Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Self Publishers Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      November 20, 2018

Home  >  Self Publishing  >  Trafford Publishing vs Xlibris

Best

Self Publishers

  1. Virtual Bookworm
  2. Books Just Books
  3. iUniverse
  4. Trafford Publishing
  5. Xlibris
  6. Breezeway Books

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!
  • Compare

Your Information Is Secure
Secrets of Marketing Legends Newsletter

Latest Reviews

Bunk Beds

Charm Bracelets

Dating Sites

Eczema

Flower Delivery

Guitar Lessons

Hair Loss

Lice

Menopause Relief

Online Stock Brokers

Watches

 

Individual Reviews

Outskirts Press

Virtual Bookworm

Books Just Books

iUniverse

Trafford Publishing

Xlibris

Breezeway Books

 

Disclosure: We pay our reviewers for their reviews. We are not compensated by companies for their reviews, but we may be compensated for links and advertisements on our website. Click here for details.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Trafford Publishing vs Xlibris

Best Self Publishing Companies

To help you find the Best Self Publishers, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Trafford Publishing and Xlibris.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Self Publishers, please Click Here

Publishing a book used to be an expensive chore both in terms of time and money. You had to submit your work to a major publishing house, hope that it was accepted by their editors and review boards, and pay exorbitant publishing fees. After all that, there were extensive marketing and distribution methods and fees - all of which conspired to force many would-be authors to abandon their craft.

Thankfully, times have changed. Today, anyone can have their work professionally printed, marketed, and distributed through a variety of self-publishing services.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2018

Self Publishing Reviews

2.5 stars
Trafford Publishing

TRAFFORD PUBLISHING Visit Site

Cost:

From $47 to $6,497

Royalties:

16.5%

The Trafford Publishing website could use a redesign. The top-rated self-publishing services provide a variety of publishing packages to choose from and list detailed information for each one. In comparison, Trafford presents long pages of text which yo must read through to find the information you're looking for.

After navigating through the various web pages we found that Trafford is an on demand publishing company. Trafford requires the author to buy a publishing package when they submit a manuscript. When the book is ready to go to print, the process stops until Trafford receives orders for the book. The author can order books at a discounted rate, but it is not required.

Trafford Publishing sells their books in their own online bookstore as well as other major online bookstores. Packages range from the "Press Ready" option at $547, all the way up to the "Signature" package for $6,497. With these packages, you get a basic list of services that include cover templates, an author support representative, and complimentary books.

The entry-level "Press Ready" package is extremely basic. Services such as revisions, templates, basic copy editing, and even distribution are all add-on services. Without these, the value of the "Press Ready" package becomes questionable. Unfortunately, the next service level provided by Trafford Publishing is the "Standard" package, priced at $1,297 - and even then, some services that we consider basic are still not included.

Poor web design, steep prices, low author royalties, and missing services conspire to make Trafford Publishing a less-than-attractive option when it comes to self-publishing

Visit Site

2 stars
Xlibris

XLIBRIS Visit Site

Cost:

From $899 to $15,299

Royalties:

10% to 50%

For two decades, Xlibris has helped more than 40,000 authors publish their work. According to the company, their promise is "to create and deliver a first-class quality book, to deliver to your timetable, and to suit your budget."

If you choose Xlibris as your self-publishing service, you'll definitely need a big budget! They offer six general packages, starting with the Basic at $899 and going all the way up to Platinum at $15,299. What's included in Xlibris' packages? The easiest way to determine which package you need is by looking at the Pricing Chart under the Services tab at the top of the page. In general, however, every package includes the following services:

  • Paperback and E-book editions
  • Interior templates
  • Author photo and cover art
  • Cover templates
  • Electronic galleys
  • 1 paperback author copy
  • At least 5 paperback package books
  • ISBN and Books in Print registration
  • Worldwide distribution and online listing
  • Author homepage and book page (online)
  • Google Books Preview, Amazon Look Inside, Barnes and Noble Read Instantly
  • Online sales and royalty accounting
  • At least 50 business cards, bookmarks, and postcards
  • At least 5 posters

From there, depending on your needs, you can access additional services - either for an extra fee or as part of a higher-tier package. Some of these services include Library of Congress registration, web design services, and press release campaigns.

You can also choose a Specialty Publishing Package, depending on the genre of your book and/or your goals for your book. These can be found under the Services tab as well and include Christian, Sci-Fi, Poetry, Romance, and Children's Book Publishing packages and Title Pitch Publishing (i.e. getting your book displayed at bookstores and libraries).

Keep an eye out for special offers that can give you extra savings. For example, at the time of our review, we found a promotion for saving 10% on publishing packages and a free upgrade for ALC subscribers. What is an ALC subscriber? ALC stands for "Author Learning Center", but unfortunately all of the links on the Xlibris site that referenced the ALC provided no information: the pages were blank or didn't go anywhere. This was disappointing.

We also found that, Xlibris' royalties structure is not only confusing but also leaves you, the author, without getting much in return. How much will you be paid? That depends on how your book is purchased: 50% in royalties for e-books, 25% for printed copies or audiobooks purchased directly through the Xlibris bookstore, and a mere 10% for printed or audiobook copies purchased through a distribution channel like Amazon. Xlibris does offer a 100% royalty program for 3 years, but only as part of the higher-end Executive and Platinum packages.

And, of course, you will probably want to buy copies of your book to sell at author signings and other events. You will get an author discount ranging from 30-60%, but if your book is more than 165 pages long, you'll have to get a custom price quote - their pricing chart only goes up to 145 (we have no idea what happens for books between 145 and 165 pages long, as the disclaimer only mentioned custom quotes for books over 165 pages).

We were pleased to see that Xlibris' parent company, Author Solutions LLC, maintains a solid "A+" rating as an accredited business with the Better Business Bureau. On the BBB site, we did find out that Author Solutions LLC owns two of the other self-publishing businesses in our review, iUniverse and Trafford Publishing. This could be useful to know if you're comparing the three services.

On the other hand, we found more than 200 complaints on the BBB site alone from Author Solutions' customers, with many specifically criticizing the services received from Xlibris - or lack thereof. Authors described frustration with the quality of promotion and marketing services purchased, poor editing, and challenges with copyright issues.

Overall, Xlibris is the most expensive of all of the self-publishing services in our review, charging the most for packages and offering the lowest royalties. If their results were astronomically better than their competition, it might be worth the higher expenses - but lackluster author/customer reviews left us believing that most writers will get more bang for the buck with another self-publishing business.

Visit Site

Continued from above

Self publishing companies create books for thousands of authors every year thanks to advancements in computer technology and a concept called Print-On-Demand (POD) publishing. This concept allows for books to be quickly printed and shipped as they are ordered, which eliminates the need for large upfront costs and storage.

However, not all self publishing companies are created equal. There are a wide range of services that are (or are not) offered by these companies, including professional editing services, custom graphic work, book cover options, personalized photos, marketing methods, distribution services, fees, and perhaps most importantly, royalties paid to you, the author.

There are a number of self publishing companies that exist today. They all have different fee structures and specific services that they can provide. You should consider important aspects of each self publishing company before you decide to choose one. Some of these aspects include:

  • Cost and Fees. What is the cost to self-publish your book? Will they keep a percentage of each future sale?
  • Included services. Does the company provide a wide range of self-publishing services for one set fee, or do they provide a list of services that you can choose from?
  • Turn-around time. How fast can the self-publishing company produce your book?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best self publishing companies available today. We hope this information helps you start your publishing career right away!

Self-publishing grows and grows, despite the old stigma

The other day at lunch, my friend - a writer and former journalist - raised a palm toward me to stop my monologue and said: "I don't get it! Why would anyone self-publish a book" I had just described ...

Published:  Sun, 18 Nov 2018 06:09:00 GMT



What Is the Self-Publishing Network

Carl Moberg, Director of Technology for Cisco Network Services Orchestrator, talks to Ray Le Maistre about the self-publishing network and the next steps for service providers to take in their automat...

Published:  Thu, 15 Nov 2018 06:28:00 GMT



Seen and Heard: Writers find self-publishing to be rewarding route

Last year, Minnesota libraries created MN Writes MN Reads as a resource to support writers, providing tools for authors and readers to share, create, and read ebooks. Last month, they announced the wi...

Published:  Fri, 09 Nov 2018 17:15:00 GMT



Writers to learn about self-publishing

In "The Self-Publishing Path: When and How" Friedman discusses the value of publishers, then reviews scenarios in which authors may not need those benefits. She shares invaluable advice on steps to ta...

Published:  Wed, 07 Nov 2018 07:32:00 GMT



Noteflight Marketplace Provides Instant Self-Publishing and Purchasing of Digital Sheet Music

SOMERVILLE, Mass., November 7, 2018 (Newswire.com) - Noteflight, the world's first and largest online music notation software community with over 3.5 million users, now offers musicians the ability to ...

Published:  Wed, 07 Nov 2018 04:45:00 GMT



Noteflight Marketplace Now Offers Musicians the Ability to Instantly Self-Publish Music

Noteflight, the world's first and largest online music notation software community with over 3.5 million users, now offers musicians the ability to instantly self-publish original music and arrangemen...

Published:  Wed, 07 Nov 2018 05:39:00 GMT



Lebanon Author Finds Success After Self-Publishing on a Dare

If you've ever read a book filled with ninja-quick dialogue and thought, people don't actually talk like that - well, then, you haven't met Amber Lynn Natusch. The Lebanon author, whose young-adult fi...

Published:  Thu, 15 Nov 2018 19:08:00 GMT



Share Us!    Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Twitter Share TopConsumerReviews.com on LinkedIn Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Google+ Share TopConsumerReviews.com on Pinterest

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure