Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Popular Diets Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      August 23, 2019

Home  >  Popular diets  >  South Beach Diet vs Whole 30

Best

Popular Diets

  1. Weight Watchers
  2. Nutrisystem
  3. South Beach Diet
  4. Keto
  5. Paleo Plan
  6. Atkins
  7. Meal Plan Map
  8. Whole 30
  9. Medifast

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
Amazing Weight Loss and Health Tips Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Cellulite

Cruise Vacations

Colon Cleansers

Keto Diets

Olive Oil Clubs

Online Fitness

Personal Trainers

Pet Meds

Popular Diets

Printer Ink

 

Individual Reviews

Noom

Paleo Plan

Nutrisystem

South Beach Diet

Keto

Paleo Plan

Atkins

Meal Plan Map

Whole 30

Medifast

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

South Beach Diet vs Whole 30

Best Popular Diets

To help you find the Best Popular Diets, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of South Beach Diet and Whole 30.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Popular Diets, please Click Here

What's the best Popular Diet? For those who'd like to drop a few pounds or maybe even shed 100 or more, there's no shortage of services promising to make that dream a reality. Are there any diets that actually work?

The good news is yes, there are many weight loss programs with a solid track record of helping people redefine their relationships with food, learning what and how much to eat, and making changes that aren't just a temporary low number on the scale. But as you've probably noticed, every popular diet seems to have a different approach to shedding unwanted pounds.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2019

Popular Diet Reviews

4 stars
South Beach Diet

SOUTH BEACH DIET Visit Site

Cost:

Plans start at $289.99 for 4 weeks of meals

South Beach is one of several popular diet plans that focus on a lower-carb, high protein approach to losing weight. However, the company's approach is less restrictive than similar plans (Keto, Paleo, Atkins). With South Beach, you'll be aiming for 40-50 net grams of carbs per day, depending on the phase you're on, and you won't be aiming for a state of nutritional ketosis like traditional Keto plans require.

In the first phase of South Beach, you'll jumpstart your weight loss with high-protein, low-carb foods designed to reduce your sugar and starch cravings. In the second phase, you'll add in "good" carbs from fruits, whole grains, and more vegetables, plus two DIY breakfasts, lunches, or dinners each week - to help you learn how to eat healthy for a lifetime. Once you hit your weight goal, you'll learn how to enjoy all foods in moderation and eat happy and healthy for good.

Ideal for those who:

  • Like the convenience of prepared foods with the flexibility of occasional DIY meals
  • Are interested in Paleo/Keto/Atkins without as many restrictions
  • Don't mind spending a little more for an all-in-one plan

Not ideal for those who:

  • Are on a tight budget
  • Don't like the low carb approach to dieting
  • Want to do most of the cooking for themselves

South Beach offers three 4-week diet plans. With each plan, you can choose "Chef's Picks" (recommended for your first order) or pick your own menu:

  • Silver: the most basic plan, which includes 4 weeks of breakfasts, lunches and dinners. This plan sells for $289.99 for women and $329.99 for men.
  • Gold: this plan offers a wider menu variety, including junk-free snacks. This plan sells for $329.99 for women and $359.99 for men.
  • Platinum: the most robust of the three plans, this package also includes 20 Simply Fit shakes. This plan sells for $359.99 for women and $389.99 for men.

If you look under the Plans tab, you'll also find a Diabetes Gold plan. This is your best option if you are managing Type 2 Diabetes.

Every plan comes with free FedEx shipping. Be aware that it is only available within the continental US and can't be shipped to PO boxes or military addresses.

To save the most money, you'll want to sign up for South Beach's auto delivery program. (In fact, the pricing on the website assumes that you're signing up for auto delivery and gives you that price as the default). Also, when we went to leave the South Beach Diet website, we got a pop-up offering a discount of $50 if we placed an order in the next 60 minutes. There was also a promotion at the top of the page offering free shakes with our order.

The foods included in all South Beach plans actually sound like meals you'd enjoy - and if the hundreds of user reviews for each food are any indicator, they taste good! For example, the Broccoli and Cheese Stuffed Chicken Breast has a 4.5-star average over 800+ reviews, and the Turkey Sausage & Egg Muffin looks just like what you'd get at your favorite fast food restaurant.

Overall, South Beach is a solid choice among popular diets. Nutritionally balanced meals, flexibility and convenience are all strong positives for choosing this plan for your weight loss goals.

Visit Site

3 stars
Whole 30

WHOLE 30 Visit Site

Cost:

$30 for first month, $15/month thereafter

$49 for the first quarter, $36/quarter thereafter

$99 for the first year, $84/year thereafter

Whole30 is a popular diet plan that requires major changes in your eating habits. But, for those who have benefited from putting it into practice, this approach to food can be life-changing.

If you suffer from allergies and/or sensitivities but haven't quite figured out what's causing the problem, struggle with conditions with no apparent cause, or have had trouble losing weight no matter how hard you've tried, Whole30 has been effective for millions of people like you.

Ideal for those who:

  • Are struggling to identify allergens and want to figure out sensitivities
  • Can make a 30-day commitment
  • Enjoy meat, seafood, eggs, vegetables, and natural fats

Not ideal for those who:

  • Aren't ready to make HUGE changes to their everyday diet
  • Want a long-term plan for changing their eating habits
  • Aren't willing to give up all added sweeteners, alcohol, grains, legumes, and dairy

Whole30 is designed to change your relationship with food, increase your energy, and change your cravings over the course of 30 days (hence the "30" in the name). There are several extremely important rules you will need to follow in order to be successful on this popular diet:

  • Eat real food. In other words, the closer to the way the food is in nature, the better it is for you. (Think raw vs. stewed tomatoes, ground beef vs. hot dogs) Whole30 prioritizes meat, seafood, eggs, plenty of vegetables and natural fats, lots of herbs, spices and seasonings, and some fruit.
  • Don't eat ANY of the "forbidden" foods. The list is long, and may be too daunting for all but the most dedicated health-seekers: no added sugar (not even substitutes like stevia or xylitol), no grains, no legumes (which also means no peanut butter), no dairy (from cows, goats, or sheep), no sulfites/carrageenan/MSG, and no junk food!
  • Don't weigh yourself or take any body measurements for the whole 30 days.
  • NO cheating. Not for a special occasion, not as a "slip", nada, for the entire month. Because you may be trying to figure out which of the most commonly-allergenic foods are causing you problems, you'll reset the clock if you have bread, corn, or dairy even one time, and you'll wind up feeling like this program was a total failure.

With all of those rules and can't-eats, it's easy to understand why someone would want help in planning and preparing for a Whole30 month! That's where Real Plans comes in. Your subscription lets you choose a start date and the length of your program (minimum 30 days, of course), and how many breakfasts, lunches, and dinners you want help planning.

This service is 100% customizable, within the accepted parameters of the Whole30 program. Maybe you absolutely hate asparagus or already know you're allergic to eggs, so feel free to set those preferences right away.

After your first 30 days, Real Plans helps you work on your 10-day reintroduction: in other words, gradually bringing back in some of the no-no foods as you determine if you are sensitive to each of them.

Best of all, this system generates shopping lists based on the meals you've selected. Go to your pantry first to check off whatever you already have, too. And, if you've finally figured out which type of mustard is "Whole30 approved", you can add a photo of any specific ingredient so that you don't have to read the label over and over again. (Next level pro tip? Real Plans integrates with Instacart, so you can get all of your Whole30 ingredients delivered right to your doorstep).

Pricing for this popular diet plan is reasonable. If you're taking the cautious approach and just want to subscribe for a month, you'll pay $30 for Month 1 and $15/month for every month after that. Ready to commit for a little longer? Choose the $49 quarterly plan, which drops to $36 per quarter after the first 3 months. If you're feeling particularly gung-ho - or if you've done Whole30 in the past and know it's the right thing for you, but you just need some structure - the annual plan is the best deal at $99 for a year and $84 for every year afterwards.

In general, Whole30 is probably the only popular diet plan that can be a game-changer for people who want to identify food sensitivities by eliminating the most likely suspects. And, Real Plans is one of the best resources available for taking as much of the planning and preparation stress off the table.

But, for the average person, Whole30 is HARD. The list of things that you can't eat is long, and if we're being honest, most of us are too lazy or unmotivated to give all of them up completely for an entire month. If you stick to the plan, you might lose a bunch of weight - but that might be from not having anything you WANT to eat, not just from finding out that you've had a food sensitivity all along. For many people, Whole30 is an interesting (and difficult) experiment, but not a sustainable change for the rest of their lives.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Some diet plans will tell you that you have to count every calorie, while others want you to focus on eating more whole and unprocessed foods instead of tracking what you eat. Whichever plan you select, it's important to make sure that it's a program you can realistically follow, based on your current lifestyle. For example, if you frequently travel for work, can you stick to a diet that requires you to cook with hard-to-find ingredients and a full spice cabinet on hand?

And, unless you just want to drop a dress size for an upcoming school reunion or other event, you probably want to find a plan that helps you make sustainable changes for a lifetime. It's easy to do something drastic for a week or even a month, but to avoid the yo-yo effect of fad dieting, you should be honest with yourself about what changes you are able and willing to make - and which ones just aren't the right fit for your personal needs, preferences, and goals.

As you consider the many popular diets offered today, how can you figure out which ones will be the best fit? Here are several criteria to keep in mind:

  • Cost. What will you pay for the diet plan? Is it a one-time investment, a monthly subscription, or some other pricing structure? Does it give you a good value for your money?
  • Time Required. How much effort will you need to put into following the diet? Are your meals premade and delivered, or should you expect to spend a lot of time in the kitchen?
  • Customer Feedback. What do "real people" have to say about their success (or lack of it) when following this diet plan? Most sites will show you their best-case results, but what can an average person expect in terms of weight loss and other health benefits?
  • Personalization. Just like clothes aren't truly one-size-fits-all, neither is dieting. Does the diet plan have a way to customize their recommendations for food, exercise, and more? Do you get any one-on-one input from a coach, nutritionist, or even through an online community of other people using the plan?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best popular diets available today. We hope this information helps you find the right plan to help you smash your weight loss goals!

The Keto Diet Is Popular, but Is It Good for You?

Low-carbohydrate diets have fallen in and out of favor since before the days of Atkins. But now an even stricter version of low-carb eating called the ketogenic diet is gaining popular attention, ...

Published:  Tue, 20 Aug 2019 02:36:00 GMT



The 5 Most-Searched Celebrity Diet Trends Loved by Kourtney Kardashian and More

When we're trying to get into shape, celebrity diets are our number one inspiration ... There's no better time than the present to live our best lives as our best selves! This post is brought to you ...

Published:  Thu, 22 Aug 2019 08:09:00 GMT



How to get rid of visceral fat: Best diet to reduce the belly fat - eat this cheese

Visceral fat can be harmful to a person's health because of where it's stored in the body - next to vital organs such as the liver, stomach and intestines. This is why if visceral fat builds up it can ...

Published:  Thu, 22 Aug 2019 06:58:00 GMT



Tom Brady Cheats in the Best Way Possible on His Diet

After accumulating six Super Bowl rings during the course of his career, Tom Brady has become known as one of the quarterbacks in NFL history. Because Tom has been in the NFL for almost two decades, ...

Published:  Thu, 22 Aug 2019 12:39:00 GMT



The Real-Life Diet of Criss Angel, Who Is 51 and Able to Do the Splits

Real-Life Diet is a series in which GQ talks to athletes ... not allowing your adrenaline or excitement being in front of an audience to get the best of you. You have to remain focused and calm with ...

Published:  Thu, 22 Aug 2019 07:52:00 GMT



The Paleo diet may have been eclipsed by other eating plans, but it's still a major player in the wellness world

"I'm always skeptical of something that is a trendy, popular diet, because there's a reason why it trends, and usually that's because it's just a new way of repackaging restrictions of some kind that ...

Published:  Thu, 22 Aug 2019 10:40:00 GMT



Fruit's so hot right now, but it can't deliver a balanced diet alone

In Spain there is a popular saying which goes ... and that we can get rid of them with a diet based heavily on juices. Intoxication requires medical attention, not a smoothie.

Published:  Wed, 21 Aug 2019 09:50:00 GMT



Share Us!    Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Twitter Share TopConsumerReviews.com on LinkedIn Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Google+ Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure