Best Reviews Best Roadside Assistance Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      May 26, 2019

Home  >  Roadside Assistance  >  Allstate Motor Club vs Auto Road Service


Roadside Assistance

  1. Allstate Motor Club
  2. Carchex
  3. AAA Roadside
  4. Better World Club
  5. Auto Road Service
  6. Paragon Motor Club
  7. Best Roadside Svc

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
What To Do if Your Car is a Lemon Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Cruise Vacations

Fruit Baskets

Hair Removal

Learn to Read Programs

Menopause Relief

Paid Surveys

Pet Meds

Pool Tables

Tax Software



Individual Reviews

Good Sam

Allstate Motor Club


AAA Roadside Assistance

Better World Club

Auto Road Service

Paragon Motor Club

Best Roadside Service


Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Allstate Motor Club vs Auto Road Service

To help you find the Best Roadside Assistance, provides you with an in-depth comparison of Allstate Motor Club and Auto Road Service.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Roadside Assistance, please Click Here

Get Roadside Assistance with Good Sam Today! Whether on a cross-country road trip or a quick errand across town, it’s never a good time for a vehicle to break down. With a Roadside Assistance plan, drivers have protection against the inconvenience and danger of being stranded by the side of the road and can trust that help will be on the way.

While motor clubs used to be the only way to access these protection plans, today there is a wide range of Roadside Assistance plans from which to choose, from credit card providers to insurance companies. Plans can include flat-tire changing, fuel or coolant delivery, help with stuck vehicles, and some even offer financial help with legal defense in the event of a speeding ticket!

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews


Roadside Assistance Program Reviews

4.5 stars
Allstate Motor Club



$52/year - Basic

$109/year - Deluxe

$186/year - Platinum Elite

Allstate is one of the most recognized providers in the auto insurance market, and it's no surprise that their Motor Club roadside assistance plans are thorough, reputable, and widely available. Allstate offers three levels of service: $52/year for a Basic plan, $108/year for the mid-range Deluxe plan, and $186/year for the Platinum Elite plan. Unlike another well-known provider, Allstate's premiums are the same nationwide and do not depend on one's ZIP code.

While each plan only includes two household members, Allstate generously covers teen drivers ages 16-18 in the same household with Emergency Roadside Assistance at no extra cost. For drivers ages 16-23 who want full membership benefits, they can be covered at $24/year per person. All plans cover members in any vehicle: their own, a rental, or even as a passenger with a friend. These two aspects of the Motor Club should get the attention of families with teenagers.

Allstate's coverage is similar to the majority of roadside assistance companies: all plans include lockout service, fuel delivery, road and tow service, trip interruption up to $750, $500 arrest bond, $100 roadside assistance benefit, plus member-only discounts on travel, shopping, and more. Unlike other providers, Allstate does not limit towing by mileage but rather by the cost of the service: $100 with the Basic plan, $150 with Deluxe, and $250 with Platinum Elite, all per occurrence. Even in more expensive locations like California, where towing can cost as much as $10 per mile, this still provides more coverage than those companies who limit towing reimbursement to the first five miles.

Allstate definitely tries to meet the needs of every possible customer; there is coverage available for RV users, for example, and for those who prefer access to service discounts without the commitment of a yearly membership, their Good Hands Rescue option is pay-per-use.

All plans come with an on-time service guarantee: members receive help within 30 minutes or Allstate will give them a 25% discount on next year's dues

Allstate Motor Club also has a 30-day money-back guarantee, refunding dues within the first month. If members wish to cancel a new or renewed membership past the initial 30 days, Allstate will reimburse membership fees prorated from the start of the membership plan.

Our only less-than-positive impression of Allstate's Motor Club is in regards to the number of covered calls per membership year. While it was difficult to find the information on the site, a call to the toll-free customer service number revealed that coverage is limited by service level: Basic includes 3 calls, Deluxe includes 4 calls, and Platinum Elite has no limit but usage is monitored. While Allstate's Basic plan is affordable and attractive for larger families, only three covered service calls in a year might not offer enough coverage; however, with the unlimited calls promised with the Platinum Elite membership, it may be worth the extra cost per year.

Overall, Allstate Motor Club is an excellent choice for roadside assistance coverage.

Visit Site

3.5 stars
Auto Road Service



$69.99 - 1 year

$199.99 - 3 years

$329.99 - 5 years

$459.99 - 7 years

Auto Road Service is a division of auto warranty company Auto Advantage Inc. a well-respected business with an A+ rating and accreditation by the BBB. They pride themselves on being a "truly affordable" provider of roadside assistance coverage, and their no-frills plans include a towing range of 35 miles, three allowable claims per year, and travel planning and discount programs similar to the big-name companies within the auto coverage industry.

Their website has a thorough FAQ for customer questions, and a quickly-answered call to their toll-free number resulted in a confirmation that Auto Road Service's coverage follows the member regardless of the car driven. We would have liked to see this information featured on the site, along with several customer testimonials or reviews indicating their overall experience with the services provided.

Customers should understand that Auto Road Service truly does offer just the basic roadside assistance services—towing, battery jump start, fuel/fluids, etc.—and not any of the additional services commonly offered by other roadside assistance memberships, such as legal defense assistance, arrest bond coverage, or travel interruption benefits. However, their coverage does extend beyond the fifty states to Canada and Mexico, unlike a few of the bigger-name companies. Also, coverage is available for RVs and motorcycles.

While their call center handles over 4 million roadside assistance calls annually, using the same network as many other major companies, Auto Road Service offers a $100 reimbursement if a network provider is not available for a needed service. Within their network, they offer "Sign and Drive": Auto Road Service pays the provider directly, while the member only needs to sign for the qualified services and drive away.

Unfortunately, Auto Road Service's membership price offers less coverage for services extended by other major roadside assistance companies with comparable membership fees.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Some plans also tie the coverage to specific vehicles, while others allow the covered member (and often the other drivers in the household) to receive roadside service regardless of the vehicle. The latter can be particularly useful if a covered member is riding in a car belonging to another driver when a breakdown occurs, as the coverage will be extended to servicing that vehicle.

If you’re shopping for a reputable provider of Roadside Assistance, you should consider the following.

  • Coverage Details. While all plans will cover the cost of towing, either by covering it outright or by reimbursing you for payments made to the towing company, there are significant differences in coverage depending on the provider you choose and the comprehensiveness of the plan. Carefully review the coverage details to make sure that your most likely needs are covered.
  • Length of Coverage. What best fits your lifestyle and plans for car ownership? A manufacturer plan might be enough to protect you, but if you want to cover more than one vehicle without worrying about warranty expiration, a traditional roadside assistance plan would be more appropriate.
  • Reliability of the Provider. How long have they been in business? How satisfied are their customers? How long does it take, on average, to get a tow truck or locksmith dispatched to the customer? Is there a satisfaction guarantee if the promised services don’t meet expectations? has reviewed and ranked the best Roadside Assistance providers available today. We hope this information helps you find the right roadside assistance plan for you and your family!

Vehicle Roadside Assistance Market to Reach US$ 32 Bn by 2027, due to Rising Need for Vehicle Maintenance, Noted TMR

ALBANY, New York, May 24, 2019 /PRNewswire/ -- The global vehicle roadside assistance market features an extremely fragmented vendor landscape due to the presence of a large number of players in ...

Published:  Fri, 24 May 2019 04:09:00 GMT

Global Connected Roadside Assistance Solution Market 2019-2025 - Rise in Demand for Real-Time Communication Systems

Dublin, May22, 2019(GLOBE NEWSWIRE) -- The"Global Connected Roadside Assistance Solution Market Forecast to 2025"report has been added to'soffering. The global connected ...

Published:  Wed, 22 May 2019 05:14:00 GMT

Global $2.7 Bn Connected Roadside Assistance Solution Market Forecast to 2025 -

The "Global Connected Roadside Assistance Solution Market Forecast to 2025" report has been added to's offering. The global connected roadside assistance solution market is ...

Published:  Wed, 22 May 2019 05:53:00 GMT

Steelbird Tyres launches "Puncture Doctor': Roadside assistance for two-wheelers across India

Steelbird Tyres has tie-ups with tyre repair shops at several locations and is working with them on revenue sharing basis. The whole financial aspect has been drafted on the basis of augmenting each ...

Published:  Thu, 23 May 2019 02:22:00 GMT

Victim in fatal Coquihalla crash struck after offering roadside assistance

A man in his 40s is dead after a multi-vehicle crash shut down the Coquihalla Highway between Hope and Merritt for several hours on Thursday night. RCMP said the incident began when a small car ...

Published:  Fri, 17 May 2019 12:36:00 GMT

Grant Stockwell: More lights, safety needed for B.C.'s emergency roadside workers

Two years ago tomorrow, Saskatchewan became the first province to allow roadside assistance workers to use flashing blue lights in conjunction with amber ones to improve their visibility on the ...

Published:  Mon, 13 May 2019 18:00:00 GMT

Vehicle Roadside Assistance - Market Study

The global Vehicle Roadside Assistance market size is estimated to reach the market value around USD 29 billion by 2026 and rising at a 3.8 % CAGR over the forecast time frame 2019-2026. Towing ...

Published:  Fri, 17 May 2019 05:41:00 GMT

UAE- Roadside assistance in Sharjah gets a boost with Rafid initiative

(MENAFN - Khaleej Times) Integrated services package will be provided to vehicle owners in Sharjah through "Roadside Assistance" project - an initiative from Rafid Automotive Solutions, in ...

Published:  Sat, 18 May 2019 04:05:00 GMT

Onlia adds on-demand Roadside Assistance to its suite of digital safe driving products

TORONTO: Onlia Holding Inc., an innovative new digital company that is disrupting the insurance industry with its unconventional approach to road safety, announced the introduction of its on-demand ...

Published:  Sun, 12 May 2019 22:41:00 GMT

Entrepreneur launches Uber-style breakdown assistance app - and there's no need for a membership

A mobile app which helps motorists find and track breakdown assistance without paying for a membership has been launched by a Nottingham entrepreneur. ResQ allows users to select a number of roadside ...

Published:  Sun, 19 May 2019 00:14:00 GMT

Share Us!    Share on Twitter Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+ Share on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure