Best Reviews Best Charm Bracelets Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      November 12, 2019

Home  >  Charm Bracelets  >  Kay vs Pandora


Charm Bracelets

  1. Kay
  2. Reeds Jewelers
  3. Pandora
  4. Zales
  5. Claire's
  6. Heavenly Treasures

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
How to Buy Jewelry Online Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Ballroom Dancing Lessons

Copyright Registration

Drum Lessons

Health Insurance

Keto Diets

Painting Lessons

Self Publishing Companies

Teeth Whiteners

VOIP Services

Wedding Planning Software

Wedding Websites



Individual Reviews



Reeds Jewelers




Heavenly Treasures


Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Kay vs Pandora

To help you find the Best Charm Bracelets, provides you with an in-depth comparison of Kay and Pandora.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Charm Bracelets, please Click Here

Get Your Next Charm Bracelet at Overstock Today! Where can you get the best charm bracelets? There are many online retailers that offer an incredible selection of bracelets and individual charms, making it easy to find the perfect addition to your jewelry collection - or to honor a special someone with a gift tailored exactly to their interests and experiences.

Although charm bracelets were originally designed to either bring good luck or ward off evil spirits - often with symbols like horseshoes and four-leaf clovers - today's trends use charm bracelets for less superstitious reasons. Many parents start a charm bracelet when their daughter is born, adding a new charm each year to commemorate a treasured memory and then giving her the completed bracelet for her 16th birthday or quinceañera.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews


Charm Bracelets Reviews

4.5 stars

KAY Visit Site


35 bracelets

1,100+ charms

Return Policy:

Within 60 days for a refund

Within 90 days for an exchange

When you hear the name Kay Jewelers, do you immediately think of the catchy tagline, "Every Kiss Begins With Kay"? It's okay to admit it - because Kay is one of the biggest specialty jewelry retailers in the United States. Owned by parent company Signet Jewelers, Kay is part of a brand family with annual sales of nearly $6 billion through more than 3,600 retail stores and a well-designed online store too.

Kay has a good selection of 35 bracelets that are specifically compatible with charms, both the kinds that slide on and those that attach with a clasp or ring. We did notice that most of the bracelets are limited to 7- and 7.5-inch lengths, which may not accommodate wearers with smaller or larger wrists. Most of the bracelets list the length in the main product description; otherwise, click on the bracelet and you'll find the length in the product description dropdown.

In addition to the main Charm Bracelet page, Kay has a huge selection of individual charms in their Charm Store. You can browse through their 1000+ options all at once, but you'll probably have a better experience if you narrow it down by Beads or Traditional Charms, or by brands such as Charmed Memories or Rembrandt Charms.

We were really impressed by some of the engravable charms; Charmed Memories offers a Family Tree bead starting at just under $55 that allows you to have a last name or other word (like "faith" or "unity") engraved directly into the silver. We also found many charms on sale at savings of up to 70% or more, including popular themes like Star Wars and Disney's Frozen. Charmed Memories is compatible with Pandora, if you already happen to have a Pandora bracelet or vice-versa.

When you sign up for Kay's email newsletter, you may get a promotional discount of 20% off your first purchase. Look for a pop-up when visiting the site.

Kay has one of the best return policies in the industry. You can return your bracelet or charm within 60 days if you want a refund, or within 90 days if you'd prefer an exchange. Returns can be made via mail or at any Kay Jewelers retail location. The only restriction is that you can't return anything personalized/engraved. Note that it doesn't say that you can only get a refund on charms/bracelets in new condition - so if your bracelet just doesn't fit quite right or the charm falls off the jump ring, there should be no hassles in getting a refund. "If you're not happy, we're not happy and we will make it right" is Kay's promise.

Fantastic selection, competitive pricing, and an unparalleled return policy are just a few of the reasons we think you'll love shopping for your charm bracelet at Kay.

Visit Site

4 stars

PANDORA Visit Site


33 bracelets

580+ charms

Return Policy:

30 days (by mail or in-store)

Pandora deserves credit for bringing charm bracelets back into popularity. Although traditional charm bracelets, usually with dangling charms attached by jump rings, are still around, most women wear the style that Pandora is known for: the solid silver or gold style with beads that slide over the bracelet itself. Their selection has expanded to include braided leather styles in a range of colors and solid metal bangles that also accommodate Pandora charms.

As you shop for bracelets, Pandora makes it foolproof to get the right size: most bracelets have a range of sizes, and right above the available sizes you'll find a link to their helpful size guide. We also love that if you see something you like, you can click on the "send a hint" link to let someone know that it's on your wish list.

Many of the bracelets have numerous customer reviews for you to consider. Pandora's two most popular charm bracelets are the Iconic Silver Charm (169 reviews) and the Silver Charm with Heart Clasp (226 reviews), both of which sell for $65. You can read those reviews towards the bottom of each bracelet's page; next to the reviews tab, click on the Ask a Question tab if you need more detailed information or want to see what other customers asked.

Pandora charms are the original that others copy. With almost 600 choices, you'll find everything from whimsical to wow. On our most recent visit, we saw cute options like Bruno the Unicorn and Figaro the Disney cat; on the elegant end of the spectrum, we also spotted the Heraldic Radiance charm featuring rose gold plus pink and purple crystals and the Opulent Flower made of 14k gold and cubic zirconia.

Because Pandora tends to set their prices universally, you'll usually find the same price whether you shop directly from the Pandora store or on a competitor site. Of course, Pandora wants you to buy directly from them - so they offer free 3-day shipping on every order. Plus, shopping on the Pandora site ensures that you're getting genuine merchandise, not a counterfeit. And, you may find a wider selection of Pandora charms on the official site than when you shop through a third-party seller.

But, that also means you won't find any compatible charm brands: you're limited to just what Pandora offers. There are many other brands whose charms fit the traditional Pandora bracelet style, in designs that Pandora doesn't offer. That's worth keeping in mind, especially if you're trying to create a themed bracelet.

If you get your bracelet or charm and it's not what you were expecting, you can return it within 30 days of purchase by mail or to a Pandora retail location. However, it's important to note that if you return an online order to a local store, you will only get a merchandise credit to be used there instead of a refund. For that reason, you might want to take advantage of the free, prepaid shipping label to send it back to Pandora directly.

There's no question that Pandora charm bracelets and charms are well-made and beautiful, setting the standard that most charm bracelets try to imitate. A solid return policy and perks like free shipping make the Pandora online store a great place to shop.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Another popular theme for charm bracelets is travel. Imagine how quickly those memories come back as you see your Eiffel Tower dangle charm, Mickey Mouse glass bead, or passport charm on your wrist every day.

And, of course, charm bracelets are ideal for accessorizing. With thousands of charms available in silver, gold, and the full spectrum of colors, there's no end to the possibilities. Silver and blue with snowflakes for winter? Pumpkins and leaves for autumn? Sun beads, flip-flop dangles, and palm trees for the summer? You can do all that and much more with a charm bracelet.

As you shop for your bracelet and charms, how can you tell which online stores should get your business? Here are several criteria to keep in mind:

  • Variety. How many bracelets and charms does the retailer offer? The more charms they sell, the less likely it is that you'll have to spend your time shopping on more than one website. Can you get a range of brands and styles, or is the selection limited to just one or two?
  • Price. How does the store compare with other retailers? Is shipping included with your purchase? Are there any discounts or rewards programs?
  • Return Policy. If you receive your bracelet and/or charms and aren't satisfied, can you return them for a full refund?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about their experience with the store? Are they rated and/or accredited by the Better Business Bureau? has reviewed and ranked the best Charm Bracelet stores available today. We hope this information helps you put together a charm bracelet that perfectly showcases your unique style!

Is It OK to Wear Jewelry While You Work Out?

Is It OK to Wear Jewelry While You Work Out? Is exercising in jewelry bad for your accessories-and your skin? Here's the deal. Jewelry made of pure gold, gold fill, sterling silver, and silicone ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 16:03:00 GMT

Fine Jewelry Brand Mejuri To Introduce Hybrid Showroom Model

Direct-to-consumer fine jewelry brand Mejuri has come a long way since its 2013 launch. Aside from announcing it received a $23 million in Series B funding earlier this year, the brand is further ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 11:45:00 GMT

"Rhode Island is a diamond in the rough,' founder of Providence jewelry business says

Question: The jewelry industry was a big part of Rhode Island's economy in years past, but to what extent is it part of the state's future economy? Answer: I believe in building on strengths, and ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 03:48:00 GMT

NYC Jewelry Week: The 2nd Edition

Now it's second year, NYCJW (New York City Jewelry Week) is a jewelry enthusiast's dream. The only question is -how to fit in all of the events you may want to attend during November 18-24th? And, ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 08:34:00 GMT

Burglars hit Mall of America owner's NYC mansion, steal $100,000+ in bags, jewelry

The New York City home of Don Ghermezian, the CEO of Mall of America Owner Triple Five Group, was broken into over the weekend by masked burglars who reportedly made off with more than $100,000 in ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 04:23:00 GMT

Burglars Steal $100K in Jewelry, Handbags From Shopping Mall Developer's Bronx Mansion

The home belongs to Dan Ghermezian, CEO of Triple Five Group which owns the Mall of America in Minnesota, according to sources Thousands of dollars of jewelry and handbags were stolen from the home of ...

Published:  Sun, 10 Nov 2019 18:23:00 GMT

Inside the Most Luxurious New Watch and Jewelry Boutique in the Midwest

Attention Midwesterners: A serious watch and jewelry store is bringing hard-to-get pieces to Ohio. Buyers looking for a boutique experience at D.C. Johnson Ltd. will find pieces from Nikos Koulis, ...

Published:  Sat, 09 Nov 2019 16:06:00 GMT

Tow truck driver stole AAA customer info to buy clothes, jewelry, car parts, cops say

City Wide fired Reyes. Police identified at least 20 victims of the scheme and say Reyes used the stolen information to purchase clothing, shoes, jewelry and car parts. They also said they had ...

Published:  Sat, 09 Nov 2019 20:45:00 GMT

Veteran with PTSD creates jewelry to empower women

Tara Hutchinson calls herself a fine jewelry artist and goldsmith. In fact, she runs and supports herself through her small business Tara Hutch Designs. Jewelry was never something Hutchinson had ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 17:56:00 GMT

Families Search for Answers After Jewelry Disappears From Safe Deposit Boxes

But that's not the case for some frustrated customers, who told NBC4 their belongings just disappeared. Those items include one jewelry collection appraised in the mid-six figures and another that ...

Published:  Mon, 11 Nov 2019 18:47:00 GMT

Share Us!    Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+ Share on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure