Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Halloween Costumes Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      July 8, 2020

Home  >  Halloween Costumes  >  Costume Craze vs Costume Discounters

Best

Halloween Costumes

  1. Halloween Express
  2. Costume Craze
  3. Spirit Halloween
  4. Trendy Halloween
  5. Costume Kingdom
  6. Buy Costumes
  7. Costume Discounters
  8. Shindigz
  9. Extreme Halloween
  10. Frank Bee
  11. Find Costume
  12. Costumes 4 Less
  13. Costume City
  14. Anytime Costumes

Your Information Is Secure
100 Top Halloween Recipes and Crafts Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Bicycle Parts

Credit Counseling

Feather Pillows

GMAT Test Prep

GRE Test Prep

Homeschool Supplies

LSAT Test Prep

MCAT Test Prep

Senior Care

Thyroid Health

 

Individual Reviews

Costume Supercenter

Halloween Express

Costume Craze

Spirit Halloween

Trendy Halloween

Costume Kingdom

Buy Costumes

Costume Discounters

Costumes by Shindigz

Extreme Halloween

Frank Bee Costume Center

Find Costume

Costumes 4 Less

Costume City

Anytime Costumes

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Costume Craze vs Costume Discounters

Best Halloween Costumes

To help you find the Best Halloween Costumes, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Costume Craze and Costume Discounters.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Halloween Costumes, please Click Here

Halloween has become one of the most entertaining holidays of the year. Kids and adults both get to dress up in fun and frightening costumes, attend parties, enter contests, and share in festivities. Halloween costumes themselves have become far more elaborate than the old "bedsheet-over-the-head" ghost of yesteryear.

Indeed, in retail stores you can find yourself spending hundreds of dollars on just one costume. Halloween costumes themselves have become far more elaborate than the old "bedsheet-over-the-head" ghost of yesteryear. With the advent of the internet, however, you can save 50% or more off traditional retail prices. From the comfort of your own home, you can easily browse hundreds of costumes to find just the one you're looking for.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Halloween Costume Store Reviews

4.5 stars
Costume Craze

COSTUME CRAZE

Visit Site

Costume Craze has a clean, easy site that is loaded with information but still effortless to use. And with thousands of customers to browse, they offer one of the largest costume selections in our review.

They start by prominently featuring their customer service hours at the top of the page. We found this very helpful; most sites have this information buried somewhere 2 or 3 levels down from the home page.

Down along the left side of the screen they list 20 costume categories, including cartoon characters, superheroes, and teen costumes. Some of these links send you to further subcategories; the traditional link, for example, sends you to a page where you can choose from over 40 more categories, including angels, Pirates, and Princesses. Once you reach a final category of costumes, you are presented with a thumbnail preview of each item. Clicking on a thumbnail will present you with a larger view of the costume, although in most cases the thumbnails themselves are large enough for you to easily see what the costume looks like.

Costume Craze also provides you with search options across the top of the screen; here you get to choose from Costumes on Sale, Adult, Teen, Child, Dog, and Shoes. Clicking on these links will let you browse through thousands of costumes at a time. However, we wish they had further provided themes within these categories; in order to see all the adult vampire costumes, for example, you have to manually look through the hundreds of thumbnails within the adult category.

Alternatively, Costume Craze provides a very useful search bar at the top of the home page. Entering information here (like "Vampire" or "Star Trek") quickly takes you to the thumbnail results of your search. When using the search bar, you are also presented with a unique ability to further refine your search with 5 options - Price range, Gender, licensing, Age, and Vendor. Some of these, including price and gender, are extremely helpful when viewing a large number of matches. It would be nice to see these options on all their costume lists!

When looking at pricing, we were pleased to see costs that compared favorably to most of the sites in our review. In fact, on some items Costume Craze had the lowest price of any of our reviewed sites.

Costume Craze provide same-day shipping on most items if the order is placed by 4pm cst. They also guarantee a flat $5.99 shipping fee for standard ground transportation for your order, no matter how many items you buy. That is a cost-savings option for those people ordering more than one costume or a number of accessories. And you can easily check the status of your order online.

The return policy offered by Costume Craze provides a worry-free return policy. This means that if you return the item in perfect condition with all pieces prior to 30 days from purchase for a full refund. If returned after 30 days the company charges a 15% restocking fee and anything left will be in the form of an in-store credit. Clearance items are considered final.

Costume Craze does almost everything right. They have a huge selection of costumes, low prices, same-day shipping, and helpful search options. Overall Costume Craze earns very high marks in our review.

Visit Site
3 stars
Costume Discounters

COSTUME DISCOUNTERS

Visit Site

If you want cheap costumes, Costume Discounters is the site for you! Costume Discounters provides many of the same costumes other stores offer but at a significant savings. However, that doesn't come without any drawbacks in service.

This no frills website provides a just ok website to assist you in locating what you're looking for. YOU may choose from Kids, Adult, Teen, Pet, Accessories and more. Once you select your department you can further select from popular theme, and characters, male or female, and age of the child if that applies. We thought it was a bit odd that once you selected "kids" they brought up 4 costumes for toddlers and then you had to scroll down to the bottom of the page to find the additional categories. Overall the navigating of this discount store is awkward at best and product information is lacking. Costume Discounters provides a size chart but no specific on accessories, materials, or cleaning instructions.

Costume Discounters offers free shipping on orders over $70.00. The return policy allows for return within 10 days of delivery . A restocking fee of 15% does apply if you have ordered 4 or more of the same product. In the event that you choose the wrong size, Costume Discounters requires that you actually return the first item and purchase the next. No exchanges. All returns must be "authorized" and exclude wigs, hose, and other accessories for sanitary reasons.

Costume Discounters provides a toll free number for customer service questions but we had a little trouble getting them to answer our questions and their actual hours available are unknown. However, we thought the "In Home Delivery Date Calculator" was a good tool available to determine the actual delivery date to your home dependant on the delivery method you select.

Costume Discounters is a good site for those looking for a bargain and know what costume and size they need. For those super organized shoppers, perhaps trying on the costume at the store and then shopping at Costume Discounters would provide the best results - more work but a savings opportunity. The return policy and overall professionalism at Costume Discounters was a little less impressive than our higher ranked stores.

Visit Site

Continued from above

No more driving from store to store, fighting the crowds, or settling for what's "left over" after all the good costumes have been taken. With the advent of the internet, you can save 50% or more off traditional retail prices. From the comfort of your own home, you can easily browse hundreds of costumes to find just the one you're looking for.

When shopping at different online Halloween costume stores, you want to consider a few factors. Some of these include:

  • Selection.  Some stores have thousands of costumes available; others may have just a couple hundred. The more costumes they have, the greater chance you'll find what you're looking for.
  • Cost.  Even among online stores, costs vary widely. You want to find a store that reliably has low prices, passing the savings on to you.
  • Customer Service.  Do they let you check the status of your order online? Answer your questions in a FAQ section? Provide support after the sale?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Halloween costume stores online today. We hope these reviews help you with your next halloween costume purchase!

These Hilarious Halloween Puns Are Scary Good, They'll Have Everyone Howling

Halloween doesn't have to be all about spooks and scares! Between all that pumpkin carving and marathon candy-eating, keep things silly this spooky season with the best laughs and giggles, thanks to ...

Published:  Mon, 06 Jul 2020 08:10:00 GMT



15 '90s-Inspired Halloween Costumes You'll Fall in Love With

The resurgence of '90s-inspired fashion, brands, and even home decor has infiltrated the sartorial set, giving us plenty of fare for the forthcoming holiday. So if you love all things Britney Spears, ...

Published:  Tue, 30 Jun 2020 01:55:00 GMT



Need to Go to Walmart on Halloween? Here Are the Superstore's Holiday Hours

Whatever the last-minute conundrum is, you can keep the widely anticipated holiday on the right track thanks to one shopping saving grace- Walmart! The superstore typically closes only on Christmas ...

Published:  Thu, 25 Jun 2020 13:02:00 GMT



Creativity runs wild with the costumes on "The Masked Singer'

Under utmost secrecy and with limited time, costume designer Marina Toybina brings forth, lions and tigers and swans, oh my.

Published:  Wed, 01 Jul 2020 07:00:21 GMT



17 Fun Halloween Birthday Party Ideas to Fill Your Day With Tricks and Treats

Halloween birthdays are special - especially if you love all things spooky and scary. Of course, you don't need to be born on October 31 to throw an epic Halloween birthday party. Really, any day in ...

Published:  Wed, 01 Jul 2020 16:11:00 GMT



Best Tween Halloween Costumes You Can Make Together

Even if Halloween has always been your family's favorite holiday, things get tricky when your kids become tweens. Middle schoolers aren't interested in little kid costumes, but they're not quite ...

Published:  Wed, 24 Jun 2020 10:06:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure