Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Christmas Ornament Stores Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      January 25, 2020

Home  >  Christmas Ornaments  >  Wayfair vs Pier 1 Imports

Best Christmas

Ornaments

  1. Wayfair
  2. Christmas Ornaments
  3. Personalization Mall
  4. Pier 1
  5. Christmas Central
  6. Christmas Sleigh

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
How to Take the Stress out of Christmas Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Cheesecake Clubs

Chocolate Clubs

Copyright Registration

Credit Monitoring

Dog Treat Clubs

Painting Lessons

Popcorn Clubs

Wedding Planning Software

 

Individual Reviews

Ornament Shop

Wayfair

Christmas Ornaments

Personalization Mall

Pier 1

Christmas Central

The Christmas Sleigh

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Wayfair vs Pier 1 Imports

To help you find the Best Christmas Ornament Stores, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Wayfair and Pier 1 Imports.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Christmas Ornament Stores, please Click Here

Find Your Christmas Ornaments at Ornament Shop Today! When decorating for the holidays, a beautiful Christmas tree is a must. And what does every Christmas tree need to be complete? Ornaments, of course! Whether your style is classic with white or multi-colored lights and metallic round ornaments, or you go all-in to support your favorite sports team, you'll need the right Christmas ornaments to match your theme.

One popular trend in Christmas ornaments is personalization: instead of a plain store-bought design, many shoppers prefer to have an ornament that reflects something about themselves or their loved ones. For example, some families have the tradition of giving each child in the family a new ornament every Christmas - perhaps a soccer ball in the year their team won the championship, or a graduation cap to commemorate finishing high school.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Christmas Ornament Store Reviews

4.5 stars
Wayfair

WAYFAIR

Visit Site

Personalization:

Yes

Cost:

From less than $1 to $506.99

Shipping:

Free for orders over $49, $4.99 for orders of $49 and under

If you've ever shopped online for home decor, chances are good that you're already familiar with Wayfair. Their selection of more than 500,000 products runs the gamut from dog houses to bath towels and everything in between, and their Christmas ornament collection is no different. With a staggering 8,000+ ornament styles to choose from, you'll find virtually every imaginable size, shape, color, and price range.

Shopping the Wayfair site to find the ornaments you want may feel a little overwhelming. Start by using the left-hand navigation options to filter the available products by type, price, theme, customer rating, color, and more. Be sure to click on "Personalization" under the heading of Features if you're specifically looking for a customized ornament; although some of the items that turned up in that results list did not have personalization options, for some reason, most of them will tell you in the product description how many characters you can enter in the provided space. Otherwise, the description will clearly indicate that you'll need to do the personalization yourself once you receive your ornament.

There's definitely something for every style and budget in Wayfair's collection of Christmas ornaments. On the budget-friendly end of the spectrum, there are nearly 7,000 options under $25, including sets of 12 or 14 round glass ornaments and glitter snowflakes. On the opposite end of the spectrum, especially in the Queens of Christmas and Value Arts Company product lines, you'll find shatterproof finials for the top of your tree, or intricately-painted cloisonné sleigh bell ornaments.

Wayfair's shipping costs are better than many of their competitors': a flat rate of $4.99 on orders of $49 or less, and free shipping for orders over $49. Also, all non-personalized orders can be returned for a refund within 30 days of delivery; be aware that you will be responsible for the costs of return shipping. The only exception to the 30-day policy is over the winter holidays: you have until January 31st to return orders placed between November 1st and December 31st, making it less stressful for your holiday shopping process. Also, it wasn't clear if this was a limited-time promotion or a regular deal, but we noticed that Wayfair had the following offer: "Place any order now to unlock 30 days of unlimited free shipping on future purchases".

The only negative we found with buying Christmas ornaments at Wayfair is their overall rating as an online retailer. Although we didn't see any reviews that specifically talked about Christmas ornaments, there are more than a few customer comments on various sites that describe issues with shipping, returns, and getting timely, appropriate responses from Wayfair when there are problems with an order or products. However, with over 500,000 products it stands to reason that not every purchase will go as planned, and Wayfair's "A+" rating as an accredited company with the Better Business Bureau means that they're doing a more-than-adequate job of taking care of customer concerns.

We're confident that you can find a great selection of Christmas ornaments for your holiday decor at Wayfair.

Visit Site
3 stars
Pier 1

PIER 1

Visit Site

Personalization:

No

Cost:

From $1.00 to $99.95

Shipping:

Free on orders of $49+ with promo code, starting at $5 for regular orders

Pier 1 is a household name when it comes to unique products for the home from around the world. With hundreds of retail locations throughout the US and Canada and a website for convenient shopping, it's easy to browse their collection of just over 250 Christmas ornaments.

If you're looking for personalization options, you're not going to find what you're looking for at Pier 1. We didn't see any ornaments that had a space for writing in a name or date on your own, and there were none that offered any kind of personalization prior to shipment. On the other hand, Pier 1 offers many ornaments at very affordable prices: simple jingle bells in gold, silver, or red for a dollar, red glitter ball ornaments for under $3, and several other options for decorating your tree on a budget. Other types of Christmas ornaments sold by Pier 1 include cloisonne patterns, European glass, and the exclusive Li Bien series that involves designs painted on the inside of the ornament by artists using an L-shaped brush.

To make your shopping even more affordable, Pier 1 does have special offers from time to time. On the day we reviewed the Pier 1 site, there was a pop-up offering a 10% discount for subscribing to their email list.

On the other hand, shipping can be spendy at Pier 1. While we spotted a "free shipping on orders of $49+" promo at the top of the page, regular shipping fees start at $5 for orders under $15 and go up from there.

Customers do like Pier 1's return options: you can return any purchase to a Pier 1 store within 45 days of purchase, or you can request a shipping label from their Customer Relations team. This is one of the most generous return policies in our review, mostly because none of the Christmas ornaments at Pier 1 are customized and thus non-refundable.

Overall, Pier 1 offers a small-but-sweet collection of Christmas ornaments, and returns are free and easy if for some reason your purchase is less than satisfactory.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Being able to customize these ornaments with a name, date, or other details creates a keepsake to treasure well into the future. Unfortunately, shopping at big-box retailers and even mall kiosks can be a hassle. Fighting the holiday crowds in multiple stores while trying to find the perfect Christmas ornaments for your tree can leave you feeling more like a Scrooge than a Santa.

For this reason, today's shoppers frequently turn to online retailers to buy their Christmas ornaments, getting the very best selection and personalization options without ever having to leave home. What should you look for when deciding where to buy your Christmas ornaments? Consider these five criteria:

  • Selection. Does the store give you a wide variety of options to choose from, or just a handful of products in a limited range of styles and colors?
  • Price. Can you buy ornaments at affordable prices? Does the retailer offer any discounts, such as free shipping or a buy-one, get-one free promotion?
  • Quality. Are the ornaments made to last, or are they likely to break or fade after a few seasons on your tree? Are there any customer reviews provided on individual ornaments that can give you an idea of how well they are made?
  • +
  • Personalization. Can you add a name, date, or other message to the Christmas ornaments you choose?
  • Customer Service. Does the store have a good track record for keeping customers happy? What is their return policy and satisfaction guarantee?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Christmas Ornament stores available online. We hope these reviews help you find the perfect decorations for your Christmas tree at the best possible price!

NC man stole $250,000 in checks, credit cards, Hamilton tickets, Christmas ornaments from 1,300 mailboxes

They found piles of stolen mail in Magana's Charlotte home. "Contained within the defendant's apartment were undelivered Hamilton tickets, Christmas ornaments, merchandise, passports, state and ...

Published:  Wed, 15 Jan 2020 16:28:00 GMT



Cary Christmas Tree Recycling Through January

Flood Brothers Disposal will collect Christmas trees throughout the month of January at no additional charge. Trees must be free of any lights, ornaments and decorations. Collection will occur on your ...

Published:  Fri, 24 Jan 2020 09:58:00 GMT



Glass Ornament Valentine's Heart from Michaels

Bev Schatz from Michaels show Wayne and Hope how to make a cute Valentine's Day inspired wall art piece utilizing broken glass Christmas ornaments.

Published:  Wed, 22 Jan 2020 14:56:00 GMT



Do New Orleans Christmas trees go to wetlands or landfills? Video raises questions

Every year, the City of New Orleans asks residents to participate in a Christmas tree recycling program to help restore the wetlands. But some people are concerned that their recyclable trees won't ...

Published:  Thu, 16 Jan 2020 17:44:00 GMT



Ann Arbor offering Christmas tree disposal through January

ornaments, tinsel and plastic are removed. The collected trees will be chipped on a regular basis at the park sites, the city said. All drop-off locations will be closed once January ends. To dispose ...

Published:  Sun, 12 Jan 2020 08:00:00 GMT



OL Offering Curbside Pickup For Christmas Trees Through Friday

OAK LAWN, IL - The Village of Oak Lawn is offering curbside Christmas tree pickup the first three weeks of January. Residents may leave their trees at the curb on their regular day of scheduled trash ...

Published:  Mon, 13 Jan 2020 09:06:00 GMT



Mobile to redecorate Christmas tree at Mardi Gras Park for Mardi Gras

""Our hope is that citizens and visitors will enjoy the tree as much as they did during the Christmas season, when it became the backdrop for countless selfies and a popular meeting place for families ...

Published:  Sat, 11 Jan 2020 20:09:00 GMT



TDS still accepting Christmas trees for recycling

Trees and decorations must be free of flocking, lights, ornaments, metal and other non-living contaminants. A $45 contamination fee will be assessed for trees and decorations that have not been ...

Published:  Fri, 17 Jan 2020 21:25:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure