Best Reviews Best Olive Oil Clubs Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      October 27, 2020

Home  >  Olive Oil Clubs  >  Zingerman's vs Gourmet Cooking & Living

Best Olive

Oil Clubs

  1. Amazing Clubs
  2. Zingerman's
  3. The Olive Press
  4. Gourmet Cooking & Living

Your Information Is Secure
Eat Right To Feel Great Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Auto Loans


Christmas Cards

Credit Counseling

DUI Lawyers

Fruit Clubs

Home Brew Beer Supplies

Homeschool Supplies

Music Publishing

Senior Care


Individual Reviews

Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club

Amazing Clubs


The Olive Press

Gourmet Cooking & Living


Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Zingerman's vs Gourmet Cooking & Living

To help you find the Best Olive Oil Clubs, provides you with an in-depth comparison of Zingerman's and Gourmet Cooking & Living.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Olive Oil Clubs, please Click Here

Join the best Olive Oil Club with Fresh Press Olive Oil Today! Who offers the best Olive Oil Club? If you consider yourself a "foodie" or even if you just love the flavor and health benefits of a Mediterranean diet, you're probably well-acquainted with olive oil. The preferred olive oil for most cooking needs is, of course, extra virgin olive oil (sometimes referred to as EVOO).

What makes this olive oil so special? The production process doesn't include refining, leaving a greater flavor variety in the oil itself. That means that you'll experience a different taste depending on where the olives were grown, from California to Italy and beyond. Plus, extra virgin olive oils contain a higher percentage of nutrients, making it the best all-around choice for both taste and health benefits.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews


Olive Oil Club Reviews

4 stars


Visit Site


$125 for 2 months (2 half-liter bottles)

$200 for 4 months (4 half-liter bottles)

$260 for 6 months (6 half-liter bottles)

Handmade terraced olive oil dipping plates included in first shipment

Free shipping

Zingerman's knows gourmet food. Based in Ann Arbor, Michigan, this company has a decades-long history of making mouth-watering breads and desserts, farmhouse cheeses, and much more - and fortunately, most of it is available for delivery direct to you!

Around the world

Zingerman's Olive Oil Club brings you what they call "rare" varieties. Although selections may vary, their products usually include a half-liter bottle from these sources around the world:

  • Peranzana (Italy)
  • OLV (Spain)
  • La Spineta (Southern Italy)
  • Agrumato Lemon (Italy)
  • Roi (Northern Italy)
  • Onsa's (Tunisia)

Dipping plates

Also, with your first delivery, you'll get a set of handmade, terraced olive oil dipping plates worth $30 but included at no extra charge. All shipments include free delivery (though there's a $10/delivery charge if you're sending them to Alaska or Hawaii), as well as an informative newsletter on how each oil was made and suggestions for delicious use.

Best Olive Oil Clubs

A little expensive

As you might expect with a product described as "rare", this Olive Oil Club is on the spendy side:

  • $125 for 2 months
  • $200 for 4 months
  • $260 for 6 months

Fantastic reputation

There are no customer reviews for these subscriptions on the Zingerman's website, so you might hesitate to spend that kind of money on an Olive Oil Club, not knowing what other people have said. Rest assured: Zingerman's has a fantastic reputation, demonstrated by their "Returnless Guarantee". We encourage you to read it - because it's just plain entertaining, and because you'll see right away that you don't have to worry about being satisfied with your Olive Oil Club deliveries. "We consider it an honor when you let us help fix a problem" and "the only taste that counts is yours" are just a few examples of how this company makes sure you're satisfied, either with a refund or by sending you something you'd like more.

Hand-crafted right from the source

Another cool thing we found while digging around the Zingerman's website: they taste every single olive oil they offer, to make sure the quality is still up to par. And, with few exceptions, every olive oil is sourced directly from farmers who make the products using what they've grown on their own estates - often producing only a couple thousand bottles each year. The olive oil you'll get from Zingerman's is truly hand-crafted, artisanal, and produced small-scale: definitely no fillers or dilution here.

Top shelf quality

Although their Olive Oil Club is more expensive than most, with fewer delivery/subscription options, Zingerman's is worth considering if you're looking for the highest-quality, small-batch olive oils available today. You can be assured that your culinary experience with any bottle you receive will be exceptional - or Zingerman's will do everything to make it right.

Visit Site
3 stars
Gourmet Cooking & Living


Visit Site


From $34 to $82/month for 1-3 bottles

Free shipping

Gourmet Cooking & Living is based in Brooklyn and is a family-owned business dedicated to bringing the best Italian foodstuffs to their customers. Their flagship product is their Italian Olive Oil of the Month, with an exceptional extra virgin olive oil selected from a new region of Italy every month.

Born in olive oil

Fun fact: one of the founders of the company grew up on his grandparents' farm in Calabria, Italy, and his mother was harvesting olives two hours before bringing him into the world. That's why the family says he was "born in olive oil"!

Lots of customization options

Gourmet Cooking & Living allows a lot of customization in their clubs - which can make the ordering process a little confusing. You can choose between 1, 2, and 3 bottles per delivery, with shipments arriving every month or every other month. Don't get confused when you choose the box that says "shipments every month": it doesn't mean that you'll get 2, 3, 4, 6 or 12 bottles of oil in each shipment, but rather for how many months you want to receive a single delivery!

Nice gift giving option

You can also opt to have a gift box used on your first shipment: a great option if you're giving a subscription as a present (but only need the fancy presentation for the initial delivery). And, if you'd like to add the company's hand-selected, gourmet Italian Product of the Month - ranging from olives to artichokes and more - you have the ability to add that to your order for an additional $14.95.

What you can expect

Here's what you can expect to pay for your Olive Oil Club with Gourmet Cooking & Living:

  • 1 bottle per package: $34
  • 2 bottles per package: $59 (savings of $9)
  • 3 bottles per package: $82 (savings of $20)

Free shipping

Shipping and handling are included with all memberships at no extra charge. You'll also get detailed information about the oils in each delivery: the history of the region where it was produced, tasting notes and olive oil profile, a biography of the oils' producer, and a recipe that highlights the particular oils' best features and flavors.

Website issues

When it comes to website functionality, this club has some challenges. Even though the site has been around for quite a while, its copyright date was several years old at the time of our most recent review. And at first, our selected Olive Oil Club didn't go through and the site told us our shopping cart was empty, but a second try let us get our order placed.

No satisfaction policy

Gourmet Cooking & Living also doesn't have a posted return/satisfaction policy. If you get a delivery that was damaged in shipment or an oil that just tastes off, there's no way of knowing if they'd replace it, refund your money, or simply shrug and say, "there's nothing we can do for you". There's a form for requesting to make a return, but no information about what you can expect if you fill it out.

Reasonable choice

In general, the Olive Oil Club offered by Gourmet Cooking & Living sounds like a reasonably-priced option that will be a favorite of those who want a strictly Italian selection of olive oils in their pantry. With some improvements to the website and more clarity with respect to their customer satisfaction policies, this Olive Oil Club could quickly move up in the rankings.

Visit Site

Continued from above

However, you may have found yourself disappointed with what you find at your local grocery store. According to Business Insider, many olive oil bottles contain product that has been diluted with lower-quality or even chemically refined oil - or worse, mixed with older, sometimes rancid batches left over from previous seasons. While there are some tips you can follow to get fresher olive oil - looking on the bottle or packaging for a harvest date no older than a year, certifications like EVA or COOC, and so on - there's no guarantee you'll find a good selection, even at your favorite specialty retailer.

That's where Olive Oil Clubs come in. Delivered monthly or quarterly, these subscription plans ensure that you have nothing but the freshest, highest-quality olive oil sourced from the most reputable providers. Carefully curated by experts, the selections may range from all-California or all-Italy to a range of olive oil varieties from around the world. And, surprisingly, the cost per bottle is often comparable with what you'd find for premium olive oil from your local supermarket.

When choosing an Olive Oil Club, how can you decide which one is the right subscription for you? Here are several criteria to keep in mind:

  • Variety. Do you prefer olive oil that comes from California-grown olives, Italian harvests, or from many different places? Are you looking for flavored oils or plain extra virgin olive oil? Be sure that the club you choose fits those preferences.
  • Cost. How much will you spend on the club membership? How many bottles are included in the subscription price, and how much product will you get? Is shipping included?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about their experience with the Olive Oil Club? Does the company have a strong track record of excellent customer service and high-quality products? has reviewed and ranked the best Olive Oil Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the perfect Olive Oil Club for all of your future culinary endeavors and flavor adventures!

Chasity Pritchett, 36, human resources administrator, Auxiliary Systems Inc., and owner of Emblem Olive Oil | Top 40 Under 40

I provide quality and trusted olive oil to consumers around the world ... president of the Hampton Roads Tuskegee Alumni Club, and a chair of the Tuskegee University Board of Trustees' ad hoc ...

Published:  Mon, 12 Oct 2020 03:46:00 GMT

Is Costco a Better Deal Than Sam's Club?

But when it comes to quality, Costco's Kirkland brand has earned more kudos than Sam's Club's products for everything from olive oil to tequila. Winner: Costco. At Costco you can return virtually ...

Published:  Thu, 08 Oct 2020 17:00:00 GMT

Staying in this Halloween? Food and drink to make at home

Anyone else holing up in their home Halloween night, conjuring a spooky vibe away from any potential pandemic scares? I am, and I plan on having some festive food and drink to keep the evening fun ...

Published:  Wed, 21 Oct 2020 02:21:00 GMT

The West Wing reunion: How the show inspired our TV Dinners menus from canapes to Oval Office chilli

As the characters from The West Wing gear up for a one-off reunion, Olivia Potts and Kate Young explain how it gave rise to popular supper clubs ...

Published:  Tue, 13 Oct 2020 23:28:00 GMT

Let's Hear It For the Chefs: State of the Food Industry

The pandemic has affected everyone-but it's hit restaurants particularly hard. Diablo takes a moment to recognize the heroic work of our frontline food purveyors.

Published:  Fri, 23 Oct 2020 00:06:00 GMT

15 Ways To Make Everything Taste Like Bacon

The first rule of Bacon Club is NEVER THROW AWAY BACON FAT ... asks you to saute or roast food with another fat like olive oil or vegetable oil - except that this way, that food will end ...

Published:  Fri, 02 Oct 2020 17:00:00 GMT

Healdsburg Airstream owner creates cookbook with stress-free recipes for the road

When I went away to college, I got a subscription to Gourmet magazine, and I started cooking for all of my starving friends." Back in March, when she was laid off from her former job at a large wine ...

Published:  Tue, 13 Oct 2020 16:18:00 GMT

A nudge from Leah Chase leads Baton Rouge chef to open restaurant with healthy, Louisiana fare

Chef Charles Wilford and his wife and business partner, Lecia Wilford, focus on healthy Louisiana fare at their restaurant, Chef Charles House - The Bis'Treaux, on Merchant Drive. Charles Wilford's ...

Published:  Tue, 13 Oct 2020 09:00:00 GMT

Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure