Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Fruit Baskets Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      June 5, 2020

Home  >  Fruit Baskets  >  Manhattan Fruitier vs Pittman & Davis

Best

Fruit Baskets

  1. Harry & David
  2. A Gift Inside
  3. Manhattan Fruitier
  4. Stew Leonard's
  5. Shari's Berries
  6. Wine Country Gift Bskts
  7. All About Gifts
  8. Gift Tree
  9. Pittman & Davis
  10. Gourmet Gift Baskets
  11. FTD
  12. Design It Yourself
  13. Edible Gifts Plus

Your Information Is Secure
101 Gift Basket Ideas Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Bad Credit Loans

Buying Gold

College Textbooks

GMAT Test Prep

Investment Newsletters

MCAT Test Prep

Photo Books

Seafood

Slipcovers

Structured Settlement Buyers

 

Individual Reviews

The Fruit Company

Harry & David

A Gift Inside

Manhattan Fruitier

Stew Leonard's Gift Baskets

Shari's Berries

Wine Country Gift Baskets

All About Gifts and Baskets

Gift Tree

Pittman & Davis

Gourmet Gift Baskets

FTD

Design It Yourself Gifts and Baskets

Edible Gifts Plus

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Manhattan Fruitier vs Pittman & Davis

Best Fruit Baskets

To help you find the Best Fruit Baskets, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Manhattan Fruitier and Pittman & Davis.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Fruit Baskets, please Click Here

Who has the best fruit baskets? Fruit Baskets make for a fun and delicious gift. Do you have that one family member that is always so difficult to buy for because they have everything? Or how about that client that you want to surprise with a thank you gift and have no idea what to get? Are you tired of sending flowers or gift cards and want to select something that helps you stand out?

Fruit baskets are a great way to show you care. Not only are they healthy, they're tasty and can be a special way to charm anyone on your gift giving list. However, when you're trying to decide which fruit basket to give, the choices can seem a little daunting.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Fruit Basket Reviews

4 stars
Manhattan Fruitier

MANHATTAN FRUITIER

Visit Site

Cost:

From $40 to $375

Inspired by Dutch still-life paintings and nature, Manhattan Fruitier's products are created to delight. The fresh fruit gifts have been handcrafted to provide tasteful and elegant gifts for any occasion. All baskets are made from natural materials and are designed to be reusable and minimize waste. They can be delivered anywhere in the US but do have some options only available for delivery in NYC.

Manhattan Fruitier has many options to choose from and range in price from $40 to $375. Baskets can include: fruit, flowers, nuts, chocolates, brownies, cookies and dried fruit. One basket even offers a jar of apricot jam made fresh in the Hamptons. All contents of the basket are detailed in the description, but often one of the contents listed is "Fresh Fruit - Exotic and Seasonal fresh fruits" so you do not know if you will receive apples, oranges, pears or another type of fruit.

The York Hamper is a great example of this and will cost $60, or $75 if you want only organic fruits. It will include approximately 9 pieces of fresh fruit (exotic or seasonal fresh fruits), along with the cute, closed lid hamper and some fresh flowers and leaves to create an artful delight. The picture shows the basket including a kiwi, 3 oranges, an apple, 2 pears, a mango, and an avocado, but you are not guaranteed that this is what you will receive. You do need to be cautious when comparing prices of baskets here to other sites on this list as you will most likely get less fruit for the same price, but it will look amazing!

Shopping for baskets on the Manhattan Fruitier site is very easy. They have a special feature called "Quick Shop" that allows you to easily narrow your options by price and occasion so that you can quickly pick the basket or box that is perfect. While viewing the details behind each product, there is also a section that allows you to put in your zip code so you can learn the shipping price while you are browsing. This will help you determine the total price of the basket when determining which one to purchase and you won't be shocked by the shipping prices when checking out. If you are not local to NYC, you can click the checkbox at the top of the search page to show only the results that deliver nationwide. This puts the NYC options at the end of the list, so you are not distracted by a gift that cannot be delivered to your location.

Manhattan Fruitier gives you several ways to pay for your fruit basket, including 3 major credit cards (sorry Discover card users) and PayPal, making it convenient to purchase gifts. They do indicate that they protect your information but are a little vague on the details of how they do it.

Manhattan Fruitier is dedicated to inspiring delight with the products they deliver and the customer service experience they provide. They cater to every customer and provide personalized service by listening carefully and exceeding expectations. Even though you are unable to return your gift basket once delivered (since it contains perishable goods), they do provide a satisfaction guarantee ensuring your fruit arrives in pristine condition or it will be replaced. This gives you the confidence of knowing that your experience will be positive and the gift will be beautiful!

The main downsides to Manhattan Fruitier are cost, the lack of specifics on the type of fresh fruit you will receive for many of their baskets and the fact that some offerings are only available to a limited NYC audience. But they do make beautiful creations and you can tell that they pay attention to the details. They take the time to pick and choose the best fruits for your basket and make sure it is free from bruising or blemishes. Also, any of the fruit that does not meet their high standards for quality to include in a basket is donated to City Harvest, a food rescue organization in NYC. All the reviews clearly indicate many satisfied customers and it comes as no surprise that they also have an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.

So, if you are looking for a sophisticated and artfully styled gift that is sure to leave an impression, Manhattan Fruitier is a solid choice, especially if you are local to NYC.

Visit Site
3 stars
Pittman & Davis

PITTMAN & DAVIS

Visit Site

Cost:

From $22.99 - $119.99

Pittman & Davis offers an extensive array of fruit gift baskets for consumers. They supply over 40 options, and provide pictures with each gift basket available, allowing transparency for products offered. Additionally, they provide a filter towards the left side of the screen, allowing you to narrow the numerous options down to those that best meet your budget.

Fruit gift basket options primarily include some combination of Navel Oranges, Ruby Red Grapefruits, Comice Pears, Red Apples, Clementines, D'Anjou Pears, Fuji Apples, Mountain Apples, and Starkrimson Pears. Select gift baskets also offer various chocolates, cheeses, nuts, and cookies assortments, in addition to the fruit. Amongst the gift baskets available, Pittman & Davis sell several different Holiday themed baskets, Family Gourmet baskets, and baskets which honor the local Texas culture of the company, such as the "Texas Two-Step" basket.

While Pittman & Davis have built up quite a loyal fan base over the near 100 years of their operation, we find that the company's selection of baskets could offer more creative designs and an even wider variety of fruits, when compared with the other contenders on our list. Pittman & Davis do an excellent job of delivering quality fruit options for customers at budget-friendly prices - however, so do many other companies on our list, and they do so in a more thoughtfully packaged manner.

Pittman & Davis offer free standard shipping on all purchases, and provide consumers with a "family-feel" to their business. They will likely meet your needs when searching for a fruit gift basket to order - but there are other companies that will go above and beyond your expectations for similar prices. And while Pittman & Davis advertise a full refund for unsatisfied customers, many reviews have painted less than ideal pictures of their customer service team. In fact, we found several reports where customers dialed customer service, only to be hung up on or responded to in an unkind manner. Although the majority of reviews highlighted pleased customers, there were enough of these poor reviews that make the claims worth considering when making your fruit basket purchase.

While Pittman & Davis do offer an extensive variety of fruit baskets for affordable prices, their fruit selection could ultimately be more robust and their presentation more impressive for customers. Additionally, the complaints of poor customer service are worrisome. You could likely find a basket to fit your needs within your budget with Pittman & Davis, but if there is financial flexibility, we recommend higher rated companies on our list.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Some questions that might come to mind include where do I find a reputable company, how can I ensure the fruit is good and not too ripe, what type of fruit do I want to include in the basket? When looking for the best company to purchase your fruit basket, you'll want to consider the following:

  • Supplier of the Fruit. Where is the fruit grown and how does it make its way to your gift basket? Will it change hands several times before it gets to you? Or will it come straight from the orchard? The freshest fruits will come from companies with a direct connection to an Orchard.
  • Selection. How many different choices does the company have? Do they have a range of prices and sizes available so that you can find the perfect one? Is there variety in the contents of each basket to delight the recipient?
  • Cost. How does the cost compare from one site to another? How much fruit am I getting in the basket compared to a similar product on another site? What are the shipping costs? Are there any service fees?
  • Satisfaction Guarantee. Does the site offer a satisfaction guarantee? Under what circumstances will that guarantee be valid? Fresh fruit is a perishable item that is rarely able to be returned. Working with a company that has a satisfaction guarantee will protect you and ensure you are satisfied with your purchase.

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Fruit Baskets available today. We hope these reviews help you find the perfect fruit basket for your needs right away!

Celebrating Father's Day from afar? Send Dad a delicious gift basket

Father's Day is right around the corner - and if you can't spend the day with Dad this year, you can celebrate from afar. One way you can show your dad how much you love and appreciate him is by ...

Published:  Wed, 03 Jun 2020 17:07:00 GMT



From One Frontline Worker To Another: Allegheny Co. Sheriff's Deputies Deliver Fruit Baskets To Medical Workers

Some local medical workers received some fresh fruit baskets Thursday morning, courtesy of the Allegheny County Sheriff's Office.

Published:  Thu, 28 May 2020 13:03:00 GMT



43 birthday ideas for a fun and socially distant celebration

Anyone from Mom to Grandma would enjoy this edible work of art. 3. Edible Arrangements Happy Birthday Fruit Basket Edible Arrangements Happy Birthday Fruit Basket Edible Arrangements Happy Birthday ...

Published:  Wed, 03 Jun 2020 17:06:00 GMT



Que sera sera: With holidays and fruit baskets, people of Bangladesh tackle Covid-19

Bangladeshis line up with fruit baskets for quarantined patients and tend to treat the Covid-19 pandemic like any other viral infection that kills hundreds every monsoon ...

Published:  Fri, 22 May 2020 01:04:00 GMT



Modern Pops are sweet, puckery, and mostly made of flash-frozen whole fruit

Just 45 to 60 calories each the pops' flavors include strawberry lemonade, pineapple, raspberry pomegranate, mango, and more.

Published:  Tue, 02 Jun 2020 09:06:00 GMT



Allegheny County Sheriff's Office Delivers Fresh Fruit Baskets To Frontline Workers

Frontline workers at Allegheny General Hospital and UPMC Mercy got a special delivery this morning -- fresh fruit baskets from the Allegheny County Sheriff's Office.

Published:  Thu, 28 May 2020 11:02:00 GMT



This company knows that a thoughtful, well-timed gift can actually help close deals

When it comes to closing a deal, timing is everything. Great salespeople know that a thoughtful, well-timed gift can make a world of difference. But many people still resort to cheap wine, baskets ...

Published:  Wed, 03 Jun 2020 08:50:00 GMT



The best healthy food delivery services for 2020: Blue Apron, Freshly, Sun Basket and more

If you've been struggling to resist the siren call of heavy comfort food and chocolatey treats while you're coping with quarantine, fret not! Healthy eating is still achievable during a pandemic. If ...

Published:  Thu, 28 May 2020 19:17:00 GMT



People spend weekend at Bilpin Fruit Bowl in Bilpin, Australia

People spend their weekend at the Bilpin Fruit Bowl in Bilpin, Australia, on May 30, 2020. (Xinhua/Bai Xuefei) People spend their weekend at the Bilpin Fruit Bowl in Bilpin, Australia, on May 30, 2020 ...

Published:  Sat, 30 May 2020 19:31:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure