Best Reviews Best Cigar Clubs Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      January 29, 2020

Home  >  Cigar Clubs  >  Clubs of America vs Gotham Cigar Club


Cigar Clubs

  1. Thompson Cigar
  2. Clubs of America
  3. Amazing Clubs
  4. Gotham Cigar Club

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
Cohiba 101: A Guide to Cohiba Cigars Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Cheesecake Clubs

Chocolate Clubs

Copyright Registration

Credit Monitoring

Dog Treat Clubs

Painting Lessons

Popcorn Clubs

Wedding Planning Software


Individual Reviews

Premium Cigar of the Month Club

Thompson Cigar

Clubs of America

Amazing Clubs

Gotham Cigar Club


Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Clubs of America vs Gotham Cigar Club

Best Cigar Clubs

To help you find the Best Cigar Clubs, provides you with an in-depth comparison of Clubs of America and Gotham Cigar Club.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Cigar Clubs, please Click Here

If you or a cigar aficionado in your life are looking for the ease and pleasure of trying new, unique cigars each month, then a cigar club might be the perfect answer. At a relatively low cost, you can receive premium cigars each month, manufactured from a variety of locations across the world, and with a tantalizing assortment of tobacco blends.

Along with the monthly delivery, members of some cigar clubs can also receive a newsletter to help learn about the specifics of each unique cigar and it's manufacturer. While some of these aspects may be standard in some cigar club memberships, the frequency of delivery and duration of membership can vary greatly from one cigar club to the next.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews


Cigar Club Reviews

4 stars
Clubs of America


Visit Site


$30.95 per month

The cigar club membership at Clubs of America is dedicated to delivering high quality cigars on time, and at a very fair price. As a cigar club member you'll receive 5 handcrafted, richly-flavored, hand rolled cigars, sent straight from a humidor in double airtight packaging. Cigars arrive around the 3rd or 4th week of the each month or as specified at sign-up. In addition to cigars, Clubs of America also offers membership programs that delivery foods, wines, and more.

Cigar club members can also count on a club newsletter called "Cigar Expeditions" to learn about the cigars that have arrived at your doorstep. These premium cigars are made in countries such as Honduras, Jamaica, the Canary Islands and The Dominican Republic.

The Clubs of America cigar club membership includes:

  • Cigar Origin: Around the world
  • Duration: monthly or 1- 12 months in length
  • Frequency: Monthly, every other, or every third month
  • Membership Minimums: none - cancel at any time
  • Shipping: Free

You can choose deliveries either monthly or anywhere between 1-12 months, and then you can choose the frequency of the delivery at monthly, bi-monthly or quarterly as you best see fit. Clubs of America also cuts you a deal if you are willing to pay for your cigar club monthly membership upfront.

If you give a cigar club gift from Clubs of America, they'll send a personalized gift announcement of your choosing. In the event that you're not satisfied with any aspect of the process, Clubs of America provides a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Clubs of America leads the pack in membership flexibility and fair pricing. They allow you or your gift recipient to enjoy a wonderful experience with premium cigars, free shipping, and great newsletters. Whether you purchase it for yourself, or as a gift for someone you know, a Clubs of America cigar club membership is a great choice.

Visit Site
2.5 stars
Gotham Cigar Club


Visit Site


Starting at $29.95 per month

Gotham Cigars is a Florida based company, in business since 2001. They maintain a sizeable inventory of cigars and have staff on hand to assist with questions five days a week.

Gotham sells both cigars and cigar clubs via their website. They list four different levels of membership. To be clear, the membership levels identify the length of membership purchased. No matter the length of membership, all customers will receive the same five cigars that particular month. The different memberships at Gotham are called:

  • Silver Membership for $29.95 for 1 month
  • Gold Membership for $79.99 for 3 months
  • Platinum Membership for $149.99 for 6 months
  • Diamond Membership for $299 for 12 months

While Gotham spends little to no time explaining their selection process, the website lists anticipated deliveries of popular brands like Cohiba, Gurkha, and Rocky Patel and more. Cigar members can anticipate free shipping, wood matches and an informative newsletter with each delivery. A free cigar cutter is included with the initial membership cigar club membership.

The Gotham Cigar Club Membership Summary:

  • Cigar Origin: Global
  • Duration: 3-12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Membership Minimums: 1 month with 30 day notice
  • Shipping: Free Shipping

The return policy at Gotham is a little confusing and seems to be different for the Cigar Clubs compared to regular cigar purchases. When you look at the Cigar Returns under their Company Policies it states that if you received an item in error or a damaged item that they will pay for return shipping and credit you accordingly. You must contact them within 3 business days to return a purchase. They do not accept returns after 3 business days. They state that subscriptions are a final sale and they do not accept returns or exchanges for their Cigar Club. They require a 30 day notice for cancellations. All club shipments depart the first week of the month. If the order is placed after the 5th of the month it ships the following month.

Their website does not provide a lot of information compared to those of the other Cigar Clubs reviewed. It also does not state how the cigars are packed for shipment. Gotham Cigars may be competitive in their pricing, but their website fails to give the cigar aficionado the details that they may be looking for to make them want to purchase from them.

Given Gotham's once a month ship dates along with less than friendly customer policies they fall a little below average.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Before you enroll in a cigar club for yourself or for someone as a gift, you should consider a few important aspects of a cigar club membership. Some of these include:

  • Cigar Origin.  Where are the cigars produced? Are they all from the domestic United States, or will they come from more exotic locales?
  • Duration.  What is the cigar club membership length? Can it vary to suit your needs?
  • Frequency.  How frequently will the cigars arrive? Can you select your desired timeframe - monthly, every other month, or quarterly as needed?
  • Membership Minimums.  Are you required to stay in the cigar club for a certain period of time? Or can you cancel at your discretion?
  • Cost.  How does the price of the cigar club membership compare with their competition?
  • Shipping.  Are there extra shipping charges in your cigar club membership? Knowing what additional charges may exist are important. has reviewed and ranked the best cigar clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the right cigar club for your needs!

Another cigar bar will open in uptown right below a new bar aimed at the ladies

Havana Smoke hopes to become a clubhouse for bankers, consultants and other corporate types, said Jones, who has 22 years of hospitality experience and more than a decade as general manager at ...

Published:  Wed, 22 Jan 2020 08:37:00 GMT

Inside Extell's private club for the 0.1%

The club, looming 1,000 feet in the air, will span 50,000 square feet across three floors and offer an array of luxury services and amenities. Meanwhile, the actual 100th floor of the building will ...

Published:  Mon, 27 Jan 2020 13:00:00 GMT

Brennan's owner planning cigar bar, art gallery in former auto body shop in the Grove

The proposed project is a renovation of a long vacant auto body shop into an event space, cigar bar and art gallery. "The Gibson property will be in large ... Central West End announced they would be ...

Published:  Thu, 23 Jan 2020 18:30:00 GMT

Review: Cigar Point, Mexico City, Mexico

If you haven't tried the Havana Club Seleccií³n de Maestros, start there. There are many Mexican beers, but also some Belgian dubbels and quadrupels available, as well as well as two dozen cocktails.

Published:  Tue, 28 Jan 2020 14:12:00 GMT

EXCLUSIVE: Uptown midrise lands upscale cigar lounge, rooftop bar

"We don't have anything like it in Charlotte," says entertainment operator Ian Jones of the rooftop bar. "It's a beautiful setting." ...

Published:  Tue, 21 Jan 2020 12:15:00 GMT

Flo Rida is building a vodka distillery. It will have a wine bar (and cigar lounge)

Bottles start at $19.99/750 ml or $28.99/1.75ml. Restaurants and bars currently offering VG include YOLO, Tuscan Prime and more, totaling more than 130 locations. The distillery and cigar lounge will ...

Published:  Tue, 21 Jan 2020 12:27:00 GMT

Woman kills retired trooper, self at Chicago-area cigar bar

The shooting at the Humidor Cigar Lounge in Lisle was "without apparent provocation," Lisle police ... (AP) - Former Attorney General Jeff Sessions, giving a recent campaign speech to a suburban ...

Published:  Sat, 25 Jan 2020 09:21:00 GMT

CANarchy Shipments Up 14% in 2019; Hard Seltzer Expansion, Cigar City National Distribution on Tap in 2020

As part of the sponsorship, Cigar City opened a new taproom adjacent to the arena and is wrapping up a renovation of its original taproom. In Utah, CANarchy is working on two new bars for its ...

Published:  Fri, 17 Jan 2020 13:37:00 GMT

Woman fatally shoots man, self at cigar bar near Chicago

The shooting happened just after 10 p.m. Friday at the Humidor Cigar Lounge in Lisle, police there said in a statement posted to Facebook ... (AP) - Former Attorney General Jeff Sessions, giving a ...

Published:  Fri, 24 Jan 2020 22:44:00 GMT

Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure