Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Popcorn Clubs Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      February 25, 2020

Home  >  Popcorn Clubs  >  Shirley's vs Gourmet Gift Baskets

Best

Popcorn Clubs

  1. Shirley's
  2. Moose Munch
  3. Popcorn Factory
  4. Snacktime Express
  5. Gourmet Gift Baskets

Your Information Is Secure
101 Gift Basket Ideas Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Latest Reviews

Catholic Dating Sites

Cheesecake Clubs

Credit Monitoring

Custom T Shirts

Handbags

Patent Applications

Piano Lessons

Popcorn Clubs

Tea Clubs

Transcription Services

 

Individual Reviews

Amazing Clubs

Shirley's

Moose Munch

Popcorn Factory

Snacktime Express

Gourmet Gift Baskets

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Shirley's vs Gourmet Gift Baskets

To help you find the Best Popcorn Clubs, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Shirley's and Gourmet Gift Baskets.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Popcorn Clubs, please Click Here

Join a Popcorn Club with Amazing Clubs Today! Where can you find the best Popcorn Clubs? If you - or someone you love! - is a fan of the white, fluffy goodness that is popcorn, what better than to have it delivered right to the home or office on the regular? Because really, the stuff you get at the theater is usually way too salty, dripping with fake butter, and definitely doesn't taste good after a day of sitting in the bucket. And, what you can buy at your local supermarket has probably been sitting on a shelf for so long, there's no way that it's going to be fresh. Right?

Popcorn Clubs take this treat to a whole other level of deliciousness. Did you know that cheddar and caramel are not the only two flavor options out there? Start shopping around and comparing monthly subscription plans, and soon you'll discover that there are artisans crafting crazy flavors like Dill Pickle, Mango Habanero, and holiday-specific tastes like Cranberry and Winter Spice.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Popcorn Club Reviews

4.5 stars
Shirley's

SHIRLEY'S

Visit Site

Cost:

Starting from $74.95 for a 3-month subscription ($25/month)

You know that cute little popcorn store on Main Street, or the one you always make sure to visit when you're on vacation in your favorite small town? That's the kind of experience you'll get when you subscribe to Shirley's Popcorn of the Month Club. Made right in their Bluffton, Ohio store, their gourmet popcorn is fresh and flavorful with each delivery, with one classic flavor and one premium flavor in every box.

Most of Shirley's flavors tend to be on the sweet side. Past selections have included Lemon Cheesecake, Caramel to Die For, and Chocolate Almond, along with traditional cheddar varieties. All orders are packaged fresh on the 10th of the month, so keep that in mind if you're ordering for a special occasion (i.e. if you don't order by the 8th of the month, your deliveries won't start until the 10th of the following calendar month).

You'll pay $74.95 for a 3-month plan that includes two large bags (approximately 10-12 cups of popcorn per bag). If you'd prefer a 6-month plan, the cost is $139.95, and a full-year subscription is $259.95. Shirley's includes the shipping fees at no extra charge, which is a nice perk you might expect from a small, customer-centered company like this one.

Shirley's also wants you to be delighted with every shipment in your Popcorn Club membership. If you're unhappy for any reason, just let them know and they'll send a replacement popcorn gift of equal value right away.

You only need to browse customer reviews of Shirley's for a short time to see that this small business really delivers. From the friendly, attentive customer service representatives to the perfectly-flavored popcorn, this store inspires enthusiastic praise and repeat buyers. The BBB agrees, giving Shirley's a flawless "A+" rating as well.

So, if you enjoy supporting a family-owned business that offers big flavor, great prices, and excellent customer service, you'll want to consider Shirley's Popcorn Club for your next gift subscription.

Visit Site
2.5 stars
Gourmet Gift Baskets

GOURMET GIFT BASKETS

Visit Site

Cost:

Starting from $89.99 for a 3-month plan ($30/month)

Gourmet Gift Baskets was founded in 2002 and offers a range of gifts featuring "exceptional gourmet ingredients handcrafted with care". Although the site doesn't specify who's responsible for their Popcorn Club, the product page says that the popcorn is handmade daily by a woman-owned family business.

Each delivery in the Popcorn Club includes a 1-gallon tin with a single flavor of popcorn. Past flavors have included Mint Cookie Mayhem, Nacho Cheese, and Caramel Apple, to name a few.

You've got four delivery options with Gourmet Gift Baskets' Popcorn Club: 3 months, 6 months, 9 months or 12 months. Prices range from $89.99 to $229.99, averaging out to be a monthly cost from just over $19 to just under $30. Shipping fees are included in those prices.

You can also spread your membership plan out so that deliveries come every other month: select that under the Frequency drop-down. And, as with most Popcorn Clubs, you can specify when you'd like deliveries to start; Gourmet Gift Baskets is the only company we found that lets you select a date as far into the future as 18 months from the date of your order!

The company enjoys a strong overall reputation across all of the gift baskets and other products they sell: over more than 1400 customer reviews, more than 90% gave Gourmet Gift Baskets a 4- or 5-star rating. But, the customer feedback specific to the Popcorn Club was pretty sparse: there were no reviews on the product page itself, so it's hard to know what people think about the freshness and flavor of the popcorn.

We also weren't super impressed by Gourmet Gift Baskets' satisfaction guarantee - or lack thereof. While they have a refund policy, it only talks about products that arrive damaged. What if your caramel popcorn arrives in September and you live somewhere hot...and everything is a sticky, lumpy mess after sitting on your porch after delivery? There's nothing that says you'll be able to get a refund or replacement. If the company would indeed send you a new package or give you a credit, they should definitely say so on their website.

Because this is the most expensive of all the Popcorn Clubs we evaluated, we were expecting a little more for the money. But, compared with our highest-ranked retailer, Gourmet Gift Baskets comes up short in several ways: cost, amount of popcorn you get for the money, and a lack of variety in each monthly delivery. Plus, with no solid customer satisfaction guarantee, you may receive better service from one of the Popcorn Clubs that promises to make it right if you're unhappy for any reason. For these reasons, Gourmet Gift Baskets' Popcorn Club is the lowest-ranked in our review.

Visit Site

Continued from above

As a gift-giving option, Popcorn Clubs make it easy to really "wow" your lucky recipient. Most plans let you choose how many deliveries you'd like to buy, usually ranging from a single month to once a month for a full year. Some even let you stagger the shipments, bringing freshly-crafted popcorn once per season. The best clubs let your recipient preview what will be coming in their upcoming deliveries, so that they can skip a month if a flavor isn't their favorite or if they're going to be out of town.

Of course, no two Popcorn Clubs are alike, so it's worth doing a little bit of research before you select the one for your next monthly subscription. Want the inside scoop on picking the right one for you? Here's a helpful list of criteria that can help you find the perfect one for you or the person you're gifting:

  • Amount. How much popcorn will you get in each delivery? Some Popcorn Clubs include a whopping two gallons of product, while others are just enough for a few handfuls.
  • Variety. Do you want more than one flavor in each package? Do you prefer more run-of-the-mill flavors, really wild ones, or maybe a little of both? Does the company let you specify a taste preference, or swap flavors if one isn't quite your favorite?
  • Cost. What will you pay for your subscription? Are shipping costs included in the monthly price? Do you get a good value for your money?
  • Customer Service. What do people say about the Popcorn Club? Is there a good refund policy or satisfaction guarantee if your popcorn doesn't arrive in great condition or even if you just don't like something you receive?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best Popcorn Clubs available today. We hope this information helps you find the perfect tasty treat for your next gift-giving occasion - or just for your upcoming movie nights at home!

KFC's 80-Piece Popcorn Chicken Bucket Is Back!

Yes! The 80-piece popcorn chicken bucket, which will set you back £5.99 (that's around 8p a piece!) will only be available to buy until 23 March, so move fast. Oh, and you need to be signed up to the ...

Published:  Mon, 24 Feb 2020 16:14:00 GMT



Houston's Rooftop Cinema Club releases spring lineup

Tickets for couples, or anyone looking for a roomier love seat, plus bottomless popcorn, are $24 per person. Student discounts are available starting at $15.30 per ticket. A valid student I.D. is ...

Published:  Sun, 23 Feb 2020 08:57:00 GMT



What's Happening: Popcorn Club, Perogie Days

We welcome your feedback and encourage you to share your thoughts on this story. We ask that you be respectful of others and their points of view, refrain from personal attacks and stay on topic. To ...

Published:  Tue, 18 Feb 2020 05:53:00 GMT



KFC Has Launched An 80-Piece Popcorn Chicken Bucket For £5.99

KFC fans - and, more importantly, popcorn chicken fans - will be delighted to know the ... The only caveat is that you must be signed up to the KFC app and the loyalty scheme - the Colonel's Club - to ...

Published:  Mon, 24 Feb 2020 03:29:00 GMT



Celebrate National Popcorn Day this Sunday with half-price popcorn at Regal

buttery popcorn at all Regal theatres. This holiday deal will be available to all members of the Regal Crown Club on Sunday, Jan. 19. "Popcorn and movies have been the perfect pairing for decades. We ...

Published:  Wed, 12 Feb 2020 13:15:00 GMT



Laughing Matters - "Eco" Movies Offer Hope, But No Popcorn

(But, unfortunately, there's no popcorn.) From March through May, there will be seven screenings but the ... The next in the series, on May 4, is the documentary, The Condor & the Eagle, followed by ...

Published:  Fri, 21 Feb 2020 06:30:00 GMT



$1.25m in seed funding helps to bring skinless popcorn back to the market under Papa's Pops brand

and a 14-16 week program slated for Sam's Club. Other retailers include Wakefern, Jewel-Osco, King's and others. While some startups might be intimidated by such broad distribution out of the gate, ...

Published:  Mon, 17 Feb 2020 08:22:00 GMT



Popcorn, Property Taxes and Tortilla Chips

Junction City-based 4Him Food Group, the parent company of popcorn manufacturer Cosmos Creations, filed for bankruptcy in July 2019, citing the loss of two major sales accounts in 2015-16 that ...

Published:  Thu, 13 Feb 2020 00:25:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure