October 19, 2019

Home > Gift Baskets > Design It Yourself Gift Baskets vs The Best Gift Baskets

Best

Gift Baskets

Compare Products

Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
Compare

Latest Reviews

Ballroom Dancing Lessons

Self Publishing Companies

Teeth Whiteners

VOIP Services

Wedding Planning Software

Wills

Individual Reviews

Gift Tree

Gourmet Gift Baskets

Design It Yourself Gift Baskets

All About Gifts and Baskets

Pemberton Farms

Canterberry Gifts

The Best Gift Baskets

From You Flowers

Gift Basket

Gift Basket Occasions

How to Choose the Right Gift Basket

What Is a Gift Basket?

What Types Of Gift Baskets Can Be Ordered?

Why Gift Baskets Make Impressive Gifts

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Design It Yourself Gift Baskets vs The Best Gift Baskets

To help you find the Best Gift Baskets, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Design It Yourself Gift Baskets and The Best Gift Baskets.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Gift Baskets, please Click Here

Where can you find the best Gift Baskets? Gift-giving can be a challenge - what do you give your neighbor who just had a baby? What arrangement sends the right message to a colleague, striking the perfect balance of "wow" and "professional"? And, everyone knows that gift cards are just plain boring, right?

Gift baskets hit all the right notes no matter the occasion: expertly packaged, beautifully arranged, and full of an assortment of the perfect snacks, toys, or other items designed to match the moment. The sky is truly the limit, with budget-friendly gift baskets that might have a small toy and a candy bar for a child's birthday, all the way up to the most decadent, luxurious array of fine wine and gourmet cheese to commemorate a long-anticipated promotion.

Continue reading below reviews

2019

Gift Basket Reviews

DESIGN IT YOURSELF GIFT BASKETS

Cost:

From $29 to $155+

Are you tired of the same old gift baskets? Wishing you could pick out exactly what you want? That makes you the ideal customer for Design It Yourself Gift Baskets! With this store, you can take the reins as much - or as little - as you like, which means your gift will be perfectly customized for your gift-giving occasion.

If you love the idea of picking it all, you'll want to choose the Design It Yourself route. You'll select a theme, a container, and then all of the products you want to include. Some of the available themes are Spa & Pamper, That's Italian! and Coffee Lovers. Containers range from woven decorative baskets to collapsible gift boxes, and you can easily see the total "completed gift basket" price next to each one. Finally, you'll select each of the products that will go into your finished gift. The interface is a little outdated-looking, but we loved being able to choose even the smallest details, such as the color of a hand towel or the scent of a candle.

But, maybe you feel overwhelmed by the thought of having to choose every little thing in your gift basket order but still want to send something unique. Design It Yourself' Gift Express option is perfect for you. Just specify your budget, choose a theme, fill out the gift card and select any add-ons you definitely want to include. From there, the team at DIY will build a gift basket to match. You won't know exactly which products are going into your delivery, but maybe that's part of the fun?

And, for that third category of people - the ones who just want to click a button and say "yes, send exactly THAT" - Design It Yourself offers a good selection of traditional, ready-to-go options. One of our favorite pre-selected gift baskets is the BIG Texas Thank You. Because this company is based in Houston, they know what it takes to send a Lone Star State-themed arrangement! Priced at $94.95, here's what's packed inside the southwestern-styled galvanized tub:

Lammes Texas Chewy Pralines
Texas Tin with Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies
Dolcetto Creamy Vanilla Wafer Squares
Beanitos Nacho Tortilla Chips
Sucklebusters Clucker Duster BBQ Seasonings
Several varieties of pretzels, crackers and more

All of the gift baskets, from DIY to pre-selected, have optional upgrades and add-ons at the bottom of the page. They may not match your theme - would you really put a jar of Nutella in a Texas-themed arrangement? - but it's a nice way to pick out something extra, add some balloons or stuffed animals, and so on.

In that same section of the page, you'll find the option to include a personalized message on a satin ribbon? Choose the ribbon color and add a message of up to 45 characters (including spaces) for an extra $7.95.

Design It Yourself Gift Baskets has made some welcome improvements to their customer policies since our last review. Everything you order is now covered by a 100% satisfaction guarantee: you can opt for a full refund, store credit or replacement if you're not happy with the quality or condition of any part of the gift basket. The company asks that you contact them within 3 days of delivery if there's a problem, and they promise to make it right.

Improvements like that are a big part of the reason for this store's positive reputation. They enjoy an "A+" rating and accreditation from the BBB. We would like to see more customer feedback on the DIY site itself, especially reviews on individual gift baskets, so that shoppers have a clearer idea of which products have been a hit with their recipients.

Pricing with Design It Yourself Gift Baskets is comparable to other stores on the market. Helpful hint: make sure to click on the Specials & Best Sellers tab at the top of the page. On our last visit to the site, we found a discount coupon for a savings of 10% sitewide - and that wasn't advertised anywhere else, no pop-up, etc.

Shopping for a gift basket doesn't have to be boring. We recommend Design It Yourself for its wide selection of add-ons, the ability to create a truly unique gift, and their improved commitment to customer satisfaction.

THE BEST GIFT BASKETS

Cost:

From $30 to $400

The Best Gift Baskets is one of the newer gift basket companies on the market. You'll find the typical assortment of gift-giving occasions like baby showers and birthdays, without too many unique options that really jump out at you. Even the holiday-themed gift baskets weren't really specific to that celebration: the Halloween choices had candy but nothing with pumpkins, skeletons or decorations, the New Year's baskets primarily focused on alcohol, and so on.

We found the pricing on The Best Gift Baskets to be relatively high. For example, the Ghirardelli Galore Chocolate Gift Basket was priced at $59.99 (which doesn't include delivery). Considering that the package contains 2 bags of Ghirardelli squares, 2 candy bars, and 2 pouches of hot chocolate, you do the math and decide if that sounds like a good deal. We also didn't see any possibilities for adding extra items like candy or stuffed animals, no personalization options for the gift packaging, and no reviews from previous customers.

Shipping is more expensive with The Best Gift Baskets than some of the retailers in our review. Expect to pay $14.95 for ground shipping, no matter what kind of gift basket you order. Expedited options are available, starting at $24.95 for 3 business day delivery, $39.95 for next business day, and $59.95 for Saturday delivery.

What kind of a reputation does The Best Gift Baskets have? Great question. At the bottom of the site, it clearly says "no rating available" when looking at the Google score. There's also no listing for this company on the Better Business Bureau database - and, strangely, when we called the customer service number on the company's "Contact Us" page, it was a personal phone number! (We wondered if it was the "Bill" listed in the email contact info. The site does say that's his personal email. That's awkward!)

This could be the best gift basket company to hit the market - but with such a limited history, it's hard to know if it will really deliver. Will they honor their 100% satisfaction guarantee? Will you get attentive, courteous customer service if there's a problem? There's no way of knowing until this store builds up a history of solid customer interactions and reviews.

Continued from above

But, as you'll quickly notice as you begin to shop for a gift basket, some companies consistently deliver high-quality selections while others provide just the bare minimum and don't put much thought or effort into the presentation or the included items.

To make sure that your gift basket is a delivery that impresses, here are several criteria to keep in mind as you consider the gift basket companies on the market today:

Variety. How many options does the service offer? Within a single category (e.g. baby shower, wedding, get well soon), do you have a number of choices?
Quality. Are the products gourmet, high-end, and/or well-constructed, or are you getting cheap things you could buy at a supermarket or dollar store?
Price. What will you spend on the gift basket of your choice? Do you get a good value for what you spend, especially compared with other stores? Does the company offer any customer-friendly perks like free shipping?
Customer Service. How easy does the gift basket company make it to find what you want? Do they offer a satisfaction guarantee if the basket is late or just doesn't meet expectations? What do previous customers have to say about their experience with the company?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best gift baskets available today. We hope this information helps you find the perfect basket for your next gift-giving occasion!

< Go To Reviews >

Holiday Gifts Under $200 for Those You Really Want to Treat

Whatever their needs are, we've found the perfect gift that will ensure you slay the holiday season. Below, the best gifts under $200, no matter who you're buying for (even if it's yourself-no ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 12:41:00 GMT

The 35 Best Gifts for Tween Girls, According to Tweens

To make things easier, we asked 12 tweens about what's at the top of their must-have lists. Read on for the VSCO essentials, clothing, art supplies, and other gifts that they say are sure to impress ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 12:40:00 GMT

This $700,007 Aston Martin DBS designed by Daniel Craig is one of Neiman Marcus' 2019 Fantasy Gifts

Oh, and let's say that you're also super rich. What do you get them? You get them this special Aston Martin DBS Superleggera bundle from Neiman Marcus' 2019 Fantasy Gift catalog, of course. Only seven ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 13:04:00 GMT

These will be the hottest gifts of 2019

To help you give the best presents, we've rounded up what we predict will be the top 10 gifts of 2019. Psst: Some of these are on the list of things to buy before Black Friday just in case they sell ...

Published: Thu, 17 Oct 2019 14:43:00 GMT

A Better World: Gifts that give nonprofits flexibility

For most nonprofits, expenditures are funded in a variety of ways: government contracts, grants, corporate sponsorships and gifts. Because of the nature of giving, donors often place a different value ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 06:08:00 GMT

The Best Holiday Gifts For Fashion-Forward Women

If you're still stuck, browse through ET Style's top picks of gifts curated for those who love fashion, ahead. For the girl who can't have enough hair accessories, these Kitsch rhinestone clips will ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 11:04:00 GMT

Wichita Mayor won't face charges over gifts he received

WICHITA, Kan. (AP) - Sedgwick County District Attorney Marc Bennett says he will not file charges against Wichita Mayor Jeff Longwell over gifts the mayor received from companies involved in building ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 12:33:00 GMT

The Best Gifts For Gamers

It's a minefield. One wrong step and you're blown to pieces, metaphorically. Unless you gift someone Battleship. Gifts for gamers are even harder to find. They're into games, sure. So do you buy them ...

Published: Fri, 18 Oct 2019 08:40:00 GMT

Neiman Marcus Reveals Its Over-The-Top Travel-Themed Gifts

As the holidays quickly approach, you might be starting to think about what gifts to buy family and friends. And while many of us will wait for those Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals, Neiman Marcus ...

Published: Thu, 17 Oct 2019 09:54:00 GMT

Reproduction in whole or in part in any form without the express written consent of TopConsumerReviews.com, LLC is strictly prohibited.

Design It Yourself Gift Baskets vs The Best Gift Baskets

Gift Basket Reviews

DESIGN IT YOURSELF GIFT BASKETS

THE BEST GIFT BASKETS

Gift Baskets In The News