Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Flooring Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      July 12, 2020

Home  >  Flooring  >  Menard's vs Simple Floors

Best

Flooring

  1. Lowe's
  2. Wayfair
  3. Build Direct
  4. Menards
  5. Fast Floors
  6. Simple Floors

Your Information Is Secure
Home Decorating Tips Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Bicycle Parts

Calendars

Credit Counseling

Feather Pillows

GMAT Test Prep

GRE Test Prep

Hemorrhoid Relief

Homeschool Supplies

LSAT Test Prep

MCAT Test Prep

Senior Care

Thyroid Health

 

Individual Reviews

Home Depot

Lowe's

Wayfair

Build Direct

Menard's

Fast Floors

Simple Floors

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Menard's vs Simple Floors

To help you find the Best Flooring, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Menard's and Simple Floors.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Flooring, please Click Here

Get Your Flooring at Home Depot Today! Where can you find the best flooring for your home or business? Making the right choice can mean the difference between a space you love and one that irritates you every time you see it. Naturally, the first decision on the list is what kind of flooring best suits the room you're considering and your own tastes.

Possibilities run the gamut: carpet is still a traditional choice for bedrooms and living rooms, imitation and genuine wood has become one of today's most popular flooring options, and tile takes first place in many homes further south. From there, you'll still need to decide on the color, quality and durability, and any finishes you prefer.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Flooring Reviews

3 stars
Menards

MENARDS

Visit Site

Return Policy:

90 days, may be charged a 25% restocking fee

Menards is a family-owned company, headquartered in Eau Claire, Wisconsin and in business for more than 60 years. You'll find an excellent variety of flooring products when you shop at Menards.

Great selection of flooring options

The flooring options at Menards include:

  • Tile & Stone
  • Carpet & Carpet Tiles
  • Laminate
  • Vinyl
  • Hardwood
  • Area Rugs, Mats & Runners
  • Cork
  • Exercise & Gym
  • Garage
  • Fan Shop (e.g. sports-themed flooring options)

Sample swatches

Not sure how your flooring will look in your home or office? Keep an eye out for the "Order Sample Swatches" button below the "Go to Cart" button. You'll have to pay for the sample, but it'll give you the chance to see and feel the flooring in person.

Stores are mainly in the midwest

Menards has a limited presence when it comes to brick-and-mortar locations. If you're fortunate enough to have a store near you, that will make returns easier - but some locations are hundreds of miles away. If you don't live in the Midwest, you probably won't have a Menards within a reasonable driving distance. That could be a problem if the type of flooring you want is one of the many that are listed as "sold in stores" or "ship to store" only. We found that to be the case for many of the options on the site.

Hit or miss helpful information

We also found their online flooring store to be somewhat hit-or-miss. When we first visited the site, we were excited to see a link for a Flooring Calculator - but we got a 404 Not Found error after we clicked on it, and then the link was gone when the page refreshed! On a more positive note, Menards offers buying guides for most of the flooring types they carry, so if you need information about carpet terminology, PEI Ratings for tile, or which wood species is the right fit for your home, you'll get some guidance there.

90 day return policy

How about returns? Generally speaking, Menards allows for returns for up to 90 days after purchase, with a 25% restocking fee on custom orders. They don't specify if flooring is considered a custom purchase, but on items like carpet where you have to enter a cut size/length, we think it's better safe than sorry to expect a restocking charge. Because this store seems to assume that you've got a store nearby, they don't offer many details about returns - especially with online orders. We're not sure what their policy is if you live too far away to bring your flooring order back to a store.

Overall, Menards has an ample selection of flooring across brands and types. If you live near one of the 300+ retail locations scattered across 14 states, it could be a big money-saver to order your flooring online and pick up in-store. However, because there are other online flooring stores that make the buying process easier for people across the US, Menards only earns an average rating.

Visit Site
1 star
Simple Floors

SIMPLE FLOORS

Visit Site

Return Policy:

None provided

Based in Atlanta with showrooms throughout the US, Simple Floors specializes in hardwood, bamboo, cork and laminate styles, but you'll also find traditional carpet and vinyl in their online inventory.

Few options, but free samples

You won't find as many options when shopping for your flooring at this retailer. They carry mostly off brands, instead of the big-name manufacturers you might recognize. That's reflected in their pricing: when we shopped Simple Floors recently, some of their most popular engineered and hand scraped hardwoods ranged from $4.32 to $7.49 per square foot. We appreciate that Simple Floors provides free samples (with no shipping charges) so that you can make sure what you see on the screen is a good match for what you have in mind for your home.

Lack of heelpful tools

This site doesn't offer too much in the way of tools. You can find measurement information on the "How Much Do I Need?" link at the bottom of the site, but it's mostly a bunch of text and not much in the way of visuals. It's also very focused on hardwood flooring, so if you're looking to install carpet this section might not be as useful. It may be easier if you call their toll-free number to speak to one of their personal flooring consultants.

Website pages missing

Simple Floors used to have a posted return policy of 14 days, along with a 25% restocking fee. But at the time of our most recent visit, the Returns link on their site returned a "404 Not Found" error. Not very reassuring, is it? We had similar issues when we looked for additional information on the FAQ page and the Customer Testimonials link.

With an "A+" rating from the BBB, Simple Floors obviously isn't doing a terrible job at keeping customers happy - but we think that has more to do with their brick-and-mortar sales than their online service. For the majority of customers wanting to buy their flooring online, this store leaves a lot to be desired. We think you'll have a much more satisfying shopping experience with any of the higher-ranked flooring stores in our review.

Visit Site

Continued from above

While shopping at your local home improvement or flooring specialty store might be your first thought, it may not be your best move. Why? Sometimes calling that toll-free number (you know, the one that everyone seems to have memorized from the TV commercials and radio spots?) leaves you tied to pushy salespeople who don't necessarily have your preferences and budget as their priority.

The route that many savvy shoppers are taking is buying their flooring online. Not only does that free you from the in-home pressure of a sales rep, but it also gives you the world's best inventory with just a few clicks of the mouse. There's no need to schedule an appointment or wait for samples when you can browse all of it 24/7. Plus, the best online flooring retailers give you all the tools you need to get the right measurements the first time, for a perfect DIY installation. And, many of them can also connect you with licensed professionals, if you don't feel like tackling the job yourself.

No two flooring companies are alike. How can you tell which one should earn your business? Here are several criteria to keep in mind:

  • Selection. You're more likely to get flooring that is "just right" if the store offers ample brands, styles, and price points.
  • Tools. How does the online retailer help you with your purchase? Are there measuring tools, guides for which flooring is right for your home, climate and usage?
  • Customer Service. Can you get your questions answered by a real person if something comes up during the ordering process or installation?
  • Pricing. Compared with other online flooring retailers, are their products priced favorably? Are there any money-saving perks in place, like free shipping or promotional discounts?
  • Return Policy. What happens if your flooring arrives and it's not what you expected? Can you return it? If so, how long do you have to make your decision, and will there be any restocking fees deducted from your refund?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best flooring stores available today. We hope this information helps you find the perfect carpet, tile or other flooring for your home or office!

COVID-19 pandemic brings big increase in demand for flooring materials in Colorado Springs, nationwide

A major benefactor is the flooring industry -- businesses that make, install or refinish carpet, hardwood, tile floors and similar surfaces. Flooring companies in Colorado Springs said they're ...

Published:  Sat, 11 Jul 2020 10:47:00 GMT



How to choose the right flooring for your kitchen

Say you've already done your homework and learned the basics about flooring for your kitchen: It should be durable, water-resistant and simple to ...

Published:  Thu, 02 Jul 2020 14:42:00 GMT



Wellmade Flooring to build first manufacturing plant in Georgia

Oregon-based Wellmade Flooring is set to invest $35 million to build its first manufacturing facility in Georgia.

Published:  Thu, 02 Jul 2020 13:21:00 GMT



Lynx Equity buys DeBenedetto's Commercial Flooring

Canadian private equity firm Lynx Equity has acquired DeBenedetto's Commercial Flooring, a Portland, Oregon-based provider of commercial flooring solutions.

Published:  Wed, 08 Jul 2020 08:08:00 GMT



Kaiser Flooring

Cheyenne, Wyoming in 2005. With strong ties to the community, our reputation is on the line with every job we tackle. Unlike big box flooring suppliers, we can't hide behind an out-of-state corporate ...

Published:  Wed, 08 Jul 2020 13:59:51 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure