Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Dessert Clubs Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      September 25, 2018

Home  >  Dessert Clubs  >  Harry & David vs Month Club Store

Best

Dessert Clubs

  1. David's Cookies
  2. Wolferman's
  3. Cheryl's
  4. Harry & David
  5. Month Club Store

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
Deliciously  Decadent Cheesecake Recipes Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Acne Products

Coffee Clubs

Company Incorporation

CPA Exam Reviews

Credit Repair Companies

Dog DNA Testing

LLC Formation

Meal Delivery Programs

People Search

Pet Insurance

Wholesale Dropshippers

 

Individual Reviews

Amazing Clubs

David's Cookies

Wolferman's

Cheryl's

Harry & David

Month Club Store

 

Disclosure: We pay our reviewers for their reviews. We are not compensated by companies for their reviews, but we may be compensated for links and advertisements on our website. Click here for details.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Harry & David vs Month Club Store

Best Dessert Clubs

To help you find the Best Dessert Clubs, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Harry & David and Month Club Store.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Dessert Clubs, please Click Here

Finding a new, exciting gift year after year for a friend, family member or business contact can be a challenge. A great new idea that has been gaining in popularity the last few years is a dessert club membership.

In a dessert club, delicious desserts are sent monthly, bi-monthly, or quarterly, depending on the flexibility of the club and the customer's preference. Dessert selections are either predetermined by the company, selected by the gift recipient, or can arrive as a complete surprise. For dessert lovers, especially those hard to buy for, receiving a new dessert every few weeks can be a delightful experience.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2018

Dessert Club Reviews

3 stars
Harry & David

HARRY & DAVID Visit Site

Cost:

From $31.67 to $36.67 per month, plus shipping costs

Harry & David is one of the most popular names in gift-giving. Although some of their most popular items are available in retail stores - their Moose Munch comes to mind - their best selection is available online, including seasonal fruits, gift towers and baskets, and gourmet foods.

Their Dessert of the Month Club includes options of 3, 6, or 12-month deliveries, with selections ranging from premium popcorn and cookies to cheesecake and chocolate-covered strawberries. At the time of our review, prices were $109.99 for a 3-month membership, $209.99 for six months, and $379.99 for a full year's subscription.

Membership Overview:

  • Dessert Selection: Harry & David preselects the desserts for each shipment
  • Duration: 3, 6, or 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly
  • Shipping: $6.99 per shipment

Harry & David does allow you to choose which month you'd like to start shipment of your Dessert of the Month Club from the current month or the next two calendar months. However, your options only include 3, 6, or 12 months, with no option for quarterly deliveries. In other words, if you choose a 3-month membership starting in March, the desserts will come in March, April and May.

One plus is that Harry & David publishes all of their desserts for the calendar year, letting you see well in advance if there's a different time of year you'd rather start your subscription. For example, if their January dessert is a HoneyBell Cheesecake and you're not a fan, you may want to wait until February's selection of Sea Salt Caramels to begin your Dessert Club membership.

We weren't terribly impressed with Harry & David's pricing - average to expensive compared with other competitors - or with the fact that the Dessert Club is not eligible for free shipping within the Celebrations Passport program. This program allows shoppers to pay an annual fee of less than $30 and get free shipping across a whole group of brands that includes 1-800-Flowers, The Popcorn Factory, and Simply Chocolate. Instead, Dessert Club subscribers should expect to pay $6.99 per delivery, even if they purchase the Passport for other purchases. On the other hand, when we visited the site, there was an offer to save 20% off the total subscription cost of any length of membership, which would almost exactly cover those shipping fees.

We do like that Harry & David - and every other brand in the group - offers "the strongest guarantee in the business", where customers can expect a replacement or refund if anything isn't an absolute hit. This is a good thing, especially given that the only review on the Dessert of the Month Club is very negative: the customer said that at least four of the desserts were a disappointment, with a soggy pie, bitter-tasting blondies and brownies, and a dry chocolate cake.

So, should you choose Harry & David's Dessert of the Month Club for your gift-giving needs? They do allow you to include a personalized gift message at no extra charge, or you can select a personalized greeting card for an additional $3.99. And, you may like being able to see which desserts are scheduled each month, to tailor your purchase to your recipient's tastes. Just be aware that at least one customer was less-than-thrilled with the overall quality of the food they received, and be prepared to request a refund or replacement if needed.

Visit Site

2.5 stars
Month Club Store

MONTH CLUB STORE Visit Site

Cost:

From $62.99 to $248.99

Month Club Store provides a cookie club membership that is straightforward but with too few bells and whistles. The website lacks detailed information and a professional appearance that we've come to expect from dessert clubs.

The Month Club Store provides a dessert club that includes 1 dozen cookies delivered each month for 3 to 12 months, based on your selection. Alternatively, you can choose to have 2 dozen cookies delivered for only $6 more per month. One of our concerns when comparing Month Club Store with the other clubs is that the weight of the cookies was not listed and may drastically differ from those offering 1 to 2 pound averages.

The cookies are manufactured by Eileen's Cookies and include choices such as oatmeal raisin, chocolate chip, peanut butter and more. The first delivery includes a personal message of your choice.

Membership Overview:

  • Dessert Selection: Month Club Store selects the cookies for each period
  • Duration: 3 - 12 months
  • Frequency: Monthly only
  • Shipping: Included in the cost

Unlike some of the higher ranked dessert club memberships, you cannot choose from a bimonthly, quarterly or less frequent membership to reduce the overall cost. In addition to lacking flexibility, they also made no guarantee about the product they deliver. Overall, Month Club Store provides a lackluster dessert club membership that is missing a professional appearance, membership flexibility, and a good reason to select them over the higher ranked programs.

Visit Site

Continued from above

However, not all dessert clubs are alike and it's important to understand the policies before you sign up. Important aspects of a dessert club membership to be aware of are:

  • Flexibility. Will you be able to select the length of dessert club membership and frequency of delivery that fits your budget? Will you be able to select the dessert choices or are they selected by the company?
  • Cost. What can you expect to pay for the dessert club that best meets your needs? Can you make monthly payments or do you need to pay a single, flat rate fee?
  • Satisfaction Policy. If you aren't happy with the timeliness, quality or taste of the delivered desserts are you able to stop the membership and receive any portion of the cost back?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Dessert Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the right dessert club to meet your needs!

Palm Desert Duo Donates Birthday Money To Children's Hospital

Funds raised through the Birthday Club will benefit new Children's Hospital tower, currently under construction. LLUCH patient Codi Pelton, 13, of Desert Hot Springs, was all smiles as she ...

Published:  Mon, 24 Sep 2018 13:00:00 GMT



39760 Manzanita Dr, Palm Desert, CA 92260

CA 92260 is a mfd/mobile home for sale located in the Palm Desert Greens Country Club neighborhood. Browse realtor.com® for nearby schools and neighborhood information. Find homes similar to 39760 Man...

Published:  Mon, 24 Sep 2018 04:52:00 GMT



Kris Jenner Picks Up Ultra-Modern Desert Mansion

that describes itself in marketing materials as "the modern interpretation of California's classic old-line country clubs." The sellers were luxury ... According to the Desert Sun, who first sniffed o...

Published:  Mon, 24 Sep 2018 14:28:00 GMT



A Kardashian-Jenner trust bought a Madison Club mansion. Here's a look at the exclusive country club

A Kardashian-Jenner trust bought a Madison Club mansion. Here's a look at the exclusive country club Madison Club is one of the most private and exclusive neighborhoods in the Palm Springs area. Check ...

Published:  Mon, 17 Sep 2018 16:39:00 GMT



Appetizers No. Entrees Don't need "˜em. It's all dessert at this sweet spot in WR

lemon bars, cannoli, double chocolate muffins, banana nut mini-loaves, rice crispy squares and Danish pastries. After that, there is a display of their in-store-only dessert skillets, including a choc...

Published:  Tue, 11 Sep 2018 14:15:00 GMT



New martial arts facility, motorcycle club aim to be an oasis for veterans

His sanctuary is a karate school in Mount Penn that is home to the American Veterans Warriors Martial Arts Club and the clubhouse of the Berks County chapter of the Desert Knights of America Motorcycl...

Published:  Sun, 16 Sep 2018 13:17:00 GMT



12 Surprisingly Easy Cheesecake Bars For Any Occasion

and Bars. She is a wife and mother who is passionate about cooking and baking... especially when chocolate is involved! With 6 small children, meals, snacks, and desserts that come together ...

Published:  Wed, 19 Sep 2018 09:18:00 GMT



39800 Desert Greens Dr E Dr E, Palm Desert, CA 92260

CA 92260 is a mfd/mobile home for sale located in the Palm Desert Greens Country Club neighborhood. Browse realtor.com® for nearby schools and neighborhood information. Find homes similar to 39800 Des...

Published:  Sat, 15 Sep 2018 04:37:00 GMT



Share Us!    Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Twitter Share TopConsumerReviews.com on LinkedIn Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Google+ Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure