced from around the globe.

Imagine the joy of receiving a fresh assortment of candies at your doorstep every month or having them sent to your office. It's a treat everyone would eagerly anticipate. But with so many candy clubs to choose from, how do you find the best one for your sweet cravings?

Tuesday, March 19th

2024 Candy Club Reviews

Old Time Candy Review Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award 5 Star Rating

Old Time Candy

5 Star Rating Top Consumer Reviews Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award

Since 2000, Old Time Candy has been bringing joy to customers with a focus on sweet favorites from the 1950s to the present day. Their mission is to ensure that everyone can relish the candies they loved as children. Offering four candy club membership options, flexible scheduling, and personalized gift-giving choices, Old Time Candy stands out as the ideal destination for your monthly dose of sweets.

Candy Favorites Review 4.5 Star Rating

Candy Favorites

4.5 Star Rating

Candy Favorites, part of the McKeesport Candy Company, boasts almost a century of candy expertise and offers three enticing candy clubs: Retro Candy of the Month, Gummi Candy of the Month, and Fruit Candy of the Month. Subscriptions start at $74.95 for three months, with free shipping included. While they have a less-than-generous refund/replacement policy, their reputation is strong, with an "A+" BBB rating and 90% positive customer reviews. However, they may make candy substitutions without customer input, which is something to consider. If you're looking for nostalgic treats and competitive pricing, Candy Favorites is an overall great choice for a candy subscription.

Japan Candy Box Review 4 Star Rating

Japan Candy Box

4 Star Rating

Japan Candy Box is an adorable candy club that brings the modern-day culture of Japan to your doorstep with a monthly delivery of 10 delightful treats, spanning both sweet and savory snacks. Customers are quick to praise this club for the sheer enjoyment of it, right down to the charming packaging and monthly theming. The company elevates the experience by providing free shipping to candy enthusiasts worldwide, and an affordable monthly price of under $30. Indulge in cuteness overload and savor the flavors of Japan with this fantastic international candy club.

Treatsbox Review 3.5 Star Rating

Treatsbox

3.5 Star Rating

Treatsbox is a Canadian candy club with a mix of well-loved and unique treats. They offer three box sizes: Regular, Epic, and Colossal, priced in Canadian dollars (CAD). While the subscription cost at Treatsbox may seem high, especially with high shipping fees to the US, currency conversion often favors US customers. Gift options are available, but shipping timeframes and box contents aren't customizable. Treatsbox is active on social media and gets lots of attention from happy subscribers. If you appreciate diversity and surprise in your candy club deliveries, it's worth considering.

MexiCrate Review 3.5 Star Rating

MexiCrate

3.5 Star Rating

MexiCrate delivers a diverse assortment of Mexican candies and snacks. Priced between $7.99 and $32.99 per box, the subscription comes in three sizes and plans range from one to six months. While the majority of customers praise the contents and overall experience, some report late or missing deliveries, cross-border issues, and difficulties canceling subscriptions. MexiCrate earns a 3.5-star rating, making it a decent option for those seeking a variety of Mexican goodies, but coming a little short of our top candy clubs.

Harry & David Review 3 Star Rating

Harry & David

3 Star Rating

As part of the 1 800 Flowers family, Harry & David is a well-established American company known for gourmet gifts, especially premium fruits, chocolates, and gourmet food products. Despite a slightly DIY approach to their candy club offerings, they have an excellent reputation, offer a great satisfaction guarantee, and the Celebrations Passport is an option for getting free shipping. While not the best choice if you're looking for a traditional candy club, Harry & David doesn't fail when it comes to reputation, customer service, and gift-worthy packaging.

See's Candies Review 3 Star Rating

See's Candies

3 Star Rating

See's Candies, an iconic American candy manufacturer established in 1921, offers a range of delightful chocolates and confections, renowned for their quality and traditional recipes. See's provides a unique candy subscription service called "More See's Please." Unlike typical candy clubs, you manually choose candies from their eligible list for automatic deliveries. Prices vary depending on your candy choices, and shipping costs range from $5.95 to $12.95, waived on orders over $65. While See's Candies has a strong reputation with an "A+" BBB rating, there have been some recent concerns about candy quality. We'd recommend looking at the higher-ranked candy clubs on our list first, because See's is a little harder to set up and might not be worth what you spend.

Universal Yums Review 2.5 Star Rating

Universal Yums

2.5 Star Rating

While not strictly a candy club, Universal Yums provides a broader exploration of international snacks, delivering a curated selection from different countries worldwide. Each month, subscribers receive a box filled with sweet and savory treats, introducing them to the diverse flavors of global cuisine. The service offers three box sizes starting at $16/month, each containing a variety of snacks from a particular nation/region and a booklet with country-themed trivia and games. Subscribers can typically choose the country theme for their first box, with subsequent boxes featuring countries selected by Universal Yums. Mixed reviews diminish the company's unique approach to snack discovery, earning a 2.5-star rating with cautionary notes about customer service responsiveness and occasional repetition of snacks (and pointing out the obvious fact that this isn't strictly a candy club).

Candy Club Review 2.5 Star Rating

Candy Club

2.5 Star Rating

Candy Club entices you to "live sweetly" with their monthly candy deliveries, offering a mix of candies from small artisans and well-known brands. They provide a unique candy experience, but there are some important changes to note. The membership now offers one size, featuring six 6-ounce cups of assorted candies, which you can select to be "Mostly Sweets" or "Mostly Sours" at a cost of $39.99 per month, a slight increase from the previous price. Shipping is now free, and occasional promo codes for discounts may be available, but gifting options are limited. With an average rating of 2.4 out of 5 stars from nearly 600 reviews, Candy Club has faced complaints regarding taste and customer service. Although they offer a satisfaction guarantee, these concerns place Candy Club among the less recommended options in the candy club niche.

Classic Candy Box Review 1 Star Rating

Classic Candy Box

1 Star Rating

Classic Candy Box, available through Cratejoy, features a diverse assortment of classic candies from the early 1900s to the 1980s. Each box includes a minimum of 25 pieces of candy. However, despite the promise of nostalgia and variety, this candy club doesn't offer the best value for your money. Many subscribers are disappointed at receiving common and uninspired candies such as Tootsie Rolls, KitKats, and Hershey's Kisses. Beyond the candy quality, many customers complain about never getting what they paid for. Overall, Classic Candy Box will almost certainly not deliver a sweet experience, earning our lowest ranking among candy clubs.

Compare the Best Reviews

Continued from above...

The process is simple: you get to select the type of candy you love and how frequently you want to receive your candy deliveries. Each candy club has its own unique subscription options. Some allow you to pre-select a fixed timeframe, like 3 months or a year, after which your membership ends. Others offer automatic renewals on a monthly basis until you decide to cancel your subscription. There are also candy clubs that give you the flexibility to space out your deliveries, perhaps receiving them once every three months or even less often, in case you want to pace yourself.

Candy clubs also make an excellent choice for gift-giving. Many of these clubs offer you the opportunity to include a personalized gift message for your lucky recipient, making the sweet surprise even more special. Who wouldn't prefer a monthly candy delivery over an outfit that doesn't quite fit or a gift card to a store they may never visit? The answer is simple - candy clubs make for thoughtful and delightful presents, sure to bring smiles to the faces of those you care about.

With numerous candy clubs available, it can be challenging to determine which one will suit your preferences. Here are some factors to consider when making your decision:

  • Candy type and quantity. What types of candies does the candy club offer? Make sure they have your favorite treats: traditional, retro, international, or something else? Also consider the quantity included in each shipment. Some clubs provide just a handful of candies, while others deliver dozens or even hundreds.
  • Cost. How much will you pay each month for your candy club subscription? Keep in mind that some providers include shipping in the membership cost, while others may have additional fees that can significantly increase what you spend.
  • Reputation. Research the candy club's reputation, like feedback from other candy enthusiasts, to ensure you are making the right choice. Check if the company has a history of on-time deliveries and responsive customer service. Finally, look for ratings and reviews from organizations like the Better Business Bureau to gauge the club's overall reliability.

If you're struggling to decide which candy club to choose, Top Consumer Reviews has reviewed and ranked the best ones available today. So why wait? Explore the world of candy clubs and indulge in a monthly experience that brings delight straight to your doorstep. Whether it's for yourself or a loved one, a candy club subscription is sure to add a little extra sweetness to your life!

The Best Candy Clubs Compare Candy Clubs Compare Candy Club Reviews What are the best Candy Clubs Best Candy Club Reviews

Candy Club FAQ

Great question! Most chocolate based candies, like candy bars can be frozen. The shelf life for frozen candy, if stored in an airtight container or bag, can last anywhere from 12 to 18 months.
There are many kinds of memberships such as the Fun Box, Party Box, Signature Sweets, or a chocolate-only collection. Each package will contain anywhere from 3 to 6 full size products. Candy types can range from sweet and sour to spicy to even indulgent chocolates.
Dark chocolate, also known as semi-sweet, has 4 main differences from milk chocolate. Dark chocolate contains no more than 12% milk fat, less cocoa butter, contains at least 15% chocolate liquor, and has a more intense chocolate flavor. The only other difference is that milk chocolate uses fresh whole milk rather than milk fat.
Great question! Nut-free means that the candy has been made without a trace of nuts. In fact, Nut-free candies are generally created and packaged in a nut-free facility. If you still have questions, feel free to reach out to the company's customer service.
When looking at the package, unless stated, there should be the letter K or U with a circle around it. There are more kosher symbols, but those two are the most popular. If you still are uncertain, feel free to contact customer service or visit oukosher.org and search the product name and brand to see if it is on the approved kosher food list.
It all depends on the number of guests you have, but a good rule of thumb is to estimate that each guest will eat about 4 oz. of candy. The formula to calculate this is the total number of guests multiplied by (four ounces) = total. For conversion to pounds, 4 ounces is equal to 1/4 of a pound. So, if you had 200 guests, you would have 50 pounds of candy.
The shelf life of hard sweets can be stored at room temperature or dry, cool conditions up to one year. Whereas the shelf life of hard candy can vary. Typically candy bars and concession candy can last up to one month. Bubblegum, candy corn, dark chocolate, Jordan almonds, and licorice have a shelf life of 2 months. Milk or white chocolates tend to last 3 months and jellybeans last up to 6 months. Longer shelf-life candy that lasts up to 12 months include caramel, gummy candy, hard candy, lollipops, and novelty candy. The longest shelf life is 24 months and is typically limited to mints. In general, the temperature the candy is stored at is important to the overall quality of the sweet.
Of course, this whitish powder is called chocolate bloom and is not white mold. Chocolate bloom does not affect the quality of the product and occurs when there is a temperature change. Keep in mind, if the chocolate is older than the recommended shelf life and contains white stuff on it, we recommend you discard the product and purchase fresh and delicious new candy.

Compare Candy Clubs

Select any 2 Candy Clubs to compare them head to head

best-candy-clubs
  • Old Time Candy
  • Candy Favorites
  • Japan Candy Box
  • Treatsbox
  • MexiCrate
  • Harry & David
  • See's Candies
  • Universal Yums
  • Candy Club
  • Classic Candy Box
Old Time Candy vs Candy Favorites Old Time Candy vs Japan Candy Box Old Time Candy vs Treatsbox Old Time Candy vs MexiCrate Old Time Candy vs Harry & David Old Time Candy vs See's Candies Old Time Candy vs Universal Yums Old Time Candy vs Candy Club Old Time Candy vs Classic Candy Box Candy Favorites vs Japan Candy Box Candy Favorites vs Treatsbox Candy Favorites vs MexiCrate Candy Favorites vs Harry & David Candy Favorites vs See's Candies Candy Favorites vs Universal Yums Candy Favorites vs Candy Club Candy Favorites vs Classic Candy Box Japan Candy Box vs Treatsbox Japan Candy Box vs MexiCrate Japan Candy Box vs Harry & David Japan Candy Box vs See's Candies Japan Candy Box vs Universal Yums Japan Candy Box vs Candy Club Japan Candy Box vs Classic Candy Box Treatsbox vs MexiCrate Treatsbox vs Harry & David Treatsbox vs See's Candies Treatsbox vs Universal Yums Treatsbox vs Candy Club Treatsbox vs Classic Candy Box MexiCrate vs Harry & David MexiCrate vs See's Candies MexiCrate vs Universal Yums MexiCrate vs Candy Club MexiCrate vs Classic Candy Box Harry & David vs See's Candies Harry & David vs Universal Yums Harry & David vs Candy Club Harry & David vs Classic Candy Box See's Candies vs Universal Yums See's Candies vs Candy Club See's Candies vs Classic Candy Box Universal Yums vs Candy Club Universal Yums vs Classic Candy Box Candy Club vs Classic Candy Box
Compare the Best Candy Clubs
- VS -
Review the Best Candy Clubs
The Best Reviews of Candy Clubs