TopConsumerReviews.com is a world-leading consumer product review site. We provide detailed reviews and ratings for thousands of products and services.

 

One Great Family vs My Heritage

We recommend

 

Disclosure: We are not compensated by companies for their reviews, but we may be compensated for links and advertisements on our website. Click here for details.

 

ONE GREAT FAMILY

One of the most common goals for people looking to explore their ancestry is to create a family tree, and One Great Family does that quite well. With a tagline of "the world's largest online family tree", it's no surprise that One Great Family specializes in helping people around the world connect with each other through the creation of family trees.

One Great Family's online family tree service is different from those offered by other genealogy websites in several ways. First and foremost, much of what One Great Family does is automated, from identifying and eliminating duplicated data to searching for matches among different user-entered trees. When discrepancies are found, One Great Family highlights them and prompts the user to analyze the differences and makes suggestions for how to resolve them.

Access to One Great Family's "world tree" costs $14.95 for a monthly plan, and customers have the option to choose the discounted quarterly ($29.95) or yearly ($79.95) plans. For an additional $70, yearly subscribers can access a one-hour consultation with a One Great Family genealogy specialist, to get personalized help with their specific tree. Prospective users can get a free 7-day trial, in order to determine if One Great Family's service will be a good fit for their genealogy needs.

While we like the automated nature of One Great Family's family tree service, especially because it has the potential to save users a considerable amount of time when compiling their trees, we wonder if similar connections can be made using one of the other genealogy services in our reviews - ones that not only have the ability to create and share family trees, but also to access the kinds of documentation to substantiate the information entered in those trees (for example, birth certificates to prove birthdates and places, census records that show all of the members of a household).

In that vein, we question whether or not One Great Family's trees might have the downside of perpetuating misinformation across multiple users trees; for example, if one user enters a mistaken death date and five other users agree with it, despite its being incorrect, that information could be accepted by multiple people without any connections to a source document to refute it.

In summary, One Great Family offers a unique automated process to building one's family tree, and appears to do that quite well, but genealogy lovers may find a more robust package of services and information with one of the other providers in our review.

Visit Site >

MY HERITAGE

Based in Israel with additional offices in Utah and California, My Heritage has been making connections between genealogy researchers and their ancestors since 2005. With more than 83 million users and 33 million family trees, My Heritage is clearly committed to helping people connect with one another. In fact, their Smart Match and Record Match system automatically alerts users when any records pop up that might be related to someone entered in their family tree. Those matches come from My Heritage's more than six billion historical records, from census records in the US, UK, and even Nordic nations, to family trees created by users at Family Search, Geni, and My Heritage itself.

Where My Heritage loses us is when it comes to their pricing and membership options. It takes a considerable amount of digging through the website to determine that there are three membership plans: Data, Premium, and Premium Plus. For $119.40 per year, a Data Subscription allows users full access to My Heritage's SuperSearch and Record Match features. The Premium plan includes up to 2500 people in the family tree, Family Tree Builder Premium, priority customer support, and several special features like Timeline and Enhanced Smart Matching. Premium Plus includes all of the benefits of the Premium plan, along with an unlimited number of people within the family tree and the ability to use My Heritage's Instant Discoveries feature, which allows users to add a group of ancestors in one click rather than having to enter each one individually.

What do those upgrades cost? Even after a considerable search of the site itself, the only information My Heritage makes available is "contact our sales representative for more information". Given that the starter plan is already a considerable amount, we would expect much more transparency with their pricing plans, especially with some user reviews stating that the pricing may vary based on how many users one has in his or her family tree.

We also were discouraged to see so many negative user reviews, almost exclusively regarding My Heritage's pricing and difficulty in getting refunds. Many customers complain that they attempted to cancel during a 14-day free trial period but were billed anyway, and getting a refund proved difficult-to-impossible for a significant number of users.

While My Heritage may give users access to an excellent variety of records and have features that make family tree building a simple process, their customer service and pricing information (or lack thereof) give us pause. In order to improve their rating, we'd expect to see more obvious pricing information and improvement in customer reviews, particularly with respect to refunds.

Visit Site >


Genealogy

To help you find the Best Ancestry Services, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of One Great Family and My Heritage.

Genealogy, or the study of family history and lines of descent, is second only to gardening in terms of its popularity in the United States. From TV shows like Finding Your Roots and Who Do You Think You Are?, to DNA testing kits that show an individual's unique genetic roots and relatives throughout the world, it's easy to see that learning about one's ancestry has captured the hearts and minds of millions of people.

In the past, researching a family tree was an arduous, often lengthy process. Vital documents had to be requested from local, state, and federal governments, and sometimes required proof of kinship in order to be granted. Many of these requests came with significant fees, sometimes as much as $20 per document.

Also, it was not uncommon for a request to go unfilled because the details provided by the requestor were incorrect - perhaps the individual was actually born in an adjacent county, or in a different year, or had a different name on his or her birth certificate.

Further complicating matters, most people's family trees contain ancestors whose native language was not English, making it even more difficult to locate and request information. Fortunately, today's genealogy buff has access to an unprecedented amount of birth and death certificates, obituaries, census records, and other researchers' results, just to name a few.

Genealogy services can help people find out more about their family history in a matter of minutes, rather than months or even years, through indexed records, broad databases, and even translations of vital documents from many different countries. Modern technology also allows genealogy buffs to take their research to the next level through DNA testing.

Often with just a simple swab of the cheek or a vial of saliva, curious individuals can get scientific evidence of their roots, connect with people who have shared ancestors, even discover family traits that have been passed down for generations.

  • Cost. How much will you need to pay to access the records and other information on the site? Are there monthly options, if you only need to find a few records, or discounts for yearly subscriptions?
  • Variety of information available. What types of records does the site provide? Is it a wide range of governmental data (e.g. census, death certificates, etc.), published information (e.g. obituaries and other newspaper articles), and family trees submitted by other users? Can the information the site provides be found for free on other websites?
  • Family tree features. Does the service allow you to create your own family tree and easily link information you find on the site? Are you able to connect with other researchers interested in the same ancestral line? Can you add photos, stories, and other personal details to your family tree?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Genealogy Services available today. We hope these reviews help you find your ancestors and discover more about your own family tree today!



Genealogy In The News

Genealogy helps solve 2007 murder mystery of woman killed in Carlsbad apartment

It took DNA, genealogy and a lot of work, but after 11 years, the case of the brutal killing of a woman in her Carlsbad apartment - an attack that still lacks apparent motive - has been solved, author...

Published:  Tue, 13 Nov 2018 17:29:00 GMT



Take your genealogy research to the next level

If you're looking to start a family tree or find missing information in an existing project, check this out - East Central Regional Library is pleased to introduce access to MyHeritage Library Edition ...

Published:  Thu, 15 Nov 2018 10:45:00 GMT



Genealogy meeting to explore animal history

EDMOND - Animals have history, too. "The Squawk, Meow and Roar of Animal Genealogy" will be presented by Amy Stephens during the Edmond Genealogical Society's meeting at 6:30 p.m. Nov. 19 at the ...

Published:  Wed, 14 Nov 2018 01:00:00 GMT



'I honestly never thought they would find him': DNA test, genetic genealogy lead to arrest in woman's 2001 killing

An Orlando, Florida, man is behind bars and accused of killing a young woman 17 years ago, after police say he was identified through genetic genealogy. Authorities arrested Benjamin Holmes Friday ...

Published:  Tue, 06 Nov 2018 11:29:00 GMT



Investigators turn to genealogy databases to solve old crimes

WEBVTT THERE ARE SOME SERIOUS, ETHICAL ISSUES. KRISTEN: IT IS A TAKE -- IT IS A CASE THAT TOOK DECADES TO SOLVE. ACCORDING TO THE ATTORNEY GENERAL'S OFFICE, DNA TESTING LED INVESTIGATORS TO UNCOVER HI...

Published:  Tue, 13 Nov 2018 09:17:00 GMT



DNA match from genealogy website leads Orlando detectives to suspect in 2001 slaying of college student

Results from a genealogy website led Orlando detectives to the arrest of a man they believe killed a University of Central Florida student 17 years ago. Benjamin Holmes, 38, was arrested Friday on cha...

Published:  Wed, 07 Nov 2018 08:40:00 GMT



Genetic genealogy and how it's being used to help solve cold cases

Genealogy is a popular way for people to learn about their ancestry. Now, it's become a major asset for law enforcement in helping solve cold cases. When investigators tracked down the suspected ...

Published:  Tue, 13 Nov 2018 16:32:00 GMT




We recommend

 

- View Full Site -