Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Cigar Clubs Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      November 24, 2020

Home  >  Cigar Clubs  >  Rare Cigar Club vs Gotham Cigar Club

Best

Cigar Clubs

  1. Thompson Cigar
  2. Rare Cigar Club
  3. Cigars International
  4. Cigar of the Month Club
  5. Amazing Clubs
  6. Gotham Cigar Club
  7. Southern Cigar Company

Your Information Is Secure
Cohiba 101: A Guide to Cohiba Cigars Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Auto Loans

Babysitters

Christmas Cards

Credit Counseling

DUI Lawyers

Fruit Clubs

Home Brew Beer Supplies

Homeschool Supplies

Music Publishing

Senior Care

 

Individual Reviews

Premium Cigar of the Month Club

Thompson Cigar

Rare Cigar Club

Cigars International

Cigar of the Month Club

Amazing Clubs

Gotham Cigar Club

Southern Cigar Company

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Rare Cigar Club vs Gotham Cigar Club

Best Cigar Clubs

To help you find the Best Cigar Clubs, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Rare Cigar Club and Gotham Cigar Club.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Cigar Clubs, please Click Here

Where can you find the best Cigar Clubs? Are you an aficionado? A novice? Somewhere in between? No matter where you are on the cigar enthusiast scale, joining a cigar club could be the best way to enhance your cigar experience.

The popularity of Cigar Clubs has really increased in recent years - and brought new and exciting cigar clubs into the marketplace. But don't just keep the fun to yourself. Gifting a cigar club membership to those in your life who care about cigars is a great way to increase their cigar enjoyment as well!

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Cigar Club Reviews

4.5 stars
Rare Cigar Club

RARE CIGAR CLUB

Visit Site

Cost:

$42.95 per month + $5 shipping

The Rare Cigar Club, a part of the highly regarded Month of the Club group, is unique among the best cigar clubs available today. This club is for the most discerning of cigar enthusiast, the cigar aficionado.

Limited production cigars

With the Rare Cigar Club you'll receive extremely limited production cigars made by boutique manufacturers, along with high-end cigars from the super-premium brands. Each month you'll receive four top-rated cigars of different shapes and sizes, hand crafted by top producers in Central and South America and the Caribbean using the highest quality aged tobaccos and amazing tobacco blends.

Reusable humidification device

With each monthly shipment from the Rare Cigar Club you will also receive the monthly newsletter giving detailed cigar profiles, the history of the manufacturers, tasting notes, and suggested alcohol pairings. Also, each shipment arrives in a reusable humidification device, ensuring the high quality of each cigar isn't compromised while in transit.

Best Cigar Clubs

Cigar club options

The Rare Cigar Club provides a flexible option of membership duration. You can select from 2 to 12 shipments with no auto renewal, or choose the ongoing option and continue receiving cigars until you wish to cancel your membership. You can also choose how often to receive your cigars - monthly, every two months, or every quarter.

Membership overview:

  • Number of Cigars in Each Delivery: Four
  • Cigar Origin: Central and South America and the Caribbean
  • Duration: 2-12 shipments or ongoing
  • Frequency: monthly, every two months, or quarterly
  • Membership Minimums: 1 shipment
  • Shipping: $5/shipment

Panel of tobacconists

The Rare Cigar Club ensures the highest quality cigars by testing every brand and style before sending any cigars to you. Their panel of nine tobacconists rate over 200 different cigars every week. These experts rate for things like aroma and flavor profile and only 5% of tested cigars are rated high enough to be included in the club. They say, "We smoke a lot of bad cigars so you don't have to." Collectively, the panel spends nearly half their working year on-site in places like Nicaragua and Dominican Republic cultivating relationships with producers, refining blends, and inspecting the final products.

Among the best

Limited production, high quality, rare cigars is what Rare Cigar Club offers those willing to spend a little more for the best cigar club experience. In fact, this is the most expensive club on our list, but if you really love cigars, it may be worth it. If you're looking for the easiest way to try the best of the best or gift a wonderfully elaborate membership to a cigar aficionado Monthly Clubs, Rare Cigar Club should be at the top of your list of considerations.

Visit Site
3 stars
Gotham Cigar Club

GOTHAM CIGAR CLUB

Visit Site

Cost:

From $24.99

Gotham Cigars, a division of a larger wholesale tobacco company, was created in 2001. The Gotham website provides all things Cigar from a long list of popular brands. Customers can choose from premium cigars, machine made, filtered, and much more.

4 cigar clubs

Besides a plethora of cigars and cigar gift options, Gotham provides four different cigar club memberships to choose from. The Silver Membership is a recurring monthly membership while the other levels are for set durations. Gold members will receive shipments for three months, Platinum members for six months, and Diamond members for 12 months.

5 premium cigars

All four membership levels deliver five premium cigars monthly which are hand selected by Gotham's cigar experts. And every delivery is sent with a detailed newsletter explaining each cigar's origin and flavor profile, has free shipping, and includes a cigar cutter and wooden matches.

Lacking club details

While much of this sounds attractive to the cigar club shopper, Gotham's websites lacks the club details we were looking for. How does Gotham choose their cigars for each delivery? What effort is put into the selection process?

Membership overview:

  • Number of Cigars in Each Delivery: Five
  • Cigar Origin: around the world
  • Duration: 3, 6, or 12 month, or ongoing
  • Frequency: monthly
  • Membership Minimums: 1 shipment
  • Shipping: free

Lower rating

The Cigar Club from Gotham Cigars offers several levels of membership, but lack the delivery frequency options that other clubs provide. That, combined with the disappointing lack of information and insight into how the cigar club selection process is made, contributes to their lower rating.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Instead of searching long and hard for different types and sizes of cigars produced in the best regions around the world, let one of the top cigar clubs deliver them to your door. Rather than weighing the advantages of top name brands vs. smaller limited production labels, have the experts do the work for you and your gift recipient. All you need to do is sit back and enjoy your membership benefits. And get it all at a discounted price compared to buying them individually on your own.

With every shipment you can expect the best cigar clubs to deliver information on each unique selection and the manufacturers. And the very best cigar clubs give you more than just high quality cigars. They give options and allow the customer to tailor the membership to their needs. With a rise in cigar club popularity there is a lot of competition for your business and savvy consumers will do their due diligence.

Be sure to look into these club aspects when choosing the right cigar club for you:

  • Cigar Origin. What regions of the cigar world are the cigars produced? Domestic manufacturers or are they made in more exotic locations?
  • Duration. How long is club membership? Do you have options to make it the right club for you?
  • Frequency. How often do your cigars arrive? Do you have frequency flexibility?
  • Membership Minimums. Do you have the option to cancel membership when the time is right for you? Or are you locked in for specific term lengths?
  • Cost. Compared to the competition, is the club a bargain or over-priced?
  • Shipping. Any extra costs for shipping? What does that do to your overall price?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best cigar clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the right cigar club for your needs!

Light up at these comfy cigar bars in Las Vegas

Visitors can puff away on some of the finest products available Stripside at Davidoff of Geneva Cigar Bar ( 702.473.5001 ), the first cigar bar in the brand's portfolio of boutique retail stores. The ...

Published:  Thu, 19 Nov 2020 00:50:00 GMT



Cigars and rum: The ultimate pairing guide

If you have ever visited Havana, Cuba, then the chances are that you'll be familiar with the classic cigar and rum pairing that is traditionally enjoyed acros ...

Published:  Thu, 12 Nov 2020 09:10:00 GMT



Florida Time: Jose Marti was the father of Freedom Clubs from New York to Key West

And now, on this night, no less than Jose Marti himself stood before them. The man, just 38, had organized Freedom Clubs from New York to Key West. Two decades earlier, Spanish authorities had ...

Published:  Thu, 19 Nov 2020 10:10:00 GMT



Chattanooga Cigar Club exposure warning

The Hamilton County Health Department issues a Covid-19 exposure warning for the Chattanooga Cigar Club on Market Street. Case investigators say that people in their infectious period attended the ...

Published:  Fri, 13 Nov 2020 19:14:00 GMT



The Property Cigar Club Announces Stephen Hendry MBE As Global Brand Ambassador.

Time World Snooker Champion Stephen Hendry MBE has been named the official Global Brand Ambassador for The Property Cigar Club. Stephen Hendry will begin his role on behalf of T ...

Published:  Thu, 12 Nov 2020 07:37:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure