Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Jewelry Stores Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      June 19, 2018

Home  >  Jewelry Stores  >  Super Jeweler vs Ice

Best

Jewelry Stores

  1. Helzberg Diamonds
  2. Super Jeweler
  3. Jared
  4. Reeds Jewelers
  5. Szul
  6. Jewelry
  7. Kay Jewelers
  8. Jewelry Television
  9. Diamond Delight
  10. Ice
  11. True Facet
  12. Netaya
  13. Diamonds International
  14. Palm Beach Jewelry
  15. Jeulia

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
How to Buy Jewelry Online Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Business Cards

Company Incorporation

Fitness Clothing

Golf Clubs

Green Cards

Home Warranties

Medical Alert Systems

Personal Checks

Refrigerators

VPN Services

 

Individual Reviews

Blue Nile

Helzberg Diamonds

Super Jeweler

Jared

Reeds Jewelers

Szul

Jewelry

Kay

Jewelry Television

Diamond Delight

Ice

True Facet

Netaya

Diamonds International

Palm Beach Jewelry

Jeulia

 

Related Articles

Diamond Cuts Explained

How Much Should You Spend on a Wedding Ring?

What Are the Different Shapes That a Diamond Can Come In?

What is Diamond Clarity and Why Is It Important?

What You Should Look For in a Jewelry Store

What You Should Look For in Diamond Color

 

Disclosure: We pay our reviewers for their reviews. We are not compensated by companies for their reviews, but we may be compensated for links and advertisements on our website. Click here for details.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Super Jeweler vs Ice

Best Jewelry Stores

To help you find the Best Jewelry Stores, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Super Jeweler and Ice.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Jewelry Stores, please Click Here

What's the best Jewelry Store? Every year, almost 40 million people shop online for jewelry - and with good reason! Why stand in line for over an hour during a peak season like Valentine's Day or Mother's Day, hoping that there might be something she'd like, when you can shop any time of day (or night) and get the world's best selection while sitting in your living room?

Today's best online jewelry stores make it almost unthinkable to shop at a local store. The lack of overhead with online jewelry means that they can bring you prices as much as 50% lower than what you'd find elsewhere. When you add in free shipping, extended return periods, and the same certifications and guarantees you get from a local jeweler, and it's easy to see why it makes sense to buy jewelry from an online store.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2018

Jewelry Store Reviews

4.5 stars
Super Jeweler

SUPER JEWELER Visit Site

When you first visit the Super Jeweler site, you might be overwhelmed by the layout. You'll see flashing boxes, scrolling tickers, and jewelry shown with three different prices (list, Super Jeweler price, special or deal price). Don't click away or you'll miss some of the web's best-priced jewelry.

Super Jeweler is the only retailer we found with free shipping to every continent. Within the US, orders under $479 ship via DHL Smart Mail, up to $5000 goes by USPS Priority, and orders over $5000 get free express next-day delivery. Want extra savings? Keep an eye on the site; when we visited, there was a coupon code advertising a 10% discount on any order.

Super Jeweler's everyday prices are almost always lower than or the same as the most competitive jewelry stores online. And, the online shopping experience is better than most. When you select the category you want, you can easily sort through your options visually, and/or narrow down your results by metal, karats, ring size availability, price, gemstone, clarity, and much more. You'll definitely want to use those sorting options; in rings alone, Super Jeweler has more than 5,800 to choose from!

The only jewelry category where Super Jeweler doesn't keep pace with the competition is in watches and other accessory-type items. Super Jeweler only carries rings, earrings, bracelets, and necklaces.

Shoppers will appreciate Super Jeweler's availability: not only do they have agents available from 7am-7pm (Eastern) Monday through Friday and from 9a-6p on Saturdays, but their online live chat is accessible 24/7 - for those middle-of-the night "I forgot my anniversary is next week" panic attacks, perhaps.

And, customers who are using Super Jeweler for fine jewelry purchases are happy to find out that their items are protected by a Limited Lifetime Guarantee, which covers all products with diamonds and/or gemstones. This guarantee covers any side stone lost during the lifetime of either the purchaser or recipient, and any center gemstone or diamond lost in the first year of ownership. That's a great perk not offered by most jewelry stores.

Super Jeweler also exceeds expectations with their return policy. Their competitors usually accept returns within 30 days of receipt; Super Jeweler allows returns within 60 days of the shipment date as long as the items are in original condition.

How does Super Jeweler perform in actual customer reviews? Not surprisingly, the scrolling ticker-style reviews all showed 5-stars and glowing comments. When we looked at third-party review sites, though, we found a few less-than-perfect reviews. However, Super Jeweler had an average of 4.5 out of 5 stars in nearly 13,000 reviews within the last 12 months. Super Jeweler does get bonus points for having an "A+" rating with the BBB to go along with their other customer feedback.

We found lots of good reasons to shop at Super Jeweler and think you will too.

Visit Site

3 stars
Ice

ICE Visit Site

Ice was founded in 1999 as the "online destination for premium fashion jewelry". After an extensive rebranding at the end of 2017, the Ice website is streamlined, attractive, and intriguing to shop.

Pay attention to Ice's description: as a retailer of costume jewelry, they don't tend to carry higher-end items. For example, even their highest-priced engagement sets are "diamond and moissanite" - that last one is a synthetic stone with similar color, clarity, and hardness to diamonds but that appraises for much less. But, Ice is very upfront with what their jewelry is made of; there's no trickery involved. You get what's advertised.

If you're looking to save a little cash and you don't mind giving out your email address, you can sign up for Ice's VIP newsletter and get 10% off your first purchase. Just look for a pop-up, or go to the bottom of the site where it says "Connect". We also spotted a discount code at the top of the engagement rings page on the day that we shopped at Ice; we could save 12% and get free shipping on orders over $150 with the provided coupon code. (Note: although it wasn't advertised, there was free shipping on every order regardless of price at the time of our review.)

Within certain categories, Ice has an excellent selection. In bracelets alone, they carry nearly 3,000 unique products. Earrings, necklaces, and rings have a similar range to choose from. However, you won't find watches, precious stones like genuine rubies (although they do have lab-created ones), and several other categories you might find at a traditional jewelry store.

Our search experience was a little strange. When we searched for rubies, the initial results were on point - although, again, the rubies were all synthetic. As we got deeper into the product list, however, we got a number of items that had nothing to do with rubies at all: solitaires, engagement rings, and so on, with not a speck of red stone in sight.

Ice's return policy was lackluster compared with many other jewelry stores': you can only get a full refund on unworn merchandise returned within 10 business days (approximately 2 weeks) from when the item was delivered. Ice will accept returns for exchange or store credit for up to 30 days after delivery, but not for a refund. Your return must include any gift boxes that were used in packaging. You'll be responsible for any shipping costs if your return is for any reason other than a defective product.

Ice's reviews are also mixed. An "A+" grade with the BBB as an accredited retailer is a definite plus, and some customers rave about the high-quality, affordable jewelry from this store. On the other hand, we also found complaints about less-than-responsive customer service representatives, stones falling out of ring settings, and incorrect sizing.

Our overall impression is that Ice is actively trying to create a new name for itself and win customers within the jewelry marketplace - but this store still has a few improvements it can make to be more competitive with other retailers.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Of course, not every jewelry store is the same. Some specialize in "fashion" or "costume" jewelry; if you're looking for an inexpensive piece just to add some sparkle to a fun evening, or maybe an imitation item that won't break your heart if it gets lost, this type of jewelry might be perfect. Those stores are less likely to sell luxury, high-priced jewelry with precious metals and gemstones, however - so you may need to select a store that specializes in heirloom-quality craftsmanship and materials.

As you begin your search for the ideal online jewelry store, what should you keep in mind? Here are several criteria that can help you make your decision:

  • Selection. What does the store carry? Is it a limited range of rings, necklaces and earrings, or do they have options for men and children too?
  • Prices. How does the jewelry store measure up to the competition? Do they offer free shipping, pop-up discount offers, or any other promotions?
  • Quality. What do customers say about the jewelry they've purchased? Does it last, or have stones fallen out after a few wears? Are items marked as "diamond" authentic, or are they synthetic stones?
  • Return Policy. If you don't like the necklace, ring, or watch after you've received it, can it be returned? Will you have to pay a restocking fee?
  • Reputation. Are customers generally happy with their experience, both with the jewelry they received and with the customer service department if help was needed? Is the company easy to reach if there's a problem? Does the store have a rating with the BBB?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best jewelry stores available today. Whether you're shopping for an engagement ring, a necklace for your significant other, or just a new bit of sparkle to add to your collection, we hope these reviews will help you find the right piece of jewelry at the right price!

Arrest made in brazen armed heist at Jersey Gardens mall jewelry store

One of the four robbers who stormed into a Jersey Gardens mall jewelry store and robbed the business at gunpoint in September has been charged after he was caught in Massachusetts with a bag of loot from the heist, authorities said. William Valentin, 42 ...

Published:  Fri, 15 Jun 2018 13:37:00 GMT



An Estimated $300,000 in Jewelry Stolen During Mission Valley Heist

An estimated $300,000 in diamonds were stolen in Mission Valley on Saturday when two thieves attacked a jewelry store vendor who was leaving work. San Diego Police reported that a vendor was pulling out of the Robbins Brothers store parking lot with ...

Published:  Sun, 17 Jun 2018 22:45:00 GMT



Two Men Attack, Rob Jewelry Vendor In Mission Valley

SAN DIEGO, CA -- Two robbers made off with boxes of jewelry outside the Robbins Brothers jewelry store in Mission Valley late Saturday, and they remained at large Sunday. Soon after 7 p.m., a vendor had just left the store, located on Friars Road east of ...

Published:  Sun, 17 Jun 2018 13:18:00 GMT



US Jewelry Stores Revenue Rises

RAPAPORT... Sales at specialist jewelry stores in the US increased 14% year on year to $2.49 billion in March, according to data from the nation's Census Bureau. The rise in revenue - which is not adjusted for seasonal fluctuation - comes despite a 2 ...

Published:  Thu, 14 Jun 2018 04:59:00 GMT



Mebane Jewelry Store Robbed After Suspects Crash Their Car Into It

MEBANE, N.C. -- Mebane Police say two people are still at large after a jewelry store break-in. Police were called to Millstead Drive around 5:30 a.m. Friday because of a breaking and entering in progress. Police say the suspects drove their car into the ...

Published:  Fri, 15 Jun 2018 13:06:00 GMT



'If you can describe the ring, it is yours': Hardware store owner finds lost jewelry in a work glove

Maybe not the kind that would end up as a Netflix documentary or a "Dateline" episode. But the case of the lost man's ring is a head-scratcher, nevertheless. It was Mark Driscoll who found it - of all places, inside a man's black work glove that ...

Published:  Thu, 14 Jun 2018 14:11:00 GMT



Share Us!    Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Twitter Share TopConsumerReviews.com on LinkedIn Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Google+ Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure