Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Medical Alert Systems Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      April 25, 2019

Home  >  Medical Alert Systems  >  Medical Guardian vs Life Station

Best Medical

Alert Systems

  1. Bay Alarm Medical
  2. Mobile Help
  3. LifeFone
  4. Philips Lifeline
  5. LifeStation
  6. Rescue Alert
  7. ADT
  8. Life Alert
  9. Alert 1
  10. Response Link

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
Guide to Dealing and Caring for the Elderly Newsletter

Latest Reviews

ADHD

Eczema

Flower Delivery

Fruit Baskets

Hair Loss

Hair Removal

Menopause Relief

Pet Meds

Ringworm

Watches

 

Individual Reviews

Medical Guardian

Bay Alarm Medical

Mobile Help

Life Fone

Philips Lifeline

Life Station

Rescue Alert

ADT

Life Alert

Alert 1

Response Link

 

Related Articles

Are Medical Alert Systems Reliable?

Are Medical Alert Systems Worth The Money?

Convincing An Elderly Parent They Need A Medical Alert System

How Do Medical Alert Systems Work?

Is It Time to Get a Medical Alert System?

Safety For Your Aging Parent

Who Needs A Medical Alert System?

Why are Medical Alert Systems so Popular?

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Medical Guardian vs Life Station

Best Medical Alert Systems

To help you find the Best Medical Alert Systems, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Medical Guardian and Life Station.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Medical Alert Systems, please Click Here

Who has the best Medical Alert Systems? As the US population ages, the need for medical alert systems grows. Given the increasing number of seniors who prefer to "age in place" - living in their own home as long as possible, rather than moving to an independent or assisted living facility for the elderly - it is easy to see why a medical alert system could make the difference between life and death.

Medical alert systems give users the ability to rapidly contact emergency services, typically through a button worn on the wrist or as a pendant around the neck. All it takes is a click of that button to get in touch with an operator who will help determine if a call to emergency medical services is needed. For added peace of mind, a number of companies offer equipment that can automatically detect when the wearer has fallen.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2019

Medical Alert System Reviews

5 stars
Medical Guardian

MEDICAL GUARDIAN Visit Site

Cost:

Starting at $29.95/month

TopConsumerReviews.com Best-In-Class Blue Ribbon Award Medical Guardian was created by CEO Geoff Gross to address the need to help older adults live with greater freedom while still ensuring their safety, after seeing what his own grandmother went through after falling at home and needing assistance. As an A+ rated company with the Better Business Bureau and glowing reviews from thousands of satisfied customers, Medical Guardian has established itself as the nation's first choice for medical alert systems.

All plans include wearable, lightweight, waterproof panic buttons, as well as round-the-clock monitoring that is always based in the US. There are two main types of service offered by this provider: In-Home and On-the-Go. If you're primarily looking for protection at the user's residence, you'll be choosing among the following three plans:

  • Classic Guardian: starting at $29.95 per month, this plan uses a home landline to connect with Medical Guardian's 24/7 monitoring center. The button-to-base coverage is 1,300 feet - almost as long as four football fields, ensuring that the wearer can connect to the base station no matter where they are in the home. The system also has a 32-hour backup battery life, keeping the user connected even in the event of a power outage. Fall Detection is available for an additional $10/month.
  • Home Guardian: starting at $34.95 per month, this plan frees you from the requirement of a landline, because it uses cellular coverage to connect. You do sacrifice some of the coverage range, which is only 600 feet. On the other hand, because the system uses the AT&T nationwide network for its cellular coverage, you can bring the system with you if you're visiting family or going south for the winter. Fall Detection is also available with this plan, for the extra $10/month.
  • Family Guardian: starting at $79.95/month, this plan combines the extended range of the Classic plan with the cellular coverage of the Home plan. It also gives you the ability to monitor your loved one's activity levels through three in-home safety sensors and the Family Guardian mobile app. You'll be able to see that the person is up and active, or if they've left a door open or wandered during the night. Once again, you can add Fall Detection for $10/month more.

On the other hand, if you're looking for protection that goes with the user, you'll want to consider Medical Guardian's two mobile medical alert systems:

  • Mobile Guardian: starting at $39.95/month, this plan includes a portable device with a built-in speaker, small enough to be worn on a belt or tucked into a pocket or purse. Pushing the emergency button connects the user directly to the monitoring center. This plan also includes a smaller pendant or watch button, with a range of 350 feet from the portable unit. The portable device has a 24-hour battery life and comes with a charging cradle. The system also includes GPS tracking, allowing the wearer to receive help at his or her exact location There is no Fall Detection upgrade available with the Mobile Guardian plan.
  • Active Guardian: starting at $49.95/month, this plan includes the benefits of the Mobile Guardian plan and adds several benefits. You do have to wear the device as a lanyard, because the plan includes Fall Detection. This device also includes WiFi capabilities, allowing the emergency operators to pinpoint the wearer's location through hotspots in the event that the GPS isn't available (e.g. inside a building). The Active Guardian device features a 5-day battery life and recharges within 3 hours.

Medical Guardian also offers several add-ons you may want to consider. For example, if first responders may need a key to enter your residence, you can include a 4-digit lockbox for $2/month; the code is then given to the emergency personnel by the call center, so that they can get in as quickly as possible if the door is locked. You may also want to install a wall-mounted button in locations of frequent falls, such as the bathroom.

We found the pricing for all of Medical Guardian's systems to be very affordable and competitive with other services, especially given that there's no charge for the equipment itself. And, while you never have to sign a lengthy contract to use this company's services, you can save money by choosing a quarterly or annual payment plan. Also, at the time of our review, new customers could get two free months by using a promo code featured at the top of the site, so keep your eyes open for any special promotions that may be in place at the time of your order.

Another plus of using Medical Guardian for your medical alert system is their fantastic customer-friendly policies. If you're not happy with your device, coverage, or any other aspect of the system, you have 30 days from delivery to call Medical Guardian, and another 15 days to return your equipment - for a full refund of your service fees, with no cancellation charge. This is the most generous return policy in the industry.

It's no surprise that customers have glowing things to say about their experience with the service. Their comments say everything you'd want to hear about a medical alert system: "fast response time", "reliable coverage", "saved my life more than once", and much more.

Medical Guardian consistently outpaces other systems with respect to affordability, technology, and reliability of both equipment and emergency response. With their five different plans, available Fall Detection upgrade, and no required contracts or activation fees, Medical Guardian earns our highest rating among companies offering the best medical alert systems.

Visit Site

3 stars
Life Station

LIFE STATION Visit Site

Cost:

Starting at $25.95/month when paid annually

LifeStation is based in New Jersey and has been in business for 14 years. They offer both landline- and cellular-based medical alert systems, along with Fall Detection if desired.

Unfortunately, you can only get pricing on non-landline medical alert systems if you call a representative; LifeStation could improve their ability to compete with other services by being more transparent with all of their systems and prices right on their website.

We did speak with a very knowledgeable customer service representative. We like that their reps do not work on commission, which makes it less likely that callers will be pushed to commit to a plan. Between the representative and the website, here is the available information for LifeStation's plans:

  • In-Home: landline required. Base unit plus button wristband or pendant. 500 foot range. Fees range from $25.95/month to $29.95/month, depending on whether you choose annual, quarterly, or monthly payment plans. Fall Detection can be added for an extra fee.
  • Enhanced Location with GPS: necklace has two-way speaker to communicate with the monitoring center. We were given a quote that included Fall Detection, priced at $42.95/month if paid annually, $44.95/month for quarterly, and $46.95 if we paid month to month.

LifeStation does offer a 30-day trial period, where you can return the equipment and get a full refund if you're not satisfied with any part of the service. However, if you choose a prepaid plan and cancel after the first 30 days, you will not be eligible for a refund of your prepaid fees. This is also true if the user no longer needs the service, so we suggest you consider carefully before committing to a quarterly or annual plan if there's any chance that you may not use the medical alert system for the full three months or year.

The rep we spoke with gave us a "limited time offer" of $29.95 per month on the Enhanced Location system, but we would have had to give them a credit card over the phone to hold the price until making a decision. Without having that pricing in writing, we were hesitant to give them that kind of information.

Looking at many of the complaints filed with the BBB, it's a good thing we didn't: several people report being asked to provide a credit card "to hold the special pricing", and they were charged for the plan/medical alert system even though they never called back to authorize it. LifeStation has an A+ rating with the BBB and seems to respond - using a copy/paste response - to the complaints.

On a positive note, a plus offered by LifeStation is 24/7 customer service. While all medical alert services have 24/7 monitoring for emergency response, these operators aren't necessarily able to help users with technical issues like getting a GPS unit to track properly or installing a base unit. LifeStation does both: 24/7 monitoring as well as customer service, to make sure their clients can get either kind of help whenever they need it.

LifeStation gets high marks for a good rating with the BBB and round-the-clock customer service. On the other hand, they could improve by adding transparent pricing to their website, as well as by not seeming to play games with using credit cards to hold "special-offer pricing" and then charging customers without their permission.

Visit Site

Continued from above

There are a wide variety of choices when it comes to medical alert systems: some services that have been on the market for many years, and others that are newer to the industry. When shopping around for the right product for yourself or for a loved one, you may find a straightforward, easy-to-use website that clearly explains your options. On the other hand, some companies still rely on pushy sales tactics that won't give you much information unless you speak with a representative.

As you compare the various medical alert systems currently available, there are several aspects to keep in mind:

  • Cost. How much will you spend for equipment and monitoring fees?
  • Variety of Productsand Services. Can you get the coverage you need? Does the business offer upgrades like fall detection?
  • Cellular vs. Landline. If you or your loved one doesn't have a landline, can they still use the system? Or will you need to incur the extra expenses of installing a landline and paying for a phone plan?
  • Ordering Process. Can you easily shop the site and get what you need on your own terms, or will you have to work with a representative in order to start service?
  • Contracts. Will you have to sign a lengthy service contract for the medical alert system? Can you cancel the service if it doesn't meet your expectations or the user no longer needs it?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about the company, the equipment, the service, and the attitude of company representatives? Does the business have a rating with the BBB?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best medical alert systems on the market today. We hope these reviews give you the information you need to select the medical alert service that will give you or your loved one extra safety and peace of mind.

Breaking Healthcare Tech News: NXT-ID Subsidiary LogicMark Expands Retail Distribution of its Personal Emergency Response Systems

The Company is a leading provider of medical alert systems that offer this emergency service without a monthly fee or annual contract. LogicMark offers both monitored and non-monitored PERS devices.. ...

Published:  Thu, 25 Apr 2019 06:36:00 GMT



3 Most Innovative Life Saving Medical Alert Systems For Seniors

Medical alert systems provide emergency monitoring in and out of home. They are designed to signal an emergency requiring urgent attention and to call emergency medical personnel. They can also alert ...

Published:  Sun, 21 Apr 2019 01:19:00 GMT



Medical Alert Systems Market to Make Great Impact In Near Future by 2027: Business Opportunities, Industry Analysis, Size, Share and Forecast

The medical alert systems market is anticipated to grow in the forecast, owing increasing aging population and increasing penetration of smartphones in healthcare and constant innovations in ...

Published:  Fri, 12 Apr 2019 22:26:00 GMT



African healthcare systems are in an arms race with a rising fake medicine problem

Last month the World Health Organization's Global Surveillance and Monitoring System for Substandard and Falsified Medical Products issued an alert over the circulation of confirmed fake ...

Published:  Tue, 23 Apr 2019 00:07:00 GMT



Bay Alarm Medical Announces Support For 4G LTE Cellular Networks

April 15, 2019 /PRNewswire-PRWeb/ -- Bay Alarm Medical (https://www.BayAlarmMedical.com), a leading provider of medical alert systems for the elderly, today debuted two new products using AT&T's 4G ...

Published:  Mon, 15 Apr 2019 01:07:00 GMT



Medical Alert Systems Market 2018 - 2027: Business Opportunities, Industry Analysis and Forecast

The medical alert systems market report provides an in-depth insight of global market covering all important parameters including development trends, challenges, opportunities, key manufacturers ...

Published:  Tue, 23 Apr 2019 21:59:00 GMT



Security Vulnerabilities Detected in ICDs: Addressing Ransomware Risk in Medical Devices

In late March 2019, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) published a statement to alert the ... same operating systems to ensure they can gain the maximum coverage. Since medical devices ...

Published:  Tue, 23 Apr 2019 22:00:00 GMT



Use of the Stryker Wingspan Stent System Outside of Approved Indications Leads to an Increased Risk of Stroke or Death: FDA Safety Communication

Stryker's Wingspan Stent System (Wingspan) is used to open narrowed arteries ... who have had two or more strokes despite aggressive medical management; whose most recent stroke occurred more than ...

Published:  Thu, 25 Apr 2019 08:16:00 GMT



Our health care system, perpetually on alert

European nations with single-payer systems produce better results at significantly lower ... In all of these communities, the key difference is the local culture of medical practice, while operating ...

Published:  Tue, 16 Apr 2019 21:00:00 GMT



Breaking Healthcare Tech News: NXT-ID (NASDAQ: $NXTD) Subsidiary LogicMark Expands Retail Distribution of its Personal Emergency Response Systems

The Company is a leading provider of medical alert systems that offerthis emergency service without a monthly fee orannual contract. LogicMarkoffers both monitored and non-monitored PERS devices..

Published:  Thu, 25 Apr 2019 07:10:00 GMT



Share Us!    Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Twitter Share TopConsumerReviews.com on LinkedIn Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Google+ Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure