TopConsumerReviews.com is a world-leading consumer product review site. We provide detailed reviews and ratings for thousands of products and services.

 

Sports Memorabilia Reviews

We recommend

 

Disclosure: We are not compensated by companies for their reviews, but we may be compensated for links and advertisements on our website. Click here for details.

 

FAN'S EDGE

Being sports fans ourselves, we don't know how we could have found a more perfect site. Whether you're looking for a University of Kansas bedspread, or a signed Michael Jordan Tar Heels jersey, you'll find sports memorabilia for both NCAA and professional teams alike.

Fan's Edge makes it easy to find exactly the sports memorabilia that you're looking for. Their site navigation is put together extremely well and makes for a fast, easy shopping experience. They offer a wide variety of items and make it simple to find anything. Shop by player, team, sport, or even more specific than that. Shop New York Giants apparel made specifically for children, for women, or for men. They offer numerous categories to help you find exactly what you are looking for.

With Fan's Edge ranking in the Top 500 Internet Retailers, it has been proven that they know what the customer wants. While shopping, if you come upon a bump in the road and need some assistance, you have the option to contact customer service by phone or by email. Fan's Edge guarantees a speedy response to your questions and concerns.

You can also expect a fast delivery of your purchased product. Comments from satisfied shoppers compliment the quick shipping of their new item. If you're not happy with your purchase, or find something wrong with it, Fan's Edge offers an incredibly simple return policy. Without even contacting them ahead of time, you can just mail it to the address given to you within 60 days of receiving the item and expect a full refund or immediate exchange.

Fan's Edge is a company that focuses first and foremost on what the fans want. You will find sports memorabilia and everyday items from every team, player, and sport. For all this, they earn our highest rating.

Visit Site >

SPORTS MEMORABILIA

Sports Memorabilia offers their customers a large variety of items from every sport imaginable. Sports memorabilia from seemingly every team and player in the NBA, NFL, MLB, NHL, NCAA and more will give you an incredible number of options to choose from.

This website is put together very well. It's easy to navigate and find your way around. On the homepage you're presented with clear graphics that guide you right to the sports collectible area you're looking for.

Additionally, if you're shopping for a loved one and need some extra help finding the perfect gift, Sports Memorabilia makes it hassle-free for you to pick out the perfect item. Simply go to their gift center, choose a favorite player, or team, or just browse through their best selling gift items and you might come across something your special someone will love.

While shopping, if you have any questions you can expect a very quick response from Sports Memorabilia. You can contact their customer service team with a toll-free number, live chat with a representative, or email.

Once your purchase arrives, if you're not pleased with it, you can take advantage of their simple return policy. If the item is damaged, you can send it back to them within 5 days of receiving it and get a full refund or exchange it for a new item.

All in all, Sports Memorabilia is a great place for a sports memorabilia enthusiast. With an extremely professional website, a large selection of items, and easy navigation while shopping, Sports Memorabilia earns high marks.

Visit Site >

SPORTS INTEGRITY

Sports Integrity is a New Jersey-based company specializing in sports memorabilia. Although at first glance the site might lead customers to believe that the only available products are for the sports of football, baseball, basketball, hockey, and boxing, the drop-down menu under the "Shop" heading lists many more categories.

Some of these include:

  • Golf
  • Soccer
  • UFC
  • NASCAR
  • Tennis
  • Horse Racing
  • Olympics
  • Wrestling
  • Entertainment

Sports fans can find autographed jerseys, balls, helmets, and other memorabilia related to their pastime of choice, and Sports Integrity also sells a variety of display cases for items purchased on their site or ones already in a collection.

We were impressed by Sports Integrity's free shipping on all orders within the United States. If you aren't satisfied, Items may be returned in unused, original condition within 14 days of delivery.

We also appreciated Sports Integrity's very active presence on Twitter and Facebook; their responsiveness to their customers' requests (and infrequent complaints) is impressive, and people seem genuinely satisfied with the interactions they've had and the quality of the products they've received.

The only drawbacks we found with Sports Integrity are a somewhat limited selection of college memorabilia (e.g. footballs and jerseys for collegiate football but not basketball or other sports) and a few difficulties with navigating the site. For example, the drop-down menu for "Shop" includes an intriguing category of "Man Cave", but when following the link we were brought to a page that said we didn't have the permissions necessary for viewing it. We also found that the "Upcoming Signings" page said that now is the time to pre-order from future events, but none were listed at the time of this review.

Overall, we found that Sports Integrity is dedicated to providing top-quality, fully authentic sports memorabilia covering a wide range of interests.

Visit Site >

STEINER SPORTS MEMORABILIA

For decent prices, Steiner Sports Memorabilia gives you a broad range of sports memorabilia. Each sport has several different items to choose from for your collection. In baseball, for example, you can choose from:

  • Photos
  • Bats
  • Baseballs
  • Batting
  • Helmets
  • Cleats
  • Gloves

In football you can choose from:

  • Footballs
  • Photos
  • Helmets
  • Jerseys
  • Seatbacks
  • Elite framed and matted momets

Along with these two sports, you are also able to browse sports memorabilia from basketball, hockey, Olympic teams, auto racing, and horse racing. However, if you're looking for sports memorabilia from an NCAA team, you'll only be able to choose from a few items. Other sites in our reviews were able to give us every collegiate team with several options of memorabilia.

Steiner Sports Memorabilia offers an 'Upcoming Signings' link, where you can check out who will be autographing sports memorabilia, when, and where, at any time. If you have any questions, Steiner Sports Memorabilia offers you two numbers to call, as well as several email options to help connect you with the right representative.

When your item comes in, if you're not satisfied with your purchase you can return it for a full refund within 30 business days, with a 15% restocking fee.

Visit Site >

PRESS PASS COLLECTIBLES

Press Pass Collectibles is a sports memorabilia company specializing in autographed merchandise. Their selection, though lacking in some categories - especially when compared to highly rated sites - covers all major North American and international sports.

General shopping on the Press Pass Collectibles website is fairly easy but specific shopping is another story.

Example 1: General shopping. If you're browsing for a cool or interesting item in your favorite sport, say baseball, you can easily go to the Baseball tab and select any of 10 different categories. Within seconds you'll already be scanning through every autographed batting helmet, baseball card, or jersey they have in stock.

Example 2: Specific shopping. If you know exactly what you want, say an autographed rookie card for your favorite basketball player, it takes a few more steps and the results seem spotty at best. You'll need to type your criteria in the search field or, after selecting Autographed Cards from the Basketball drop down list, select the team or player name from another drop down list; either way the process seems cumbersome and search results appear less than accurate or complete.

We tried both search methods with mixed results. We specifically searched for an autographed Dirk Nowitzki rookie card and along with some accurate results there were Nowitzki items (not cards) and items from other NBA players, even other sports altogether. Then, we went through what we thought would be the easier method and used the drop down lists. After selecting Autographed Cards from the Basketball heading and selecting Dallas Mavericks, many player cards came up in the results but none were for Dirk Nowitzki.

Press Pass Collectibles does have a return policy, though it is less customer friendly than other sports memorabilia sites we've reviewed. Items must be returned in as-received condition, within 14 days of receipt, with all documentation (labels, certifications, and so on). There is a 15% restocking fee and the customer pays for return shipping. For items damaged in transit, contact Press Pass Collectibles immediately upon receipt.

Press Pass Collectibles scores a low rating because of the cumbersome and inaccurate search functions on their website, a substandard return policy when compared to other reviewed sites in its category, and the lack of a broad selection in different areas when compared to our highest rated sites. We do not recommend Press Pass Collectibles for your sports memorabilia shopping needs.

Visit Site >


Sports Memorabilia

Collecting sports memorabilia is a rewarding hobby on a grand scale. Sports lovers tend to prove their love of the game by collecting sports pieces in limited supply, or that are not available to anyone else. A finely stocked sports memorabilia collection can provide a real level of prestige.

Traditionally, only a few people lucky enough to live near specialty stores could enjoy collecting sports memorabilia. Far more often, the little corner shop miles away from your home, that is open only a few hours each day, has a very limited and expensive selection.

However, the internet has changed the reach of sports memorabilia enthusiasts. The beauty of looking for sports memorabilia on the internet is the vast selection you can find, and the convenience that is offered. Finding a rare baseball card from the 1970's or an autographed picture of your favorite Nascar driver can be done in just a few clicks. And the ability to compare prices requires only a moment of your time.

Several online sports memorabilia stores exist today that can help you add to your collection. When looking at different online stores, there are specific factors you should consider in order to find the best value for your money. Some of these include:

  • Selection. Some stores have thousands of sports memorabilia available; others have just a couple hundred. The more sports memorabilia inventory they have, the greater chance you'll find what you're looking for.
  • Ease of Use. Is the website clear and easy to navigate? Will you quickly and efficiently find the sports memorabilia that you're looking for?
  • Return Policy. Does the company allow you to return sports memorabilia products for a full refund? How much time do you have to make a return?

TopConsumerReviews.com has reviewed and ranked the best sports memorabilia stores available online today. We hope these reviews help you find the right sports memorabilia that you're searching for!



Sports Memorabilia In The News

Settlement reached in New York Giants, Eli Manning memorabilia fraud case

Three sports memorabilia collectors who accused New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning of providing bogus "game-worn" equipment that was sold to unsuspecting fans settled their lawsuit against the Super Bowl-winning quarterback Monday, days before the ...

Published:  Tue, 15 May 2018 14:15:00 GMT



Saquon Barkley Making an Impact on Sports Card Collectibles

Not so long ago, kids clamored to pharmacy and candy store shelves, digging through their pockets for change to purchase a pack of baseball cards. They carelessly tore the cardboard prizes from the wax-covered packages which held tasty, yet albeit short ...

Published:  Mon, 21 May 2018 03:00:00 GMT



NFL: No discipline for Eli Manning in memorabilia suit

New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning will not face league discipline in the wake of a sports memorabilia fraud lawsuit. While a settlement was reached in the case earlier this week, the NFL said Manning will not be punished under the league's personal ...

Published:  Sat, 19 May 2018 10:02:00 GMT



Eli Manning sports memorabilia case delayed

HACKENSACK, N.J. >> A trial has been delayed in a lawsuit accusing New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning of selling bogus "game-worn" equipment to unsuspecting collectors as part of a long-running scam. Jury selection was to have begun this week, but ...

Published:  Tue, 15 May 2018 08:33:00 GMT



Why Settling in Memorabilia Fraud Lawsuit Was the Smartest Decision for Eli Manning

With a controversial trial set to begin, the New York Giants, Eli Manning and Steiner Sports have settled a civil lawsuit over allegations that they fraudulently conspired to trick a group of memorabilia collectors by giving them fake game-used helmets ...

Published:  Tue, 15 May 2018 05:07:00 GMT



NFL: Eli Manning Memorabilia Fraud Case 'Not a Personal Conduct Policy Issue'

"Not a [Personal Conduct Policy] issue." On Monday, it was announced Manning had reached a settlement with three sports memorabilia collectors who sued him for providing them with fake "game-worn" items that were later sold to fans. "[Plaintiffs] Eric ...

Published:  Sat, 19 May 2018 08:56:00 GMT



KC ROYALS SPORTS MEMORABILIA SWEEPSTAKES OFFICIAL RULES

PRIZE NOTIFICATION RESPONSE TIME: Seventy-two (72) hours from the time of issuance of Prize Notification (defined below) (the "Required Response Time"). WINNERS LIST: For a list naming the Winners, mail a request and a self-addressed stamped envelope to be ...

Published:  Sun, 20 May 2018 05:57:00 GMT



Eli Manning, Giants memorabilia fraud lawsuit settled

The memorabilia fraud case against Eli Manning has been settled. A spokesman for the defendants on Monday said a settlement had been reached to resolve the claims after three sports memorabilia collectors accused the Giants quarterback of providing fake ...

Published:  Tue, 15 May 2018 05:49:52 GMT




We recommend

 

- View Full Site -