Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Personal Trainers Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      January 20, 2020

Home  >  Personal Trainers  >  Thumbtack vs My Home Personal Trainer

Best

Personal Trainers

  1. Born Fitness
  2. Thumbtack
  3. Livekick
  4. Fitness Trainer
  5. Find Your Trainer
  6. My Home Trainer

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
Exercise Your Body Type Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Allergy Relief

Cheesecake Clubs

Copyright Registration

Dog Treat Clubs

Home Security Systems

Painting Lessons

Tinnitus

Wedding Planning Software

 

Individual Reviews

Trainiac

Born Fitness

Thumbtack

Livekick

Fitness Trainer

Find Your Trainer

My Home Personal Trainer

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Thumbtack vs My Home Personal Trainer

Best Personal Trainers

To help you find the Best Personal Trainers, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Thumbtack and My Home Personal Trainer.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Personal Trainers, please Click Here

Where can you find the best Personal Trainers? Do you just walk up to the most ripped guy at the gym and ask who he works with? Or go with the ones on staff at your local gym, even though you've never really felt a good connection with them? Good news: there's a much more effective way to get the guidance and expertise you need to make progress with your health and fitness goals.

Today you can use the web to either work with an online personal trainer, or find the perfect local fit for your personality and training needs. Whether you choose a fully-online personal trainer, or a local professional, depends on your situation. Is it important to have someone at your side, guiding you through each exercise and giving you face-to-face accountability? Or, does your schedule make it so that you need a personal training solution that is completely portable, with flexible sessions and on-the-go availability? Your answers to those questions will influence which type of personal trainer you choose.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Personal Trainer Reviews

4 stars
Thumbtack

THUMBTACK

Visit Site

Cost:

Depends on the personal trainer you hire

Thumbtack is a referral service for professionals across a variety of industries, mostly in the home repair/improvement fields. They also include Personal Trainers in their available services, and we were pleased to see that there were more than 100 in our suburban area.

Start by choosing Personal Trainers as the service you're looking for and then enter your zip code. You'll get a list of people in your location, and you can further sort your results by where you prefer to work out: Trainer's gym or private studio, public outdoors location, your home or apartment gym, or a location recommended by the trainer. You can also indicate if you're training alone or in a pair (with a friend, significant other, etc.). Then, choose your preference: female trainer, male trainer, or no preference.

Even if you don't indicate your preferences and just go directly to the list of personal trainers in your area, you'll still be asked those questions when you find one you like and click the button to check for availability, so be thinking about what your answers would be. You have to enter your email address in order to find out the person's availability - so expect to be contacted directly if you take that step.

What we love about using Thumbtack for finding a personal trainer:

  • Photos! You can see exactly what your prospective trainer looks like, and they're usually decent shots.
  • Lots of info available before submitting your personal information. In your list of results, you'll see those photos, an estimated hourly cost per session, number of reviews from previous clients, number of hires directly through Thumbtack, a blurb from their profile, and some have extra indicators showing how long they've been in the industry, if they respond quickly to inquiries, and so on.
    Then, when you select View Profile, you can get a lot more: links to their social media pages, introductions from the trainer(s), whether or not they've been background checked, typical availability hours, photos and even videos of their training in action, detailed customer reviews, and any specialties the trainer can help with (e.g. people with back problems, athletes training for an event, and so on).
    We think that Thumbtack does an amazing job of letting prospective clients get to know the trainers before making contact. For example, in the top profile in our area, we were able to see answers to "What is your typical process for working with a new customer?" and "What education and/or training do you have that relates to your work?" and see exactly what we could expect.
  • Free to use. You don't have to sign up for an account to use Thumbtack, so there are no membership fees, nothing to pay in advance, no contracts. That's a big plus! You choose the contractor you want and pay them the rate they've advertised, with no long-term commitments required by Thumbtack.

What we think Thumbtack could improve:

  • Sorting the results by distance from the entered zip code. When we pulled up our list of possible contractors, there was no way to tell where they were located. We did a little research by looking at some of their social media accounts, and the first two on our list were 30-45 minutes from our location. Especially if you're looking for a trainer that works out of their own studio/gym, you'll want to know upfront if they're close enough for you to want to drive there before reaching out to them.
  • Ability to pay through the platform/app. To really increase the convenience level, Thumbtack could make it possible for customers to pay their personal trainers right through the app or online portal.

Overall, Thumbtack was a very pleasant surprise! People looking to match up with a personal trainer in their area should be able to find a great range of professionals for hire, and with so much information available upfront, there's no risk involved in using the service to "shop around". And, as a company with an "A" grade and accreditation from the Better Business Bureau, Thumbtack shows that it's a name to trust when choosing a personal trainer. This is our top choice as a referral service specifically for in-person, local personal training options.

Visit Site
2.5 stars
My Home Personal Trainer

MY HOME PERSONAL TRAINER

Visit Site

Cost:

$6.49/month for 3-month plan

$4.99/month for 6-month plan

$3.99/month for 12-month plan

$79.99/month extra for email support from a fitness coach

My Home Personal Trainer is probably the most no-frills service in our review. It's also the cheapest, giving you access to fitness videos, a fitness plan generator, a full library of workout plans, hundreds of meal and recipe ideas, and a couple of fitness and nutrition e-books for the rock bottom price of just $3.99 to $6.49 per month.

If you want personalized input on your current state of fitness or any other one-on-one support, you'll need to add on My Home Personal Trainer's Fitness Coach option. This costs an extra $79.99 month, and only gives you access to your designated coach via email.

This is all part of their Fit Pro account membership. The site also offers a database of in-person trainers near you, free online resources, and an online fitness store if you need to buy weights, yoga mats, or other gear for your workout.

While there's nothing wrong with My Home Personal Trainer, it lacks the features and attention of most of the services in our review. Their website feels very outdated and definitely lacks visual appeal.

Plus, a lot of what they offer in their paid membership plan is available for free with other wellness apps like MyFitnessPal and SparkPeople. Considering that you'd be spending at least $80/month to get access to the fitness videos, nutrition plans, and email support from a coach, your money would probably be better spent on a personal trainer plan that gives you the same for less - or much more customized workouts and nutrition advice, instead of generic videos and recipes, even if you have to invest a little more to get it.

We recommend you consider some of the more fully-featured personal trainer services in our review, especially if you want nutritional and fitness advice that is specifically designed for you.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Working with an in-person trainer gives you some advantages. You can choose a professional that has worked with other clients in your area and who may have access to local fitness facilities for your sessions together. Especially for beginners who are just learning how to safely and effectively use free weights or body weight exercises, it's reassuring to know that each rep will be done with the proper form, making injury less likely.

On the other hand, the range of possibilities when working with online personal trainers is incredible. You tend to get more for your money, scheduling at your convenience, and more support outside of your actual live training sessions. Plus, if you regularly travel for work but want to maintain your wellness routine, no problem - you can still do your session via video chat on your phone, and your trainer will give you a workout that doesn't require any extra equipment.

Whichever type of personal trainer you prefer, there are several criteria to keep in mind when making your selection. Here are some things to consider:

  • Cost. Prices vary widely, from as little as $3.99/month to $200+ per month. Is the personal trainer affordable, keeping in mind any extra costs you might have (e.g. gym membership, equipment to have on hand at home, etc.)
  • Personalization. Will you get guidance that is tailored specifically to you, your dietary needs, and your level of fitness? Or is the instruction more generic?
  • Reputation. What do other customers say about the personal trainers who work with the company or who are included in the referral database? Are people generally satisfied with the value they get for their money? Is the company rated by the BBB or any other industry experts?
  • Satisfaction Guarantee/Refund Policy. If you work with the personal trainer and wind up feeling like it's not the right fit, can you get your money back?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Personal Trainers available today. We hope these reviews give you all the help you need to find the perfect fitness expert for your goals!

Rebel Wilson looks noticeably slimmer after enlisting a top personal trainer and declaring 2020 'the year of health'

A video posted by "transformation trainer" Jono Castano shows Wilson performing battle rope slams at luxury Sydney gym Soma Collection.

Published:  Sat, 18 Jan 2020 04:20:00 GMT



Flight Live matches users with trainers for online, on-demand personal workouts

Her message is, "don't be nervous. You don't need to have trained for a marathon before doing personal training." To help put people at ease, Flight Live created a short video to show what a workout ...

Published:  Thu, 16 Jan 2020 15:35:00 GMT



Shakira's Personal Trainer Gives Us All the Details on Her 6-Day Workout Week Ahead of the Super Bowl

But they're not at it alone. Speaking exclusively with E! News, Kaiser spoke to us about what it's like training with the Colombian singer for nearly a decade, her workout routines, her workout ...

Published:  Wed, 15 Jan 2020 18:22:00 GMT



Get training guidance and personal coaching from this smartwatch

It's all about taking some time to properly figure out what matters to you, and if personal coaching is something you would benefit from, we recommend checking out the Huawei Watch GT Active. This ...

Published:  Tue, 14 Jan 2020 06:49:00 GMT



Gym client suing personal trainer after session ends in pain

A TRIP to the gym turned into a painful experience for a Gold Coast woman, who is suing the gym and a personal trainer over an exercise injury. Wendy Milkins, 63, claims the back injury she suffered ...

Published:  Sat, 18 Jan 2020 16:00:00 GMT



Shout Out: Brian Mahoney, personal trainer

Brian Mahoney is a former software developer who shifted careers to become a personal trainer. He has worked in many North Shore communities for over 20 years. A: I was lifting weights as a kid as I ...

Published:  Mon, 06 Jan 2020 07:53:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure