Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Seafood Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      July 16, 2020

Home  >  Seafood  >  Cameron's Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market

Best

Seafood Stores

  1. Vital Choice
  2. Cameron's Seafood
  3. Fulton Fish Market
  4. Giovanni's Fish Market
  5. The Crab Place

Your Information Is Secure
Culinary Delights: 220 Recipes Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Bicycle Parts

Calendars

Credit Counseling

Feather Pillows

Fruit Clubs

Hemorrhoid Relief

Home Brew Beer Supplies

Homeschool Supplies

Music Publishing

Senior Care

Thyroid Health

 

Individual Reviews

Sizzlefish

Vital Choice

Cameron's Seafood

Fulton Fish Market

Giovanni's Fish Market

The Crab Place

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Cameron's Seafood vs Giovanni's Fish Market

To help you find the Best Seafood, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Cameron's Seafood and Giovanni's Fish Market.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Seafood, please Click Here

Get Your Seafood at Sizzlefish Today! Where can you buy the best seafood online? If you're a fan of crab, lobster, shrimp, oysters and more, you already know how challenging it can be to find your favorites locally - especially if you live far from the coast. Getting the best seafood at a supermarket or even a specialty store can be extremely hit-or-miss, because of high prices and lack of variety most of the time.

Fortunately, like almost everything else you buy, seafood can easily be ordered online. Sound "fishy"? Not at all: some of the world's most renowned fishmongers make their products available for direct delivery to your home, giving you access to the freshest fish on the market (short of catching it yourself!).

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Seafood Reviews

4 stars
Cameron's Seafood

CAMERON'S SEAFOOD

Visit Site

Gift Options:

E-gift cards (sent via email) from $20 to $250, gift messages, samplers

Cameron's Seafood specializes in fresh Maryland crabs and related treats like crab cakes. You can also order Alaskan Snow and king crab, gulf shrimp, lobster, sea scallops, and more - though obviously, as a Maryland-based company, those products are sourced elsewhere. When it comes to Maryland Blue Crabs, these guys are the experts - selling over 75,000 bushels each year that are caught by their very own fleet of crabbers.

Top grade seafood

We were impressed to discover that all of the seafood sold by Cameron's is top-of-the-line grade. Just like you can get different cuts of beef that are classified according to their quality, seafood has a ranking system as well - but you'll only get the highest quality grades here, no matter what you select.

Choose your catch date

Here's another fun fact: because you can place your order up to 60 days in advance, you can actually choose the date your crabs are caught. Your order is then caught, prepared and packaged on the very same day it's scheduled to ship, arriving at your doorstep as quickly as 24 hours from the time your seafood was pulled from the water. Talk about fresh!

Preparation instructions

Whatever you order, it'll come packaged with the right amount of gel packs and/or dry ice to keep your order at the perfect temperature at every stage of shipping. You'll find all of your contents clearly labeled (not everyone is a seafood expert!) and with easy-to-follow preparation instructions for even the most novice of chefs.

Discount offers

When you first visit the site, you might get a spin-and-win chance at a discount or some freebies. You'll have to enter your email and your name, and any coupons you get have to be redeemed within 12 hours. You could get savings of up to 10% or free products (but you can always click on "I don't feel lucky" if you'd prefer not to give them your information right off the bat). We also spotted a $10 off code at the top of the page, no personal info necessary, so be sure to peek up there too.

Best Seafood

Delivery costs

How about shipping? That will depend on where you live, the amount of your order, and how fast you want your seafood to arrive. Most states east of the Mississippi are considered "local", so ground shipping is free on orders over $199 and $19.99 for purchases under that amount. 2-Day Air is $24.99 and $34.99, respectively (same order threshold of $199), and overnight is $59.99 regardless of the order total. For the rest of the US, you'll pay $29.99 and $39.99 (again, same price point of $199) for 2-Day Air and $79.99 for overnight. You may want to factor delivery costs into your calculations if you're giving a gift certificate and want it to cover both the seafood and the shipping fees.

Few gift giving options

Gift-giving options are a little slim. You can send a Cameron's Seafood e-gift card in amounts ranging from $20 to $250 and let your recipients choose something for themselves, and there's a place for you to enter a short note as well. Or, you can select the seafood you want to send and enter a gift message during checkout. It's nothing fancy, but the focus is on the food and not fancy packaging when shopping here.

100% satisfaction guarantee

Finally, every purchase you make comes with a 100% satisfaction guarantee. If anything isn't right with your seafood order, contact Cameron's within 24 hours of delivery to request either a reship or a full refund.

Great reputation

Cameron's Seafood does really well in the reputation department, starting with the Better Business Bureau. The BBB gives this fishmonger a perfect "A+" rating and accreditation over more than 25 years in business - and better yet, there were no complaints filed. Plus, over more than 2,300 independently-verified customer reviews, this retailer earned an average rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars. Shoppers say that the crab cakes are huge, the seafood is packaged exceptionally well to ensure maximum freshness at delivery, and that customer service is very responsive when any problems have come up. We even found people saying that they were switching their brand loyalty to Cameron's Seafood (after previously buying from another online seafood store) because of how impressed they were with multiple orders from this retailer.

Strong choice - especially for crab

Although you won't find the world's most robust gift-giving options or widest range of seafood options here, Cameron's Seafood provides delicious crabs and crab products that won't disappoint (along with several other types of seafood that are equally good). You're sure to have a great dining experience no matter what you order, and we highly recommend them - particularly if you're interested in top-of-the-line Maryland Blue crab.

Visit Site
3.5 stars
Giovanni's Fish Market

GIOVANNI'S FISH MARKET

Visit Site

Gift Options:

Gift shop with seafood tools, accessories and clothing; gift cards

For many years, Giovanni's Fish Market has been family-owned and operated in California, started by a commercial abalone diver back in 1973. Most of their seafood is sourced locally, with some imports as well. (You know you're really getting fish "fresh from the boat" when a store has a video showing its fishermen off Morro Bay - and the sea lions are eagerly hoping for a taste, waiting in the water! Watch the video and see for yourself.)

Basic shopping experience

Shopping online is pretty basic: you can browse their main page, but it's easiest to go directly to the links on the left side. Generally speaking, you'll find abalone, crab, fillet fish, lobster, oysters, shellfish, shrimp, smoked fish, sushi, and also some sauces and spices to enhance your dining experience. Be sure to click on the Specials link if you want the day's hottest deals. Also, don't miss the featured items listed a little further down; at the time of our most recent visit, those included calamari, halibut, poke cubes, and sablefish.

Simple gift options

Giovanni's Fish Market has some of the gift options you'd expect: gift cards that can be used in person or gift codes for online purchases, in denominations ranging from $25 to $250. You can also enter a gift message in the second step of checkout, in the same place where you would add delivery instructions, if you choose to send a gift code or you're sending a specific seafood product to someone else.

Seafood accessories

They also have some gift possibilities that you might not find at other seafood stores. Maybe your special someone has always needed a crab claw cutter or shrimp deveiner. Giovanni's has got you covered! Of course, if you'd like something a little less savage, you can also order t-shirts, hats, and sushi-making kits.

Expect some shipping costs

Giovanni's doesn't quite measure up when considering shipping costs. The company only delivers orders over $300 for free, while some of their rivals have a much lower threshold - or ship every purchase at no cost. All other orders ship strictly by weight: lower prices for California residents, but still anywhere from $25 to $39.99. Outside of CA, your shipping costs will range from just under $50 to just under $200. Granted, that's for overnight shipping (no other speeds are available), but it's still something you should factor in when comparing seafood retailers. Also, because it's overnight delivery, they don't automatically include dry ice: you'll have to select that (for an extra $10) during the checkout process. Orders can be shipped ASAP or delivered on a specific date.

Very favorable reviews

Moving on to reputation: although the Giovanni's site is somewhat outdated-looking (with a site copyright of 2006, for example), their customer reviews are absolutely current - and very favorable! From people who placed a big order for a BBQ to those who use this seafood store to keep their freezers stocked, it's hard to find anyone with a bad thing to say about the quality of the fish offered here. We didn't find a BBB listing for this company, but thousands of shopper reviews across the internet didn't leave us with any major concerns.

Returns for in-store credit

It's good to know that their customers are so satisfied, because Giovanni's return policy had us scratching our heads a little. Like most online seafood stores, they guarantee that your delivery will be fresh. You'll have 24 hours from delivery to request a return authorization form. Yes, you read that right: they will actually have you return your seafood. We don't know that we'd want to be on the receiving end of those returns, but hey, not our problem, right? Their policy is described as a refund, but it comes in the form of a full store credit.

Worth considering

Giovanni's Fish Market has a lot going for itself: a phenomenal track record with its customers and some unique gift options, to name a few. But, when you look at their higher-than-average delivery costs and slightly strange return policy, they're just a little bit off in comparison with our highest-ranked seafood stores. We still think they're a trustworthy source of seafood online, just not our first-place recommendation.

Visit Site

Continued from above

The best online seafood stores guarantee that you'll be 100% satisfied with your order, so that you don't have to worry about the quality of the packaging or the food itself. Another great perk of buying seafood online from a reputable store is the ability to select package deals. Why settle for just crab legs or a lobster tail when you can mix-and-match all of your favorites?

Some retailers go beyond seafood and allow you to purchase full meal packages, surf-and-turf combos, and much more. And, best of all, many of these packages and individual seafood items can be sent as a gift to the foodies on your gift-giving lists. (Say goodbye to boring gift cards!)

Whether you're buying seafood for yourself or someone else, you've got lots of options. How can you tell which online seafood store is the right one? Here are several factors to keep in mind as you make your decision:

  • Selection. Does the company offer a wide variety of seafood to choose from, or do they specialize in just a few kinds? What gift-giving options are available?
  • Pricing. How much can you expect to spend for the seafood you're craving? Are prices competitive with what you'd find at a competitor's site?
  • Reputation. What do other shoppers say about their experiences buying seafood from the company? Is the customer service team knowledgeable and responsive if problems arise? Is there a strong satisfaction guarantee in place, in the event that your seafood arrives less-than-fresh?

TopConsumerReviews.com has evaluated and ranked the best sources of seafood available to order online. We hope this information helps you get the freshest, most flavorful seafood delivered right to your home - or to the home of your lucky gift recipient!

Seafood on display at San Francisco's new California Fish Market Restaurant

The result, California Fish Market Restaurant, opened this month with a seafood-centric menu and a retail shop, as first reported by Tablehopper. "San Francisco is famous for the seafood," Covucci ...

Published:  Tue, 14 Jul 2020 17:25:01 GMT



Ocean Eddie's Seafood Restaurant, 70 years | Anniversary Issue

Ocean Eddie's Seafood Restaurant - the only restaurant on the beach in Virginia Beach - marks 70 years in business.

Published:  Wed, 15 Jul 2020 04:50:00 GMT



Jimmy's Famous Seafood apologizes after post about Black-owned vegan eatery prompts racist insults

It all started July 10 when the social media account for the seafood restaurant near Dundalk retweeted an image of vegan crab cakes. #crabcakes #vegans #veganism #Baltimore ...

Published:  Mon, 13 Jul 2020 16:53:00 GMT



Coronavirus Latest: Maryland Seafood Festival Postponed Until 2021

The Maryland Seafood Festival will not happen in 2020, the organizers announced Wednesday. They said their decision is based on the desire to keep their staff and customers safe. All tickets already ...

Published:  Wed, 15 Jul 2020 12:14:00 GMT



You Can Buy Frozen Seafood Boils at Aldi and Our Mouths Are Watering for Cajun Spices

Well, it's time to meet your new best friend, your partner in crime, your antidote to just-another-Saturday-afternoon in coronavirus quarantine: Aldi is now selling Fremont Fish Market Seafood Boil in ...

Published:  Tue, 14 Jul 2020 14:22:44 GMT



Million's Crab seafood restaurant open in West Chester, coming soon to Tri-County Mall

A new Million's Crab seafood restaurant is open in West Chester and a second one is expected to open at the Tri-County Mall in two months.

Published:  Mon, 13 Jul 2020 11:20:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure