Best Reviews TopConsumerReviews.com Best Slipcovers Best Reviews
Best Reviews
      September 28, 2020

Home  >  Slipcovers  >  Slipcover Shop vs SureFit

Best

Slipcovers

  1. Slipcover Shop
  2. Bed Bath & Beyond
  3. Overstock
  4. Home Depot
  5. Lowes
  6. Sure Fit

Your Information Is Secure
Home Decorating Tips Newsletter

Compare Products

  • Select any 2 companies in our reviews to compare them head-to-head!

Latest Reviews

Auto Loans

Babysitters

Christmas Cards

Credit Counseling

DUI Lawyers

Fruit Clubs

Home Brew Beer Supplies

Homeschool Supplies

Music Publishing

Senior Care

 

Individual Reviews

Wayfair

Slipcover Shop

Bed Bath & Beyond

Overstock

Home Depot

Lowe's

SureFit

 

Our professional reviewers evaluate products and services independently, but Top Consumer Reviews may earn money when you click on the links on our pages. Learn more.

Better Business Bureau Reliability Seal

Slipcover Shop vs SureFit

Best Slipcover Stores

To help you find the Best Slipcovers, TopConsumerReviews.com provides you with an in-depth comparison of Slipcover Shop and SureFit.

To see ALL of our reviews for the Best Slipcovers, please Click Here

Where can you find the best slipcovers? The answer to that question could depend on what you're hoping to accomplish with your purchase. Are you looking for a quick-and-easy way to protect your favorite couch from Fido's claws and hair?

Or maybe you're dreaming of a top-to-bottom upgrade to your living room decor and want to change the look of your furniture without breaking the bank? Either way, you'll find thousands of slipcover options when you shop online.

Continue reading below reviews

Best Reviews

2020

Slipcover Reviews

4.5 stars
Slipcover Shop

SLIPCOVER SHOP

Visit Site

Cost:

Starting at $32 for ready-made, $169+ for custom

Free shipping on orders of $69+ in the lower 48 United States

Returns:

30 days if new, unused and in original packaging

No returns on custom orders

Customer pays return shipping fees

Returns allowed after 30-day period with restocking fee

Slipcover Shop has improved quite a bit since our last review, and we're excited to tell you about it. This New York-based, family-owned business specializes in custom work, with all of their slipcovers and other items proudly made in the USA - but their website used to be outdated and hard to look at. Not anymore! While it's still not the fanciest online slipcover store we've ever seen, the Slipcover Shop site is clean and much easier to shop now.

Ready-made or custom slipcovers

You've got two main options with this store: ready-made or custom slipcovers. Ready-made options are in stock all the time and usually ship out next-day, while custom designs are ready in a week. If you decide to go for the ready-made option, or if you're just not sure where to start, we recommend you begin by looking at the Help Center. There, you'll find sizing charts for the ready-made styles, an FAQ for custom slipcovers, and general guidance for making the right purchase.

Show Filters

So, how do you get started with your shopping? Let's say you decide on a ready-made slipcover. Once you've clicked on that category, you could start scrolling through all of the options - but the easier, albeit less obvious, choice is to click on the SHOW FILTERS box just above the images. There, you can narrow down the options by material, pattern, or color. With respect to fabric, choices range from all cotton and cotton/blend to suede, chenille, denim, stretch and suede. While naturally prices will depend on which slipcover you choose, we found lots of options within the range of $35 to under $100 in the ready-made styles.

Best Slipcovers

Slipcover options

Click on a style that interests you, and you'll be taken to your options, plus a closeup of the fabric, links for cushions and other related products, and ordering options. Be sure to find the dropdown box for which furniture you're trying to cover (e.g. chair, loveseat, sofa). If you have any doubts about measurements, be sure to click on the Additional Info tab for a handy measurement guide specific to the slipcover you're considering. And, the Specs tab lets you know the material, pattern, and care details.

Fabric swatches

And, right next to the Help Center tab, check out the Fabric Swatches link - you can order samples of most of their options. As they put it, "fabrics are not two-dimensional...many fabrics have a texture that a picture may not be able to bring out". Fabrics are sent via USPS the day after you request them, so you can see in-person how each one looks in your home and how it feels.

Custom slipcovers

Of course, ordering a custom slipcover requires a little more effort, but it's worth it to get the exact one you envisioned for your furniture. You begin by selecting a pattern - like poplin lilac, vintage suede, or twill rust - and then prepare to follow several steps to ensure the perfect fit. You'll have to click on the Price or Order button and walk through the selection of seat cushion shape, back style, and so forth. One of the lengthiest (but most necessary) parts of the process is filling out the printable worksheet for taking measurements. Never fear: Slipcover Shop takes you through each part, complete with helpful images, so that you'll have no problem knowing exactly what and where to measure. At the end of the process, you'll get a quote for the exact price of your custom slipcover.

Pillow slipcovers

Slipcover Shop also makes custom cushion covers for any furniture or pillows you have in your home - so if you've got a futon cover that has seen better days, a body pillow that you just can't find a sham for, or any oddly-shaped cushions that need an upgrade, reach out to them and see what they can do for you.

Free shipping

At Slipcover Shop, you'll get free shipping if you live in the continental US and your order is at least $69. You can also take advantage of their very reasonable return policy, but keep in mind that doesn't apply to custom orders: 30 days from delivery, must be in new/unused condition and in original packaging, and return shipping fees are on you. Slipcover Shop takes it a step further by allowing returns past the 30-day window, but expect a restocking fee in that case.

Great reputation

This retailer has a strong reputation, demonstrated very well by their accreditation and "A+" rating from the Better Business Bureau. In fact, not only did we not find any complaints on the BBB site, but we also noticed that Slipcover Shop had a flawless 5-star rating in its customer reviews there. That's a good indicator that you'll get what you expect when buying your slipcovers from this store.

High quality slipcovers

As the only provider of high-quality custom-made slipcovers in our review, we're glad that Slipcover Shop has proven itself and improved their site - because many customers prefer to have a one-of-a-kind slipcover tailored to their furniture. And, for those who are happy with ready-to-order designs, this store will happily oblige. Either way, if you want a reasonably-priced slipcover that's made in the USA and backed by a good company, we think you'll like shopping at Slipcover Shop.

Visit Site
2 stars
SureFit

SURE FIT

Visit Site

Cost:

From $10 to $300

Free shipping on $119+

Returns:

30 days, minus shipping costs

10% return processing fee deducted from refund

Must be in resalable condition, with original packaging and paperwork

SureFit got its start more than 100 years ago in Philadelphia, and since that time they've grown to be one of the most widely-distributed slipcover brands in the world. You may have even seen their home decor products at your local department store or other retailers of pillows, drapes, and other items. Fortunately, there's no need to have a brick-and-mortar store nearby: SureFit maintains an online inventory of more than 1,000 products that are available directly to consumers.

Helpful information

We love all of the helpful tools SureFit offers, to help you get the ideal slipcover for your furniture. Be sure to look towards the bottom of the site for their measuring guides, styling tips, and even their "Slipcovers 101" info. You can also contact their customer service team from 9AM - 5PM (EST) on weekdays, either through their toll-free number or live chat.

Wide range of slipcovers

You'll want to start by identifying what kind of cover you need: a pet furniture cover, a furniture cover, or a traditional slipcover. You'll find those categories at the top of the page. Here's what you can cover with a traditional design at SureFit:

  • Sofa
  • Loveseat
  • Chair
  • Wing Chair
  • Recliner
  • Dining Chair
  • Sleeper
  • Ottoman

Because there are so many options, you'll want to use the filters on the left side of the page. For example, in the Sofa Slipcovers category alone there were over 50 choices - so our shopping experience went much more quickly when we filtered by pattern, color, and price range.

Form fit or relaxed fit

Generally speaking, you'll choose between two fits: form and relaxed. SureFit's relaxed slipcovers use woven fabrics, can be adjusted more loosely and are a good choice if you have skirted furniture. On the other hand, form-fitting slipcovers use stretchy fabrics for a closer fit; this style fits your cushions and furniture's contours more tightly and is a good pick if you have T-cushions or box cushions. You'll find fabrics like cotton duck, stretch suede, designer suede, stretch piqué, denim and many more.

Discounts available

Prices at SureFit range from $10 to just under $300 on most slipcovers, with the majority falling right around $150. As we browsed the SureFit site, we got a pop-up offering us a discount of 20% on our first purchase if we became a subscriber to their email list. That discount only applied to first-time customers, and there were other restrictions in place. At the time of our most recent visit, there was also a promotion featured at the top of the site, for a Buy One, Get One 50% off discount when using the provided coupon code.

Disappointing return policy

SureFit isn't as generous with their customer policies as some of their rivals. For example, you'll have to spend at least $119 to get free shipping. Also, if you need to return your slipcover, you'll have 30 days from the date of purchase, not from when you received your purchase - and you should expect a 10% "return processing fee" (in other words, a restocking fee) to be deducted from your refund.

Not the only negative

Unfortunately, that's not the only negative we discovered when evaluating SureFit. When we looked at the company's reputation with the Better Business Bureau, we found that the BBB gave this retailer a disappointing "D-" rating. While 18 complaints over 3 years isn't a huge number, the fact that SureFit left most of them unanswered is unacceptable. We found descriptions of calls to customer service where no one picked up the phone, $30 return fees taken from products that only cost $45, and so on.

At the end of the day, you might get a great-fitting slipcover by shopping at SureFit. However, if anything goes wrong - the color doesn't match, the cover doesn't do a good job of protecting your furniture as promised, and so on - you could be in for a really rough experience when trying to get a satisfactory answer from SureFit's customer service department. Because of this drop in reputation, especially as demonstrated by the "D-" at the BBB, SureFit falls to the bottom of our rankings for buying slipcovers online.

Visit Site

Continued from above

In the past, slipcovers had a reputation for being less-than-attractive, largely because they fit badly and didn't earn many points for style or sophistication. Today, however, there are trendy and affordable slipcovers that fit so perfectly, your guests won't even be able to tell that they're not original to your sofa or recliner. You can even get custom-cut slipcovers in the fabric, style, and size you need for any piece of furniture.

You may have already discovered that your local brick-and-mortar stores carry few if any slipcover options. Most of what you'll find is limited to styles that really only amount to a washable pad that you throw over the top of your chair or couch, hoping that it will cover high-use areas like the seat and back. While that's a convenient option, especially if your main priority is protecting surfaces from pet claws and hair, or spills and other accidents, it definitely won't give you a classy upgrade to your home decor. Fortunately, options abound online, putting every imaginable fabric, pattern, and style within reach.

As you decide what kind of slipcover you need and which online retailer should earn your business, how can you tell which stores are the best? Here are several criteria to guide your shopping:

  • Selection. Does the retailer give you lots of options? Are their slipcovers all in-stock? You should be able to select from a wide variety of sizes, colors, and fabrics, in order to get the right slipcover for your furniture.
  • Pricing. How competitive are the prices that the store offers? Are there any money-saving perks like free shipping or discounts?
  • Return Policy. If your slipcover doesn't quite fit, or doesn't look like you pictured it, can you return it for a refund? If so, how much time do you have to make your decision? Will you be charged any restocking fees or return shipping costs?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best slipcover stores for practically every sofa, chair, or other piece of furniture. We hope this information helps you change your decor and protect your furniture with the perfect slipcover!

These Sofa Slipcovers Can Protect Your Couch from Kids, Pets & More

The easiest way to ensure your couch stays clean is to get a sofa slipcover. The bets sofa slipcovers aren't the bulky, sheet-like slipcovers of yesteryear. Advances have certainly been made ...

Published:  Tue, 18 Aug 2020 11:55:00 GMT



How to Clean Denim Slipcovers

To keep your denim slipcovers from shrinking, never wash them in hot water or dry them in the dryer. Remove the denim slipcovers from your furniture carefully to avoid pulling or ripping the fabric.

Published:  Wed, 25 Sep 2019 11:23:00 GMT



How to Measure Furniture for Slipcovers

Slipcovers give new life to furniture. They do not alter the basic frame or upholstery and, therefore, do not interfere with the antique or sentimental value of a piece. They can be washable ...

Published:  Mon, 23 Jul 2018 13:12:00 GMT



Is This the Most Influential Room Ever Designed?

The La Fiorentina living room has inspired designers for decades-including Mark D. Sikes, who pays homage at the inaugural Kips Bay Dallas Decorator Show House.

Published:  Sun, 27 Sep 2020 06:22:00 GMT



Here Are 11 Vinyl Record Storage Hacks Every Collector Should Know About

always put records back into their slipcovers when they're not being used With all that in mind, and once you've picked yourself up a decent record player, the task then becomes trying to ...

Published:  Thu, 17 Sep 2020 10:34:00 GMT



Share Us!   

Home      About Us      Terms & Conditions      Privacy Policy      Contact Us      Disclosure