Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Home Brewing Supplies Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      November 26, 2020

Home  >  Home Brewing Stores  >  Mr. Beer vs Brooklyn Brew Shop

Best Home

Brewing Supplies

  1. Brew Demon
  2. Mr. Beer
  3. Brooklyn Brew Shop
  4. Adventures in Homebrewing
  5. Love 2 Brew
  6. Williams Brewing
  7. Brew & Wine Supply

Your Information Is Secure
Over 600 Recipes to Brew Your Own Beer Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Auto Loans

Babysitters

Christmas Cards

Credit Counseling

DUI Lawyers

Fruit Clubs

Home Brew Beer Supplies

Homeschool Supplies

Music Publishing

Senior Care

 

Individual Reviews

Midwest Supplies

Brew Demon

Mr. Beer

Brooklyn Brew Shop

Adventures in Homebrewing

Love 2 Brew

William's Brewing

Brew & Wine Supply

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Mr. Beer vs Brooklyn Brew Shop

Best Home Brew Beer Kits

To help you find the Best Home Brewing Supplies, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Mr. Beer and Brooklyn Brew Shop.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Home Brewing Supplies, please Click Here

Where can you find the best home brewing supplies? For over 7,000 years, there has been nothing better than sitting back, kicking up your feet, and enjoying a beer. Home brewing has provided a historic, scientific, fun, and ultimately tasty experience for brewers of any level.

With a home brewing kit, you'll be able to first master the process, and then explore and customize your own creations. Soon you'll be the hit of the neighborhood block, enjoying everything from holidays to warm summer nights with your brew.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Home Brewing Supply Reviews

4 stars
Mr. Beer

MR. BEER

Visit Site

Mr. Beer has long been lauded for their reputation as a top option for novice beer brewers, searching for a way into brewing. They offer a professional, affordable, and reliable option for customers especially seeking a reliable brewing process.

Water extraction process

Growing for over 20 years, in 2011 Mr. Beer merged with Coopers Brewery, a 150 years strong company based in Australia. This gave Mr. Beer new access to a rare water extraction process, which seriously increased the quality of their malts for sale to customers.

12 home brew beer kits

For novices, Mr. Beer sells 12 different 2-gallon beer making kits, and one 6-gallon beer making kit. These kits vary in price based on included features, but are the most affordable out of all competitors ranked on our list, include free shipping - AND at the time of this writing (June 2020) are offering a 10% off discount for first orders. Those are some serious savings, which translate to happy customers.

Best Home Brew Beer Supplies

Beer kit contents

With Mr. Beer, even the simplest kit contains:

  • 2 Gallon Fermenter with Lid
  • Spigot, Washer and Nut Assembly
  • Recipe of choice
  • Packet of Yeast (Under lid of Brewing Extract)
  • Booster Pouch
  • Packet of No-Rinse Cleanser
  • Easy-to-Follow Brewing Instructions

Extras available

With more expensive kits containing necessary bottles for storing your finished product, or bottles available as an additional price for more affordable kits, the brew kits should include everything else you need. You can also buy from an extensive ingredient, equipment, refill, and recipe list (over 100 options!), for customizing and creating original home brews. And for those interested in a different taste, Mr. Beer also sells a root beer and hard cider kit.

Solid introductory system

Most reviewers note that the quality and flavor profiles produced by Mr. Beer's home brewing systems are standard, if simplistic. However, they continue to be applauded as an introductory system that affords customers the opportunity to decide whether this is an interest worth pursuing for them. Mr. Beer maintains a professional, clean, and easy to use website, so customers can find what they need without a second thought. They have an A+ from the Better Business Bureau, and allow customers to return products within 30 days of delivery. For beginning brewers especially, we highly recommend Mr. Beer be considered for your home brewing needs.

Visit Site
4 stars
Brooklyn Brew Shop

BROOKLYN BREW SHOP

Visit Site

The Brooklyn Brew Shop is a premium home brewing company that has been climbing in reputation and recognition within the home beer brewing world, ever since its founding in 2009.

Simple, tasty, stylish brews

What started as a means to help space strapped New Yorkers delve into the magic and deliciousness of beer brewing, has boomed into a well-respected business that capitalizes on simple, tasty, and stylish brews. Just check out their Unicorn beer brewing kit - complete with a pink color and multicolored sprinkles - for the proof! The Brooklyn Brew Shop has been featured in The New York Times, Nylon, Food & Wine, Glamour, Thrillist, Travel & Leisure, Vogue, Time Out and Martha Stewart. They continue to top gift guides for friends, parents, Boyfriends/Girlfriends, beer geeks, and holiday gift lists.

Over 20 beer kits

The Brooklyn Brew Shop offers over 20 beer brewing kits to choose from, and all kits are reusable. So, once you've enjoyed your first batch, you can set your sights and watering mouth on the next batch to try. All beer brewing kits are one-gallon and all-grain, so this company is especially appealing for brewing novices; although they do sell a limited number of 5-gallon beer mixes.

Best Home Brew Beer Supplies

What's in your beer kit

At the Brooklyn Brew Shop, all beer brewing kits come with:

  • All-Grain Ingredient Mix
  • Gallon (3.8 L) Glass Fermenter
  • Glass Spirit-Filled Thermometer
  • Vinyl Tubing
  • Racking Cane & Tip
  • Chambered Airlock
  • Brooklyn Brew Shop Cleanser
  • Screw-Cap Stopper
  • Sanitizer to clean equipment

Great variety of flavors

Coming in as the second most affordable home brewing option on our list, The Brooklyn Brew Shop is generous in cost, variety of flavors, and customer service. Some examples of this include: their provision of free shipping for orders more than $59, their feature of a chat function to connect to a customer service representative right away, and several helpful beer brewing videos to follow along with as a guide while you're getting the hang of it.

Not just for beer

Beer not your thing? The Brooklyn Brew Shop also sells brewing kits for Kombucha, Hard Cider, Sparkling Rose, and Sparkling Wine, so there's a taste for everyone to love. And for those interested in scrumptious food options to serve alongside their freshly brewed batch of beer, The Brooklyn Brew Shop sells other kits for making bagels and cream cheese, soft pretzels and cheese, cinnamon sugar soft pretzels, and even fermented veggies.

Highly recommend

Although the 1-gallon beer brewing kits still make 8-10 bottles of beer, it would be nice if the bottles were included; and/or if there were options for more experienced brewers who are already sold on The Brooklyn Brew, to purchase larger batch equipment. We are excited to see how The Brooklyn Brew Shop will continue growing in acclaim and service to a loyal fan base, and highly recommend considering them as your introduction to home brewing.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Originating in the Neolithic period in Mesopotamia (say that 3 times fast after 3 beers!), beer developed as a thicker drink and was dominated in production by women. With the advent of new tools allowed by the Industrial Revolution in the 18th century, beer was finally able to be mass produced and provided for the everyday man everywhere. Throughout history beer has been has been beloved, prohibited, praised, and enjoyed.

With the ability to try something new, perfect a craft, or give the gift that keeps on giving, home brewing equipment and recipe kits provide beer lovers, of all kinds, the ability to unite with one sip of a golden ale.

You may feel a little nervous starting out - and that's okay! There are plenty of companies out there with simple starter-kits that have boiled the brew process down to the basics. Maybe you have some experience, and are ready to upgrade to a more individualized brewing experience. Perhaps you already know you enjoy the crisp and refreshing brews of a pale summer ale, or the chocolatey and coffee notes of a deep stout, and you're looking to put your own spin on it. No matter what your particular position may be, we believe you'll find a company that can satisfy your particular brewing desires.

Basic store-bought brands won't ever be the same after enjoying a cold beer following your dedication and hard work. Many of the home brewing supply companies we've reviewed will offer equipment to match your skill level, and recipes to match your taste buds. All you have to do is pick the brew that best suits you!

With such high demand, and a broad and expansive marketplace to choose from, it's no wonder home brewing continues to rise in popularity. However, the brewing supply companies themselves are likely to vary in style, flexibility, focus, and price point. It's important to research what brew supply features are most important to you:

  • Price. What is the cost of supplies? Do you have to pay an additional cost for the recipe itself? Is there a shipping cost? Are there any discounts available?
  • Brew Skill Level. How complex or simple would you like your brewing equipment to be? Often more simplistic brew kits are easy to follow, but difficult to customize. What is your previous experience with brewing? How much beer are you hoping to make?
  • Customer Service. How reputable is the company? Do they have a return policy? Are they well-known for their treatment of customers?
  • Selection. Do they also sell hard cider brewing equipment? Wine making equipment? Do they offer food add-ons or mixes, so you can enjoy those along with your well-earned beverage?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Home Brewing Supply Companies available today. We hope these reviews help you find the right home brewing supplies to suit your needs!

After PPP: Home brewery outlet expects a long recovery despite adding new revenue streams

Philly Home Brew Outlet generated half of its $840,000 in 2019 revenue from installing and cleaning beer taps at restaurants and bars, but when Covid-19 hit in March, virtually all of that business ...

Published:  Mon, 16 Nov 2020 02:20:00 GMT



The joys of home brewing

JEREMY BUDDMEIER HAS been brewing beer for almost 20 years, but only seriously the last four. That's when he moved to Georgia and became a member of the Savannah Brewer's League, a local club devoted ...

Published:  Tue, 17 Nov 2020 09:16:00 GMT



Arizona's first Black-owned brewery launches this week. Say hello to Kitsune Brewing

Tyler Smith, a Scottsdale home brewer, opens Kistune Brewing Company. He will launch Arizona's first Black-owned brewery from Simple Machine in north Phoenix.

Published:  Wed, 11 Nov 2020 21:01:34 GMT



Midland Brewing Company crafts recipe for success

With a serious nod to Midland's early history steeped in the lumber, beer and railroad industries, Midland Brewing Company is crafting a formula that has it well on its way to becoming a regional, if ...

Published:  Tue, 24 Nov 2020 02:13:00 GMT



Shmaltz Brewing Releases "Golden Jelly Doughnut Pastry Ale" & "She'brew #RBG IPA" in Collaboration with Moustache Brewing

Shmaltz Brewing Company officially turns 24 this Hanukkah season as the largest, the smallest, the most award winning, and astonishingly still the only Jewish celebration beer company in the country.

Published:  Wed, 25 Nov 2020 12:47:00 GMT



Jackie O's beer store opens in Columbus

The store opened Tuesday in the space that was once home to the Elevator Brewing Company warehouse and taproom at 165 N. 4th St. in Downtown Columbus. That space went up for sale over the summer when ...

Published:  Tue, 24 Nov 2020 08:29:00 GMT



Wawa and 2SP Brewing Bring Back Coffee Collab Beers

Even 2020 can't stop Wawa and 2SP Brewing Company from continuing the tradition of brewing collaborative limited-edition beers just in time for the holiday season. Back for its third year, the ...

Published:  Mon, 23 Nov 2020 05:00:00 GMT



Lake of the Woods Brew Co. making batch of lake bottom beer

It's not every day you can drink a beer that's spent the better part of six months at the bottom of a lake, but if all goes according to plan, Lake ...

Published:  Wed, 25 Nov 2020 15:16:00 GMT



Cuzen Matcha Maker whisks up the freshest matcha tea at home

If you're looking for something to give your caffeine routine a jolt -- and if you really like green tea -- this little machine is a glorious treat. To understand why, you need to realize matcha isn't ...

Published:  Tue, 24 Nov 2020 04:12:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure