Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Keto Diets Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      February 19, 2020

Home  >  Keto Diets  >  Diet Doctor vs Ketogenic Girl

Best

Keto Diets

  1. Keto Mojo
  2. Healthful Pursuit
  3. Keto Logie
  4. Keto Logic
  5. Ketogenic Girl
  6. Keto Diet

Your Information Is Secure
Amazing Weight Loss and Health Tips Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Latest Reviews

Audiobooks

Cheesecake Clubs

Credit Monitoring

Custom T Shirts

Handbags

Piano Lessons

Popcorn Clubs

Sporting Goods

Tea Clubs

Transcription Services

 

Individual Reviews

Diet Doctor

Keto Mojo

Healthful Pursuit

Ketologie

KetoLogic

Ketogenic Girl

Keto Diet

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Diet Doctor vs Ketogenic Girl

To help you find the Best Keto Diets, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Diet Doctor and Ketogenic Girl.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Keto Diets, please Click Here

Find the best Keto Diet with Diet Doctor Today! What is the best Keto Diet? Before you get started on this very-low-carb approach to eating, it's important to point out a few things. First, keto diets are different from other popular low-carb diets like Paleo and Atkins. Why? "Keto" refers to achieving a state of ketosis, a state where your body has to burn fat for energy instead of carbs.

While Paleo and Atkins may or may not get you there, a true keto diet will be very focused on high-quality fats, some protein, and very few carbs in order to help you reach ketosis. Also, following a ketogenic diet has been demonstrated to significantly improve the health and wellness of people with certain conditions.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Keto Diet Reviews

5 stars
Diet Doctor

DIET DOCTOR

Visit Site

Cost:

$9/month

First month free with registration

No registration needed to preview meal plan samples and videos

TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Diet Doctor is on a mission: to empower people everywhere to dramatically improve health through unbiased, evidence-based information. Every guide offered on the platform is created and reviewed by medical doctors and experts, and trusted by practicing doctors. Because the site is supported strictly by memberships (more than 60,000 at the time of our review!), you won't find any products being promoted, no ads, and no sponsorships from other companies. That's a breath of fresh air in the dieting world!

We appreciate that Diet Doctor lets you preview 3 meal plans and samples of the more than 500 videos on their site before committing to their keto diet plan. You can also get a free month of full access to all of the resources on the site: over 100 meal plans, "ask the experts", over 700 recipes, podcasts and more.

If you're a beginner to the keto diet lifestyle, you'll find everything you need to know to get started. We recommend starting with the video under the section listed as "1. What is a keto diet?" You can see the whole step-by-step course with your free 30-day trial, and much of the information in the videos can be found as you scroll down the page.

You can also get a two-week keto diet plan, complete with 42 recipes like pesto chicken casserole and even keto pizza. There's no guesswork: you can see absolutely everything you can choose from, without even entering your email address.

We also love that the Diet Doctor tackles some of the controversies surrounding keto diets head-on: saturated fats and increased cholesterol levels, whole grains and red meats, and more. The site is also very clear that if you take medication for diabetes or high blood pressure, or if you're breastfeeding, you should definitely consult with your medical professional before starting a keto diet.

Everything about using Diet Doctor is extremely intuitive and very appealing visually. If you want to see what a keto diet looks like, you can see which foods are lower and higher in carbs at a glance. The meal planning tool is also easy to use: create a meal plan from scratch, or customize one of the more than 100 pre-made meal plans in the Diet Doctor database. These meal plans come with shopping lists, recipes, and simple adaptations for dairy-free and vegetarian options, budget-friendly selections, and any changes you need to make for larger or smaller serving sizes.

When it comes to changing your life to incorporate - or continue - a keto diet, you want to know that you'll get great-tasting recipes with lots of variety, along with nutritionally-sound advice backed by science. And, you don't want it to break the bank. For all of those reasons, Diet Doctor should be your first visit when considering keto diets: you just won't find anything as comprehensive, approachable, and affordable on the market today.

Visit Site
2 stars
Ketogenic Girl

KETOGENIC GIRL

Visit Site

Cost:

28-day downloadable meal plans range from $49.95 to $159.95

Printed books available for an extra fee

VIP private coaching available for $5,950

Ketogenic Girl offers meal plans based on a 28-day challenge designed to get you fully immersed in your new keto diet, or to help you implement it fully if you have already tried and not been successful.

We feel that it's important to mention right away that the creator of Ketogenic Girl, Vanessa Spina, is a "completely self-taught keto diet blogger and meal plan provider...not a certified nutritionist." Her educational background includes biochemistry from a medical perspective, but keep in mind as you consider her keto diet options that her advice is primarily gained from her personal research and experience with living the keto lifestyle.

There are several meal plans available for purchase on the Ketogenic Girl site. The most popular is the 28 Day Accelerated Meal Plan, which is regularly priced at $159 for the download-only version. If you'd like a printed book as well, that usually tacks on an extra $30 to your purchase price. There's a vegetarian version as well.

For people who have already adapted to a keto diet, either with this program or another, there's also a Phase 2 meal plan for $159.95. There's a discount of $100 available to those who already completed the initial Ketogenic Girl 28-day challenge, and that code is made available within the Facebook support group. (Keep reading for more on that.)

When you purchase any of Ketogenic Girl's 28-day challenges, you'll get access to the Facebook group designed for support and fun while working your way through the keto diet. In the testimonials and success stories section of the website, you'll find lots of posts from people who participated in the challenge and the support group and had great things to say about the results they achieved while following the Ketogenic Girl meal plan and challenge.

Finally, if you want to go keto but hate cooking, this service has several No-Cook, Build Your Day meal plans too. At the time of our review, the PDF-only version of the no-cook plan was on sale for $49.95 and includes 130+ recipes, many of which are mix-and match and all are free from dairy, sugar, gluten and soy.

So, aside from the fact that Ketogenic Girl is admittedly not a nutrition professional (and charging almost $6000 for personal coaching without that background), what else jumped out at us when considering her program for keto dieting? We also were put off by some of what she included in her bio. She says that at 5'9" and 165 pounds, she had "an extra 30-40 lbs" on her, and that she got to her "dream weight" of 125 with little to no exercise. Those statements don't seem to line up with recommended height and weight parameters (i.e. at 5'9" and 160 pounds, most charts show her within the "healthy" range, and certainly not 30-40 pounds overweight). And, most professionals strongly promote exercise for all people, keto diet or not. We were left wondering if this program might be triggering or inappropriate for people who are struggling with body dysmorphia or eating disorders.

In fact, in the Warnings section of the site, it specifically says that this 28-day plan may not be appropriate for "anyone suffering or recovered from an eating disorder", or for anyone with blood sugar issues like diabetes. That part really surprised us, given that other keto diets in our review (especially those that take regular readings of blood glucose and ketones) say that they are especially helpful for people who are trying to manage diabetes.

Ketogenic Girl offers a 100% money-back guarantee, but you'll need to abide by very specific parameters: tracking your weight and every meal using the MyFitnessPal app, photos of every meal prepared according to the exact specifications in the 28-day challenge, and time-stamped photos showing your starting and ending weight. In other words, unless you follow the plan perfectly, you won't be eligible for any kind of refund.

Overall, Ketogenic Girl has quite a few happy customers/users, and the site seems to offer a good variety of keto-approved recipes. However, we have our reservations about her approach and her program for the reasons we mentioned. With so many options available for following a keto diet, especially ones that are heavily based around principles of science and nutrition, this meal plan doesn't come out as a top contender.

Visit Site

Continued from above

According to Harvard Medical School, there is solid evidence demonstrating that a keto diet is extremely effective in reducing seizures, especially in children. It's also thought that this high-fat, extremely low carb approach to eating may help patients with type 2 diabetes improve blood sugar control, and research is currently being done to see if following a keto diet can benefit people with Parkinson's, sleep disorders, and many other issues.

And, as with all big changes to your lifestyle and habits, it's essential to have a talk with your physician before committing to a keto diet, especially if you are taking medications or have health concerns. Most people following any kind of low-carb diet, including keto, will see an initial weight loss as they focus on healthier foods like vegetables and "good" fats like avocado. But, because the keto diet is designed to be extremely high in fat even compared with other low-carb approaches, it can affect the body differently.

So, you've talked with your doctor and you're ready to jump into the keto lifestyle! With so many programs and plans on the market, how can you tell which one is going to be the best fit? Here are several criteria to keep in mind as you evaluate different keto diet plans:

  • Expertise. Is the keto diet created by professionals like nutritionists and doctors, or is it the result of someone's personal experience with "living keto"?
  • Effectiveness. Will the program help you achieve a true state of ketosis? Will it help you lose weight safely and/or manage your health issues?
  • Cost. What will you spend to follow this keto diet? Do you have to buy supplements, test kits, or any other products that aren't a one-off purchase?
  • Ease of Use. Does the keto diet tell you exactly what to eat, prepare, and buy at the store, with no guesswork? Will you get the guidance you need to follow your plan?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Keto Diets available today. We hope this information helps you find the perfect plan for reaching your health goals!

Modified Keto Diet

The ketogenic or keto diet has garnered a lot of attention in recent years as a means of quickly losing weight. Some researchers have also posited that it could be helpful in preventing the spread or ...

Published:  Tue, 18 Feb 2020 12:02:00 GMT



Modified Keto Diet: What You Should Know

But first, a review of what the keto diet is. The classic keto diet leverages the body's innate ability to burn fat to fuel activity and weight loss by drastically cutting carbohydrates and increasing ...

Published:  Tue, 18 Feb 2020 11:54:00 GMT



The US government is testing the keto diet to treat veterans' diabetes. Critics say it could have long term health risks.

Virta Health is partnering with the VA to offer a low-carb keto diabetes treatment for veterans but critics argue the high-fat diet has health risks.

Published:  Tue, 18 Feb 2020 13:03:00 GMT



Former American Airlines flight attendant claims he failed breathalyzer because of keto diet

A former flight attendant with American Airlines says he was unfairly terminated from his job after failing a breathalyzer test, claiming that his ketogenic (keto) diet was responsible for the false ...

Published:  Mon, 17 Feb 2020 10:06:00 GMT



Could a keto diet be bad for athletes' bones?

A low-carbohydrate, high-fat ketogenic diet could alter bone health in athletes, according to a thought-provoking new study of elite racewalkers and their skeletons. The study, one of the first to ...

Published:  Tue, 11 Feb 2020 16:12:00 GMT



Study reveals why more than a week of keto may not be beneficial

Study reveals why more than a week of keto may not be beneficial Researchers at Yale University have conducted a mice study to review the effects of the keto diet Check out this story on ...

Published:  Tue, 18 Feb 2020 13:07:00 GMT



Maye Musk was a dietitian for 45 years-why she doesn't believe in fad diets like keto or intermittent fasting

"I never did the fad diets," Maye Musk, a 71 year old model, registered dietitian and Elon's mom tells CNBC Make It. Here's why, plus the evidence-based diets she thinks are worthwhile.

Published:  Tue, 11 Feb 2020 16:38:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure