Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Diamonds Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      January 24, 2020

Home  >  Diamonds  >  James Allen vs Kay Jewelers

Best

Diamonds

  1. James Allen
  2. Jared
  3. Ross & Simons
  4. Kay Jewelers
  5. Diamonds USA
  6. Diamond Princess
  7. Sun Jewelry
  8. Carats Direct 2 U

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
How to Buy Jewelry Online Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Cheesecake Clubs

Chocolate Clubs

Copyright Registration

Credit Monitoring

Dog Treat Clubs

Painting Lessons

Popcorn Clubs

Wedding Planning Software

 

Individual Reviews

Blue Nile

James Allen

Jared

Ross & Simons

Kay Jewelers

Diamonds USA

Diamond Princess

Sun Jewelry

Carats Direct 2 U

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

James Allen vs Kay Jewelers

Best Online Diamond Stores

To help you find the Best Diamonds, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of James Allen and Kay Jewelers.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Diamonds, please Click Here

If you've purchased a loose diamond before, you know that it's both an art and a science. Carat size, color, certification, depth, symmetry, retail mark-up, and many other factors determine the ultimate price of a diamond.

Most retail diamond stores are typically equipped to provide you with only 2 or 3 choices of stones in your desired size and price range. That means that you'll most likely have to drive between several retail locations, trying to find a diamond that you can afford and feel confident about.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Diamonds Reviews

4.5 stars
James Allen

JAMES ALLEN

Visit Site

Diamond Selection:

Over 100,000

James Allen is an online jewelry retailer in business since 1999. This Maryland based company specializes in the ultimate diamond shopping experience. Unlike most diamond retailers, James Allen providers shoppers an actual 360 degree image of each of their diamonds available for sale. Shoppers will also like the extended return policy and A+ Better Business Bureau rating.

Features:

  • 24,425 diamonds available for purchase
  • 60 day money back return policy
  • GIA, IGI, AGS certified diamonds
  • 1500 engagement settings
  • Real 360 degree images of each diamond
  • Diamond certification letters attached
  • A+ BBB rating

James Allen offers a well organized website and solid search engine but really stands out with their technology. Many people want to see the actual diamond they are purchasing before making the leap. James Allen puts the shopper at ease by providing a 360 degree image to get the best look and feel of the diamond before making the purchase. The accompanied diamond certifications also help in the process. For those that are "seeing is believing" folks, James Allen is a great place to shop.

The selection of diamonds is also impressive. For those that are new to the purchase process, they need to be aware of the diamond grading with the stone they choose. GIA is considered the elite certification company in diamond grading. A "G" colored stone by GIA standards will tend to be less colorful than those of the IGI and AGS companies. However, the actual pictures of stones will eliminate many of the customers questions and allows for a better side-by- side comparison.

We also liked the abundant selection of diamond settings. The pictures of the options are large and easy to see. We think this is very helpful for those that want to feel confident before making such an expensive purchase. James Allen allows customers to choose either the diamond or setting first and the process of putting the two together is simple.

However, if you aren't fully satisfied with your purchase, James Allen provides a generous, no-hassle 60 day return policy that customers can feel good about.

James Allen provides diamond shoppers a huge selection of diamonds to choose from. The generous, no-hassle return policy and amazing diamond pictures is very appealing. James Allen receives one of our highest rankings.

Visit Site
3.5 stars
Kay Jewelers

KAY JEWELERS

Visit Site

Diamond Selection:

3,836

Kay Jewelers is another chain store that offers a decent selection of diamonds for purchase over the Internet. While chain jewelry stores aren't our favorite choice, we know that many people like them for their good service. When purchasing an item from Kay Jewelers, online, you may take it in for service and repair at a local store. Kay Jewelers also comes with a strong Better Business Bureau A+ rating.

Features:

  • 3,836 diamonds available for purchase
  • 60 days return, 90 day exchange
  • GIA, IGI, AGS certified diamonds
  • 55 engagement settings
  • Actual pictures
  • Diamond certification letters attached
  • A+ BBB rating

The online shopping experience at Kay Jewelers is functional. Shoppers will find the option to sort by diamond shape, color, clarity, carat size, and price. Additional options include narrowing by certification lab, polish, symmetry and more. Customers will appreciate the real pictures of the actual diamonds sold at Kay, along with the option to drag their simulated loupe over the stone to look for inclusions. This is a nice feature that one of the other companies also offers. Many people want to see an actual picture of the diamond and this is a great way to feel like you know what you're buying.

Once you've chosen a diamond the website allows the option to choose a matching setting. Unfortunately there's only a limited selection compared to many other companies reviewed.

Kay offers a nice 60 day return and 90 day exchange policy if you're not satisfied with your purchase. Please see the specific policy online to identify any exclusions.

Overall, Kay Jewelers has serviced millions of happy customers and will continue to do so with their online options. We were less excited about the diamond and setting selections at Kay but appreciate the perfect BBB score and customer policies.

Visit Site

Continued from above

While the task of finding the right diamond has traditionally been a frustrating and time-consuming process, the internet has made all this much easier. With the introduction of online diamond stores in the last few years, you now have access to thousands of diamonds, and can easily choose the color range, clarity, cut, and more that you're looking for. You can also compare several diamonds at the same time to find the best diamond at the best price.

Not all online diamond stores are the same. Before making your big diamond purchase, you should consider the following:

  • Selection. How large is the diamond selection? Will there be a substantial selection of all diamond cuts in various grades and color?
  • BBB Rating. What kind of history does the company have with their customers?
  • Return Policy. If your diamond purchase shows up at your doorstep but doesn't dazzle you, will you be able to return it for a full refund?
  • Settings. Will you be able to set your diamond purchase in a beautiful mounting, if so desired?
  • Diamond Certification. What lab certification companies review the diamond selection? Will you be buying the best quality diamond for the money?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Diamond Stores available today. We hope these reviews help you find the perfect diamond that you're looking for!

Shareholder in Russia's Alrosa proposes selling up to $1 billion of diamonds to Gokhran: Ifax

The government of Russia's Yakutia region, which has a stake in diamond producer Alrosa, has proposed the company sell rough diamonds worth $0.5-$1 billion to the precious metals and gems repository ...

Published:  Tue, 21 Jan 2020 06:17:00 GMT



Charlize Theron Wore Diamonds In Her Hair For The Most Relatable Reason

© AFF-USA/Shutterstock The next time you don't have time to get to the salon to refresh your hair colour, you could reach for a temporary root fix - or you could raid your jewellery box like Charlize ...

Published:  Mon, 20 Jan 2020 04:30:47 GMT



Jennifer Lopez Is Well-Accessorized at SAG Awards with $9 Million in Diamonds and Dapper Fiance Alex Rodriguez

Lopez swept her hair back into a bun, leaving a few pieces out to frame her face, and accessorized with $9 million of Harry Winston diamonds (including a 73.55 carat necklace). Her proud fiance Alex ...

Published:  Sun, 19 Jan 2020 18:21:00 GMT



Jennifer Lopez wore $9 million in diamonds to SAG Awards

Awards look. The 50-year-old actress and singer stunned on the red carpet at the annual awards ceremony on Sunday (19.01.20), in a head-turning ensemble comprised of a whopping $9 million in Harry ...

Published:  Mon, 20 Jan 2020 02:15:00 GMT



All the Details on Jennifer Aniston's 2020 SAG Awards Diamonds

Jennifer Aniston is having a night as big as the diamond ring on her finger. The Morning Show actress proved that less is more tonight at the 2020 SAG Awards red carpet, from her simple yet elegant ...

Published:  Sun, 19 Jan 2020 18:58:00 GMT



Has King of Diamonds reopened? A new strip club has popped up with a similar name

Is King of Diamonds back? Roughly a year after the last cheek ceased shaking at the beloved strip club's North Miami venue, a new strip club called KOD Miami has opened. The original King of Diamonds ...

Published:  Wed, 22 Jan 2020 13:14:00 GMT



Jennifer Lopez Rocks Over $9 Million Worth of Diamonds at 2020 SAG Awards -- See the Stunning Look!

Pulling out all the stops for the annual awards, J.Lo wore over $9 million worth of Harry Winston Diamonds. Her luxurious jewels consisted of a cascading diamond drop necklace, diamond drop earrings, ...

Published:  Tue, 21 Jan 2020 06:38:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure